8 ms·
Meeting Ayn Rand on the Las Vegas Strip
- dmfdmf 12y agoThe only way to meet Rand now is by reading her books.
- techpeace 12y agohttp://wonkette.com/561974/john-oliver-presents-the-philosophy-of-ayn-rand-or-being-a-selfish-ahole-video http://wonkette.com/561974/john-oliver-presents-the-philosop...
- techpeace 12y agoOr, if you prefer: http://thecolbertreport.cc.com/videos/xjpl01/the-word---rand-illusion http://thecolbertreport.cc.com/videos/xjpl01/the-word---rand...
- techpeace 12y agoDon't forget to downvote both comments, Randians!
- dang 12y agoThe HN guidelines ask you not to bait others into downvoting. All: Please only make comments which improve the signal/noise ratio of a thread.
- t0rb3n 12y agoLast Week Tonight is a great show, but this piece made me think about it... if he misrepresents Ayn Rand so blatantly, how accurate is he on other topics? edit: fixed name of the show
- techpeace 12y agoWhat, exactly, is the segment misrepresenting? It was mostly video clips of Ayn Rand expressing her thoughts directly, with a voice-over (rightly) mocking conservatives for supporting her given the fact that she was both militantly atheist and militantly pro-choice.
- t0rb3n 12y agoYou're right. Also, the absurdity of expecting facts from a comedy show has been brought to my attention just recently. All in all, what a great first comment on this site ; ) Anyway, I'd argue there is an obvious atmosphere of disgust. The voice-over before the first interview segment states her philosophy amounts to being a selfish asshole. See the relevant part of the interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pFy9A7WEzPA#t=104 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pFy9A7WEzPA#t=104 from 1:45 to around 3:40. The net result is the impression that everything she's saying is basically bullshit. It seems to me that it's considered unacceptable to refer to her ideas.
- fourspace 12y agoRegardless of your views on Ayn Rand, this journalist goes to a week long conference and writes about two talks? Click bait. Pass.
- ghaff 12y agoUmm. He's not a journalist. He's an academic. And he's hardly obliged to do blow-by-blow reportage of an entire event.
- nickff 12y agoThis article is more of a rambling tirade than anything else. The only things I learned from it are how much the author disdains Rand and Las Vegas. I think the quote that demonstrates the author's slant is the following one about the Venetian hotel, and how "[o]nce inside, you have to follow the arcade of shops along a faux canal". This canal seems to conform to the dictionary definition of 'canal', and the author seems to be trying to exaggerate what he deems to be the flaws of Las Vegas.[1] There are numerous other instances in the article where similar hyperbole is used, and I will not bore you with a list, but they show that the writing is more sensationalist than journalistic or academic. [1] http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/canal http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/canal
- andrewvc 12y agoIn this thread: Randians downvoting all dissenting views so as not to disturb their carefully constructed echo chambers. Hi guys!
- jessaustin 12y agoUmm, that's not what I see. It looks more like the Rand aficionados are getting downvoted, not that that is actually any more valid than what you hoped for would have been.
- dang 12y agoThe downvote situation is always in flux. That's one of the reasons not to post comments about downvotes on HN: by the time people read the comment, it will probably be obsolete. The greater reason not to post such comments, of course, is that they're inevitably off-topic and tedious.
- meepmorp 12y agoConsidering the hour difference between your posts, maybe the situation has changed.
- andrewvc 12y agoHmmm, the situation has changed since when I wrote that. At the time there were a lot of grayed out comments that were pretty neutral. That's great news!
- PhasmaFelis 12y ago> “There is nobody out there who can talk about self-esteem, about individualism, and about capitalism with the moral certainty and the moral fervor we can,” Brook declared. It is so telling that this guy thinks moral certainty and "fervor" are a good thing. A person who is 100% certain and unquestioning in his beliefs is a person who cannot be reasoned with. This avowed rationalist speaks with the language of religious fundamentalistism.
- lucio 12y agoby definition you cannot support objectivism and at the same time be impervious to reason. http://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/reason.html http://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/reason.html
- pja 12y agoHuman beings are really, really good at constructing logical arguments for things they want to be true and ignoring or downplaying counter-arguments. Objectivism is no exception.
- Retric 12y agoFurther, any philosophy that includes axioms limits the value of logical reasoning. If X (which is assumed to be true) and Y then Z. It might be logically valid, but it’s still meaningless.
- mentat 12y agoWhich is... every philosophy that exists?
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Further, any philosophy that includes axioms limits the value of logical reasoning. On the contrary, as logical reasoning in any particular system of logic depends on the set of axioms defining that system of logic, any philosophy which does not admit any axioms likewise does not admit logical reasoning, and any philosophy which only includes those axioms necessary to support a system of logic can't lead to any conclusions other than those that constitute the description of the system of logic. In order for a philosophy to have interesting consequences, it must have substantive axioms.
- phelmig 12y agoI liked Atlas Shrugged when I read it. But I think if Dagny Taggart would see today's world she wouldn't be too happy as well. While capitalism won over communism the corruption of governments didn't die out it just became more clever. I sometimes toy with the thought of writing a second ending to be Atlas Shrugged where old Dagny looks at our world and can't grasp what is wrong with it.
- SkyMarshal 12y agoIn Atlas Shrugged she didn't just rail at communism, but also at the use of political "pull" over merit to shape (distort) the economic landscape. That's still very relevant in many domains today, though I think the "Dagney's" of the world (and most hackers and other astute observers) just as easily grasp it then as now.
- phelmig 12y agoIt's not only about the "pull" over merit as you state it but about politically established priorities that harm good businesses. Just as the US cloud business was harmed by the NSA when national security (and intl. espionage) was put above competitiveness. Those political priorities still come from "Washington" and rule over NY (or Silicon Valley). Both cities are meant within context of the book.
- lordnacho 12y agoI'm reasonably sympathetic so some libertarian views. But I've never been able to motivate myself to read Ayn Rand. Can someone tell me how a fiction book can make a good argument for any political view? Is it just a thin layer of story-writing on top of actual, evidence-based argument? Or is it like I fear, just a long story where everything goes right for the guys with the right views? Because I'm pretty sure you could write a book where the righteous commies win. Considering how big the book is, I'd like to know before I try to read it.
- lucio 12y agoIt is a epic history based on a novel philosophy. The philosophy defines "right/good" values based on objective observation of reality, and then concludes that the top value for a being with reason is it's own life. So good/right things are those things that enhance your life and the things you value (your family, your love, your principles). One top principle is to "respect others reason and will, do not start aggression or go against the will of another reasoning being"
- sten 12y agoExcept that humans are incapable of making objective observations in practice with anything resembling consistency.
- bcheung 12y agoSo you are saying your above observation is not objective and doesn't resemble anything consistent? I think the entire history of engineering is a testament that we can make observations on a consistent enough basis to be practical.
- Tycho 12y agoHave you ever read Socratic dialogues? It's a bit like that, where characters come to embody certain philosophical positions, except the scope is broadened beyond just discussion/debate and into action (which allows it to be a novel).
- teekert 12y ago"For eight days last summer, a new generation of Randians was indoctrinated in the auditoriums of The Venetian. Where better to absorb Atlas Shrugged 's teachings than in a city of extremes?" Indoctrinatied? What a way to start but he sure makes his stance clear with that sentence. As someone who really values Ayn Rands work (I am one of those who was influence by Atlas Shrugged), I find it difficult to get through this piece (as it is with things you disagree with). I find it very biased yet it never really gives any good arguments against objectivism. Of course one should not treat Ayn Rand as a god and be dogmatic about her ideas, and certainly don't judge her by the people that do.
- Tycho 12y agoI think one of the appealing things about Objectivism is that it's a complete top-to-bottom guide to how life should be lived for individuals, communities and nations. Most rival philosophies seem narrower. Christianity, for instance, has lots of advice for dealing with individuals but seems disconnected from politics. Something like Marxism talks about the organisation of industries and classes but not so much about personal situations. Mainstream political movements seem more like packages of stances (on things like abortion, welfare, immigration...) with no clear unifying principles. Then there's interesting philosophies like say Utilitarianism, that lots of people know about and write about but seemingly no one seriously adheres to as a way of life. If you agree with the principles of Objectivism you can more or less follow it as a way of life, without doing anything drastic like abandoning all your worldly possessions, or feeling like a hypocrite.
- teddyh 12y agoThere’s always Confucianism.
- adamnemecek 12y agoIdk, is being wrong on multiple fronts that much better than being wrong only on one?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dang 12y agoThis story was killed by user flags. That was a bad use of flagging, so we've overridden it. The article is clearly substantive enough to pass the minimal bar for this site. Whether it's great or not, or even good or not, is a different question.
- Tycho 12y agoPresumably these are the sorts of people who would apply for positions in the Thought Police if they got the chance.
- chc 12y agoIt is substantial, but it is not relevant. This article is clearly far enough afield from the topic of this site that it deserves to be flagkilled. Whether it's substantial or not is a different question. Also, if you're going to override people's flags, you should also override all the upvotes, because there is no way to just downvote irrelevant crap like this, so political diatribes, Buzzfeed links and everything else that has a solid core of upvoters will dominate if we can't filter for relevance.
- dang 12y ago> This article is clearly far enough afield from the topic of this site I'm afraid you have a misconception, and it's a crucial one. There is no "topic of this site". The axiom of Hacker News is intellectual curiosity, and intellectual curiosity does not limit itself to one set of things. Of course we're not all curious about the same stuff. That's why we have voting—to express personal interest. But to flag an article like this one is to say it has no (or nearly no) potential for intellectual curiosity at all, and that seems clearly to be a bad call.
- chc 12y agoI think the guidelines suggest something a little less broad than "whatever you personally find interesting": "Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic." Let me elaborate: Should I start spamming links to long-winded vegan propaganda? I would find it interesting, because it appeals to a viewpoint I happen to agree with. I also find Sailor Moon to be interesting. Should I start linking Sailor Moon content? Exactly how ridiculous and fluffy do my interests have to be before we can agree that there would be a better forum for the content? Although they might be interesting to some particular hackers, vegan evangelism, libertarian politics and Sailor Moon are pretty far from the obvious intent of "things that good hackers would find interesting." More than that, political content is poisonous to good discussion. The more you allow politics in, the more politics will consume everything, and the more comment threads you'll have that only gratify people's need to be outraged. I can understand that some political stories legitimately reflect a new trend that affects hackers and entrepreneurs, but allowing anything that interests anyone just allows far too much junk and hastens the site's decline.
- Afforess 12y agoI think the biggest draw for Ayn Rand and her works is that there are very few "role models" for fiscal conservatives in today's political environment. Most Republicans are neo-conservative warhawks that only pay lip-service to fiscal conservatism. Very few of them represent the older, Eisenhower traditional-Republicanism, who feared the Military-Industrial complex and understood fiscal conservatism. Even the "tea party" conservatives are mostly anti-intellectual, anti-tax, social conservatives. Fiscal conservatives are usually intellectuals who have a wide range of social beliefs and do not fit in with that crowd. Ayn Rand's Objectivism aligns well with fiscal conservatives and capitalists in a way that is hard to find elsewhere. I have met a lot of people who are pro-capitalism fiscal conservatives and they seem to have fallen through the political cracks. I see very few politicians or public-figure role models who appeal to Capitalists.
- digisign 12y agoAgreed, in America the Goldwaters, Buckleys, and other intelligent conservatives died out in favor of the fox contingent. A shame really.
- api 12y agoOne reason: fiscal conservatism doesn't offer anyone any advantage, and politics is (sadly) mostly about competing over unfair advantage. The goal of a political campaign is to exercise your power over someone else (e.g. theocrats, PC fanatics), slant the law in your favor (regulatory capture), or directly access the treasury. The second reason: Keynesian economics works, at least in the short to medium term. When a recession hits, real fiscal conservatives lose big. Democrats know this and play to it explicitly. Republicans also know it, and are masters at politically weaponized Keynesianism. They espouse fiscally conservative rhetoric while being ardent Keynesians in practice, usually through military spending and financial bubble-blowing.
- AnimalMuppet 12y ago> One reason: fiscal conservatism doesn't offer anyone any advantage... I disagree. Fiscal conservatism means that I get to keep more of my money, instead of having the government take it. That's certainly an advantage to me. But I think you meant "it's not an advantage of one person over another", which is true. And by extension, I think you meant "therefore it doesn't help one candidate get elected over another", which I think is false. Telling people that you're going to let them keep more of their money shouldn't be a very hard sell. (Now, true, most conservative candidates don't seem to be able to articulate such a message, but I think that's because most "conservative" candidates aren't fiscal conservatives at all.)
- lucio 12y ago"When you see that trading is done, not by consent, but by compulsion - when you see that in order to produce, you need to obtain permission from men who produce nothing - when you see that money is flowing to those who deal, not in goods, but in favors - when you see that men get richer by graft and by pull than by work, and your laws don't protect you against them, but protect them against you - when you see corruption being rewarded and honesty becoming a self-sacrifice - you may know that your society is doomed." Source: Atlas Shrugged, Francisco's "Money Speech" Anyone living and producing goods or services in a corrupt country will understand this. You need to experience several years in the society described in the quote to fully understand the implications.
- cbd1984 12y agoI agree that it's important to understand that Rand came from the USSR to fully grasp why her philosophy is the way it is. Understanding a philosophy doesn't mean accepting it.
- santacluster 12y ago> when you see that in order to produce, you need to obtain permission from men who produce nothing This part alone shows how much superficial BS this is. You cannot produce anything without using the earth's resources. They do not naturally belong to any man. So it's either "take what you want, by force, and fuck everyone else", or we find some peaceful way to share those resources amongst each other. Preferably without terminally destroying them for future generations. Yes, the latter is done through a huge variety of intricate social constructs, and all of them are corrupt to some degree, because such is mankind. But the only society in which you do not need permission from your fellow men is one in which the majority of the population has the status of serfs.
- notahacker 12y agoTo put things into perspective for those not familiar with the book, the character Francisco is supposed to one of the world's richest men having inherited a mining fortune from his conquistador ancestors. According to Rand's back-story, it's all down to the family lineage passing on genius from one generation to another and nothing at all to do with working slaves to death, as actually tended to happen in South American mines. It's not documented whether his ancestors asked permission from the indigenous population. Atlas Shrugged is basically the reductio ad absurdum version of saner arguments for capitalism.
- mangoldm 12y agoWho should be the beneficiary of your actions? Answer that and all the rest follows.
- applecore 12y agoWhat I learned from this discussion: Ayn Rand (and, to a lesser extent, Objectivism) is the highly electrified third rail of Hacker News.