13 ms·
How automakers invented the crime of “jaywalking”
- lotsofmangos 12y agoI didn't realise quite how mental the US is over something as simple as crossing the road till I read this: "A distinguished British historian claims he was knocked to the ground by an American policeman before being arrested and spending eight hours in jail — because he crossed the road in the wrong place. Felipe Fernandez-Armesto said he had been the victim of "terrible, terrible violence" after he inadvertently committed the offence of "jaywalking" in Atlanta, Georgia, last week and failed to realise the man telling him to stop was an officer. The slight, bespectacled professor claimed that five burly officers pinned him to the ground after Kevin Leonpacher kicked his legs from under him as he hesitated to show his ID. He was left "traumatised and disorientated" and with a gashed forehead as he was taken to the local jail and charged with pedestrian failure to obey a police officer and physical obstruction of police." http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1539148/Historian-pinned-to-ground-by-US-police-and-beaten-for-jaywalking.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1539148/Historian-pin... In the UK, we were just taught this thing called the "Green Cross Code" as children in a series of slightly surreal public information films, though the message in it is basically no more complex than to just to stop and pay attention to what the traffic is doing, before deciding to cross the road. Pedestrians aren't allowed on motorways (freeways), but that is about it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Cross_Code http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Cross_Code
- eru 12y agoOh, they weren't getting him for crossing the road, but for subsequent contempt of cop. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contempt_of_cop https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contempt_of_cop)
- grkvlt 12y agoInterestingly, when pedestrian crossings were being introduced in the UK it was decided that a statement like 'DON'T CROSS' was problematic. There was no legal basis on which pedestrians could be prevented from crossing a road and the instruction was therefore being given without due authority! The town council had no right to tell a law-abiding Englishman not to cross the street! So, we got the 'Green Man' signs intead, and of course there is still nothing preventing you from crossing the street wherever you wish here in the UK. Another interesting snippet was the fact that in East London it was thought that signs on crossings would not work due to the large number of Russian immigrants, since "[...] these people are excitable and ill-disciplined." See this article for more information http://www.cbrd.co.uk/articles/pedestrian-crossings/ http://www.cbrd.co.uk/articles/pedestrian-crossings/
- Zikes 12y agoThe article seems to paint the automakers as a cabal of villains for convincing people to not walk in front of a moving vehicle. I'm not sure what I'm supposed to make of it.
- happyscrappy 12y agoYou are supposed to rage against corporate fascist America, duh. But still look both ways when you cross.
- mrxd 12y agoThey may have had other motives besides public safety.
- Zikes 12y agoWell, I've no doubt about that, but should we care that people do the right thing for the wrong reason? I suppose there's some room for debate about whether it's the "right" thing, as the goal of the article seems to be "hey, roads used to be for PEOPLE", apparently forgetting that there's people in the cars as well whose want and right to unobstructed travel is just as valid as those outside the car.
- akgerber 12y agoThough the driver's desire for unobstructed travel is just as legitimate as anyone else's, the amount of land area required to cater to that desire is far larger than that of the pedestrian, cyclist, or mass transit user: http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-JFCIT3QO2IE/UxqPRqcRK7I/AAAAAAAAY30/VNPZu68Q2ms/s1600/pedestrians,+buses,+cars,+road+space.jpg http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-JFCIT3QO2IE/UxqPRqcRK7I/AAAAAAAAY3... Beyond simple use of space, cars moving at high speeds preclude a safe and pleasant experience for those outside of cars. The driver's desire to travel at high speeds is perfectly reasonable, but when we as a society attempt to meet that desire in a dense urban area, the result is unpleasant at best and deadly at worst.
- 12y ago
- svantana 12y agoIt may be interesting to note that here in Sweden, "jaywalking" is not a crime, and we have what may be the lowest rate of driving-related deaths in the civilized world. People here do indeed jaywalk more than in many other countries, but we look both ways first.
- speeder 12y agoIn Brazil "jaywalking" does not exist either, we do have pedestrian crossings on streets, and the law says you are supposed to use them, but I think there is no legal penalty for ignoring them. In fact after learning english it took me several years to understand what the hell was "jaywalking" because as a Brazillian it makes no sense.
- Someone1234 12y agoIn the UK either [0]. The entire country would be completely unworkable if you could only cross at a "cross-walk." Some villages literally don't have any. The only jaywalking-type laws in the UK are for motorways (70 MpH). The whole jaywalking thing seems very authoritarian are arbitrary in the US. But the US has a lot of that type of thing in general. Just look at the recent articles about New York's ticketing strike, some of the things they were ticketing for on mass were a little odd and petty. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaywalking#United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaywalking#United_Kingdom
- fennecfoxen 12y agoNew York's been following what's called a "broken window" policing strategy. The premise is that you go into areas that have high rates of (serious) crime, and do zealous enforcement of even minor crimes (graffiti, jaywalking), and that this sort of enforcement contributes towards the reduction of the crime that matters. It's named for the premise that ostentatious signs of lawlessness and urban decay (like broken windows) invite further, more dangerous, disorder, like gangs staking out turf and assaulting/robbing people passing by. This sort of policing policy is controversial in New York and is relatively uncommon in the rest of the nation. For what it's worth, violent crime and murders in most of these predominantly-minority communities has been reduced substantially in the past several years. However, it seems to result in at least some members of the community feeling substantially more oppressed, and it does result in inequal treatment of minorities by police if for no other reason than geographic correlation. (Disclaimer. The general desirability of this approach is neither endorsed nor condemned herein.)
- kazinator 12y agoDamn it, pedestrians should be able to go anywhere at any time they please. Airport tarmacs, power stations, water treatment plants, you name it! If I want to step off the train station platform and onto the tracks, it's my god-given right. "Authorized Personnel" or "Staff Only" be damned, along with "No Tresspassing". "Sign sign, everywhere a sign / Blocking out the scenery, breakin' my mind ..." goes the song. It's all just a scheme to repress the people. Or rather, to repress them in a small way so their attention is thwarted from the big ways. Yeah, that's it!
- smacktoward 12y agoI never realized there were people who had to walk across an airport tarmac or a water treatment plant to get from home to the corner store.
- scott_s 12y agoI think we hit Poe's Law.
- SapphireSun 12y agoPoe's law doesn't go far enough. I find Poe's law is true in the real world as well as the written world.
- kazinator 12y agoYou think so? Did I neglect to make a clear indication of sarcasm that would distinguish the posting from a frank expression of extremism? I'm reminded that when Jonathan Swift published _A Modest Proposal_, it was taken seriously by some. Or at least legend has it.
- scott_s 12y agoI caught it. But it looks like smacktoward did not.
- kazinator 12y ago
- pacofvf 12y agojaywalking is not a crime in my country, when I'm in the US one of my biggest fear is to spend the remaining days of my life in a US prision for a stupid thing like jaywalking.
- rhapsodic 12y agoDo you really think the US imposes life sentences for jaywalking?
- astrodust 12y agoPeople have had virtual life sentences for parking tickets. Can't pay them on time? Your car's impounded and you're jailed for sixty days. Oh, you lost your job because you're in jail? You were evicted from your home? Too bad. Then your life is over.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- RealGeek 12y agoIn jaywalking arrests, cops may also press additional charges resisting arrest, assault on police officer, obstruction of justice, endangering public safety etc.
- sosborn 12y agoThey may also just give you a warning.
- PhantomGremlin 12y agoOne time I was about to jaywalk in downtown Portland Oregon. There was a policeman nearby. He said: "Sir, please don't jaywalk in front of me." I guess that counts as a warning. I don't recall if I noticed him there before I stepped off the curb.
- 12y ago
- adregan 12y ago99 percent invisible did a great episode about the invention of jaywalking in 2013: http://99percentinvisible.org/episode/episode-76-the-modern-moloch/ http://99percentinvisible.org/episode/episode-76-the-modern-... It's linked at the bottom of the article as further reading, but it's such a good podcast, I thought I'd mention it (emphatically).
- harmonicon 12y agoI didn't understand the Chinese wall reference in the pro automobile cartoon. Thought it was interesting. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_wall http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_wall
- oxryly1 12y agoA historic American term related to China this is not racist... that is a surprise.
- andrewtbham 12y agoIt's increasingly obvious to me that in the future we won't have flying cars. Transportation will be below ground and the people will take back the streets. Examples of this trend include: boston big dig, atlanta beltway.
- vmarsy 12y agoThis trend is quite old if you think about other means of transportation like the train: - London Underground: 1863 - Paris Métro : 1900 But you're right about cars tunnels, the infamous Seattle project can also be mentioned http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaskan_Way_Viaduct_replacement_tunnel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaskan_Way_Viaduct_replacement...
- harmonicon 12y ago"It's strange to imagine now, but prior to the 1920s, city streets looked dramatically different than they do today. They were considered to be a public space: a place for pedestrians, pushcart vendors, horse-drawn vehicles, streetcars, and children at play." I think this point is very important. After the automobiles took over, the street slowly ceased to be the #1 public space where people hangout, shop, play or shoot the bull. Fast forward to today's US, spending an extended time on the street is associated with being poor, homeless or conducting criminal activity. Streets' sole purpose is for travel and commute. Countries with less developed economy still enjoys a vibrant street life much like the pre 1920 US (i.e. Mexico, Brazil, Turkey, China, Thailand etc). As they get richer and purchase more automobile though, the same street transformation is happening again. One can notice a big difference if one visited China in 2000 vs today. They are in some dire need for parking lots. Of course, there are definitely developed wealthy countries in Europe that also enjoy vibrant street life. However car ownership there is not as widespread as in the US due to a number of economic constraints (space cost, gas price, taxes).
- rebootthesystem 12y agoOne of the funniest things was to see a bicycle pile-up in Amsterdam when a tourist walked into the bike lanes. OK, well, it wasn't funny at the moment. This jay walking thing is dangerous, cars or not. I am all for personal responsibility. However, here in the US the driver would get sued to hell and back if a person were to jaywalk and get hit. Going back to the Netherlands, it was interesting to take tours of windmills and find no safety barriers between the tourists and the internal mechanism. Here in the US we'd probably add a full plexiglass barrier to prevent accidents. So I have to wonder how much of this is due to differences in the laws around the world.
- mcv 12y agoOh god, jaywalking tourists on bike paths! It's totally fine to cross the bike path, but you really should watch before you cross. Pedestrians can behave very erratically, and it can be incredibly hard for a cyclist to predict what you're going to do (though I've gotten pretty good at it over the years). Fortunately such collissions are rarely serious.
- dictum 12y agoJaywalking is not a crime here, but I'm always amazed when a TV segment indignantly shows people jaywalking and talks about its risks. I actually find it safer to cross the street somewhat away from the crosswalk. Crosswalks are usually close to road intersections and other places with increased traffic, where the traffic seems to be less predictable.
- grecy 12y ago>In the early days of the automobile, it was drivers' job to avoid you, not your job to avoid them. But under the new model, streets became a place for cars — and as a pedestrian, it's your fault if you get hit. I drove Alaska->Argentina [1] and I was extremely lucky that someone told me that the minute you cross into Mexico (and further south) you should expect the old way of doing things. Roads in Developing countries are not a right of way for cars. They are places to play volleyball, dry coffee beans, change your rear axle, get a tan or herd your cattle. I saw all of these and many more, even on the Pan-American highway in 60mph zones. Expect the unexpected! [1] theroadchoseme.com
- fpgaminer 12y agoIt appears to be similar in Taiwan, where I've visited for business twice now. There are rarely ever signalled cross walks. As a pedestrian you just have to gauge the best time to step into the street, and after that both the cars and people do their best to avoid collision. As an American I think it's crazy and dangerous, but given the population density here, there might not be a better option. On the bright side, most vehicles here are scooters, so they can swerve in and out of the pedestrian hordes with ease. And it seems to keep both the pedestrians and drivers aware of their surroundings at all times. Which is in stark contrast to the common, oblivious moron drivers in the U.S.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoIn China, if you hit a pedestrian with a car, it is your fault no matter what. So a lot of poor people will camp out in a road waiting for a car to hit them to make some money. On the other hand, a dog (or child) running out into the road in China is less likely to be struck by a car because this happens so often that the drivers are hyper aware. Still, I've seen a girl on a bicycle struck and killed at a Beijing intersection (the light was green for the car). You never forget that. Also, yielding on a right turn is a western myth. It is really not that great; I mean, the cars have to go slower overall, the traffic gets congested, everyone is out for themselves, there are no courtesies, and people die. There has to be a middle ground between pedestrian friendly streets and sanity.
- 12y ago
- kevin_thibedeau 12y agoThe unfortunate thing is that the police won't even bother to ticket drivers who fail to yield to pedestrians in a crosswalk. Most US drivers have no concept of how right-of-way works and their obligations to yield. I've taken to using an airhorn for busy crossings and have been chewed out by cops for expecting my traffic rights to be observed.
- jkyle 12y agoIn my town, they take pedestrian rights very seriously. They even have undercover officers use cross walks and ticket driver who do not yield.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoBay Area? Many of the mid-west bay towns run crosswalk sting operations along El Camino often.
- jkyle 12y agoMountain View ;)