3 ms·
It's not necessarily illegal. Nokia, Nintendo and Tesla all openly do naked short selling of their products. They call this a "preorder" -- you preorder a Wii/N
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
It's not necessarily illegal. Nokia, Nintendo and Tesla all openly do naked short selling of their products. They call this a "preorder" -- you preorder a Wii/N900/whatever and they deliver it on or before a fixed date.
It's only illegal when you do it to manipulate a market or if you intend not to deliver the shares.
- hristov 17y agoBad analogy. When you pre-order something you agree on the terms. In naked shorting when someone buys a share from a naked shorter in a stock exchange, they do not agree to buy a fake share or a share that will not be delivered. Instead they expect to get a real share. So if the naked shorter does not deliver the share by the end of the three day period it is violation of contract.
- joezydeco 17y agoAlso, Nintendo (or the reseller) doesn't charge your card until it ships.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoNintendo may not yet have the Wii, but they have made some and they are in production. The difference is that Nintendo can complete your order - if it were a naked short sell then the seller knows they probably can not genuinely get hold of the shares that they sold you, it may be impossible, Some other trade may have had a promise to borrow those shares and may have sold them to some other buyer. Nintendo may well actually have stockpiled your Wii already awaiting delivery (I think this is the most likely position).
- yummyfajitas 17y agoNintendo hopes they can complete your order after they build the wii, and naked short sellers hope they can complete your order after they buy your shares. In the event Nintendo doesn't build the wii, they refund your money. The naked short seller also needs to pay a large penalty. Naked short selling is more or less the same as "naked wii selling". That's why it's only illegal when you are attempting to manipulate the market.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoBut the limitations on Nintendo are less than on the NSS (naked short seller), the NSS can know that they are selling someone else's shares that have already been borrowed by someone else, indeed they can sell more shares than exist as they're not actually required to locate the shares before they sell them. Theoretically Nintendo could sell more than they can ever manufacture, but they at least are able to manufacture the product at the point at which they pre-sell it. The NSS is more like Nintendo now pre-selling a Star Trek holo-deck - they'd know it's almost certainly not achievable.