6 ms·
Uber drivers say rideshare surge pricing backfired on New Year’s Eve
- moonka 12y agoLooks like Uber has set up a system where either the riders will be unhappy with high surges, or drivers will be unhappy with the normal pricing on big nights. I never thought abut that side of it.
- davis_m 12y agoThe criticisms of the Uber driver in the article seems to reflect that of the traditional taxi driver when Uber came onto the scene.
- untog 12y agoI'm not too surprised. Uber has created a perception that their service will be unaffordably expensive at peak times like this, so people don't even check. I actually did check, and they were running at a 3.5x surge price in NYC. I stood on a street corner for 30 seconds and flagged down a yellow cab easily, so you might say their offer was lacking. EDIT: reading the article again, I think there's something more of interest in here. Drivers are annoyed at their lack of surge earnings, which makes me wonder to what extent they're unhappy with how much they make at regular prices, and how much they depend on surge pricing windows to really make money.
- mikecb 12y agoI'm not exactly sure how Uber's surge algorithms work, but this seems like it should be mitigated the smaller the price and time adjustments are made. It's not like they don't have the data to do that.
- ethanhunt_ 12y agoI saw something strange here in Seattle. Usually there is surge pricing whenever there are few cars around. However I checked multiple times on New Years Day at around 12:30AM and the surge pricing was >4.5x, but there were loads of UberXs around. Like, 10 cars within a couple blocks. And if I dragged the gps marker 10 streets over, another huge cluster of cars would show up. It looked to me like Uber overrode the algorithm and jacked up the prices really high, even though there wasn't such high demand for Ubers. I regularly take Uber at 9AM and there will often be no cars in the area (wait time of 8 minutes when usually it's <2 minutes) and the surge shows only 2.0x.
- skuhn 12y agoUber claims that New Years Eve is their highest traffic day. I could imagine they might override the surge algorithm (or give it a nudge) to provide a more consistent price based on their historical data. I've encountered a number of situations where Uber's surge prices annoyed people not simply by how expensive it was, but because the person standing next to them got 2.5x and if they had waited another 10 minutes they might get 1.25x or 8x. The non-repeatability can be frustrating and feel unfair. However, just because NYE 2014 naturally surged to 4.5x doesn't mean that NYE 2015 will, because things change. Not the least of which is the (small, but vocal) backlash against Uber that this article is a part of.
- joezydeco 12y agoUber claims that New Years Eve is their highest traffic day But that was in previous years, right? A lot of things have happened in the last 12 months to change this NYE's outcome: more competition, more of their own cars on the street, a year of bad publicity against Uber, and then telling everyone that there will be surge pricing in effect (instead of letting it happen algorithmically)? How is anyone surprised by the outcome?
- untog 12y agoIt probably speaks (at least partially) to the culture at Uber - that data and algorithms rule all. For the most part that's correct, but things often get unpredictable when you involve humans - no matter how fair surge pricing is when looking at the data, if people feel like it is unfair, they'll object. Right now I don't think Uber does a good job at, for want of a less fluffy term, "feeling sentiment". They're extremely good at parsing past data and extracting conclusions, but that's about it.
- kenzokai 12y ago> that data and algorithms rule all Well actually they don't because they overrode the algorithm instead of letting it do its job. The culture at Uber is actually "greed".
- aaronharnly 12y agoA bidding system could conceivably address this, or just a more dynamic pricing system that reduced fare multipliers as demand sagged. (Or does it work this way already?) Or, just fixed fares and sometimes you can't get a ride. Seems to work for the rest of the transportation system.
- civilian 12y agoYeah, the fare multipliers are already dynamic and NYE's riders got a good deal. The issue is that we've had some highly-noticed surge pricing stories so all of the customers figured "oh yeah, it's going to be horrible surge pricing again and I'm going to be stranded at the FOO Bar after they close." So people changed their plans to either include a DD, use public transit, use traditional taxis, or go somewhere within walking distance. Me and my friends stayed in and drank board games and played tequila.
- lmm 12y agoI was with you until the tequila. Sax on new year's eve is a bad idea.
- slayed0 12y agoa more dynamic pricing system that reduced fare multipliers as demand sagged This is supposedly exactly how it works. Fare multipliers are updated every couple of minutes and fluctuate according to number of available drivers on the road (supply) and number of ride requests (demand).
- msoad 12y agoI am a good example for this. I was planning to use Lyft but then scared of surge pricing and drove my own car. I was lucky to find free street side parking but even paying $40 for parking wouldn't be that bad compared to Lyft/Uber rates that night.
- thinkpad20 12y agoMost people avoid taking their own cars because they're going to be getting wasted, so I'm not surprised you were able to find street parking. I'm guessing your New Years was a little less "festive" than others' :) (I hope it was!)
- msoad 12y agoThere is always that one person who can't drink! :D
- buckbova 12y ago> "There should be some regulation on the numbers of drivers you allow to Lyft," another commenter wrote. "Otherwise it may seem that you are taking advantage of the fact that we are not paid salaries, and you reap the benefits regardless if it effects us." It will self regulate. If there isn't enough money in it, there will be less drivers. When ridership goes up, it will attract more drivers. Isn't that the point?
- untog 12y agoAssuming that these drivers have plenty of other job opportunities to go to, yes.
- badusername 12y agoUber has their own side of the story here: http://blog.uber.com/cheersto2015 http://blog.uber.com/cheersto2015
- tarikjn 12y agolove that first graph, one can clearly read the geographical differences in social behavior.
- ghshephard 12y agoThe entire purpose of surge pricing is to ensure that there is always a care when you want one. The purpose is not profit maximization, but ensuring there will never be a time that I go to Uber, request a vehicle, and not have one appear within a reasonable period of time. If Surge pricing is working then there should be a large number of empty cars waiting for rides. Those cars are incentivized to show up by getting paid more than they normally would for a ride of the same distance.
- pacofvf 12y agoI checked the Uber app in my city at 12:30AM and the rate was 2.0x, closed the app, reopened it until it was at normal 1.0x around 12:50AM, 4 USD was my bill , I used it again at 3:30 AM and the surcharge was 1.5, used it anyway since I was really tired, my bill was 6 USD.
- yuliyp 12y agoWell the assumption of supply adjustments to meet demand in real time that is given for Surge Pricing is just unrealistic. A driver must make a commitment (hours or days before) to be available to drive at a given time. Of course they have no idea what the surge multiplier is, so they'll have to guess. As a result the number of cars on the road is driven by the _expectation_ of the multiplier, rather than the actual multiplier. This affects the demand side too: people remember stories of people getting burned by huge surge multipliers, and as a result adjust their behavior (being more willing to call a normal cab, driving instead of taking a cab). Here again the actual surge multipliers matter less than the expectations. By providing reasonable estimates, they could set surge multipliers that would ensure a high supply of drivers and demand for them, instead of having the curves moved out of whack by overestimation.
- aristus 12y agoThis is a feature, not a bug. :) Uber has created a market with dynamic pricing, but manages to keep both ends of the transaction in the dark until the last possible moment. This information asymmetry is precisely why they are making money hand over fist.
- harryh 12y agoI don't understand why this information asymmetry is more important to their profits than the network effect of controlling a very widely used marketplace?
- jinushaun 12y agoUh... Did someone in the article seriously ask for Uber/Lyft to artificially limit the number of cars on the road? Isn't that one of the problems with traditional taxis? They never learn. Meet the new boss, same as the old boss. I'm glad to be living in a city with a functional public transit system (NYC) so I no longer have to be forced to be robbed by Uber (SF).
- jrockway 12y ago> I'm glad to be living in a city with a functional public transit system Unless you want to go to LaGuardia airport.
- bradleyjg 12y agoThe new Q70 makes it a lot better. Between it and the existing M60 it is not much different than JFK.
- jrockway 12y agoI live in Brooklyn, so it's still a choice between a 20 minute drive or an hour and a half on public transportation. Actually, I think the M60 SBS should be the actual solution to this, but I haven't ridden it yet. I fly out of JFK even if I have to connect somewhere. (That's 18 minutes on LIRR for me.)
- bradleyjg 12y agoWell that makes sense then. Brooklyn to central and northern Queens is one of the worst parts of the whole system. I live in Woodside and have friends in Park Slope, so I definitely feel your pain.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoPerhaps some sort of city-sanctioned "Lyft Medallion" is the disruptive answer they're looking for.
- 12y ago
- apendleton 12y agoI feel like on NYE, in particular, most people don't go out without already having made a plan for how they're going to get home, so even if the actual price turned out to be lower than expected, that might not have boosted demand the way one might expect because many people had already made other transportation arrangements in anticipation of Uber being unaffordably expensive.
- revelation 12y agoFlywheel offered a flat rate of $10 for all cab rides on New Year's Eve. By contrast, Uber sent a mass email warning riders that New Year's Eve would see a spike in passenger demand, potentially skyrocketing prices to over $100 for a ride after midnight. If you want to have no customers, then yeah, this is how you would do that.
- Benjammer 12y agoThat article was pretty much only comprised of anecdotes about drivers being upset about something... They even directly say "hard numbers on tech riders were not available." I want to see the actual data and how Uber, or Lyft came out after NYE. Wasn't the algorithm supposed to help stabilize the supply of Uber cars on the road? I doubt it is designed simply to gouge people when demand is high. It kind of sounds to me like the media pumped up this idea of "OMG look at how screwed these few people were by surge prices!" Then Uber responded to the critics by issuing warnings about high surge prices on NYE. This further solidified this idea that the price would always shoot up on big nights no matter what. So now you have everyone who's ever driven for Uber, plus a bunch of newcomers all going out driving thinking they are all going to be cashing in on $200 fares. Supply goes up, surge goes down. Or maybe surge doesn't go all the way down. Uber would have no reason to make the primary function of their algorithm to make drivers more money, or stabilize driver income. They are trying to increase market share and make money. Maybe they think the NYE demand is very inflexible and thus they can restrict the surge pricing to stay above a certain level and not have much of an effect on demand. This would, however, probably only exacerbate the initial problem with oversupply, as more drivers would see surge pricing in effect and start earlier, and stay out later. There isn't even any anecdotal evidence in the article about the passenger side of the experience, they only have stuff from Lyft/Uber drivers. People act like Uber/Lyft should be nice to the drivers and treat them well, when in reality they are clients, not prized employees. Uber's relationship with the drivers is a business relationship that is very carefully maintained and fine tuned. If you showed me a similar company that treated drivers very well and was still able to keep prices from exploding, I would gladly use that service over the current players, but it just seems to me that they are doing what makes sense given the current marketplace. Isn't it supposed to be a lot easier gig to be an Uber driver than a city cab driver?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]