12 ms·
Whitehouse response to Aaron Swartz petition
- jmct 12y agoIt makes me wonder, what does the White House consider a suitable forum for holding appointed officials to account? Or more appropriately, holding the appointers to account.
- couchdive 12y agoIt's voting! You vote in the folks who vote in the folks who appoint their friend to high positions! It's democracy...sorta...kinda....not really.
- btilly 12y agoThey should have at least called out which term of https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/how-why/terms-participation https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/how-why/terms-participation was being invoked. My best guess is the following passage: To avoid the appearance of improper influence, the White House may decline to address certain procurement, law enforcement, adjudicatory, or similar matters properly within the jurisdiction of federal departments or agencies, federal courts, or state and local government in its response to a petition. If that is the case then I strongly disagree. Prosecutorial overreach and our broken plea bargaining system is a national issue that desperately needs to be addressed. The wording of the petition may have been very specific, but it still provides an opportunity to address the issue. Another possible term that applies is this: You agree to only create petitions consistent with the limited purpose of the We the People platform, which is to allow individuals to petition the Administration to take action on a range of issues — to address a problem, support or oppose a proposal, or otherwise change or continue federal government policy or actions. In that case only the person who created the petition is in violation. The broad interest in signing the petition is a sign that there is an issue that should be looked at. And indeed there is - the undue impact that prosecutorial overreach can have thanks to our broken plea bargaining system. I also note that 1.5 years to respond does not fit my notion of "timely" that the platform promised us... (At a guess they waited to respond to a bunch of these until after an election cycle finished and new legislators were signed in. Best way to guarantee of both low publicity and that anyone outraged will forget about it before any future vote.
- malandrew 12y agoIf that's the term then it's unfortunate that the will of many many people now counts as "improper influence", especially in a republic where representation is the result of a democratic process. The influence of many many people is the most proper influence our representatives can consider.
- geofft 12y agoI don't know what term this is, but We The People has historically refused to respond to petitions about specific individuals as opposed to systemic/generic problems. I'm curious if the petition would have worked better if it were phrased as, e.g., "Direct federal prosecutors to be extremely cautious in invoking CFAA" instead of "Do something about this one person".
- Normati 12y agoThe election is the appropriate forum. Except that Americans somehow keep on voting for parties they don't want because they have silly idealistic rivalries.
- hnnewguy 12y agoExactly. Unless there has been a crime, you vote these people, or the people who appointed them, out.
- ecaron 12y agoDoes it make me too cynical that my initial reaction to anything on petitions.whitehouse.gov is "Who cares?" Can someone point me to a petition that actually made a difference?
- snowwrestler 12y agoThe SOPA petition drew a clear statement from the White House that they would not support any bill that messed with DNS. That was a win for the anti-SOPA folks because DNS redirection was a key part of that bill.
- thaumaturgy 12y agoIOW, it happened to be one of the few cases where the White House's intentions were already aligned with the public's wishes.
- snowwrestler 12y agoYes, I agree that the SOPA petition did not change the White House's mind on DNS. But it did provide a good PR hook for them to put a stake in the ground, and clothe it in the veneer of public support. It's probably best to think of the petitions as a PR tool, not a policy tool. Getting a petition over the signature threshhold, or getting a response, is a great news hook that activists can use to generate press coverage of their issue. For example: this discussion would not be happening today if this response had not been issued. It's also possible that a petition can help affect policy over a long term. In general, people outside of government greatly underestimate just how long it takes to go from an idea or complaint, to a policy shift, to a change in the law. It's not uncommon for it to take a decade or more. For example Silent Spring was published in 1962, but DDT was not banned in the U.S. until 1972.
- patzerhacker 12y agoI was thinking the same thing, but thinking about it more I only get angry (which I suppose is constructive because anger can lead to the drive to do something instead of shitposting on the Internet). This government would be tripping all over itself to comment if Aaron Schwartz was a police officer that had shot an unarmed kid, although he likely wouldn't have been indicted. This government would be tripping all over itself to comment if Aaron Schwartz had released data from a private, multinational and said it was about an upcoming movie, although his actions would likely be blamed on what this government considers a rogue state. This government stands silent and swings its righteous hammer of legalism without concern for harm and proportionality since Aaron Schwartz committed a victimless crime that in no way would change the political party affiliation of anybody voting in the upcoming presidential election. Maybe if he had actually killed somebody or massively hurt the bottom line of a multinational company it would be different...
- tomschlick 12y agoIt's sad that the most on point response I have seen to one of these things was the response to the "Build a Death Star" petition. Everything else just seems like a media spin.
- nmc 12y agoLink for the lazy: https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/response/isnt-petition-response-youre-looking https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/response/isnt-petition-resp...
- PostOnce 12y agoSomeone should write a plugin or bookmarklet that adds an "official whitehouse response" to every petition which just reads: "Okay? Whatever, we're going to take no action on this." because that's been the response to every petition I've seen so far.
- njovin 12y ago"You agree to only create petitions consistent with the limited purpose of the We the People platform, which is to allow individuals to petition the Administration to take action on a range of issues — to address a problem, support or oppose a proposal, or otherwise change or continue federal government policy or actions. To focus discussion, the platform is limited to a discrete set of topics, which may be adjusted over time." I wonder how releasing the white house beer recipe[1] fits that standard any more than the Aaron Swartz petition? [1] https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/response/ale-chief-white-house-beer-recipe https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/response/ale-chief-white-ho...
- snlacks 12y agoThat link, they put hours into writing those recipes and formatting... Aaron Schwartz got spin (which admittedly, probably took more work hours to not-create)
- IvyMike 12y agoWhenever there's one of these petitions that goes nowhere, there are a ton of, "I typed my name into a computer and it didn't make a difference! This country sucks!" responses. Look, I sympathize with this a little--these petitions imply more than they ever deliver. But realistically if you want to force any significant change it's going to take money, time, and a lot more effort.
- desireco42 12y agoIt seems that they think this moment is convenient with all of us being distracted, to push this through without too much of fuss. I am not a president, so I can't publicly disgrace prosecutor, but if I was, I totally would, as her office bullied Aaron Swartz and pushed him over the edge. That is all.
- monsterix 12y agoThe question here is: what do we want as a nation? When they decide(d) not to take any action, not even remove those one or two unnamed persons from their positions at the CIA (for all that rectal feeding, waterboarding stuff) why do you think any of this story would matter to them at all? It couldn't count any higher in their value system, could it? Zilch. This may be just my anguish but from where I stand and see things these tyrannical problems of our Government will only exacerbate, not subside. There is no reason for them to stop. Not until our citizenry becomes as powerful, empowered and weaponized as is the Government today.
- throwaway00011 12y agoHonestly, I felt that there would be a difference because Aaron is Jewish and attended a good University - while the waterboarded and tortured CIA prisoners were of "lessor" ethnic and educational pedigrees.
- kyleblarson 12y agoHope and change
- declan 12y agoThe White House's non-response on the two-year anniversary of Aaron Swartz's death shows why these petitions are not only flawed, but should be avoided by people who actually care about political or policy change. Look at the nearby discussion: Instead of asking why Carmen Ortiz, who's been in her current job for nearly six years, is still there, we're debating the terms of use of the petition site. Instead of wondering why a law originally designed to protect NORAD was used to drive Aaron Swartz to suicide -- despite his JSTOR "victim" never asking for a criminal prosecution -- we're reminiscing about other, equally useless, petitions in the past. I admit it's a brilliant move by this administration (to be sure, Rs would do the same thing). Instead of having people sign up to be members of EFF or ACLU or TechFreedom.org, which will send email alerts when legal fixes like "Aaron's Law" are pending in Congress, people slap their names on a petition that results in a committee-managed non-response on the two year anniversary of his death. Imagine if even 5% or 10% of the 61,179 people who signed that petition instead organized rallies in their cities, or a kind of Leave The Internet Alone rally in DC. That might or may not accomplish something; it surely would accomplish more than signing the petition did. (You could wrap in a bunch of related topics: DMCA/copyright reform, NSA reform, CFAA reform and more.) I'm sorry if I sound frustrated. I spent hundreds of hours interviewing folks involved in the case and reading court documents about the Aaron Swartz prosecution while I was at CNET before leaving to build http://recent.io/ http://recent.io/. What happened to him was a tragedy, but Carmen Ortiz will leave for a seven-figure law firm job at a time that's convenient for her, and an effort in Congress to fix things actually coughed up a bill to make current law worse: http://www.cnet.com/news/aarons-law-rewrite-backfires-reformers-now-on-defensive/ http://www.cnet.com/news/aarons-law-rewrite-backfires-reform... If you're interested, here's a detailed piece I wrote about the federal anti-hacking law Carmen Ortiz wielded against Aaron Swartz, and how it was never originally intended to cover what he was accused of doing: http://www.cnet.com/news/from-wargames-to-aaron-swartz-how-u-s-anti-hacking-law-went-astray/ http://www.cnet.com/news/from-wargames-to-aaron-swartz-how-u...
- joering2 12y ago> Imagine if even 5% or 10% of the 61,179 people who signed that petition instead organized rallies in their cities, or a kind of Leave The Internet Alone rally in DC. That might or may not accomplish something; Well, but wasn't it actually exact purpose behind creating the site? So that people vent on it, instead of rallying on the streets? Of course, this is disgusting, but wouldn't surprise me... > but Carmen Ortiz will leave for a seven-figure law To those of us who believe in Higher Power, she will face much harsher consequences when she crosses to the other side.
- JabavuAdams 12y agoIs anyone else embarrassed that the text of the petition is ungrammatical and contains typos?
- olefoo 12y agoSo, I am the person who wrote that petition. (and yes I'm aware of the issues with the wording ) The decision to name Carmen Ortiz was deliberate; she is a political appointee and thus could be dismissed at the administrations pleasure. That they chose to hide behind the 'cannot discuss personnel matters' figleaf is to put it plainly; bullshit. Political appointees are just that, political; and the fact that the administration is too cowardly to defend their choice in this matter speaks volumes. It doesn't really matter; Aaron is still dead, Carmen Ortiz still has her job (although hopefully her political career has topped out) and we carry on.
- tootie 12y agoHonestly, the fact that she's a political appointee is what makes your petition moot. They'll just appoint someone else. She was following directives from the DOJ based on the law. The petition should have called for end to the acadmic papers paywall racket. If you call for a rule that any research receiving government (or at least NIH or NSF) funding must be made freely available upon publish, that is within the purview of the executive and would solve the root problem once and for all.
- dangrossman 12y ago> If you call for a rule that any research receiving government (or at least NIH or NSF) funding must be made freely available upon publish, that is within the purview of the executive and would solve the root problem once and for all. That already happened -- https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/response/increasing-public-access-results-scientific-research https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/response/increasing-public-...
- olefoo 12y ago> the fact that she's a political appointee is what makes your petition moot. They'll just appoint someone else. If they had sacked her, that would have been an important signal to other prosecutors as to the limits of what is appropriate. And mootness or lack thereof is irrelevant in this context. It was a petition for redress of grievances not a pleading in court. That the grievance is still not redressed does not make the petition invalid or irrelevant. And the larger point here that should concern us all is that prosecutors have unchecked power and regularly exercise it in unjust and corrupt ways. If you draw the attention of a United States Attorney; it does not matter if you committed a crime or not, you will be ruined financially and most likely put into a position of pleading out so as not be in jeopardy of multiple lifetimes of prison.
- chasing 12y agoExpecting anything more than this kind of response from an online petition is naive.
- synesso 12y agoWhat a surprise. The response to the petition is meaningless dribble. I'm surprised they didn't reaffirm their commitment to using the Internet to further the cause of making politicians seem useful.
- vpeters25 12y agoAs frustrating as the lack of action by the white house might be, I think this petition accomplished something: I can almost bet Carmen Ortiz' name has been thrown to the hat for career advance nominations (federal judge, justice department) only to be immediately dismissed by white house staffers because "the internet would bury us"
- throwaway90446 12y agoHow adorable.
- gamblor956 12y agoCarmen Ortiz is already a US Attorney of the District of Massachusetts, meaning that she is the head honcho for the DOJ in that state. There isn't much higher that she could go. A federal judgeship (to a district or non-appellate court) would actually be a demotion in pay, responsibilities, and prestige. That said, the internet has very little to do with her future. The Schwartz case, legally and ethically will have little effect on her career. She has a long and sordid history of not respecting plea deals and of exaggerating drug ties in forfeiture cases. Consequently, she already faced an uphill battle in ever being seriously considered for a judgeship, and she had essentially no chance of receiving a recommendation from the ABA judicial candidate evaluation committee. Like most US Attorneys, she will either go into politics or into a very lucrative position with a law firm as a white collar defense attorney.
- jayleno 12y agoHere's a documentary about Aaron Swartz. https://archive.org/details/TheInternetsOwnBoyTheStoryOfAaronSwartz https://archive.org/details/TheInternetsOwnBoyTheStoryOfAaro... Edit: It was educational, emotional, and enlightening to see what he went through to make the world a better place. Also it's scary to see how much the government can get away with. .. Makes you think.
- cyphunk 12y agoWOW. Depending on what side of the firewall you sit this act can be interpreted as either "out of the box thinking" OR subtle arrogance and desperation. For those sitting on 192.168.* that thought this strategy up take note: Speaking of Aaron Swartz is about much more than internet freedom. His actions may relate to this topic closely but his death touches something much deeper. For anyone that cares about this person or his death it is about moral corruption and the hollow platitudes of accountability. You cannot just deal with his life without dealing with his death and attempting to separate them will be seen as arrogance to almost anyone aware of this persons name. In the future, when you're interns are throwing around ideas, take a moment to examine and better understanding of the market you peddle your next strategy to. FAIL
- cyphunk 12y agoimpressed. are votes due to https://twitter.com/cyphunk/status/553116587071635457 https://twitter.com/cyphunk/status/553116587071635457 ? whitehouse lurking around HN?
- havery 12y agowhat third party org is used to validate the petition count number?
- Jgrubb 12y agoBeing as it's a Drupal site, it's most likely a SQL query.
- tempodox 12y agoDo I get this right that this so-called response actually represents the absence of any response? And in good government manner it's phrased in a language that could mean anything and therefore means nothing at all. This just makes me want to barf.
- codingdave 12y agoFederal prosecutors always throw the book at people. That is their job, that is how the legal profession works - 2 sides come at a case from the most extreme positions, knowing that the end result will fall somewhere in the middle. Of course they found inappropriate laws to throw at him. Of course it seems over-zealous. That is how our system works. But people need to realize that prosecutors do not expect every charge to stick. They do not expect to actually get the horrible sentences that they threaten. Because this case never went to trial, any decisions or reactions based on the worst-case scenario threats of prosecutors are unfounded. Any criticisms of laws being unfairly applied would have been argued in court. The tragedy here remains that Mr. Swartz needed professional psyche help, and did not get it. A smaller tragedy was that he needed better legal help. Across the board, this is a horrible story. But people continue to focus on the wrong points. Petitions to fire the prosecutor? Really? We should be working towards better mental health in our society. I would also love to see a change in our legal system, but that one seems a tougher nut to crack.
- mapt 12y agoFederal prosecutors nearly never take cases to trial, because we provide them plentiful resources and allow them an absurd amount of leeway in threatening people who appear to be politically useful targets. We give their threats teeth by allowing them to say that the victim is liable for a nearly unlimited sentence should he fail to plead out. There are accounts that it's also common to seize a victim's assets to prevent him from paying a real lawyer to defend him. The judges actually recognize that this is cruel & unusual, and have formed an entire extralegal 'sentencing guideline' system for conventional crimes that is entirely at their discretion, separated from the maximum legal penalties by an order of magnitude; You only find out whether you're to be put on this if you dare to try and prove your innocence. That's no way to run a justice system, particularly as without anyone claiming to have been wronged, and novel circumstances of the 'crime', this was an attempt to legislate / regulate through deterrence via prosecution, or possibly just to punish. Aaron Swartz had already been targeted by the American federal justice system for having the audacity to disrupt the PACER bureaucracy that was being run as a behind-the-scenes moneymaking operation.
- 12y ago
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- crucini 12y ago78 comments here, 61k signatures, and nobody has pointed out the glaring grammatical error in the first sentence of the petition. I reckon that the intern who read the thing got a laugh from it.
- maxerickson 12y agoPosted 10 hours before your comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8855367 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8855367
- jacquesm 12y agoIt's weird. I truly believe that if this had happened to someone other than Aaron that he'd have found a way to marshall at least an order of magnitude more petitioners. He really had a knack for this kind of thing. Sad to see this blown off like that, adding insult to injury.
- jimtla 12y agoThere's a feedback form here: http://www.whitehouse.gov/webform/tell-us-what-you-think-about-we-people-and-petition-response-us-attorneys-office-personnel-m http://www.whitehouse.gov/webform/tell-us-what-you-think-abo... It's likely that nobody will ever read my feedback, but if enough people respond then maybe somebody will. In any case, here is my feedback. Please provide any additional comments about the We the People petitions system: The technology worked fine, but the response was utterly vacuous and without empathy. Aaron Schwartz took his own life almost exactly two years ago. He was a leader, a visionary, and a friend to many of the people in our community. Most importantly he was a person trying to live his life. Aaron was subjected to unjust and vicious prosecution for an act of peaceful civil disobedience. That prosecution lead directly to his death. He received a death sentence for downloading academic journals. This is not a petition about "openness" and "economic growth". This is not about ensuring that "the Internet remains a free and open platform." Hell, it's not even about firing Steve Heymann for his actions. It's about the way we choose how to prosecute civil disobedience (and the way we choose not to prosecute murder http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Eric_Garner http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Eric_Garner). It's about a justice system that feels increasingly unjust. Mostly, though, it's about the death of our friend. We'd like an apology for his death, but if you're not willing to do that, at least acknowledge the value of his life. Sympathy is not enough.