4 ms·
That analysis is based on the assumption that the copyright term from the first US copyright act from 1790 somehow got it right for all time, even for forms of
by tzs 12y ago
That analysis is based on the assumption that the copyright term from the first US copyright act from 1790 somehow got it right for all time, even for forms of expression that had not yet been invented, and even though the economics of production and copying might vastly change.
Can you justify that assumption?
- Jacqued 12y agoRight. And the World in general, and scientific, artistic and cultural creation in particular, have only gotten faster and faster since then, so we can only assume that copyright terms should be much shorter than originally thought up in the eighteenth century. So maybe 28 years should be a wild upper bound.
- anigbrowl 12y agoI don't think that's true. You can create more elaborate works in less time thanks to technology, but you could sketch or compose a copyrightable work in minutes a century ago. There once was a property case which was wildly absurd on its face A camera, an ape and an unforeseen jape fell outside copyrightable space ^ 3 minutes of creative work. Refers to http://www.pri.org/stories/2014-08-07/internet-goes-ape-over-monkey-selfie-and-copyright-battle-it-sparked http://www.pri.org/stories/2014-08-07/internet-goes-ape-over... Now this is not such a great thing that it deserves protection until 2084+my remaining lifespan, but my point is that verses of this sort could have been composed and committed to paper in 3 minutes in 1814 just as easily as in 2014.
- tzs 12y agoThere's a interesting essay by Stephen Breyer, from before he became a Supreme Court justice, that comes to the opposite conclusion. He points out that because technology was slow in the 18th century, there was little need for copyright. When a new book was published, for example, by the time those who would make copies could set up their presses and go into production most of the market for the book had been satisfied by the original publisher. The faster things get, the stronger the case for copyright.
- MereInterest 12y agoThat would give a case for a stronger copyright, but not a longer copyright. I would imagine that any 18th century competitor would be able to set up their printing presses within a year at the most. Currently, with 21st century scanning and printing, it could be done effectively immediately. Therefore, the only difference between the situations is within that first year. Certainly, this argument suggests that copyright should be strengthened relative to its 18th century form. However, this strengthening should not be in lengthening copyright terms, as the only difference is within the first year, which is covered under either copyright term. I am not arguing for an elimination of copyright. It is necessary as a starting incentive. However, in its current form, the length is far too long.
- incompatible 12y agoHow would you suggest strengthening copyright? Penalties are already draconian in some cases. Should there be universal Internet surveillance and the dispatch of a SWAT team at the first sign of any violation?
- Dylan16807 12y agoThe theoretical method of strengthening doesn't matter. And it's not vs. current law; current law is already stronger. The important thing is that lengthening is not appropriate.
- throwawaykf05 12y ago> Should there be universal Internet surveillance and the dispatch of a SWAT team at the first sign of any violation? This is not possible, which is precisely why > Penalties are already draconian in some cases. This is probably also why the simplest way of strengthening copyright in the Internet era is by lengthening terms. Most other alternatives would infringe too much on personal privacies.
- kalleboo 12y agoIn the law, copyright has already been strengthened quite a lot. From here the only way to strengthen copyright is to increase public support of it. Shortening terms to something reasonable could help.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- MereInterest 12y agohttp://arstechnica.com/uncategorized/2007/07/research-optimal-copyright-term-is-14-years/ http://arstechnica.com/uncategorized/2007/07/research-optima... With copyright's explicit purpose of "promoting the sciences and useful arts", one can derive the ideal length. It must be long enough that there is incentive to create, but not so long that future generations cannot use it as a platform. Based on this professor's calculations, 14 years is ideal. 28 years, then, should be perfectly sufficient.
- anigbrowl 12y agoOh, dear - that substantially overstates the conclusions drawn in the paper itself: http://rufuspollock.org/papers/optimal_copyright.pdf http://rufuspollock.org/papers/optimal_copyright.pdf The author warns that estimation of the ideal term depends on a number of imponderable factors like 'cultural decay' which are necessarily estimated, as well as discount rate for economic returns on copyrighted works. After considering a range of possibilities for these parameters through the medium of a probability density function, he observes that the median of the distribution is about 15 years - in other words, there's a 50% probability of that being the optimal term. The mode is about 20 years, ie the most likely suggested term for any random sample of the input value ranges. Going on, 'From the underlying cumulative distribution function we can calculate percentiles and find the 95th percentile at just under 31 years, the 99th percentile at 39 years and the 99.9th percentile at just over 47 years. This would suggest, that at least under the parameters ranges used here, one can be extremely confident that copyright term should be 50 years or less – and it is highly like that term is under 30 years (95th percentile).' So while this paper is great find, I think you need to walk back your conclusion significantly. Also, we need to be very careful about the initial assumptions on which the theoretical foundation is based: 'C is a variable denoting production costs of ‘originals’ (authorised reproductions) and U a variable denoting the production cost of ‘copies’ (unauthorised reproductions).' The author is essentially modeling the case of works-for-hire commissioned by a publisher and put on the market more or less immediately. His utility function aims to optimize the production of copyrightable works while maximizing public welfare (in terms of access to the largest possibly number of works), but it's important to note that he's using production in the sense of distribution of an already-created work by a rightsholder. This doesn't address things like creation time which may or may not be affected by technology (whereas technology has a huge effect on the reproduction of costs), or delays between creation and publication (which as I've observed elsewhere in the thread can be substantial).
- logfromblammo 12y agoAfter a traffic survey, the speed limit of the road is often set to the 85th percentile of speeds that people actually choose to drive on it. I propose that each genre of copyright-able work be subjected to a statistical analysis, to determine the number of years at which 80% of the total lifetime revenue of a work has been collected. Set the base copyright term for that genre to be the 80th percentile of that number. So you might see that 80% of fiction novels earn 80% of their revenues within 10 years or less (invented numbers). If that were the case, set the default free copyright term to 10 years. Obviously, some outliers will be late bloomers, so perhaps you make a reasonable accommodation for those by granting renewals that each last 5 years, for a flat fee plus a modest percentage of the earned revenue, which then increases with every renewal. That would work just fine for the stated purpose of promoting the useful arts. But I suspect that copyright is now also being used for the purpose of eliminating same-owner competition from older works. For instance, why watch the newest Disney animated film when you could watch any of them older than N years? Why play Gameseries 7 when you could also play Gameseries 1 through 6? So perhaps also add a "quashing and abandonment" clause, wherein if the owner refuses or is unable to license or sell copies for N years, the work enters the public domain. Given those reasonable ideas, I think maybe the founders were just guessing, and they probably didn't guess correctly for 2014.
- incompatible 12y agoI'd say copyright terms should probably be shorter today than in 1790, since the speed of publishing and distribution has increased significantly. Five years should be more than enough time to profit from a work.
- anigbrowl 12y agoIf I'm a publisher, that gives me every incentive to string you as an author along for 5 years and then publish without paying you anything. Lots of projects take longer than 5 years to reach the market - think of novels rejected by multiple publishers, film scripts trapped in development hell and so on. Copyright terms begin on creation, ie when the work is fixed in some medium - not when it's first published. try considering cases other than big commercial success stories that make a lot of money in a short time.
- dkuntz2 12y agoBut doesn't each subsequent edit constitute a separate copyright? The publisher might be able to publish the first draft, but they wouldn't have the rights to subsequent drafts and revisions. Of course, my understanding could be completely wrong, and revisions might not constitute a separate work.
- anigbrowl 12y agoYou're assuming the author is constantly revising and improving the work. If I massage your ego enough while running out the clock I could probably save myself a lot. Of course, the market would change and authors would offer shorter options and so on; I'm just pointing one perverse incentive that would become available.
- dkuntz2 12y agoIt just seems like a stretch to me that they'd be able to string an author along for five years after being given the final draft. After a year without progress I feel like most authors would try another publisher.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y ago>That analysis is based on the assumption that the copyright term from the first US copyright act from 1790 somehow got it right for all time If anything it should be shorter. So if you're open to re-negotiating this duration, I move that we reduce it to 3 years, all-inclusive. Furthermore, I move that DRM-ed works be made ineligible for all copyright protection. You either get DRM or copyright, but not both. Finally, I move that corporations can be sued to have their copyright privileges revoked for a period of no less than 50 years if they are caught destroying or interfering with works that should eventually enter the public domain. No more dumping film reels in the river because the warehouse costs are inconvenient. But, if you don't want to put this on the table to be negotiated, then perhaps we can live with 14 years. Up to you.