23 ms·
Fasting triggers stem cell regeneration of damaged, old immune system (2014)
- vegedor 12y agomore like, after three days if fasting the entire immune system has to generate, but what do I know ^^
- rjurney 12y agoI didn't read the study, but what definition of fast are they using? Water only?
- Osmoticat 12y agoInteresting, but until it's been independently replicated a couple of times, I wouldn't recommend changing your lifestyle.
- thethrows 12y agoTrue, we need to be able to reproduce and confirm technically that fasting correctly is good for people. But you cannot simply ignore millenia of anecdotal evidence that people who fast simply are more healthier. I find it odd that it's now considered normal to stuff yourself all the time, when historically before maybe a century ago it was considered totally normal to not eat all the time(involuntarily or otherwise).
- solarmist 12y agoWhat millennia of anecdotal evidence? I've heard claims like that before, but never seen the source of any of these claims. Really? In the past it was common not to eat, voluntarily? That seems hard to believe with how central food is to every culture I've ever been exposed to. In fact you are seen as odd if you choose NOT to partake when others are. If this is common knowledge to you it is certainly not for me, which is why I do want to see the results of studies like this that have been replicated. My entire historical perspective on fasting is from religious/spiritual perspective which don't mention anything about health benefits.
- wtbob 12y ago> In the past it was common not to eat, voluntarily? Pretty much every religion of which I'm aware has the concept of fasting, and on every culture people terms to make an attempt to follow their religion's strictures (c.f. all the folds you see running at the gym). Sure, as you more religions don't tend to mention the physical health benefits, but they certainly believe in the psychological health benefits. Regardless of whether they believe in them or not, such regimens will affect their participants' health for good or for ill.
- solarmist 12y agoReally? My understanding of religious fasting was it was a form of devotion. To show how dedicated you were to that cause. Or to show that you could overcome your biological instincts. In other words to demonstrate fortitude, strength of will, and discipline, and thus become closer to an ideal that is mostly considered non-biological or rather transcend the biological (God/Nirvana/etc). Or to empathize with suffering/deprivation of others. So, while I guess those could be considered benefits, I don't really see it.
- agumonkey 12y agoFunny, I'm not religious and from my distanced POV I never took fasting as a sign of devotion, more an old fashioned detox/cleanse with a sense of minimalistic life (which is not far from empathizing with deprivation).
- pan69 12y agoAren't humans hunter-gathers and not having food for some periods of time has become part of who we are? To me vasting makes total sense, whether it's religious, spiritual or otherwise.
- solarmist 12y agoWe know very little about pre-historical diets, there are almost as many theories on it as there are current human diets. Just look at any two descriptions of the "paleo diet". I'm sure though that the tribes/groups that had best access to food were the most successful, so I'd assume that fasting was something to avoid for them, not embrace. I'd be willing to bet that in reality, before the rise of civilization (and expansion to less hospitable climates), that fasting was more uncommon than the general population believes (most modern hunter/gatherer tribes eat pretty well), if food started to get scarce you went and found more. Food isn't really scarce if you live in a good area, and while our species was growing up we lived on very fertile lands.
- hk__2 12y agoA lot of things were normal a century ago while being completely unhealthy. Bloodletting has been a common practice for millenia until ~150 years ago, even if it was an useless and even dangerous practice.
- rgbrenner 12y agoanecdotal evidence that people who fast simply are more healthier. If they are healthier, are they healthier because of fasting or simply from reduced caloric intake? Would someone who ate less (smaller meals, etc) be healthier than someone who fasts?
- SwellJoe 12y agoIn caloric reduction research, there is indication that fasting can be similarly effective to caloric reduction, and may be easier to achieve for many people than a sustained calorie reduction (the amount of calorie reduction thought to be required for effectiveness is thought to be quite challenging to live with longterm...leading to feeling hungry pretty much all the time). Feeling really hungry one day a week may be easier than feeling a little hungry 24/7 every day for the rest of your life. I'm not disagreeing with you. I think there are still plenty of questions unanswered about this issue. But, I've seen enough evidence, from disparate enough peer-reviewed sources, to think fasting is worth integrating into my life.
- Squarel 12y agoCalorie reduction makes you feel hungry until you get used to it. Some people do not get hungry very often, and eat what is, for many people, very little, and are not hungry or lacking in energy.
- MartinMond 12y agoArticle is from Jun 5 2014, here's the University of Southern California's article: https://news.usc.edu/63669/fasting-triggers-stem-cell-regeneration-of-damaged-old-immune-system/ https://news.usc.edu/63669/fasting-triggers-stem-cell-regene...
- themodelplumber 12y agoLooks like this is the study: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3608686/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3608686/ (Edit: Nope, see reply below) Interesting conflict of interest (edit: potential conflict) with the researcher being the founder of a food supplement marketing company. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valter_Longo http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valter_Longo Edit: I was wondering what the fasting + supplement connection was. Here we go: "L-Nutra's first line of products stems from 15 years of research by Prof. Longo and his team at the USC Longevity Institute, one of the world's leading centers for research on aging and its translation into human interventions that optimize longevity and healthspan. It was largely motivated by the request of many patients who wanted to take advantage of the potential beneficial effects of fasting during cancer treatment but were unable to fast and forego any all meals or and snacks." (Emphasis mine) From: http://www.l-nutra.com/index.php/about/team http://www.l-nutra.com/index.php/about/team
- MartinMond 12y agoThe study you linked is from Feb 8, 2012. I think this is the actual study: http://www.cell.com/cell-stem-cell/abstract/S1934-5909(14)00151-9 http://www.cell.com/cell-stem-cell/abstract/S1934-5909(14)00...
- themodelplumber 12y agoLooks like you're right. Thanks!
- reasonattlm 12y agoAs others noted you pointed out the wrong study. For what it's worth Longo has has been working on aging, calorie restriction, and intermittent fasting research for some time. Look back through the history of his papers [1] and you'll see solid work. As I understand it he is presently doing the work needed to package up intermittent fasting into something that can be used as a treatment rigorously enough to keep the FDA happy [2], [3]. [1]: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=Longo+VD http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=Longo+VD [2]: http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-25549805 http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-25549805 [3]: http://news.usc.edu/58074/wanted-a-recipe-for-longevity/ http://news.usc.edu/58074/wanted-a-recipe-for-longevity/
- vijayboyapati 12y agoI wonder if similar benefits can be had by practicing the method of "lean gains" aka "intermittent fasting", or whether this only works with 3 days of fasting, which is a long time to go without food. I'd certainly find it hard to be productive during that extended period.
- hartator 12y agoWonder this too. Found this: http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/277860.php http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/277860.php, "prolonged periods of fasting - repeated cycles of 2-4 days with no food - over the course of 6 months,"
- rsync 12y agoEverybody is different, and my anecdote should have very little weight attached to it, but ... I do an 18 hour fast once per week, which is a very modest fast. On the other hand, I have a very, very comprehensive and intense exercise regimen, so my resting metabolic rate is quite high, and 18 hours with zero calories clears my body out very thoroughly. And I notice it greatly - it feels fantastic. I feel very quick and light on my feet. It's noticeable. Am I improving my immune system ? Who knows. However, it is definitely less than a 3 day fast, and it definitely improves my health.
- thatusertwo 12y agoOnce I fasted for 3 days, only drinking water. By day two I was pretty weak, afterwards I recovered pretty quickly. The point being, it shouldn't be to difficult to do if you aren't going to need to be too active.
- loceng 12y agoI've fasted for 2-3 day periods where I was generally as active as I'd normally be, including doing a few demanding 60 and 90 minute yoga classes during that time. The only thing I really noticed was that if I exerted myself above a certain level, such as walking at too fast of a pace, then I'd very quickly feel tired - all it took was reducing my walking pace and I felt fine again; I presume this is related to the different rates of energy being made available.
- junker37 12y agoAfter seeing this article the first time, I decided to try the 3 day fast as well. I too continued my normal morning 3 mile runs and noticed that if I couldn't push the pace for very long. I'm just an anecdote, but my immune system seems to be stronger this winter. With two little ones who've been sick a couple of times and a wife that had the flu, I've been able to get by with just minimal congestion.
- dschiptsov 12y agoBoy, we could cut spending on feeding patients in hospitals.
- PakG1 12y agoI fasted once for three days in university. Only water. Bumped into a friend who raved about it and so I tried it out. It was a faith thing. First day was not bad. Second day was horrible. That day just happened to be the day when all these university student associations decided to put on a whole bunch of events that had food. The First Nations Student Association served roasted corn, salmon, and bannock. Another club had pizza. An info session for overseas exchange studies had sushi, cookies, veg and dip, and so on. On it went. It sucked. My friend had allowed himself one cup of fruit juice during his three days, so I allowed myself one cup at the exchange info session. Dang, I needed a lot of willpower that day. Third day was fine, it felt like I was actually starting to adjust to lack of food. But knew eventually I had to eat so fourth day I ate. I try it every now and then. Honestly, if I can get over the hump of those big hunger pangs, it gets easier. Part of it may be because I eat too much in general though. Hehe.
- schrodinger 12y agoI was doing two day fasts ever other week or so for a while. The first time, it was really hard - I felt sick to my stomach, weak, and almost gave up. After that time though, once I realized that no it's not going to kill me, got much easier and I actually started to enjoy the relaxation it brought.
- ThomPete 12y agoPrevious discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7858000 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7858000
- mmastrac 12y agoIf you're interested in this, watch Michael Mosley's BBC program on this from a few years back where he anecdotally had good results trying it himself: http://www.bbc.com/news/health-19112549 http://www.bbc.com/news/health-19112549 "I stuck to this diet for 5 weeks, during which time I lost nearly a stone and my blood markers, like IGF-1, glucose and cholesterol, improved. If I can sustain that, it will greatly reduce my risk of contracting age-related diseases like cancer and diabetes."
- Renaud 12y agoHe's still doing it now, although just in 'maintenance mode' doing it 1 day per week instead of 2. He's maintaining a website and has done a couple of books on fasting, and the 5:2 diet in particular: http://thefastdiet.co.uk/ http://thefastdiet.co.uk/
- atoponce 12y agoI recognize this as completely empirical evidence, so take it as that. I am a Mormon. As part of our religious observance, we fast for 2 meals on the first Sunday of every month. Also, I have fasted for the entire duration of the Muslim month of Ramadan twice now. For Mormons, food and drink is abstained starting Saturday night after dinner until Sunday night's dinner. By the time dinner rolls around Sunday night, I am pretty weak. However, I have noticed that when I fast that Sunday, the following week, my system seems to clean itself out. I feel more alert, and energy seems to peak for a prolonged duration that first week. While participating in Ramadan, food and drink is abstained from dawn to sunset for each day during the month. This usually means packing in the necessary proteins and carbohydrates for slow breakdown in the morning, and a filler at night. Both times, I shed about 10-15 pounds. Ramadan was much more difficult for me to participate in, because I need to remain alert and active while at work. I can maintain that needed level until early in the afternoon, when I start to slow down. By the time my shift is over, I'm really not very productive. However, right about the time I am getting off of my shift, I notice that my hunger pains disappear, even though I'm still weak. While I can't say I notice the increased energy or alertness at the end of the Ramadan, shedding the weight was a positive bonus, although it was not intended. In both cases, Mormon fasting and participating in Ramadan, I can say that I have noticed personal health benefits, whether it is increased energy, or losing weight. Others I have talked to have noticed the same thing, both Mormons and Muslims alike. So, it doesn't surprise me that there will be immune system benefits as well.
- mb_72 12y agoI have Crohn's disease, have therefore been exposed to numerous doubtful stories about 'boosting the immune' system. With my illness, a 'boost' would actually make me sicker, whereas I find that fasting for a couple of days results in improvement of symptoms for me. Why? Obviously because my digestive system becomes empty, and there is less irritation of damaged intestinal lining. Going by this study, an increased production of white blood cells should make me sicker. My anecdotal evidence does not support their findings. Long story short - if their claims are true they will be able to be reproduced by other researchers. Until then, colour me sceptical.
- 12y ago
- cubano 12y agoI hate the fact that this study seems to be tainted with potential conflict of interest as outlined by @themodelplumber. I wish science could get back to just-being-science and focus on provable, repeatable results sans corporate involvement, as I think if this is really true, it could be a real breakthrough. I have some experience with fasting, and was always surprised how good I felt after a couple of days, and to be honest the times I was actively living a fasting lifestyle, I do not remember ever getting sick. Yes yes I know...a big bag of confirmation bias and anecdotal evidence, which is why I hope deeper, hard-science studies will continue.
- gfodor 12y agoReplies above claim themodelplumber was citing the wrong study -- believing claims of conflict of interest without doing your homework is just as bad as believing studies themselves without doing your homework.
- learnstats2 12y agoThere's always conflict of interest.
- misiti3780 12y agoI read Antifragile + The Black Swan once every year to remind me of this - and everytime I read something I think about confirmation bias and silent evidence. they are not tough concepts, but the human brain isn't really weird to think that way - unfortunately (as talked about in Thinking Fast and Slow also) Taleb, for all his faults, is really good at calling out people for scientific research that contains conflicts of interest - he has been calling out GMO related stuff for the past two or three months on Twitter, before than he became famous for doing it in Finance
- jweir 12y agoTaleb is also an advocate for fasting. https://m.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=10152175039588375&id=13012333374 https://m.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=101521750395...
- fesja 12y agoIt's not so surprising to me. When you have stomach ache, the first thing they tell you is not to eat until you have been cleansed. We have always done that in my family. Also, once that I had a weird allergy on my skin (I'm not allergic to anything) I fasted for 4 days drinking Aquarius and some ham and rice the last 2 days. I didn't need any pills.
- IvarRafn 12y agoIf anyone's interested in fasting I recommend watching this documentary from BBC Horizon. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xvdbtt_eat-fast-live-longer-hd_shortfilms http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xvdbtt_eat-fast-live-longer...
- mingabunga 12y agoI've been eating once a day for the past 3.5 years and I'd read about the supposed immune system benefits. I've not had a cold/flu since then and I used to get 3-4 a year, so I'm sticking with it and I've become used to it anyway.
- lalos 12y agoHow many meals worth do you eat once? Do you eat the equivalent calories of three meals in one?
- mingabunga 12y agoNot sure, I can eat quite a lot, I do a lot of exercise and I'm pretty lean. I just eat until I'm full, might have a few snacks later.
- apinnes 12y agoWhat sorts of meals are you eating when doing it once a day? Are they big/small meals, or a mix of the two?
- mingabunga 12y agoOne big meal at dinner and a bit of grazing, although if I eat enough fat I don't feel like grazing later. I'm not completely militant about it, if someone asks me to meet up for lunch I'll go, but 95% of the time I stick with it. Plus it's nice to only have to make one decision about food a day and you save some $ from not buying lunch each day.
- moron4hire 12y agoI just stopped working in an office for that effect.
- barbarian 12y agoAnother of my kind! I've been eating once a day for about 2 years now. This is obviously just anecdotal, but for me, I certainly feel more mentally alert during a fasted state; though I wouldn't say I've been sick any more / less than other times in my life. Friends think I'm quite bizarre for eating this way - but it just seems to work for me.
- reasonattlm 12y agoBetter publicity materials: http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2014-06/uosc-fts060214.php http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2014-06/uosc-fts06021... The paper: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.stem.2014.04.014 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.stem.2014.04.014 Really it's just not worth even reading whatever the popular press has to say about a particular strand of research, especially when lines like "regenerate the entire immune system" are thrown around. No, no, no. Not what is happening: read the paper or even just the publicity materials. It is a very specific mechanism involving specific cell populations. This is of interest to me primarily because it draws a comparatively sharp line in the sand between the occurrence of a beneficial immune system behavior that happens after three days of fasting but not prior to that point. There are not too many other items I can think of in connection with fasting or calorie restriction that have this discrete on/off behavior. It would be interesting to repeat this in healthy volunteers rather than cancer patients.
- con-templative 12y ago> Really it's just not worth even reading whatever the popular press has to say about a particular strand of research, especially when lines like "regenerate the entire immune system" are thrown around. To look at it from the opposite perspective, here's a helpful guide for scientists on how to get a health study into the UK news: http://www.nhs.uk/news/2014/12December/Pages/your-guide-to-hitting-the-headlines.aspx http://www.nhs.uk/news/2014/12December/Pages/your-guide-to-h...
- DanBC 12y agoI love the NHS (UK National Health Service) information "Behind the Headlines" site that your link comes from. http://www.nhs.uk/news/Pages/NewsIndex.aspx http://www.nhs.uk/news/Pages/NewsIndex.aspx
- con-templative 12y agoAmen. I imagine they'll have a post on the Telegraph article in a week or so.
- 12y ago
- mknits 12y agoForget the study, people belonging to Jainism know this for centuries. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jainism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jainism
- UserRights 12y agoNo reason to downvote this guy, he has a valid point. Scientists should look at the wisdom of people.
- rsync 12y agoWhat people should look for is a well preserved meme. Fasting is a very, very well preserved meme - across broad geography and many different ethnic and religious groups. That means something. Regardless of whether or not we understand the science of it, or how we feel about "the messenger" (in this case, religious teachings that we may or may not harbor animosity towards), a very well preserved meme is worthy of our attention. Is it true ? I don't know. It's interesting, though, and is worthy of our attention.
- jstanek 12y agoIt's important to remember that anecdotal evidence is not scientific in any way. Just because there exists "peoples' wisdom" doesn't mean that this wisdom is correct. This is why science exists in the first place, to explore and explain natural phenomena.
- bikamonki 12y agoSometimes science is not a discovery endeavour, sometimes it just 'explains' something that we already 'know'; that knowledge may be the product of accumulated experience, intuition, observation or mere chance. It seems valid then, to highlight an old religious ritual like fasting as evidence that such practice works to improve physical health. Do note that the writer of this comment is an atheist.
- harry8 12y agoIf I can venture a possible explanation of downvotes while noting I always prefer a respectful reply than a downvote for any disagreement. Every religion since forever has claimed their religious practices are beneficial. Such claims are not science regardless of the religion and, importantly they aren't science even if the claim turns out to be true. If you have a properly executed study gathering the data correctly and doing a dispassionate analysis on the effects of fasting as practised by Jainism or any other religion that's worth looking at. The easiest person to fool is always yourself and never is it easier than when looking at something about which you feel particularly strongly such as your religious beliefs and practices. Claims from religious devotees (or former devotees) about fasting or magic underwear, or genital mutilation benefits or miseries should be completely disregarded. Evidence properly gathered, analyzed and capable of being falsified about those same things should be taken with the seriousness it deserves. Religious claims might give one an idea about where to look but should but not be mistaken for any kind of rigor in themselves. Or you end up with truly barbaric, unnecessary medical "treatment" that needs to be consigned to horrific sections of history texts where mercifully at least some of it has now been. Properly done science is how you know if any given claim is true, false or its truth is still yet unknown and possibly still unknowable.
- DavidWanjiru 12y agoThis sounds like hooey to me. I mean, fasting may trigger some survival/distress mode mechanisms, but do such triggers actually consist better health? All other things being equal, to the the extent that you can experimentally make all the other things equal in this case, would I have a higher overall white blood cell count after fasting than I had before fasting? Does fasting (starving?) weaken my immune system initially? To what extent? Is that extent recovered, and exceeded, by the new WBC production that wouldn't have been triggered otherwise? I'm comparing this, admittedly based on zero evidence, with the flight response. Adrenaline makes me run faster, but it doesn't make me a faster runner. That's how I mean when I say this sounds like hooey. Of course, I could be totally wrong, and I really have no basis to make this claim in the first place.
- junto 12y agoDoes anyone have any links to suggested fasting regimes that they found useful? How often to fast for example?
- bicknergseng 12y ago>>But I think the most sensible way forward would be to synthesize this effect with drugs. I'm no naturopath, but something about this attitude really bugs me. I know in context he was cautioning against jumping to conclusions, but if there was a safe, low barrier to entry, non-drug way of achieving an effect, why would you encourage people to take a drug instead?
- ovi256 12y agoFasting for three days is not a safe, low barrier to entry, way. A healthy person with no critical commitments or delicate work can do it safely, but lots of people would not. Note that one side effect observed during the protocol was fainting.
- blowski 12y agoAnd also because drugs companies can't make money out of a non-drug solution.
- mikkom 12y agoThese were cancer patients or am I mistaken?
- crystaln 12y agoIs there any evidence that fasting for 3 days is not safe or is this just an assumption? As I understand it is perfectly safe for all but the most fragile people.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoAs long as you're in good health and stay hydrated, you can safely fast for almost 30 days. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25552155 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25552155 "Conclusion: Ramadan fasting is associated with transiently impaired insulin sensitivity, compensated for by an increased p3-cell function. However, the pattern of insulin resistance-mediating adipocytokines suggests a potentially beneficial metabolic effect of Ramadan fasting." http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-long-can-a-person-sur/ http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-long-can-a-per... "At the age of 74 and already slight of build, Mahatma Gandhi, the famous nonviolent campaigner for India's independence, survived 21 days of total starvation while only allowing himself sips of water. In a 1997 article in the British Medical Journal, Michael Peel, senior medical examiner at the Medical Foundation for the Care of Victims of Torture, cites well-documented studies reporting survivals of other hunger strikers for 28, 36, 38 and 40 days." http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-17095605 http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-17095605 "Experts believe it is possible for the human body to survive without food for up to two months."
- lawlesst 12y agoDr. Valter Longo, who was an author of this study, was on the Diane Rehm Show in January of 2014 with others discussing the benefits of fasting. All the panelists endorse fasting to some extent but it was a lively discussion that summarizes some his research as well as related research that advocates for shorter fasting periods. http://thedianerehmshow.org/shows/2014-01-09/latest-research-intermittent-fasting-0 http://thedianerehmshow.org/shows/2014-01-09/latest-research...
- ruben94 12y agothat means no water too ?
- yourapostasy 12y agoUsually a fast means you can drink non-caloric liquids, water being the preference. There are many different kinds of fasts, and some are less strict than others, but for the most part water is allowed in all of them.
- Mz 12y agoFrom what I have read, the gut constitutes about 70% of the immune system. And in alternative med circles, it is pretty well known that digestive enzymes in pill form can also be used as antivirals (something I have done with prescription digestive enzymes). The gut, like the respiratory system, is lined with mucus because it needs to manage a complex process of letting in things the body requires for life while screening out things that are dangerous. So, if the conclusions of this study are at all accurate, perhaps part of the mechanism is that fasting reduces the load on the system for a time, reduces the amount of sorting out which foreign material to use as building blocks and which foreign material to treat as dangerous invaders so it can put resources to other uses.
- fady 12y agoi fasted for 14 days on spirulina tablets and water as an office bet to prove its effectiveness and still take it everyday. every now and then i do 3-5 day fast to cleanse my body, but technically i'm still eating food. i have yet to do any blood tests to prove its effectiveness besides my own experiments and what i've read. i also don't recommend people doing a fast for 14 days...maybe 3-5 days at first. after the first few days without eating normal/cooked food it became easier per say, as cravings went down and your body goes into fast mode, even when consuming raw spirulina. i found weekends to be tough as you tend to go out more, and ads are everywhere for food. also, after the second day you really start to shed water weight and your caloric intake dips into the negatives, as spirulina has about 10 calories per serving which is about 3g. i took an average about 30-60 tablets a day, roughly 2/3g (4-6 tabs) per doze. you drink a lot of water (which you should be doing anyway) m-f was easier for me as you're busy with work when compared to the weekends. it was asked, how will we know if i'm honest and actually don't eat? we decided on the honor system and we did the math, loosely. in 14 days i should lose about 14lbs, at 1 pound /day, so i did a weigh in before and after. on the last day i weighed in and i did lose about a pound a day with a total of 14.6 lbs lost and i felt..good?/fine, lost weight, had new perspective at starvation, and food itself. you still should eat more than spirulina, which i did at 9pm that monday...green apples and raw chocolate bars were my choices :) spirulina (cyanobacteria) gives you insane amounts of energy and contains a boat load of nutrients (rich in vitamin A (beta-carotene), B1, B2, B3, B6, E, and K). it also converts sunlight to protein more efficiently than any other living thing. it has the highest content of protein of any other food source around roughly (65-71%). its ancient food, and one of the important foods of the future. it along with other raw foods (fruits/veggies) IMHO is better for you than any other human made sludge/supplements. you can't beat real food and nature.
- scrapcode 12y agoCan you share further reading material or studies behind spirulina?
- keenerd 12y agoThe wikipedia page on the topic appears reasonably good: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spirulina_(dietary_supplement) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spirulina_(dietary_supplement) However it can't be the only thing you eat. There were some studies about using spirulina on a spacecraft (or sub) for both 100% of oxygen and food. While it was feasible, it was pretty energy intensive and would tend to kill you after a few months. Something about more protein in the blood than your kidneys could filter? Will try to find a link.
- amelius 12y agoCould this also be used as a viable technique to approach auto-immune diseases like Sjogren's?
- fasting34 12y agoFasted once for 4.5 days (5 nights) and and blood work done just before breaking the fast. The fast was purely water based, cold turkey (no gradual caloric reduction). The first 2 days were a bit hard because I felt hungry, after that I felt no hunger, slept really well, woke up well rested but with tingles in my feet and felt very alert though also calm. One night I woke up to pee (I drank a lot of water) and I still don't remember what happened but I woke up with my head on the toilet bowl. The blood work came up all messed up. Glucose levels were extremely low. Sedimentation rate extremely high. Lots of ketones in the urine. Broke the fast with some fruit juice and had no problems. I've also engaged in intermittent water fading for about 3 months. All went fine. Once spent almost 40 hours of total fasting (no water). Do not recommend it, I felt seriously messed up.
- knappador 12y agoThe word "regenerate" has got to be a bit of a stretch. It's not like decades of DNA mutations are going away. I've done fasts on relatively nothing for over five days. Early on, you get some "empty-stomach intelligence" where your mind is just more alert because of plenty of oxygen (from not digesting) and probably some evolution that favored apes that got observant and driven when hungry as opposed to lazy. Fasting long enough to get the effects in the paper will use up all your glycogen stocks. Read wiki on starvation for details, but basically you want to have a small supply of starches to keep your skeletal muscle from breaking down to feed your brain. About two days in, without some glucose supply, you will unavoidably slow down. Lethargy will commence when your brain is starving. It is not euphoric. It is the world slipping out of grip without you noticing. As long as your taking care of your mandatory glucose supply, fasting over three days or more will lead to a common theme in all nutrition and health papers: all processes that break things down for re-use are up-regulated and all processes that consume resources are down-regulated. It's not difficult to propose that a system composed of mostly brand-new, turned over cells and muscles with all their proteins aligned to the principle stresses is more protein efficient than one resulting from plenty of nutrients floating around like entrepreneurs with too much money. Fasting would be expected to result in general house-cleaning so that protein that's not accomplishing much ends up reallocated to doing something useful. Some examples of where this shows up in scientific papers is the increased sensitivity to chemotherapy of cancer cells when the patient is fasting. One proposed mechanism was an up-regulation of registration for immune-system induced self-destruction through the normal pathway; a badly functioning protein might go ahead and function sufficiently in the up-regulated pathway. More obvious benefits from fasting are the same as those of anything where you build up self-discipline and also getting in touch with the difference between hunger and a lack of being full; they are much more distinct after a fast. Cravings for sugar are gone because your hormones for hunger and satiety are all operating properly, as is your pancreas. My favorite way to get empty is to just drink water and/or coffee (black) or tea. Fluids, no macro-nutrients. Get some glucose from some bread. Get some micro-nutrients from some yogurt and rabbit food. Let the rest slip into the starvation mode. Stress level and blood pressure will decline into a kind of euphoria as long as you don't over-do the calorie starving to the point that you're thinking on muscle protein. I've done it. All the mechanisms have obvious symptoms. If you are just ketogenic and in starvation, you feel euphoric and completely without variations in energy. If you are beyond starvation and skeletal protein is being converted to glucose, you piss dark yellow and feel like you're on anesthetic. Either way you lose a lot of weight, your energy will regulate much more tightly, and you won't be bothered by hunger, and you'll be drinking coffee as nature intended it instead of some holiday special milk-shake. It's well-established that reduced calorie diets promote longevity and that the spectrum of metabolic syndrome conditions are associated with all sorts of bad things, so although I'm not a doctor, I don't expect to have any regret about recommending anyone try coffee fasting to put their system through its paces.
- cheepin 12y agoThis is mostly unrelated to the title, but for those of you wondering what the limit of fasting is, an interesting study on a very obese man had him on water and vitamins for over a year (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2495396/pdf/postmedj00315-0056.pdf http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2495396/pdf/post...). The 3 meals a day rhetoric has been widespread (some even advocating even more than that), but it seems a bit overblown.
- arunitc 12y agoI have been trying intermittent fasting for the past three weeks - finish my dinner by 7 and breakfast the next day at 11 or 12. Initially it was difficult, but you get used to it quite fast. One thing I have noticed is my afternoon drowsiness has completely disappeared. I used to feel extremely lethargic and just couldn't put my mind to anything. Now I'm completely alert and my productivity has increased dramatically.
- bsdsailor 12y agoI participated in the eastern orthodox church (Christian) for a few years and was introduced to their fasting (no meat or dairy products, and eating small amounts). First timers are advised to start slowly (omit one thing) and gradually get to full fasting. The typical fasting schedule is to fast on Wednesday and Friday (with a couple of exceptions) of each week. There are also long fasting periods before Easter and Christmas (and 2 or 3 shorter fasting periods). Initially, it was quite difficult but over time became much easier. Over time I lost some weight (although that was not an objective) and generally began feeling healthier and more energetic.
- justinpaulson 12y agoThought I would weigh in as I have a personal interest and history with fasting. I once fasted for 25 days on nothing but water. I biked to class and work daily during the fast. After a couple days, hunger cravings disappeared. After two weeks I began to gain a mental clarity that I had not encountered before. I would get a head rush when I stood up too quickly after about 15'r days, but this was remedied by taking a deep breath beforehand. You begin to see and think of things differently when you find that you have given up an activity like eating that is so fundamental to human existence. I lost about 30 pounds (196-166) but almost immediately gained 15 back when I started eating again. I still remember how amazing a strawberry tasted the first time I ate after 25 days. I found a new appreciation for all types of foods I had never enjoyed before Infasted. It was a monumental experience in my life. There are some commenters claiming different things about fasting, but the body is a miraculous thing and it can go quite some time without food. I plan to complete a 40 day fast along the lines of the Pythagoreans, Buddha, Jesus, and the ancient Egyptian Schools. I do not, however, recommend this for everyone. An average person should have no problems with a prolonged fast, but there are no guarantees that you do not have some dormant medical issue. I went about my fast rather naively with no medical supervision, and though I had no negative consequences, I can not recommend my actions to others for obvious reasons. I am merely sharing my personal experience. In a more relevant note to the article, I have found that fasting always makes me recover from an illness more quickly. If I have a cold or any other trivial illness I always fast and recover fairly quickly, again N=1. But I did come to the conclusions of this idea after extensive research into the benefits of fasting.
- mipapage 12y agoI did quite the same for 15 days and had many of the same results. Like anything, until you do it you don't really get the magnitude of the results, in my case like yours also monumental. I drink a lot of coffee; when fasting I remember that I though differently, less hurried, more clear, and wondered what the field of design would be like without stimulants.
- shanusmagnus 12y agoThe mental clarity you mention is interesting. Did you by any chance do stuff during that stretch that would give a more objective mental performance -- meaning, was there a quantitative way for you to evaluate your 'mental clarity'? I ask because I've water-fasted for two days on several occasions, and I've always broken because the mental handicap was just too much, and I've had work to do.[1] In particular, I've found that writing code and writing research papers is almost impossible on day 2. However, I've wondered if either a) pushing through it, or b) keto-adapting beforehand might prevent the mental slowness. I know a superstar scientist who claims that he thinks better in ketosis, so presumably the mechanism for pushing through it would be to get to the point of keto-adaptation. [1] Well, that's kind of a copout. I could always do it while on vacation or something. So mental handicap + willpower.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]