11 ms·
A plane that will be able to fly anywhere in the world within 4 hours
- acd 12y agoThe cool part is that this plane will do US to Europe in 1-2 hours which is a game changer. Given how fast it flies, how much would the tickets cost?
- tomelders 12y agoI get the impression that the passenger flight times are more marketing talk intended to frame the technical achievement in terms people can understand rather than an actual intended use case. Reaction Engines do have plans to use the engine on a passenger plane, but the Skylon is designed to take payloads up into space cheaply. http://www.reactionengines.co.uk/lapcat.html http://www.reactionengines.co.uk/lapcat.html
- Involute 12y agoOdd that a picture of dead people (Palermo catacombs, I'm guessing) shows up beside this headline in my RSS reader (Feedly).
- tensor 12y agoNot odd at all. If you scroll down there are links to other articles. The last one is a photo of the catacomb mummies. Your fead reader simply chose the wrong photo from those on the page.
- dkopi 12y agoHopefully, they've learned a few lessons from the Concorde. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concorde http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concorde
- tim333 12y agoSeems like cool technology. I wonder if it'll actually get to fly.
- chx 12y agoCool. This http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reaction_Engines_A2 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reaction_Engines_A2 is six years old. What's the news?
- gilgoomesh 12y agoThere is no new information here. It looks like sciencealert.com got its information from businessinsider.com's Dec 11, 2014 article which references a "new video" as its source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yLD1TPsEi3E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yLD1TPsEi3E but that "new" video is from 2012.
- jessriedel 12y agoHonest question: Can someone explain why a Mach 5 air-breathing engine is important for reaching low-Earth orbit (~Mach 25)? I still don't understand after watching the video. I recall from a video interview that Elon Musk is skeptical of the utility of air-breathing engines for economic access to LEO since, as he put it, the atmosphere is "thick as soup" and you basically want to get out of it ASAP before you get up to orbital velocity. Breathing air up to Mach 5 allows you to save some weight, but you have to bring enough liquid O2 for the rest of your acceleration from Mach 5 to Mach 25. So is the idea that this modest savings in weight is all that's needed for a single-stage to orbit?
- pwnna 12y agoSome background: This company's engine is based on its previous design, the SABRE engine. That engine is designed to reach an altitude at 28km, flying at Mach 5 (which works out to be about 1.5km/s at that altitude, ~15% of orbital velocity at LEO). After that the engine is designed to switch to a rocket mode, where it burns fuel and oxygen it brought, rather than taking it from the atmosphere. Since the an air breathing engine is much more efficient (10x) than a traditional rocket engine, it allows the launch vehicle to conserve mass that would otherwise be used to overcome the high drag encountered in lower altitudes. You can roughly think of this as a rocket with all of its mass being launched at 28km, with a velocity of Mach 5 already. "Getting out of the atmosphere" is a pretty vague statement. Atmospheric pressure and density is about 1-2% that of the ground. So drag at these altitudes will be less. However, some quick and dirty calculations by me makes this seem like a relatively small number compared to the amount of energy it takes to actually get to orbit. Quick search indicates the same as well[1]. However, a "thick" atmosphere is something that has to be dealt with. For example, rockets also need to overcome pressures that exists at lower altitudes. If you take a look at any rocket launch videos, you will notice that the exhaust at higher altitudes (typically about 2-3 minutes after launch) will expand outwards with respect to the rocket itself. This means that the flow out of the rocket engine is "underexpanded", making the engine less efficient than it would be otherwise. By starting your rocket engine at a higher altitude, you can improve the efficiencies by designing your rockets to lower atmospheric pressures (I don't know if this is done for the SABRE engine, but this is theoretically possible). So based on these, the main motivation for this is probably for the mass savings and efficiency. Additionally, this engine presents itself with potentials for complete reusability, which is very attractive as most current launch cost is from the unrecoverable launch vehicle itself. [1]: forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=9959.msg189860#msg189860
- moron4hire 12y agoIt's basically the Sears-Haack body with some engines bolted on: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sears%E2%80%93Haack_body http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sears%E2%80%93Haack_body
- 0x0 12y agoIs it still 25 years away from being available to commercial airlines, like the wikipedia article mentions? Can't wait! :)
- nickhalfasleep 12y agoThey talk over and over about their engine, when there are plenty other hard problems they do not have solutions for. For instance light enough cryogenic fuel tanks don't exist. This was part of the reason the Venture Star / X-33 never met their weight budget.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoCame here to say the same thing. And note that you're "burning" 400MW of energy in the heat exchanger (transferring it to the helium) at some point you have to re-cool that helium back to liquid) if you outgas the helium you are a net loss because helium has a limited supply. Doing it with hydrogen doesn't get nearly the thermal mass. So it is a really really cool engine, but it remains to be seen how practical it can be. The second thing, consider the experience from the SR-71. To stay light and still be able to withstand the frictional heating of the air at mach 5 requires some pretty exotic materials. And matching thermal properties for materials at mach 5 vs sub mach. Covering the whole thing in thermal tiles adds weight which comes out of the payload. To me, adding on the possibility that it could be some sort of Mach 5 super airliner, suggests that the practicalities of it as an SSTO platform are perhaps not nearly so compelling as once thought. Fortunately they were not talking about the multi-gigawatt ground lasers to boil hydrogen. That idea, while nominally physically possible, is impractical to imagine the rest of the world being "ok" with.
- digi_owl 12y agohttp://www.reactionengines.co.uk/sabre_howworks.html http://www.reactionengines.co.uk/sabre_howworks.html Seems that they are using the heat absorbed from the air, via the helium to eventually heat the hydrogen going into the engine. http://www.reactionengines.co.uk/images/sabre/sabre_cycle_1024.jpg http://www.reactionengines.co.uk/images/sabre/sabre_cycle_10...
- iwwr 12y agoAny idea why they can't use hydrogen and oxygen directly? Or are they just using a smaller quantity of helium as a 'working refrigerant'?
- minor_nitwit 12y agoOk, these guys claim to have invented a great engine, really just the pre-cooler. Why are they trying to build a plane instead of licensing it to others? That seems to be several orders of magnitude more difficult and increases the likelihood of failure.
- imaginenore 12y agoDo you know any Mach 5 planes?
- jschwartzi 12y agoDoes he know of anyone in the tightly-regulated airline industry who would be crazy enough to build a completely new airframe and engine around a currently-experimental precooler?
- foobarian 12y agoAnd using LH2 and LOX as fuel? With 3g acceleration? :-)
- aragot 12y agoAt that speed, I wonder what accidents will look like. I respect this technology as totally serious but in case of accident the NTSB may just delegate the investigation to a Darwin prize: Is the plane sensitive to slight variations, like a few people walking in the alley? Since at Mach 5 we can expect a 5000K temperature for the dislocated parts [1], will the pieces completely burn and disintegrate before falling back to Mach 1, effectively acting as a MH370 at each accident, by design? Can we at least have a video of that on 9gag? Or will we have to search a 5,000-km radius if we have a 20minutes uncertainty for the accident window? [1] http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_entry#Shock_layer_gas_physics http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_entry#Shock_layer...
- marcosdumay 12y ago
- paulftw 12y agoWhere does this liquid helium come from, and more importantly where does it go after it's been heated? Im guessing they release it into atmosphere, so is there enough helium to mine for this plane to go mainstream?
- encoderer 12y agoWait. Wouldn't this be a closed system? I can't imagine they're outgassing helium?
- NickNameNick 12y agoThey aren't. The helium is cooled by the hydrogen going to the engine. You can't run the pre-cooler on the hydrogen directly, because the hydrogen infiltrates the welds (and everything else) causing hydrogen embrittlement, which will quickly tear the heat exchanger apart. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_embrittlement http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_embrittlement
- sparkzilla 12y agoIt says in the Wikipedia article that: "The key design feature for the Scimitar engines is the precooler, which is a heat exchanger that transfers the heat from the incoming air into the hydrogen fuel."
- sargun 12y agoHydrogen? How are they storing that efficiently?
- Thomashuet 12y agoThis is bullshit, -273°C is absolute zero so unless the plane is on fire, it can't cool down the air by more than 1000°C.
- nmjohn 12y agoRocket engines get extremely hot: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rocket_engine#Cooling http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rocket_engine#Cooling
- Thomashuet 12y agoThey pretend the air is precooled, not cooled after going through the engine.
- encoderer 12y agoIs this not the same concept as any intercooler?
- ms013 12y agoAir entering the engine at high speed is heated significantly due to compression.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- tdicola 12y agoI think I've read this exact same story for the last 25 years. Will believe a Mach 5+ commercial jet when I see it.
- rsl7 12y agoI think I still have some marketing materials for the National Aerospace Plane from the late 80s
- cabalamat 12y agoIt goes back longer than that; the HOTOL project started in 1982 -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HOTOL http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HOTOL
- johan_larson 12y agoAnd even earlier: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supersonic_transport http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supersonic_transport I suspect this is one of those Big Challenges that keeps tempting aeronautical engineers, and they try to apply the pushing-the-envelope high tech of their era to it. The problem seems to be the economics. There aren't a lot of people who are willing to pay 10x prices (or whatever) for 3x reductions in travel time.
- kbart 12y agoMy thoughts too. The main reason is not the engines, but the frame itself. It's not very commercially viable spend days in a hangar, after few hours of flight, scanning for the micro faults.
- jzwinck 12y agoThe article title refers to a "plane engine" not a "plane." There is a huge difference: the passenger plane airframes everyone knows and flies on are made by totally separate companies (Airbus, Boeing) from the engines (Rolls Royce, GE, Pratt & Whitney). A great engine will get you nowhere without a great airframe, and when you start talking about supersonic passenger service, you have to add politicians as well. For example, the Concorde briefly flew between London and Singapore but was stopped partly due to complaints from the Malaysian government. And of course the Concorde is long since retired, despite no comparable replacement existing; this has nothing to do with its engines not being good enough.
- rtpg 12y agoAlso important to mention why Concordes got cancelled: even with cheap oil, there wasn't much demand for the plane. After a certain point, not much changes between a 4 hour flight and an 8 hour flight, especially if you have red-eye flights. Unless we figure out a way to have fast planes be cheaper to run than current models, then markets seem to show lack of interest in a Concorde-like
- qq66 12y agoThe reason that not much changes between a 4 hour flight and an 8 hour flight is that the journey adds about 2 hours on each end, making it a 8 hour vs. 12 hour journey. (1 hour to the airport and 1 hour at the airport). Urban transit systems and airport security/boarding procedures will need to get a lot more efficient before supersonic flight will be commercially viable.
- tempestn 12y agoI would love to only have to spend one hour at the airport. From my experience, that's minimum for a domestic flight. International and you're talking 2+ hours. (Unless we're talking about Europe; in that case 15 minutes should usually suffice^; at least last time I was there, a few years back. It was great.) ^ Although I'd give it 45 to be safe.
- Zaephyr 12y agoSo is the breakthrough just the pre-cooler, or the pre-cooler together with the scimitar engine? It sounds like the innovation is the helium pre-cooler, but even at that it's hard for me to understand whether their advancements are in working with liquid helium for a coolant or in the airflow cooling (both)? I don't do anything remotely like this in my day job.
- vinayp10 12y agoRichard branson was talking about doing this: http://www.businessinsider.com/richard-branson-supersonic-plane-2014-5 http://www.businessinsider.com/richard-branson-supersonic-pl...
- BendertheRobot 12y agoBut, what about the carbon impact of this? It will only be available for one percenters, no?
- robotresearcher 12y agoA hydrogen/oxygen engine emits only water. You can choose to get the hydrogen from water using from a non-carbon energy source, for a completely carbon emission free system.
- Animats 12y agoThis company has been in business since 1989, and has never produced anything. Here's their own statement of their own history: http://www.reactionengines.co.uk/about_history.html http://www.reactionengines.co.uk/about_history.html That's not encouraging. They own a machine shop company and a sheet metal company. They should have built a working model of something by now.
- tomelders 12y agoThat sort of sentiment is why we can't have nice things. These thing stake time. Remember, this isn't a kick-starter campaign. They're not trying to dupe other people out of money on some hair-brained scheme. This work has been reviewed by the British Interplanetary Society and the ESA. It's real science, tackling a real problem. I'll make a bet with you now. In 15 years, the Sabre Engine will be carrying more payloads into space than anyone else, and for less money than anyone else can offer.
- darkmighty 12y agohttp://longbets.org/ http://longbets.org/
- hahainternet 12y ago> They should have built a working model of something by now They built and demonstrated a reduced scale engine for the ESA. If you think it's that easy just to build a spacecraft when you own a machine shop and a sheet metal company then you have a lot of reading ahead of you.
- Animats 12y agoThey demonstrated a reduced-scale pre-cooler. See Aviation Leak: http://aviationweek.com/blog/esa-validates-sabre-engine-technology http://aviationweek.com/blog/esa-validates-sabre-engine-tech... The point is that their PR describes something two orders of magnitude beyond what they've done.
- pothibo 12y ago
- untilHellbanned 12y agoBored Elon musk is already doing this in 3 hours. https://twitter.com/boredelonmusk https://twitter.com/boredelonmusk
- pariya 12y agoI actually bet he reads through that Twitter account and rolls his eyes because he has already secretly invented half of it.
- jmnicolas 12y agoIt looks like a marriage between a SR-71 Blackbird and a Concorde. At 1.1 billion each, it's about 10 times as expensive as a Concorde. I hope they will find a way to keep it profitable.
- martinko 12y agoThe A-380 costs about 414 million usd and can carry ~500 people. A flight from Europe to Sydney takes north of 22 hours (not counting stop-overs). Off the top of my head, this new plane seems like a pretty good deal, doing Europe to Sydney in ~4 hours with 300+ passengers for a unit cost of 1.1 billion.
- hvidgaard 12y agoYou cannot ignore fuel cost and investment to handle the new fuel. We'll see what happens, but the most compelling thing to me seems to be the fact that it burns hydrogen and not kerosene which seems to be more environmental friendly, but I'm no chemist.
- Luyt 12y agoBurning hydrogen releases water vapour, while burning fossil fuels release carbon dioxide and water vapour. So, you could call it indeed more environmental friendly if you consider carbon dioxide harmful. However, hydrogen doesn't occur on Earth in a pure state (at least not in mineable quantities). There are no hydrogen wells. Creating the hydrogen (for example, by electrolysis of water) is expensive and generally a net loss of energy. Maybe storing energy in hydrogen is feasible if it's generated with excess nuclear or solar electricity.
- hvidgaard 12y ago> burning fossil fuels release carbon dioxide and water vapour Either I have completely misunderstood something, or fossil fuels release only CO2 and H2O under ideal conditions, which never happens. Add to the fact that any jet engine is unable to utilize any after treatment systems to remove harmful products. I am fully aware that hydrogen is rather expensive to produce, but I think it's possible that nuclear energy, or (as you mention) excess solar/wind power is several magnitudes cleaner than even the cleanest burning fossil fuel engine (including all the resources it takes to pump it up and refine it).
- EGreg 12y agoI hope they dont make too many of these planes that breathe oxygen. We may need some for humans.
- wintermute306 12y agoI couldn't help but hum the British national anthem while reading this.
- mst 12y agoI tried to join you but for some reason my brain decided to produce the Imperial Death March instead.
- Gravityloss 12y agoTitle reminds me of this 30-minute delivery anywhere in the world (much older technology): http://designobserver.com/feature/blast-door-art-cave-paintings-of-nuclear-era/6697/ http://designobserver.com/feature/blast-door-art-cave-painti...