10 ms·
NASA Study Proposes Airships, Cloud Cities for Venus Exploration
- chriskanan 12y agoWouldn't our ability to learn about more than the atmosphere of Venus be extremely impaired from an airship? If one of the goals is ultimately colonization, how would we harvest materials beyond those available in the atmosphere? Even robots would have great difficulty doing this task for us due to Venus' hellish conditions on the ground, assuming they could get the materials back up to the sky city or airship.
- ForHackernews 12y agoActually, one suggestion has been colonizing Venus in floating cities: http://www.universetoday.com/15570/colonizing-venus-with-floating-cities/ http://www.universetoday.com/15570/colonizing-venus-with-flo...
- danielweber 12y agoColonization includes expansion. For now assume that all the carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen you want is available in the atmosphere and solar power. You still need hydrogen to make plastics, and you are going to need silicon to build more solar panels, and you need metals you can forge. The surface of Venus is 50km below, which isn't as far away as the ISS, but it's still 50km straight down and then back up for anything. It might be a nice vacation spot, or a penal colony.
- tomp 12y agoFor hydrogen, you have sulfuric acid.
- moron4hire 12y agoThere is work being done to replace silicon with graphene. It's of course a long shot, but would make this a lot more feasible if possible.
- spcoll 12y agoI find the term "colonization" offensive. So after having colonized all of the people of earth, white men want to colonize other planets next. The thirst for power of white men truly has no limits. Disgusting.
- anigbrowl 12y agoOne colonizes land, not people. The Latin word colonus also means 'farmer' or 'settler.' At the current pace, I anticipate that the first interplanetary colony will be set up by China.
- spcoll 12y agoSee what you're doing? That's called whitesplaining.
- javert 12y agoThat isn't an argument. You might as well have said "parrot bird dog mouse." Actually, it's worse than that, because it is an attempt to emotionally manipulate in lieu of presenting an argument or even making a rational, factual statement.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoRead your history books a bit more. Territorial expansion was practiced by most post neolithic cultures.
- protomyth 12y agoI'm actually hoping the gp poster is a troll account or one of the worst attempts at parody in a while. Sadly, some folks actually believe that type of thing. I remember one example from many years ago. I was working with an government grant when an evaluation team showed up for our yearly site visit. Now, site visits are conducted in order of best vacation spot / most senior staff. It shouldn't be that way, but when a staff member has a choice between Florida and North Dakota in February, you can guess which staff get assigned to North Dakota. I'm sure if asked, grant manager would say this isn't so, but well, human nature is human nature. One of the fun[1] staff members we got had decided the term "socialize" (which at the time simply meant kids mingling with kids and learning, etc.) actually had some weird indoctrination context. The havoc and psychosis of that visit lead me to believe that people who try to redefine words basically fit into the part of humanity that wants to gain outrage from people who meant none and were just trying to use the dictionary value of the word. An interesting offshoot to this is that you can see language drift in grants submitted to certain agencies that tell the funding folks who the "in" crowd is so the "in" crowd can continue to receive funding and lock out the newbies. Doesn't happen in all agencies, but it sure seems to have been a pattern. There is also the my group vs them identification of the whole thing. 1) fun = racist as they come. Some of the other behavior was scary and surreal. I blame a weekends bar bill on that visit. [edit: getting the same reaction from myself and anigbrowl leads me to believe it's a troll account]
- wtracy 12y agoIf EVA isn't even an option, what exactly is this manned mission supposed to accomplish that an entirely robotic one can't? It seems like a manned mission purely for the sake of being a manned mission.
- Pxtl 12y agoEva is an option in general, just not for that planned mission. The problem with Venus isnt the temperature and pressure, it's that the ground is too far down. At air ship altitude it's comfortable except for the acid.
- thearn4 12y agoMy guess is the main advantage is feasibility - a manned airship-like laboratory in the upper atmosphere of Venus is something we could likely accomplish sooner than a manned mission to Mars, if we chose to make that a priority. Though the scientific benefit of such an effort would largely be secondary to other considerations. But that is fairly normal in the politics of human spaceflight.
- aethertap 12y agoIt sounds like one of their main arguments is that it would be a less difficult and/or dangerous way to get some experience with medium to long-term human habitats on other planets, partially in preparation for a Mars trip. Also, while robots can do any specific experiment we devise before the trip, it's much harder to make one that can support improvisation or hacking together a follow-up experiment if an interesting result is found. The pace of iteration for experiments would probably be much higher with a human present.
- gambiting 12y agoI would argue that you could get that experience by establishing a colony on the bottom of the ocean. Conditions there are also deadly to human life without protection, and getting there and back is also not easy. Not as hard as getting to a different planet, but if we want to learn how to sustain human life in artificial habitats, then a colony 10km under water sounds like a way to start.
- 3pt14159 12y agoI've been advocating a Venus over Mars strategy for quite some time now. It is weird seeing your opinions hit the mainstream. On the one hand you are happy that other people have finally come around to your line of thinking, but on the other hand you worry that others will repeat the conclusion with little idea of the reasoning that went behind it. I was also ahead of the curve on the simulation argument. When Elon Musk started talking about it I realized it was finally becoming mainstream. I'm hoping he gets on board with a Venus first space exploration too!
- javert 12y agoWhat is the "simulation argument"? I read the article but don't remember that.
- nitrogen 12y agoIt's a fallacious extrapolation of Moore's law into the idea that our universe must be a computer simulation (of course there's more to it than my flippant summary suggests, but I still find the arguments unconvincing even if the idea itself is interesting).
- kamaal 12y agoThe rate at which computers have gotten powerful is simply mind boggling. Even as early as 20 years ago, something like an iPhone would sound like wishful thinking to someone who would think rationally. Heck WWW, internet, mobile phones and this whole thing looks right out of a science fiction book for some one in early part of 1900's Its hard to imagine how much more computers can go. But I believe people in the future will look at our way of thinking about computing limits(Moore's law) in the same we look at vaccum tubes. Or the way we look at people who thought heavier than air flying objects are impossible by laws of physics. We just don't know how many 'transistor events' or 'wright brother' events there are going to be in the future which will work around the laws of science orthogonally.
- nitrogen 12y ago
- whoisthemachine 12y agoAnd actually, one of the things that's not mentioned is the other extremely advantageous feature of Venus: plenty of energy to extract, in already combustible or nearly combustible form, which would be nice to have if humanity is to become an interplanetary species. It also helps that the planet is almost certainly devoid of lifeforms.
- yongjik 12y agoAccording to Wikipedia, Venus's atmosphere is 96.5% CO2, 3.5% N2, and trace amounts of other stuff. Not sure what "combustible form" of energy you are talking about?
- skorgu 12y ago"...at 50km, the abundance [of H2SO4] works out to ~14mg/m^3 or about 7ppm. So, between sulfuric acid and water vapor, you have about half as much mass per cubic meter as water vapor in the air near the ALMA observatory in the Atacama desert in Chile. Bone dry by terrestrial standards, but sopping wet compared to say the Moon." [0] That plus higher-than-earth solar radiation to electrolyze it into H2 and O2 and you've got yourself a floating, solar-powered rocket fuel mine. [0] http://selenianboondocks.com/2013/11/venus-isru-what-do-we-have-to-work-with/ http://selenianboondocks.com/2013/11/venus-isru-what-do-we-h...
- teamonkey 12y agoWater is more common elsewhere in the solar system. There might be water ice on the Moon, even Mercury. Comets are largely water ice, so are C-type asteroids. Many moons of the outer planets are supposed to have liquid or water ice in their cores. Titan and Europa possibly have more water than Earth. Which is to say, there's probably easier and (eventually at least) cheaper planetary targets for H2 and O2 factories.
- marcosdumay 12y agoA fuel mine deep inside a gravity weel as big as our own. It's very usefull for going into space again, but not for a refueling station.
- diltonm 12y agoThis is encouraging. I've wondered for several years why Mars when you've got places like Venus as potentially more interesting locations. Doing long term atmospheric existence there could teach us a lot about what we don't know about space travel and our ability to push ourselves. If I didn't have two bad discs and was 3 decades younger; I'd be asking where to sign up. Edit: Reading further, "while the crewed version would be nearly 130 meters long, or twice the size of a Boeing 747.". NASA needs to get much bolder in their thinking. Two people isn't enough. You need at least the size of a submarine crew to make it work and that means an airship 5000 meters long. Edit 2: "At this point, things get crazy.". Well, it wouldn't be worth it otherwise.
- delecti 12y agoObviously getting to the moon is step one. Getting to Venus and Mars are at least on a comparable level of difficulty, and Mars is much more like the moon than Venus is, so we're already used to getting around it. I think it's more a case of going with the devil you know, even if Venus might be better overall for various reasons.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- afterburner 12y agoNah, just send one of those amazingly retro Russian landers again: http://rammb.cira.colostate.edu/dev/hillger/Venera-9_lander_image.jpg http://rammb.cira.colostate.edu/dev/hillger/Venera-9_lander_...
- ant6n 12y agoWithin the CO2 atmosphere of Venus, air is a lifting gas. One could make large balloons out of air which double up as habitats for humans. Make it large and thin enough, and a dome-city would be a balloon on Venus.
- fsloth 12y agoI love the idea but could you lay out the numbers (I'm a bit busy...)?
- prawn 12y agoThis won't help with specifics, but there have been past discussions (HN?) about tethered floating cities on Earth that rely on heated air within the space to keep them afloat. I think one of those discussions had vague figures, from memory.
- pharke 12y agoMostly from sources regarding hot air balloon flight and I don't in any way claim to be qualified in this area but: Normal Air Mixture, Dry at sea level (1013.25 hPa) and 20 degrees Celsius: 1.205 kg/m3 Normal Air Mixture, Dry at sea level (1013.25 hPa) and 100 degrees Celsius: 0.946 kg/m3 Difference: 0.259 kg/m3 C02 at sea level (1013.25 hPa) and 20 degrees Celsius: 1.829 kg/m3 Difference from Normal Air at 20 deg C: 0.637 kg/m3 C02 at seal level (1013.25 hPa) and 75 degrees Celsius: 1.541 kg/m3 Difference from Normal Air at 20 deg C: 0.336 kg/m3 As you can see, by these rough numbers a normal air mixture as present on Earth should theoretically be able to act as a lifting gas at least equivalent to hot air given the conditions in the layer of the Venusian atmosphere that the article is considering. Feel free to correct if you see any obvious errors, I just used the ideal gas law and some figures for gas constants I found on engineeringtoolbox.com and I'm definitely not a physicist by any means.
- fsloth 12y agoCool... thanks for looking those up! Back of the envelope: Vehicle mass: Let's just arbitrarily add three Apollo capsules (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_Lunar_Module http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_Lunar_Module), that should contain enough gear and personnel for.. something: 45000 kg At the 50 km height in venusian atmosphere in 75 degrees celsius this would need a volume of normal air mixture of 45000 kg / (0.336 kg/m3) = 133928 m3 for neutral buoyancy. Which, in a ball shape, would mean a ball of radius of: ((133928 m3) * 3 / (4 * 3.14))^-3 = 31,7m So a sphere with a diameter of 60 meters filled with normal air mixture would roughly compare with a vehicle encompassing enough gear to fill three Apollo capsules. Which is really an arbitrary measure but means that the idea about bubble vehicles filled with fresh air bouncing in the Venusian atmosphere is actually feasible at least in the science fiction if not necessarily engineering sense of the word :)
- q2 12y agoHumans are given earth and they polluted it, destroyed its environment in the name of development and now going after Mars or Venus...etc. There may be some entities with good intentions in exploration but over a period of time, entities with evil intentions may join and story will be same like on earth, only timeline, tools, people, circumstances, places will be different.
- NeverEnough 12y agolife on earth isn't sustainable anyway. how can you not be aware of that? the sun is dying. if humans don't 'develop' enough before then, it is unlikely that any of earth's legacy will be preserved.
- q2 12y agoIt takes billions of years for sun to die. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/david-j-eicher/14-things-you-didnt-know-_b_5692426.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/david-j-eicher/14-things-you-d... Moreover, if sun dies, how Mars/Venus will help us? They are in our solar system. Is n't it? So we need not worry. Moreover if death is natural process, then some alternative star may born by that time. As of now, Science may not be that much advanced to capture new star. But that won't give a reason to destroy/pollute earth and move on. Can you guarantee it won't happen to Mars or Venus? It is just fear mongering, nothing else.
- NeverEnough 12y agomars and venus are the first step. we aren't going to jump out of the solar system on our first try. we will be lucky if we don't have a lot of failures in that endeavor, even after the experience and materials we gain from the solar system. >Moreover if death is natural process humans are also a natural process. >some alternative star may born by that time. you mean a new star is going to come to our solar system before the sun dies? I think I must be misunderstanding. If not, that's asinine. I don't really get how you can call it fearmongering. who is supposed to be afraid? most people only think as far ahead as two generations. the only people who are disturbed by your strange brand of environmentalism are people who think hundreds of years into the future, ie other environmentalists. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_far_future http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_far_future your billions figure is also a gross overestimate. our timeline is not so generous. and don't forget that life took (actually) billions of years to evolve. what are you trying to protect on mars and venus that is more important than that?
- gd1 12y agoI don't think there was any discussion in the link about how they would get back into orbit? Did I miss it?
- jccooper 12y agoYeah, that's a pretty sticky part. Venus has appx earth gravity and atmosphere at that point, so you'd need an Earth-class launcher to get off; something at least like an Atlas or Titan II. The launcher itself we could get there reasonably, but the propellant, well... that's an awful lot of mass to send to Venus. It gets much easier if you can do ISRU, which may be easier on Venus, but is still a novel development project. EDIT: after further reading the article... In the article it shows that most of the payload (60k kg out of the 70k kg payload) of the airship module is the ascent vehicle. Each of the two transit modules is launched by what looks like 4 Delta IVs and one SLS Block2--each. (Plus two crew capsule launches at each end of the mission for Earth departure and return.) So I guess they have some mass to work with. Heck of a launch schedule. That 60k kg ascent rocket is just a bit bigger than the Pegasus XL, which can launch 443 kg. A Mercury capsule is 1200kg. Granted the ascent capsule doesn't need a heat shield, but that's not a lot of rocket for two people.
- scrumper 12y agoYou did - there's a rocket ship attached to the bottom of the airship (accounting for 6/7ths of the mass of the airship IIRC).
- jvickers 12y agoIn order to go to Mars, and come back quickly and safely, it would make sense to send supplies of various sorts on a robotic mission (or a number of them). This way there would be plenty of fuel on Mars. Another possibility would be having a launchpad in Earth orbit, so that many different modules would be assembled (a lot like the ISS), but in a configuration that's designed to travel to Mars. Launching it all at once from Earth does not seem like the safest or most efficient answer to getting a very large mission payload into space, given current technology. This way, there would be allowances for failed launches, while the human crew is brought into orbit using more tried and tested methods (with sufficient rescue mission planning), on a much smaller budget than the whole mission cost. Some kind of Exploratory Space Station seems like the way to do it.
- outworlder 12y ago> Launching it all at once from Earth does not seem like the safest or most efficient answer to getting a very large mission payload into space, given current technology Or any non-scifi technology that we know of. The rocket equation is harsh.
- masklinn 12y agoEven scifi generally does assembly in space. Short of the ability to teleport stuff outside the gravity well for free Δv remains much more manageable by sending lots of smaller payloads.
- grondilu 12y agoIt's definitely worth considering. At the very least, they could make a demonstration mission with a small, unmanned airship. Also, question: 50km is pretty high, but is this too high for any chance of visibility to the ground? Such a mission would be much more interesting if it was possible to view at least a bit of the surface.
- krampian 12y agoDirect line of sight probably would be off the table because of the thick cloud layer in the Venusian atmosphere. Radar imaging as has been previously been done by orbiting probes should certainly be possible. More interestingly, it seems to me the airships would be good launching pads for all kinds of unmanned drones which could go down from there to take a look and return to base later.
- rwhitman 12y agoIf you're interested in the topic of Venus colonization, I read this article a few weeks ago and loved it: http://www.science20.com/robert_inventor/will_we_build_colonies_that_float_over_venus_like_buckminster_fullers_cloud_nine-127573 http://www.science20.com/robert_inventor/will_we_build_colon...
- pharke 12y agoSome interesting opinions here, but I can't agree with his speculation that you could build a floating habitat from wood and cotton cloth. He also seems to have gotten the concentrations of C02 and N mixed up as he believes the latter is abundant (on Venus) when it is actually ~3% If it were the reverse as he believes, normal air would not be a lifting gas.
- peter303 12y agoNASA has a huge number of exciting proposals, but can only fund a handful of them per decade. I thought the end of the Shuttle would free up money for robotic exploration. But science and manned exploration are separate budgets.
- bunderbunder 12y agoAnd they probably should be. Otherwise NASA's money for science would end up being sacrificed as a burnt offering to executive and congressional diddling, too. The spend on manned exploration expands to consume all available space. Case in point: http://www.washingtonpost.com/sf/national/2014/12/15/nasas-349-million-monument-to-its-drift/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/sf/national/2014/12/15/nasas-3...
- nickhalfasleep 12y agoI think venus holds more promise for massive teraforming. I can't find the link but calculations have been done about spinning a large occluding shield at the L1 Lagrange point to cool the surface over a few hundred years. Then with proper reflectivity adjustments, the surface could be made earth-normal. Heck, take all the extra CO2 and boost it to Mars to help them fill their greenhouses.
- Lambdanaut 12y agoInteresting idea, but Mars isn't lacking in CO2. I'm not sure if shipping it there from Venus would be economically feasible for a long time.
- seanflyon 12y agoI think Venus is short on hydrogen to make water. terraforming might require scooping large quantities of hydrogen from Jupiter and using it to burn off some the the CO2 producing water and carbon.
- dr_zoidberg 12y agoTo everyone asking "why" or "what for", please read [1] and [2]. The data behind may not be as abundant as other studies, but the conditions are met in Venus and extremophiles could already be living in the upper atmosphere. A mission like this one could potentially take exobiology from theoretical to empirical. Alternatively, we could take extremophiles cultures from earth, take a sample of venusian atmosphere, and study their survival in such an environment -- of course, taking care not to contaminate the atmosphere. [1] http://web.archive.org/web/20110807004311/http://gltrs.grc.nasa.gov/reports/2003/TM-2003-212310.pdf http://web.archive.org/web/20110807004311/http://gltrs.grc.n... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_of_Venus#Possibility_of_life http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmosphere_of_Venus#Possibility...