8 ms·
An Open Love Letter to Our PC Fans
- carlmcqueen 12y agoWhile I think it's sad that PC support is finished I certainly get their point about feeling exhausted. On the other hand, the use of bold and non-bold was driving me nuts. I feel it's up to the reader to decide what is important in the text, not the making of certain sections of bold, it was hard for me to read. After awhile, as I wanted to read the whole thing, I copied into a text editor to read.
- doodpants 12y agoThey did not say that they are finished supporting the PC, just that there won't be a PC port of one specific game.
- minimaxir 12y agoKey line that sticks out: > In three years we had made five versions of our two games. For each version, the programming was done from zero.
- pjc50 12y ago<strikethrough>Well, yes. Because mobile is such a walled garden of anticompetitive language and platform wars, it's hard to write portable applications. They eventually came round to Unity, which has a cost, but does let you deliver to all the platforms.</strikethrough> Besides, it's only 2D tower defence. The artwork probably took longer than the game, and at least that's portable. Then there's the question of which platform is most profitable. I've heard that the profitability order is iOS > Android > Web > PC for this kind of game. Maybe others have experience of this. Edit: well, I guess there's no quicker way to get correct information than to post incorrect information!
- NickPollard 12y agoC works just fine on all of the (non-web) platforms you mentioned. It might be a little long in the tooth for some, but it still gets the job done. In my spare time by myself in the last 4 years I have built a complete cross platform engine from scratch for Desktop and Mobile. If one person can do it their spare time in 4 years, a couple of programmers working full time could do it a lot more quickly (I also deliberately reinvented the wheel in a lot of places I did not need to).
- gambiting 12y agoWe have a game written in C++ that compiles to, and runs on Wii/WiiU/PS3/PS4/X360/XOne. Every one of those uses a different compiler, but all build from one IDE(VS2012). But then it was built by close to a hundred people,so it's not really the same.
- NickPollard 12y agoOh yeah, of course there are big engines that also do that (with much more platform support), I was just using my own experience as an example to show that you don't even need a huge team supporting it. I remember back in the day working on a PC/Wii/X360/PS3 engine, that was fun but definitely a lot more effort. I develop with GCC rather than VS, but I have much the same setup with a single makefile that can build for different targets instantly, e.g. > make (for PC) > make android (builds and deploys to a connected android device)
- blub 12y agoThere's this thing called C++ which happens to work on all mobile platforms. I could understand having difficulty making a cross-platform app that needs deep OS integration but a game is the very definition of cross-platform.
- bluedino 12y agoAngry Birds came out in what, 2010? At some point it seemed like every device imaginable had an Angry Birds port.
- bishnu 12y agoNot all done by Rovio, however. Eg, Angry Birds for Windows Mobile was ported and maintained by Microsoft.
- timdorr 12y agoIf they settled on Unity, why not make a PC version? It shouldn't involve ground-up rebuilding of everything. In fact, they've already targeted the most restrictive environment, so it's relatively downhill to produce. They could easily get it on to the Playstation and Xbox platforms as well.
- atanasb 12y agoI was wondering the exact same thing. EDIT: Here's what they are saying about Unity: "We never had a Unity port for Frontiers. Origins is coded in cocos2d, like all the other KR games. By the time Unity became known to us, we gave it a try with the Steam version of Kingdom Rush. This was mid 2013... Frontiers was almost ready by then. Early 2014 we started working on Origins and we used the old engine out, sine the effort of adapting the old games to new platforms wasn't exactly good to us. Origins is the last game that will use our old and loyal cocos2d engine. As we define what our next game will be, we are very much aware that it must be multi-platform."
- shmerl 12y ago> If they settled on Unity, why not make a PC version? I guess they are too exhausted at this point. Even with Unity there are bugs specific to each platform and supporting that takes time.
- socialist_coder 12y agoNot really. Going from Mobile back to PC is very very easy (PC to Mobile is another story). If your game already works on mobile, it will 99.9% work on PC. The amount of platform specific Unity bugs is actually quite small, in my experience. Especially with 2D games that aren't using crazy shaders (in my experience, most of the platform specific bugs are GPU shader crashes, especially on Android. And again, that's only on Android. PC has far less buggy GPU drivers than Android). You might need to adjust some screens so they work better with a mouse instead of with taps, but this game doesn't use multi-touch or anything that can't be done with a mouse so I don't see an issue with that. You also need to write platform specific IAP and notification code, but again, going to desktop you won't have notifications, and writing platform specific IAP code is not that big of a deal, especially compared to porting your entire game. Short story is, these guys chose their engine very poorly. They had already experienced cross platform issues in the past, and seems like they just decided to ignore them until it was too late. I have no sympathy.
- xsmasher 12y agoGame co's often hire out the porting, so they can still exploit a platform without splitting their focus. Aspyr has made a living porting popular games to the mac.
- dnlrn 12y agoAspyr also do a lot of the recent Linux ports. I love Aspyr!
- Encosia 12y agoThis seems potentially very shortsighted, as difficult as it must be to measure exactly how much of their success on mobile was due to the free advertising on Armor Games, in and out of game.
- kemayo 12y agoAs an anecdotal data point, I own the last few versions of the Kingdom Rush game on iOS, and I'd never even realized that they had a flash version until I read this post.
- Encosia 12y agoDo you recall how you found the first version that you purchased? What I'm wondering is if the free marketing on sites like Armor Games was a key part of the initial push to be discoverable on the app store rankings. Of course, the existing mobile user base may all the captive audience they need to accomplish that at this point.
- kemayo 12y agoThis was a few years ago at this point, so my memory is fuzzy. I have a sense that I may have seen someone reviewing it (the iOS app specifically) and decided that it sounded appealing.
- shmerl 12y agoThis looks like a lesson in avoiding non portable technologies. Something like SDL + OpenGL could help preventing a lot of such problems.
- teamhappy 12y agoI looked into 2D engines for iOS a couple of years ago and I remember reading on one of their websites that I shouldn't worry about porting to other platforms before the game has reached popularity. The context was probably Android and not PC, but still, this seems to be exactly what was going wrong here. If they would have chosen Unity (or any other cross-platform engine for that matter, e.g., Cocos2D-X) over Cocos2D-iPhone, there would be a PC version today. This seems to be a bit of a recurring thing where we evaluate technologies wrong very early and punish ourselves in the long run. The fact that Twitter once was a Rails app comes to mind. I can't recommend enough to write software for the best case scenario. You shouldn't have to replace your entire toolchain once the thing you dreamt about happening actually happens.
- dageshi 12y agoI kind of agree with their original thought, if the game can't succeed on one large platform then being portable is irrelevant. If it does succeed then porting is an additional cost but it's a cost you can weigh up and choose to do or not do, you have the choice. That seems like a better option than over encumbering yourself to begin with by adding in effect a bunch of additional cross platform requirements.
- sehugg 12y agoHindsight is 20/20. It was 2011 when they ported the Flash version to iOS, so Cocos2D-X had just been forked and Unity had just released its Android version. Cocos2D was what all the hit games were using at the time. The game's popular enough that Activision did them the honor of cloning them for their recent Duck Dynasty game, so it's hard to say they screwed up that badly.
- programminggeek 12y agoAnother way to look at it is that the requirements changed. When the requirement is multiplatform then you pick the best multiplatform solution, when the requirement is simply the best engine for a single platform, that's a totally different requirement. It's not that the picked the wrong tool for the job, it's that the job changed.
- teamhappy 12y ago
- huhtenberg 12y agoWeird. They should be sitting now on a wealth of experience to allow them to write the next version in a more-or-less portable fashion. My guess would be that the actual reason might be the lack of reliable distribution channels and/or rampant piracy. Though there is Steam, which seems to work just fine for a lot of game devs...
- VLM 12y ago"Though there is Steam" Google for steam tower defense click steam web page link "Showing 1-10 of 101 results" Trying to be the 102nd competitor. That's tough. I can see the disinterest. Can you split a very old market 102 ways while making a profit? Frankly, probably not.
- bjt 12y agoYou've got to sell your games where the users are. It's not like there's less competition on the iOS and Android marketplaces.
- huhtenberg 12y agoIn theory KR is a TD game. In practice though most of TD games is such a crap that Kingdom Rush pretty much sits in its own category. They should have no problem whatsoever getting to the top spot on Steam.
- ghshephard 12y agoKingdom Rush is totally separate calibre of Game. I've played probably 20-30 Tower Defense games, and KR keeps you coming back because of the incredible attention to quality, details, balanced game play, etc...
- debacle 12y agoDo these games have a large following? I tried to play one once and found it to be a pretty typical "You've played a few levels, now you have to pay to win."
- minimaxir 12y agoThe launch of the original Kingdom Rush on iOS had zero IAP elements; they were only added in later. The game is definitely not pay-to-win, although there is low flexibility in strategy. (You must use all 4 types of base units.)
- smilekzs 12y agoIIRC you can and are supposed to (at higher difficulty) beat levels without using all 4
- eric_h 12y agoBeyond the standard "Campaign" modes, every level has two more modes with restrictions on which towers (and maximum upgrade levels) that you can use. All three of these games are great fun and a great way to kill an hour while, e.g. waiting for a plane.
- maudineormsby 12y agoDefinitely not necessary to pay to play these games. Makes it easier, sure, but they don't have timers or super high difficulty spikes to overcome, except maybe the last level.
- riffraff 12y agoMobile versione might differ, but I played it on kongregate (yay flash) and you could get to the end without paying anything.
- wmeredith 12y agoAren't these the guys advertising during NFL games? I hope they have a large following.
- benmcnelly 12y agoThis is why I am such a advocate of Unity, I know it didn't work out for them, but if you stage it right you can easily port to about anything worth porting to. I tend to start out with Desktop since it has the highest curve for quality and performance, and go from there.
- TillE 12y agoThe great thing is that there are a ton of good cross-platform options available now, not just Unity. From commercial alternatives like UE4 to solid open-source libraries like SDL2, or just using OpenGL ES. If you have even the slightest inclination to release on multiple platforms, you should be building it as cross-platform from the beginning. There are very few reasons not to.
- sheeba37 12y agonon portable technologies
- frandroid 12y agoQOTD: What are we going to do for the next year? Eat pizza until we learn to speak Italian by osmosis?
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI've heard this a lot in the games industry -- "For each version, the programming was done from zero. We can’t stress this enough." That seems so wasteful and challenging, anyone from the industry care to comment on how a studio would get itself into a situation of effectively zero reuse of their code?
- sehugg 12y agoLet's say it's 2011 and you want to port your Flash game to iPhone. You can try packaging your Flash game using Adobe's tools, but it'll probably be very slow, and Apple might change their mind again about allowing Flash apps on the platform. There aren't very many well-supported C/C++ frameworks for iPhone yet -- you search the forums for each and only find unanswered questions. You're worried about it working well on the new iPad. So you do the safe thing everyone else is doing, Cocos2D and Objective C. You'll worry about porting later, if the game does well. Maybe you'll just pay someone else to do it.
- NickPollard 12y agoThe main issue is a lack of money/long-term survivability for most studios, which leads them to cut many corners in order to release the game before running out of cash. This means that code is written to ship the game out of the door, rather than for the future, so there often isn't time for proper engineering. Then if that game does OK they get to work on the next one, throw away all the hacks they did last time, and start again... It also doesn't help that due to the structure of the industry (e.g. work hours, low pay etc.) they have trouble retaining developers and instead replace them with fresh grads. A huge percentage of people I know left the industry before they hit 30 (myself included). This leads to a lack of experienced engineers.
- eropple 12y agoI'm going to preface this post with a note that, yes, there are surely good developers in game development, this is not a universal thing, etcetera etcetera. Ass properly covered, I'll be real: I'm never surprised to see this because "code reuse" is generally the sign of reasonably advanced developers and I don't know a single person in game development I would hire for a role outside of it. It's not just NIH--that's a problem but one slowly going away. It's more just a fundamental lack of understanding of software engineering and building Good Code. As time goes on I've seen gamedev acquaintances poorly reinvent most of the wheels that the rest of the world takes for granted--even something as simple as serialization for save data and network transport (but no schematic validation, because "schemas suck") was trumpeted to me as this Big Crazy Great Thing. Which contextually it may be, but I kind of feel like the state of the art for stuff not involving pointer munging is about a decade behind everybody else. So, code reuse? Gotta make good code first.
- throw7 12y agoThumbs down. Those answers were disingenuous: > Should we make a PC version? Absolutely! cool. > Can we make it? Nope. should have been Yes. > Are we focusing solely on mobile from now on? Not at all. Nice misdirection. The question should have been: > Did we decide to focus solely on mobile? Yes. Then the rest of the article explaining why.
- socialist_coder 12y ago100% Agreed. They had already been bitten by cross platform issues in the past, and instead of deciding to address them and choose a cross platform game engine for their new game, they just ignored them. Short story is, they chose their engine poorly, and are now making excuses. Very disingenuous blog post.
- ebbv 12y agoTo me this post reads as "We were really surprised by our success and have been running in circles." They've foolishly made a ton of versions instead of learning how to write cross-platform or at the very least how to port from the beginning. Crazy.
- schnevets 12y agoMeh. I always assumed mobile game companies ported to PCs just to squeeze more product out of their creation. You might as well complain about your favorite Game Boy game not being ported to the SNES (with 4 shades of olive green graphics).
- brute 12y agoBad example. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_Game_Boy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_Game_Boy
- NDizzle 12y agoThese guys need to really study the recent information put out from Microsoft about how they make Office for as many platforms as they do. I think a lot could be done to make the core of the game more portable. It's just not being done for one reason or another.
- FroshKiller 12y agoWell, you could start by linking to it yourself.
- NDizzle 12y agoSorry, here is the discussion of the video: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8678936 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8678936
- FroshKiller 12y agoThanks, I missed this, and it sounded interesting!
- dashboardfront 12y agoI like how there are commenters who feel entitled to a PC version.
- tehwalrus 12y agoI do wonder why more people don't make use of a C physics engine (portable everywhere, including browsers via asm.js), and code the logic in a higher level language which can compile down to C (like Python via Cython.) I guess the problem is that you need different rendering code? OpenGL works on PC and mobile, but you'd need to mock it out for WebGL. Has someone already done this for asm.js? Presumably there is some other huge hole in my thinking...
- highCs 12y agoThat is the goal of Haxe[1] I've always thought it is a good idea. That may be under appreciated. [1]: http://haxe.org/ http://haxe.org/
- tehwalrus 12y agoThat looks awesome, and not just for games. Thanks for the recommendation!
- wtracy 12y agoHaxe looks really cool, but the last time I looked at it, the documentation left a lot to be desired (most of it assumed familiarity with the Flash drawing APIs). It does look like the situation has improved since then, but I'm guessing that documentation is a big reason for Haxe being so underappreciated.
- Steko 12y agoDoesn't Blue Stacks work fine for Android emulation on PC? BTW IGN is giving away Kingdom Rush Frontiers promo codes for iOS, limited availability.
- ourmandave 12y agoI've never played Kingdom Rush, et al, but I've read reviews of some games that were ported to the PC and the keyboard / mouse control were almost unplayable. Or they highly recommend you play with a gamepad.
- pdknsk 12y agoI don't think that's the whole story. Most likely the numbers just don't add up for IAP-less Steam versions. Kingdom Rush Steam sells for $9.99 (and was available for less if you pre-ordered). I don't know about Origins, but Frontiers has obscene IAP price-wise. Purchasing all heroes costs $40 or so, plus there is always the opportunity to buy gems for items which make it easier to progress. (Gems also accumulate as you beat levels). In fairness, this is all optional and you can beat the game without it. They kept adding increasingly difficult post-game levels though, which no doubt have tempted many to buy stronger heroes. PS. I think they should fix the bugs in KR Steam first anyway, which was pretty much abandoned.
- ghshephard 12y agoI've completed everything in Frontiers, mostly through Origins. It's a lot of fun (after settlers, my most favorite iPad game) - and it never even occurred to me to do an IAP.
- smacktoward 12y agoI like the Kingdom Rush games a lot, and wish Ironhide Games nothing but further success. That being said, this letter is cloying. A letter where you tell someone you care about that you don't have it in you to be with them isn't a love letter, it's a "Dear John" letter (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dear_John_letter http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dear_John_letter). For the recipient, those two types of letter are very different! It would have been 100% fine to just say "look, it would take a huge effort to bring Origins to PC, and we don't have the money or the energy for that." There's no need to dress it up in shiny happy "we love PC!" platitudes.