50 ms·
Nim Advocacy and Promotion Strategies
- hahainternet 12y agoI find it disturbing that languages are now adopting promotion strategies because not enough people are using them. For fuck's sake, focus on improving the language and this will come organically. This isn't a competition as to who has the most popular language, and the most popular languages are always going to be total shit. Just write good code, marketing departments are the bane of the entire IT sphere, you shouldn't be trying to create one for a niche language.
- syllogism 12y agoMost of these suggestions are about how to make Nim more immediately useful to people, e.g. by being more focussed, making sure important libraries are well-optimised, etc. I think it's really good that they're asking, "why aren't more people using our language?". That seems like a great step towards improving it.
- hahainternet 12y agoThat's absolutely a laudable goal, it's simply the idea of a marketing department for a language that I find frustrating.
- Cyther606 12y agoAs reasonable as that is, "if you build it, they will come", is a myth. Say you have an excellent product, and I would absolutely say Nim is excellent. With priority #1 out of the way, you have to speak up for yourself.
- vegabook 12y agoFor better or worse human beings are creatures who like to categorise things. This is how we deal with complexity, even if the categories are not always optimally chosen. Marketing departments inevitably start off with pushing a category for a product and suggesting this is it's "best at" or indeed "only option" angle. This allows we category seeking beings to remember it better, and indeed, provides a secure "beachhead", even if very specific, which the product (~language) can dominate and from which it can credibly grow. Nim does not seem to have this beachhead, and basically is therefore diluted across categories and is harder to remember. I therefore agree with the original post that Nim does not have unique selling point if you will. Separately, "marketing" is of course a term loaded with negatives, but it is essentially about communicating a benefit in a very crowded and competitive environment. That benefit has to be very clearly enunciated and pushed, and if it is a clear and simple message, then it will be effective. It's a secondary concern that a language is a polyglot at all sorts of use cases, is good at everything. It first has to have users. Users have lots of choice so you're best off giving a small subset of them the idea that this is the perfect tool for their specific use case, and grow from there, than telling everyone this is good at everything, even if that is true. Unfortunately the best all rounder is often forgotten if she/he's not number one at something. TL;DR: In a crowded and complex marketplace marketing's segmentation methods are unfortunately needed.
- klibertp 12y ago> focus on improving the language and this will come organically Or not. There are dozens of languages which are good, a couple of decades old, and only known and used by a very small community. They all followed your advice and in effect they "lost" man-centuries of contributions to other languages. I don't know how well this is going to play out for Nim, but for a project which can't even have its own Wiki page because of how unpopular it is it may well be a good thing.
- proveanegative 12y ago>For fuck's sake, focus on improving the language and this will come organically. I don't have statistics to back it up but I would wager that waiting for users to come organically is among the top reasons software projects of any kind fail. Why should programming languages be special in this way?
- melling 12y agoThat's not true. Being the first few people means that the tools are not developed, common questions aren't answered, books aren't written, getting help is difficult, etc. There are only 18 questions on StackOverFlow, for example: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/tagged/nim http://stackoverflow.com/questions/tagged/nim People don't want to burn too many cycles discovering how the language works.
- mmfZ4e4OqQ7RRwP 12y agoThe fact that there are only 18 questions on StackOverflow could also mean that the language is that good that rarely you find something requiring further explanation. Or maybe Nim users use the Nim forum instead for questions (http://forum.nim-lang.org http://forum.nim-lang.org), where finding a C forum or Python forum is not that easy/direct.
- IndianAstronaut 12y agoThis is akin to saying a startup should thrive only on its merits alone and not use any marketing. Not going to work.
- fsloth 12y agoAs an engineer I would be persuaded by a) implementing something practical but simple simply, b) implementing something a bit more complex legibly and c) writing about the results which explain why they are neat. The killer promoter is of course a book. I usually wait before starting on new languages so I'm not slowed down by incomplete tooling, missing compiler features etc. What really gets me going is a 1-2-3 tutorial which explains how to implement something non-trivial like calling c dlls.
- okasaki 12y agoThe package manager Nimble is written in 800 lines of Nim: https://github.com/nim-lang/nimble/blob/master/src/nimble.nim https://github.com/nim-lang/nimble/blob/master/src/nimble.ni... Maybe that would satisfy (a)
- bjourne 12y agoAlright, then show me! For example, the beginner tutorial was linked a while ago (http://nim-lang.org/tut1.html http://nim-lang.org/tut1.html) and I wouldn't criticize it at all, because it's well written, but it doesn't show me why I would care about Nim when there are dozens of languages I could choose instead. It looks like Python, with a little more types. Fwiw, I'm also a language geek and my favorite language is Factor. If I wanted to evangelize it, I could show how idiomatic Python or Haskell code translated to Factor takes up less than half or a third in size. So that's its USP (Unique Selling Point) -- really short code. What is Nim's USP? Julia: "fresh approach to mathematical computing", Rust: "safe resource disposal without GC", Go: "C successor backed up by Google", Swift: "Replacement for Objective-C", Clojure: "Scheme on the JVM", Nim: "no idea what to write here" Is it the Why should I be excited? paragraph: "Nim is the only language that leverages automated proof technology to perform a disjoint check for your parallel code. Working on disjoint data means no locking is required and yet data races are impossible" If I understood what the hell that means, maybe I would be excited. :)
- eaurouge 12y agoI am excited about Nim because it compiles to C that can run on an ARM microcontroller. I believe this was a possibility at some point, but I don't know if this is a priority for Araq. So (personally) I see it as a (potential) "C replacement for embedded systems".
- detaro 12y agoWon't Rust and Go likely get there equally easy?
- eaurouge 12y agoNim compiles down to C and can produce code to run directly on bare metal. My understanding is that Go and Rust (to a lesser degree) require a runtime. Perhaps someone with better knowledge of all three languages could chime in.
- 12y ago
- trwired 12y agoI am looking for a systems programming language that would work well with battle prooven GUI toolkits such as Qt. Would Nim be a good choice?
- eaurouge 12y agoWriting Qt-flavored C++ was a lot of fun last I tried it (some five years ago). And now there's QML. Have you tried writing your entire project in Qt? It may be a smoother experience than you think.
- trwired 12y agoI have some experience using C++ with both Qt and wxWidgets, but I am looking for an excuse to learn something new. And a systems language with Python inspired syntax and comparable expressiveness that is suitable for creating GUI apps is something that would definitely make me want to investigate Nim further.
- Cyther606 12y agoYou may be in luck: https://github.com/filcuc/NimQml https://github.com/filcuc/NimQml
- trwired 12y agoThank you for the link, but I can reasonably expect that Qt bindings for Nim either exist or will become available soon, as most languages that get any traction get them. I still don't know, however, if it's a good choice to try and put a GUI app together in Nim. Will it surprise me with a huge binary, like Rust does? [1] Will it be easy to develop in it on multiple platforms? I can find all those things myself, but in the spirit of what the OP describes as putting the best foot forward, I'd like to be able to quickly assess whether the language is potentially a better choice to solve my next problem than those I already know or am planning to learn. [1] - http://endl.ch/content/cxx2rust-pains-wrapping-c-rust-example-qt5 http://endl.ch/content/cxx2rust-pains-wrapping-c-rust-exampl...
- cormullion 12y agoPerhaps they could fix the Wikipedia and Wikibooks presence? Has it really been "banned" from Wikipedia?
- def- 12y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Nimrod_(programming_language)_(2nd_nomination) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletio... > Lacks reliable independent secondary sources to establish notability as required by WP:GNG. Every source is WP:PRIMARY. Every one of them. Googling turned up posts to online discussion forums but nothing useful. Additionally, I note that the decision to delete at the previous AfD was unanimous for the same reasons. > Perhaps think of it this way: a language becomes notable when people who haven't been involved in its creation start writing about it. If/when this language gets to that point you'll have no problem creating an article. At the moment, though, there just hasn't been enough uptake to get the coverage we need for notability.
- bwilliams 12y agoMaybe update the site design and logo? It looks very 2000's and could be a huge benefit.
- vardump 12y agoAn aesthetically nice website is a neutral or a negative signal when it comes to technical subjects, like computer languages. Content first, graphical design is completely secondary. Just need to represent information about the technical subject clearly. If the technical merits are there, adopters will come. Technical people are not baffled by $animal . $excrement. Instead, it puts them off. Edit: I get downvoted a lot, but could someone prove me wrong? What technical concepts (like programming languages) got popular with help of nice graphical design?
- bwilliams 12y agoThat kind of thinking will only prevent adoption, not help it. Aesthetics are important to technical subjects as well. It shows that a lot of time and consideration have gone into every part of the project, not just the technical side. It's also a good sign of community support/interaction. I will agree that content is the most important, but you shouldn't write off aesthetics so easily, especially when you want people to be interested and adopt your technology.
- vardump 12y agoTry to google some popular languages. Use http://archive.org/ http://archive.org/ to see how their respective pages looked like in the past. I find it hard to believe aesthetics helped their adoption. Interesting article, related to web design and conversion rate: https://blog.kissmetrics.com/shocking-truth-about-graphics/ https://blog.kissmetrics.com/shocking-truth-about-graphics/
- bwilliams 12y agoHere's Ruby for example, before it was popular: (2004) https://web.archive.org/web/20040211074335/http://www.ruby-lang.org/en/ https://web.archive.org/web/20040211074335/http://www.ruby-l... and here's when/right before it (arguably) started picking up a community https://web.archive.org/web/20070805190709/http://www.ruby-lang.org/en/ https://web.archive.org/web/20070805190709/http://www.ruby-l... (2007) Popularity being based on the Rails 2.0 release since that's when Ruby/Rails seemingly started to take off. It's a bit before my time so if anyone knows better feel free to correct me.
- lazzlazzlazz 12y agoNim is very, very close to being the most competitive language in my toolkit. If JSON were handled more elegantly, like Python, I'd probably be completely sold. Binding to Python would also be an absolutely killer feature.
- mmfZ4e4OqQ7RRwP 12y agoTake a look at http://forum.nim-lang.org/t/360 http://forum.nim-lang.org/t/360 for Python bindings, that should lead you to https://github.com/micklat/NimBorg https://github.com/micklat/NimBorg.
- vezzy-fnord 12y agoI don't understand why Python comparisons are being thrown around here. From my limited experience with Nim (I liked the name Nimrod better, but oh well), it seemed a lot more Wirthian than it did Pythonesque. And of course: AST macros.
- phantom_oracle 12y agoLack of tutorials... Learning the syntax/features of the language should be part of documentation, not a tutorial. "Hello World" as the core/intro example with nothing else after that (or trivial command-line programs) will not get many adopters. Show people how to build REST APIs, GUI programs (like a text editor), a small web-server and maybe some other scientific/math example. Showing just a few features and then saying "go build" will not get normal people to adopt the language. Only "savants" will pick it up. Give examples/libraries and people will build on those. The syntax is also not that close to Python. It is obscure in some places and not as readable. If you're going to compare it to Python, do a readability test: Write the exact same application in Python and Nim and then ask somebody else to compare the 2. I tried to pick up Nim, but I was fighting against it every time I tried to go beyond a trivial CLI program. I'll take Pythons slower implementation with 3000 libraries over Nims "C-like" speed where I can't even build a REST API. I like Nim, but if all the effort of promoters is just promotion, the language will stay where it is. You geniuses working on Nim for a long time need to share your examples and show the noobs how you built things with decent screencasts/tutorials/lessons. Something tells me that even just 3 decent examples where real applications are built (eg. a game like Snake using a GUI and game-engine/lib) will get +1000 Youtube hits in no time.