6 ms·
U.S. ends TARP with $15.3B profit
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mikhailt 12y agoWait, WTF... At the end: > Overall, the auto bailout was the one big money loser for TARP. Even with the Ally sale, taxpayers lost about $9.2 billion. Do they mean it could have been 15.3 + 9.2 billion in the end for the total $24.5 billions in profit? I don't think taxpayers lost anything if the program broke even.
- philwelch 12y agoIf they bailed out the banks but not the car companies, the treasury would have profited 24.5 billion. If they bailed out the banks and the car companies and the car companies earned money, the treasury would have profited much more. But then, the treasury didn't do the bailout to profit. They did it to short-circuit a potential Great Depression. From that standpoint, it was a success at any price.
- waps 12y agoI think the misunderstanding is that Ally Financial is "part of the auto industry". Yes, really. So here's where the numbers come from : 1) +15.3 billion : auto industry + financial industry which is 0.06% per year, for 3.5% over 6 years 2) -9.2 billion : auto industry 3) +1.3 billion : Ally Financial Therefore: 4) (inferred) -10.5 billion : auto industry - Ally Financial 5) (inferred) +24.5 billion : financial industry TARP First caveat. Given the risk on the troubled assets, this is a pathetically bad return over 6 years. These were the worst of the worst, something everybody else would have demanded something like 13-14% interest per year for in 2008. Second caveat, we all know why the finance industry came out ahead (not necessarily a good publication in this link, just the first reasonable link on Google for this subject) : http://www.financialsense.com/contributors/greg-weldon/stock-market-fed-balance-sheet-correlation http://www.financialsense.com/contributors/greg-weldon/stock... So really, the full story is, $426 billion TARP + $3 Trillion in loans to banks was sufficient to convince the banks to pay $450 billion to the US government. They have not, of course, paid back the 3 trillion, nor are they capable of doing so. Third caveat, a lot of that $3 trillion has gone into stock buybacks, effectively giving the money to investors in S&P 500 companies (especially financials). The idea is that the S&P should continue to increase in value, despite the money flow having stopped (mostly). History teaches though, that when this happens, a more common result is a stock market crash. That doesn't happen until loans aren't free anymore though (currently the FED says rate hike will happen around June). Frankly if you're in a startup, make sure to have a job at Google, Yahoo or Amazon or some large player by the time the rate hikes happen.
- pbreit 12y ago0.6% per year. Still pretty bad.
- mikeyouse 12y agoMeh, it's more complex than that since they didn't put in $426B on day one and then get out $450B on the last day, you'd have to weight each investment on its own time frame and run independent returns. Either way, the bailout wasn't set up to make a profit, so it's fairly pointless to judge the returns..
- gbhn 12y agoExcept politically if course, where returns were abysmal.
- maaku 12y agoIf only all bailouts went like this...
- _almosnow 12y agoDoes that profit takes into account inflation and stuff? Because if not the outcome could be somewhat different. However, even if they broke even, the potential negative effects that the bailout prevented are huge.
- crazy1van 12y agoIf we're going to think about the bailout like an investment (like the article seems to do), even more important than inflation is comparing this return to other potential returns. According to the article, the USG put $426B in and made $15.3B. That's a 3.5% return on that money over 5+ years. As an investment, that seems terrible. If the USG had just bought an S&P500 index fund on Oct 3, 2008, they would have made something like +70% (Source: Yahoo Finance). Again, this is just looking at TARP like an investment by the government.
- intopieces 12y agoBut the S&P500 includes companies that were, in some way or another, affected by the bailout. So that comparison is not appropriate.
- fleitz 12y agoThe government also spent $2 trillion in QE so if that money wasn't in the market...
- justincormack 12y agoQE has been profitable too, so far. Unwinding it may be less so.
- spuiszis 12y agoWhere are you getting profitability from?
- protomyth 12y ago"When Congress created TARP, it authorized up to $700 billion for the programs. That authority was later reduced to $475 billion. To date, a total of $426.3 billion has been disbursed under TARP. As of November 30, 2014, cumulative collections under TARP, together with Treasury’s additional proceeds from the sale of non-TARP shares of AIG6, have exceeded total disbursements by $14.0 billion7. Treasury estimates that the combined overall cost of TARP will be approximately $37.5 billion. These estimates assume that the budget for TARP housing programs will be disbursed in full and do not include Treasury’s additional proceeds from its non-TARP AIG shares." http://www.treasury.gov/initiatives/financial-stability/reports/Documents/November%202014%20Monthly%20Report%20to%20Congress.pdf http://www.treasury.gov/initiatives/financial-stability/repo... Reading the press release is nice, but it does help to actually read the report to Congress.
- prokes 12y agoAt the cost of creating moral hazard, the full impact of which has yet to be seen.
- fleitz 12y agoWhat they fail to note is all the good that could have come from not doing TARP, what innovative services might have sprung up instead? Sure, Detroit might be dead (isn't it already?) but there would also be a huge infrastructure for Tesla to buy on the cheap. Imagine a world in which Tesla and other startups are the only car manufactures in the US? (Well, save for Ford which didn't need a bailout) What sort of opportunities would there be for FinTech companies sans Goldman, et al? How many small businesses could have been started with $475 billion?
- soAsian 12y ago>What they fail to note is all the good that could have come from not doing TARP, what innovative services might have sprung up instead? Maybe None. It could escalated into Great Depression and no cheap money for start up like Uber, SnapChat..etc.
- kolbe 12y ago...because the Federal Reserve offered the real bailout. TARP's few hundred billion would be worth far less had the Fed not printed trillions, and used it to buy all of the banks' bad MBSs at above-market rates.
- marze 12y agoDoesn't the purchase of the bank's junky assets at above-market valuations go by the name "quantitative easing"? Is that what you are referring to?
- vitobcn 12y agoProbably, he's referring to this official GAO (Government Accountability Office) audit report [1] from 2011, which exposed the Fed secretly loaned 16 trillion USD (!!!) to big banks worldwide at 0% rates (afaik, currently fully unreturned). Here are the top four [2]: Citigroup - 2.5 T$ Morgan Stanley - 2.0 T$ Merrill Lynch - 1.9 T$ BOA - 1.3 T$ Frankly, I'm surprised this didn't receive more attention from the media. [1]: http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d11696.pdf http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d11696.pdf (Table 8, PDF page 144) [2]: http://www.sott.net/article/250592-Audit-of-the-Federal-Reserve-Reveals-16-Trillion-in-Secret-Bailouts http://www.sott.net/article/250592-Audit-of-the-Federal-Rese...
- maxerickson 12y agoThe numbers in those tables are an example of scary addition. Quoting from the text describing the table: For example, an overnight PDCF loan of $10 billion that was renewed daily at the same level for 30 business days would result in an aggregate amount borrowed of $300 billion although the institution, in effect, borrowed only $10 billion over 30 days. In contrast, a TAF loan of $10 billion extended over a 1-month period would appear as $10 billion. As a result, the total transaction amounts shown in table 8 for PDCF are not directly comparable to the total transaction amounts shown for TAF and other programs that made loans for periods longer than overnight. Your fully unreturned is incorrect, many of the loans used to create those totals were payed back the very next day after they were made. A more interesting analysis would show a plot of the outstanding loan balance each institution maintained over time.
- acd 12y agoThis is simply not true us as us citizens has not profited from this. The banks has been printing money like crazy and the American middle class has not gotten richer while the top 1% has gotten really rich. Here is a graph from CNN about it http://money.cnn.com/2011/02/16/news/economy/middle_class/ http://money.cnn.com/2011/02/16/news/economy/middle_class/
- adventured 12y agoThe middle class got one of the world's largest bailouts in the form of record low mortgage rates. They were able to buy homes with cheap rates, and they were able to refinance with cheap rates; and that's still true even now, the homeowner bailout continues. The savings for the middle 50% of Americans is staggering. So yes, average Americans profited in a big way. Further, all homeowners got bailed out via a multi-trillion dollar asset inflation program that re-inflated housing prices. If you own a house, you saw a massive benefit from that bailout.
- antidaily 12y agoThat's not a bailout. Coupled with flat wages and rising costs of living, savings aren't exactly piling up. And home prices are expected to be pretty flat for the foreseeable future.
- adventured 12y agoWould you elaborate on how giving homeowners trillions in wealth by intentionally re-inflating the housing market, and holding down mortgage rates, isn't a bailout? The government & Fed ran programs that directly, by design, benefited all homeowners, to the tune of $5+ trillion.
- spuiszis 12y agoHomeowners aren't benefiting, they've underwater on their mortgages and are selling for pennies on the dollar. It's Blackstone and a number of other clever players who've been at this for years [1]. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-03-14/blackstone-s-home-buying-binge-ends-as-prices-surge-mortgages.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-03-14/blackstone-s-home-b...
- littletimmy 12y agoThe banks too profited handsomely from TARP, thereby creating a huge moral hazard. The government gave the banks money, which they used to make profits, AND then returned money to the government. Let that sink in for a second, the banks sunk the economy, and the government helped them make huge profits.
- rhino369 12y agoTARP didn't wipe out the massive losses the banks suffered because of financial crisis. It just allowed them to survive it. The banks who really fucked up were all sold, essentially at gunpoint, to banks who were still solvent. Those banks were sold for pennies on dollar compared to what they were priced at months before. Of course, without government intervention, they'd get nothing in bankruptcy. I think losing 95% of your investment is enough to avoid huge moral hazard. Society benefits because letting them fail sinks the economy much further.
- Zigurd 12y agoThe positive aspects of saving a banking system don't directly cancel out the negative aspects of creating moral hazard by doing it in a way that rewards TBTF banks. There were multiple options for saving the US banking system, which was insolvent as a whole, since the supposedly not-insolvent banks would have gone down the tubes instantly had any of the larger insolvent banks been allowed to fail, due to their derivatives exposure and other counter-party risk. For example, the banks could have been nationalized, and the charade of continuing large management bonuses could have been avoided. What we got as a result of TARP and related bailout approaches is an unrepentant risky TBTF system that could explode again, and a compensation structure that fuels income inequality. Feh.
- rational-future 12y agoYou are assuming the banks that sold had different owners than the banks that bought them.
- penrod 12y agoIt is no surprise that Treasury made a profit on its investments in troubled companies, since the fact of investing in them effectively rigged the market in their favor: If the government declares that it will not allow a company to fail, the company’s borrowing costs are reduced and it now has a competitive advantage over companies that do not qualify for government intervention. Of course the qualifications for this special treatment were: being very big, being politically well-connected, and having taken stupid risks. So every well-run, medium sized bank that didn’t have an army of lobbyists got screwed. And now we see that our favorites have prospered and declare “profit!” while ignoring the red ink for everyone else in the economy.
- rhino369 12y agoIt's not just that they boosted the credibility of the banks. The "toxic assets" that TARP bought weren't as bad as people feared. But the market wasn't buying them because nobody knew their true value. Everyone lost faith in the ratings agencies so it was chaos. Small banks benefited from this as well. It stabilized the market for mortgage securities, which small banks had large exposure to. It solved the liquidity crunch so the banks could stay open. If the big banks fail, it would take the small ones with them. It would also take a lot of good businesses with it. The whole economy runs on lines of credit.
- adventured 12y agoThe market would have bought them, at one point or another, exactly because there was value there (either at the time or eventually that realization would have been made, just as it had been so many times throughout US history that didn't require a program like TARP). That process would have bankrupted nearly every major bank. Buying the toxic assets was an extreme bailout for the banks, that were carrying trillions in liabilities that suddenly went under. Most of the majors were completely insolvent.
- autokad 12y agoI'm sorry but you are wrong. The market wasn't buying anything, period. Trying to fall back on the 'as it had been so many times throughout US History' is also wrong, as History, specifically the great depression, has shown us: no. At that time, there were no willing buyers (of toxic assets or banks otherwise), and if things progressed there would be no willing buyers. Tarp both directly and indirectly included the autos. Directly, because the auto bailout was funded under tarp, and indirectly because the way cars are sold - through loans, was about to be a broken process. if you remember, companies were no longer processing orders of auto parts companies unless they were paying in cash, for fear they might go under. The same situation happened in the banks. if the autos had gone, just that alone would have added another 2 million to unemployment in a month. Ford, the healthiest of the autos would have gone under too - as the companies that made GM and Christler's parts also made theirs. This alone would have destroyed the world economy for decades, let alone the financials all going kaput all at once. there were aspects of TARP that could have been implemented better, such as stipulations on c suite bonnuses, but overall TARP was needed or else we would be in a really bad place right now.
- lurchpop 12y agoAs others have said, moral hazard. This is especially important as they're set up for the next bailout will to be a "bail-in" where bank accounts will be debited directly through FDIC-insured accounts. I doubt those losses will get reimbursed to savers.
- erikpukinskis 12y ago3% over six years? I would say that qualifies as losing money. It's not even keeping up with inflation (10% in the same period).
- dodyg 12y agoThe US spends 500 billion dollars on defense every year but the biggest threat to its security is actually its banking system.
- rational-future 12y agoThe international banking system was the biggest threat to the freedoms of the colonies from before the Revolution until 1913. With the Federal Reserve Act of 1913 the banksters gained full control of the country ...
- adventured 12y agoFull control of the global economy actually, courtesy of what then happened post-WW2 with the establishment of the global FRN standard. They can crash the Soviet Union, tank modern Russia, break the pound, prop up Japan, build out trillions in manufacturing in China, encourage $20 trillion in new debt creation in China, crash oil with a stronger dollar, nominally inflate stock markets with asset inflation programs, rig the commodity market and libor, squeeze countries into default via currency or bond manipulation, and so on.
- jokoon 12y agoso if I understand it, TARP was not just money given to banks (as michael moore seemed to explain it in his documentary), it was a loan made by the government to the big banks. How did banks manage to pay back this loan ? What kind of condition did the government give ?
- higherpurpose 12y agoI'm willing to bet this isn't actually true and is misleading. The companies that got the bailout got other tax breaks and I think they got more money through other programs as well, which they then used to "pay back TARP". I really, really doubt the government came out net-positive with the loan.
- puppetmaster3 12y agolol. Welcome to a 1984 press release (for the stiff above the neck: wheat production, up, 18 %).
- percept 12y agoCan haz dividend?
- transfire 12y agoGive me a break. TARP was just cover for the real bailout.
- cnntrolls 12y agoSo what you're telling me is, adjusted for inflation, the government lost billions. http://data.bls.gov/cgi-bin/cpicalc.pl?cost1=425.00&year1=2008&year2=2014 http://data.bls.gov/cgi-bin/cpicalc.pl?cost1=425.00&year1=20... Nice spin though. Seems to have duped most of the 1337 h4x0rz here. Tell us CNN, how much of that QE* money are we getting back?
- randomname2 12y agoThe real windfall for the US has been the over $200 billion in bank settlements since 2008 in exchange for not jailing any bankers.
- imaginenore 12y ago$15.3B profit on $426B investment is 3.59% over 6 years. If they invested that money in S&P500, they would get 130% back.
- kuni-toko-tachi 12y agoThe nominal amount of profit is meaningless without reference to the value of the units relative to actual goods and services. In other words, what is the value of the currency today vs then? The idea that the government could just print money and solve the problem is naive. The costs of that bailout are reflected in a lower living standard and massive government debt as well as further imbalances.
- timtas 12y agoFrom a guy who wrote a 768 page book [1] about this: "The 'small profit', along with most of the so-called 'recovery' of Uncle Sam’s $426 billion initial investment, was ground out of the backs of America’s savers and depositors; or it was scalped from the massive financial bubbles the Fed has generated in the Wall Street casino." [2] [1] http://www.amazon.com/The-Great-Deformation-Corruption-Capitalism/dp/B00F6IGN52 http://www.amazon.com/The-Great-Deformation-Corruption-Capit... [2] http://davidstockmanscontracorner.com/the-greater-abomination-washingtons-lies-about-tarps-success-are-worse-than-the-original-bailouts-part-i http://davidstockmanscontracorner.com/the-greater-abominatio...