16 ms·
America’s Toughest, Ugliest Warplane
- billturner 12y agoIt's funny how just from the description - "toughest, ugliest" - I knew exactly what warplane it was. As a kid thirty years ago, I probably put together five different plastic models of the A-10 Warthog.
- krick 12y agoI actually thought of Lockheed AC-130 gunship.
- EiZei 12y agoFor some reason I thought of the B-52 first. Maybe it's the BUFF nickname.
- Aqwis 12y agoI took a look at the B-52's Wikipedia article. Apparently, it's expected to serve until the 2040s. If the last B-52 is active until 2045, B-52s will have been around for 90 (!) years. Isn't that utterly ridiculous? Imagine if any militaries were still using bombers from 1924 in 2014.
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoThat was the development time period. Once a military problem is solved, it often doesn't need changing for a surprising amount if time. For inatance, imagine if we were still using a gun from 1911? (.45 ACP) But a gun from three decades before that would be laughably archaic.
- tomjen3 12y agoIf we could have slapped electronic countermeasures and upgradable radars, etc on them I don't really see why we couldn't have flown the old WWII style flying fortresses today. I mean the job essentially hasn't changed since then, and even back then they would still need fighter escorts.
- hga 12y agoWell, the B-52 has in fact reverted to limited role, I gather for delivering nukes it's limited to delivering stand off missiles outside the range of SAMs etc. The fly really high concept, going back to e.g. the WWII B-25 Superfortress, ended, and the B-1 went in the direction of low level penetration (below radar, and hard to pick up from ground clutter by fighters above it, something the B-52 tried for a while, but it wasn't designed for that), and the B-2 back to flying (fairly) high, but essentially invisible to radar (it can be detected in a general sense by certain types of radar, but not such that you can shoot it down). We had to transition from piston engines if for no other reason than reliability and maintenance, plus, commonality and safety in fuel, etc. etc. The B-37 was our last in the strategic bomber role, also see the piston powered CAS A-1 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Douglas_A-1_Skyraider https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Douglas_A-1_Skyraider), heavily used in Vietnam, which the A-10 replaced.
- AaronIG 12y agoThe A-10 was the first plane to come to mind when I saw the description, as well. Living in Tucson as a kid, I saw these planes flying around quite a bit.
- caseysoftware 12y agoMe too. I love the A-10 itself and the concept. I've talked to a number of people who said that when they heard the A-10s coming in, they knew help was close. That's awe-inspiring for me.
- vacri 12y agoI don't really understand the 'ugly' part of the description. It looks quite balanced to me, just not 'standard boring plane'. A far uglier plane is the Caribou http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Havilland_Canada_DHC-4_Caribou http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Havilland_Canada_DHC-4_Carib...
- bitwize 12y agoNot helping matters is the fact that the Lightning II (or as I like to call it, the Littoral Combat Ship of the Air) is at least as ugly in functionality as the Warthog is in looks.
- chrisbennet 12y agoI suspect that troops on the ground don't get a say in this. Edit: I suspect that US troops on the ground don't get a say in this. In other words, it doesn't further some politician's (or politically motivated general's) agenda to champion this plane over something less effective.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- malkia 12y agoA10 is beautiful, but P-38 Lightning is gorgeous
- jsalit 12y agoHere's some more information on recent controversy over one of the Warthog's supposed replacements - http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2014/nov/30/a-10-warthog-retirement-debated-after-replacements/ http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2014/nov/30/a-10-warthog...
- justin66 12y agoThe idea that the B1B will replace the A10 is crazy enough that is hard to know what to say about it. (Except that I'm sure the air force is saying that if it helps them get what they want)
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoThe only reason the A-10 is constantly threatened with retirement is politics. The USAF insists they control fixed-wing aircraft, leaving the Army to helis or depend on the AF to support. But the AF looks down their nose at ground support. If we'd get politicians with backbone to yank ground support back to the Army, this yo-yo nonsense would end. And the reason the A-10 is still around is because it take the federal bureaucracy longer to end a program than it does to start a new war. Then they really need the A-10 because it works. (Ex-Air Force)
- bengali3 12y agoDo you think the USAF will look down on Textron's "world’s most affordable tactical jet aircraft."[1] and the concept of private companies building tactical aircraft prior to orders From a development cost standpoint I think this is a great experiment as it will skip a lot of the external politics, project managment headaches, requirements changes and politics again. But I fear politics will shun this type of development from taking off. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Textron_AirLand_Scorpion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Textron_AirLand_Scorpion
- thrill 12y agoDo you think the USAF will look down on Textron's "world’s most affordable tactical jet aircraft."[1] and the concept of private companies building tactical aircraft prior to orders You mean like they did with the F-20 Tigershark? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_F-20_Tigershark http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_F-20_Tigershark
- hydrogen18 12y agoI think you're missing the mark with F-20 Tigershark. The development was started under one political mindset and that mindset was blown away by Reagan. It doesn't make sense to develop an export aircraft when there are existing aircraft with superior capabilities suddenly available for export. There is a point to be made: aircraft are chosen for political reasons, not for their suitably to the mission. The A-10 is an example of an exceptionally suitable aircraft as is the B-52. This is not a reflection of good decision making, but just the outcome of random selection. If you build enough boondoogles (i.e. JSF) you eventually accidentally build a useful aircraft. These aircraft prove their utility and are kept around whereas the glass elephants are quietly retired. For example, consider the B-58. By all measures it was an amazing aircraft that met all of its goals. But by the time it was complete, it was built for a mission that no longer existed. The aircraft literally had no role by the time it became operational.
- lispm 12y agoThe last US four presidents all have been bombing Iraq. Result? It's getting worse and worse. Will it this time be different? Unlikely.
- Roboprog 12y agoI don't want to see my neighbor's kids coming home in a box with a flag on it. Sure, the elite starting these wars for profit are bastards. But, let's protect the people we ask to protect us. Sometimes, other people do start the fights, and we still need a military unless we want to be run (eventually) by somebody else with a better military. Work to change who is picking our fights for us, but don't begrudge the people doing the fighting some help.
- lispm 12y agoStop fighting.
- Bulkington 12y agoThe Air Force never wanted this plane in the first place. A renegade general who focused on effectivenes instead of glamorous, shiny supersonic planes pushed it through and went to the press to pressure congress to help keep it in service. http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2014/03/john-boyd-from-em-us-news-em/284223/ http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2014/03/john-boy...
- huuu 12y agoThis is also why the JSF will fail. A good plane is desinged for a goal. You can't design a plain that meets all goals.
- digi_owl 12y agoSums up proper design. Figure out the job requirements first, the design comes naturally from that. Trying to come up with a fancy design first and then fit that to some task just ends up with a glorified CAD rendering.
- venomsnake 12y agoI think that post Cold War US military has very hard time developing anything. Probably comes from the vague mission, unlimited resources (yes they are a curse sometimes), single super power winner mentality, lack of imminent treats for the us mainland, and lack of political will to do anything.
- ghaff 12y agoIn all fairness, the JSF program at least started out as a legitimate response to the plethora of different airframes and programs coming out of the different branches of the US military (as well as the UK). For years, there was a lot of complaining about the costs of each service demanding to have its own designs because it was special and the Marines couldn't possibly make do with a plane designed for the Air Force, etc. etc. Unfortunately, the history of trying to make merged designs isn't great. Differences in missions (and, frankly, the fact that those missions have been changing in many cases) seem to lead to designs that cost too much, don't do most tasks especially well, and take too long to design and build.
- Spooky23 12y agoIt's pretty funny that the military would replace this function partially with B-1B's as a cost savings measure. IIRC, B-1's were notorious for having a 50:1 hours in hanger/hours in air ratio. We seem to be in age of small unit combat against various guerilla-style organizations. They should start building A-10 like aircraft again.
- keithpeter 12y agoNo military experience myself but this is sounding similar to the way the harrier jump jets were taken out of service in the UK. High and increasing maintenance costs, effective in certain roles, no obvious replacement.
- masklinn 12y agoI could be mistaken, but I don't think the Harrier was ever hated by by the RAF or the RN, whereas the A10 certainly wasn't liked (or desired) by the USAF, and they've been looking for a way to dump it without the Army or USMC operating them pretty much since they got the frame.
- gaius 12y agoWhat the USAF and RAF have in common is a very clear idea of who their real enemy is: the Army and Navy. They would gladly sacrifice all war fighting capability, if it meant burning the other two services in the process. Hence the Eurofighter, and now the F35. I refuse to call it the Lightning; the original Lightning was a proper weapon.
- cstross 12y agoThe RAF Harriers were taken out of service in 2010 as part of a gigantic axe-swinging defense review with across-the-board cuts that sliced to the bone -- the Navy lost its carriers (the new ones won't be fully in service for a while yet), the RAF lost its entire anti-submarine warfare capability (the Nimrod MRa.4 upgrade program was shitcanned at the same time), the entire Tornado F.3 force (even though the Typhoon-II was only just marginally operational) and nearly the Tornado GR4 bombers (they have survived -- for now -- largely due to IS). The army just lost most of its main battle tanks -- they got off lightly! The RAF brass didn't "hate" on the Harriers -- they were just under pressure to take their part of huge defense cuts.
- vvpan 12y agoThis article is like war porn.
- Nexxxeh 12y agoIs it just my perception, or are articles receiving progressively less proofing before they're posted nowadays? >Campbell kept flying for more than hour "more than [an] hour"?
- rdxm 12y agoas an Infantry Marine, I can tell you unequivocally that when it comes to fast movers, the A10 is the only platform you really want covering your ass in a tight situation. It is mind blowing to many of us that the USMC didn't buy up all of these things when the Air Force wanted to dump them. Yeah, yeah they can't fly off a carrier. So what. What they can do is hang in there when bullets are flying, loiter for a fairly long time and fly low and slow enough to actually see what's going on on the ground...(yeah, that 30MM gatling gun is pretty handy too..heh) Side note: the only pilots that ever allowed us to shoot 81mm suppression over the top of the ingress routes to target when training to run CAS were the ANG A10 guys. All the active duty fast movers weren't game, and that included the MC Harrier pilots....
- masklinn 12y ago> It is mind blowing to many of us that the USMC didn't buy up all of these things when the Air Force wanted to dump them. Any time the USAF makes noise about dumping the A10, rumors about the USMC or the Army pop back up, and the USAF soon decides they're not dumping the A10 after all. I expect the USAF will just run the existing frames until they're gone, at which point they can tell the Army and USMC to fuck off because there's no plane left to grab and fix.
- spacefight 12y agoThere's a few out there. https://www.google.com/search?q=warthog+boneyard&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X https://www.google.com/search?q=warthog+boneyard&source=lnms...
- bengali3 12y ago>Yeah, yeah they can't fly off a carrier I want to believe we have the technology to make this happen
- bdcravens 12y agoTheir relatively slow speed requires a longer runway, I presume
- bshimmin 12y agoThe sound the gun on that thing makes is my favourite noise to come out of America. I could watch low-quality YouTube videos of the A-10 all day.
- asmithmd1 12y agoThe A10 is less an airplane with a huge machine gun and more a huge machine gun you can fly: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GAU-8_Avenger#mediaviewer/File:GAU-8_meets_VW_Type_1.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GAU-8_Avenger#mediaviewer/File:...
- ddispaltro 12y agoI was looking for a shot like that to put it into perspective thanks!
- ChuckMcM 12y agoInteresting to see the service rivalries in this thread. My dad was Air Force and he likes this plane. It is an interesting challenge arming up for war. I recall watching nearly every episode of Wings (which was a Discovery channel show that each episode focused on a single plane) and was really impressed at how people thought about things. The show on the A-10 is on youtube in 5 parts (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sM2KbwPMU18 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sM2KbwPMU18) and its worth a watch.
- WalterBright 12y agoMy Air Force dad liked it, too. He also liked the P-47 Thunderbolt, another ugly CAS airplane that could take a lot of damage and still get the pilot back home.
- supergirl 12y agogarbage "america is the best" article
- trynumber9 12y agoI think you misread the article and posted a garbage comment. The article, while perhaps garbage, is "A-10 is best, despite efforts by others to end it". Point by point the author's narrative is clear: "But it is heavily armored and wickedly armed, making it a ruthlessly effective weapon. And that is why, despite ongoing efforts by Defense Department brass to kill it, the Warthog is headed back into battle to help in the fight against ISIS." "That makes the A-10 something of a zombie—it refuses to die. The Air Force wants to scuttle the 238 A-10s" "The A-10, little more than a flying tank, is perfectly suited to the task and beloved by pilots and troops alike." "The A-10 can take a ton of abuse, and continue flying if it’s lost an engine, a tail or even half of a wing." and so on... The article is about the A-10 versus the Air Force brass, a continuation of the "Whiz Kids" versus the tried and true. The narrative is not "America is best".
- supergirl 12y agoThe whole article including your quotes praise this weapon made by US which was designed to "take apart a Soviet tank". It is “the ugliest, most beautiful aircraft on the planet.” It's like an ad for the army or something. America's toughest airplane, a flying zombie tank, is resurrected to destroy the evil ISIS. War is so cool.
- madcow2011 12y agoI fail to see anything wrong with any of the issues you mentioned.
- supergirl 12y agoWhat do you consider wrong? It should be wrong to glorify killing people. This is what the article does, doesn't it? It's basically an enumeration of things that make this war plane awesome, written in a North Korea propaganda style. Come on, it even ends with a threat...
- carsongross 12y ago“It’s getting older and more expensive to maintain, and that’s the problem,” (lol) Joint Strike Fighter cost per plane: $618 million [0] To paraphrase Bill Lind: what the pentagon says only makes sense when you realize that its purpose is graft, not war. [0] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning_II http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_F-35_Lightning_...
- engi_nerd 12y agoIt's a tiny bit disingenuous to say that the per plane cost is $618 million. That figure is arrived at by dividing the total estimated lifecycle cost of the program by the number of planes currently planned for production. Your number is, in the strictest sense, true, but just saying "per plane" isn't telling the whole story.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y agoIt provides a good way to compare platforms.
- anovikov 12y agoPutting things the other way around, USAF is about 40% of U.S. military by value, so we can assume it takes about 300 billion a year to operate. A plane's life is about 30 years. It makes up 9 trillion. And there are about 6000 aircraft it in. So each consumes about 1.5 billion over its lifetime, all accounted. Why is the difference of 'per aircraft lifecycle cost' so important then? Only plane for which it is comparable (actually greater) than USAF total spent per airframe is B-2A, which is no doubt a unique aircraft worth keeping at all cost, and providing much above average 'value'. So if F-35 will be 600 million per airframe, okay. Low combat attrition and delivery of 8 SDBs per sortie (which probably does several times more damage than B-52 did in Vietnam War, against average target) will make it a good buy anyway.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y ago>Putting things the other way around, USAF is about 40% of U.S. military by value, so we can assume it takes about 300 billion a year to operate. A plane's life is about 30 years. It makes up 9 trillion. And there are about 6000 aircraft it in. So each consumes about 1.5 billion over its lifetime, all accounted. Now you're ready to compare our AF to someone else's. >Why is the difference of 'per aircraft lifecycle cost' so important then? Only plane for which it is comparable (actually greater) than USAF total spent per airframe is B-2A, Because you can compare each platform's "efficiency" at a given mission, as you state in the last part of your post. It relies on getting in lots of wars though to get enough data to make reliable comparisons, "fortunately" we've got that part covered. >will make it a good buy anyway. That remains to be seen / demonstrated. The way it shakes out so far is that there is a lot of doubt as to whether the AF will be able to keep enough of them in the air, or enough pilots trained for them to do anything other than make cameo appearances. The unit cost keeps rising, the performance keeps getting revised down. This thing is going to be like the Space Shuttle (IMO), too expensive for what it does and never able to to fulfill all of its intended roles. EDIT: removed annoying double-double-negative
- lionhearted 12y agoClose Air Support -- CAS -- is one of those interesting things that you rarely read or think about when you think of air power, but is absolutely critical to mission success in anything that looks like conventional warfare. Someone already linked John Boyd below in the comments. He's worth reading much more about -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Boyd_(military_strategist)#Aerial_Attack_Study http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Boyd_(military_strategist)... http://www.amazon.com/Boyd-The-Fighter-Pilot-Changed-ebook/dp/B000FA5UEG http://www.amazon.com/Boyd-The-Fighter-Pilot-Changed-ebook/d... He's often credited with his later-life grand strategy, but his Aerial Attack Study in the early 1960's is actually more impressive to me. He developed a working mathematical model of how fighters (and other aircraft) can gain or lose speed, velocity, turning, etc at different speeds/altitudes/etc based on their specs. A lot of "sexy-looking" fighters performed pretty poorly, and the Air Force command were aghast at many aspects of the study. At the time, the "state of the art" was building multi-purpose aircraft that could do reconnaissance, establish air superiority (dogfighting), bomb enemy targets, etc. But these multi-purpose aircraft didn't excel on any parameter: they weren't large enough to carry the fuel and payload to be exceptional bombers, and they weren't fast and light enough to out-dogfight the leading Soviet aircraft. The book on Boyd I linked talks about the back-and-forth nature of defense contracting and the armed forces in that era, which was a problem. Likewise, it describes the various jockeying for power and budget between the various branches of the armed services: Navy, Air Force, and Army all had aircraft and certain missions assigned to them, and fought to preserve and expand their territory. Close Air Support (CAS) is a mission the Air Force was never so crazy about and was somewhat de-prioritizing compared to air superiority and strategic bombing missions... yet, at the same time, they didn't want to lose the mission to the Army for political reasons. Meanwhile, Boyd and the people he worked with, notably aircraft designer Pierre Sprey who led the A-10's build -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierre_Sprey http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pierre_Sprey -- they didn't see their roles as just related to being a technician or soldier, but were very deep historians and scientists. They noted that a lot of Nazi Germany's early success was the mix of maneuver warfare mixed with close-air support from Stuka Bombers. The Nazi advantage was erased when the Western Allies eventually achieved air superiority, but Luftwaffe CAS was absolutely devastating in the early stages of WWII. Sprey, Boyd, and the rest built around the theory of CAS and seeing the potential of it for turning a ground war, and then sat to work out an aircraft that was about as un-sexy as it gets, but was incredibly safe for the pilot, could stay involved in the battle for a very long time, and could have devastating impact on enemy ground forces. The A-10 thus isn't flashy, can't do multi-mission roles (at the time, it was the only pure CAS airplane in the U.S. armed forces; it only did close air support and nothing else), it's not particularly fast, it doesn't look good at an air show, it's not particularly prestigious. It is, however, devastatingly effective as a tank killer, artillery killer, convoy killer. Rather effective against infantry too. The lessons from Boyd, aircraft design, etc, are probably worth reading for anyone who deals with technology or organizational development, since they seem timeless -- eventually prestige and politics come to dominate true mission, and how do you navigate around that? The book "Boyd: The Fighter Pilot Who Changed the World" is worth reading; so are the remnants of various briefings Boyd and colleagues gave with commentary. A useful insight into lots of things, not the least of them how to actually get things done with ingenuity and how to really be service-oriented in a world that often doesn't reward that. Marvelous book, amazing men, great stories, lots of lessons. Highly highly recommended.
- jandrewrogers 12y agoThis article, like most others, overlooks the primary reason the A-10 has been slated for retirement for so long even though no one contests its effectiveness in its role. Due to the way the aircraft was designed, it has very limited upgradeability compared to most US military aircraft. While the airframe still makes for a great weapons platform, the sensor suites, avionics, and countermeasures are obsolete, and not in a good way. They've been doing a lot of nasty hacks to allow it to support modern weapon systems and electronics but there are a growing number of important capabilities that simply cannot be "backported" to that airframe. This has been increasing its vulnerability to more advanced threats and reducing its ability to deploy more advanced weapons over time. Its shelf-life has been extended by virtue of it being used in practice against adversaries with unsophisticated weaponry. This makes it immediately useful in practice but the military is well-aware that it would not be nearly as successful against a more sophisticated adversary and this is why they have been angling for an alternative. It is a relic of the Cold War not just in its history but, unfortunately, also in its defenses and weaponry with no obvious upgrade path. Its survivability and effectiveness are predicated on being used against Cold War level adversaries. To replace it with something that could support the capabilities they desire, they would need to design a completely new airframe.
- ori_b 12y agoIs the USA likely to go to war against anyone with sophisticated weaponry any time soon? It seems like we're mostly interested in wars in the third world at this point, and the A10 seems pretty well suited to that.
- bduerst 12y agoI know someone will have a differing opinion, but a lot of times it's not about having weaponry for the wars you will fight, but the wars that you won't fight. It's more game theory: If you have state of the art weaponry, the competition is less likely to start a war with you. This mentality also lead to the nuclear arms race, and today it is more about a race for automation and precision than just mass destruction.
- krisgee 12y ago
- JabavuAdams 12y agoA larger issue here is the very idea of different armed services. If you were designing a military today, would you have Army and Marines? I don't see how it makes sense. Let's fast-forward a few decades. If we have combat robots (not that I'm advocating this, but I think that's where we'll end up) then brain-wise one soldier can know everything that another can. I.e. there's no need for different MOS. You can have one brain that is both a special-operations infantry assaulter, and knows how to service any aircraft in your arsenal. The real differentiator would be morphology of the units. So, if every unit could conceivably be trained in all tactics and doctrine, what's the point of services vs. just specialities?
- bduerst 12y agoDivision of labor, and producing specialized units. Marines are traditionally a power force to be employed from the sea (amphibious) while the army is mostly land-based operations. Do they both see armed combat? Yes, but they are specialized for different scenarios. If we had a robot armed force, would it be better to have a single, mass-produced ubiquitous unit? Probably not. There you would probably want robots designed and specialized for each of their combat scenarios.
- graycat 12y agoA-10 stories are always amazing and fun to read. But there is another side that maybe should be mentioned: Supposedly the argument against the A-10 is that (1) the most important weapon the A-10 has is no longer that amazing gun but one or more of just various missiles and (2) can use an F-16, maybe an F-15, likely an F-18, in time the F-35 to fire such missiles but do it at higher speeds and altitudes where the plane is not so vulnerable to anti-aircraft fire from the ground. Or, it's great that the A-10 can take so much punishment, but a claim is that it would be better still to fly higher and faster and get nearly no punishment at all. I'm sure the astounding advantages of the A-10 are well understood. So, if some people want to put the A-10 out to pasture, maybe there is a reason. I'm just repeating the story I heard and am no expert. But, to argue for the A-10 again, to destroy an ISIS truck with a 50 caliber machine gun in the back, want to use a ~$1 million missile or a few shots from that amazing A-10 gun?
- fndrplayer13 12y agoThey'll be writing this story in 2030, 2040, etc. The A-10 is a good plane and it's not going anywhere. Versions of this story pop up every couple of years going back decades. A-10 is the plane that won't die (After the B-52, that is)
- erikb 12y agoThese are pretty air planes, why are they called ugly?
- PythonicAlpha 12y agoShould better read: Americas "most effective" Warplane is Going Back into Battle. As much I know, this plane is the most effective plane against ground targets. Some targets just can't be hit effectively from great heights and this plane also stays much longer in the area as other planes can. It might be the best compromise between a helicopter and a plane. Also it is very cost effective in comparison to some of the more modern planes.
- smegel 12y agoWhen was it withdrawn from service?
- kosmic_k 12y agoIt's a relic of the cold war that everyone seems to have a completely unrealistic and romanticized view of. Yes it's a heavy slow plane that was designed around a massive gun. But that gun actually isn't very effective against modern armor. The A-10 could not penetrate the T-62 from the front, let alone the better armored T-72. For a gun kill, it would need to attack from the rear, but that would put it at significant risk to soviet anti air. The solution was to use a Maverick missile against armor. There are now far more effective planes to lob missiles at armor. All while staying high and away from danger. The A-10 also was not designed with MANPAD's in mind, because they didn't exist then. Even if they do survive, there is down time in having to repair the platform. In a cold war gone hot scenario, the airforce estimated that they would have lost all of their A-10's within 2 weeks of conflict. For the CAS mission an Apache would be just as good. 16 Hellfire missiles along with strafing with a 30mm chain gun throws a hell of a punch, all while being slow enough to accompany ground troops.
- hga 12y agoThe A-10 also was not designed with MANPAD's in mind, because they didn't exist then. Nonsense on stilts. US production of Redeyes was ended, at about 85,000 total produced, a year before the detailed specifications of the A-10 were finished. The Soviet equivalent went into service a couple years before the latter. As for penetrating MBT frontal armor, I was always under the impression that top hits were the objective if trying to destroy one without using a missile, which the A-10 can carry a lot of. Airplanes do have the advantage of being above land vehicles after all.
- msandford 12y agoExcept that Apaches are fragile, while the A-10 can take a huge beating and stay in the air. Anything which claims to be CAS but can't take some hits without falling out of the sky isn't terribly useful. The reason Apaches are used is that they're not fixed wing, which means the Air Force isn't demanding to own them, meaning that they can get pilots and commanding officers who do more than pay lip service to the idea of CAS.
- masklinn 12y ago> For the CAS mission an Apache would be just as good. 16 Hellfire missiles along with strafing with a 30mm chain gun The A10 has triple the hardpoints (11 to 4) and 10 times the payload (7200kg to 770) of the Apache… So it's just as good if you have 4 or 5 times as many systems in flight.
- guscost 12y agoThis short documentary is a nice tribute to the A-10: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0YktOuoqA-I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0YktOuoqA-I It's a leaked version with blurred out faces, apparently because the Air Force decided not to release it.
- johnohara 12y agoIt was basically designed to “take apart a Soviet tank,” says Jeffery S. Underwood, a historian at the United States Air Force Museum at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base in Ohio. Just in case the collapse of the rouble, precipitous drops in oil prices (traded in dollars printed somewhere else), problems in Ukraine, the technical inability to extract vast hydrocarbons found in the Arctic, and a list of other issues, have a negative impact on Russian decision making.
- rebootthesystem 12y agoUgly? No way. That plane is beautiful. Particularly when on your side of a battle. I hope to be able to build a 10 foot wingspan RC model of the A-10 next year.
- sehugg 12y agoTime to fire up DOSBox and play some more A-10 Tank Killer? http://www.myabandonware.com/game/a-10-tank-killer-v1-5-12w http://www.myabandonware.com/game/a-10-tank-killer-v1-5-12w
- tim333 12y agoGlad to see the A10s going. I'm involved with helping raising money for the refugees in Iraq and it seemed a shame that tens of thousands of people had to flee their homes when a few A10s shooting at ISISs vehicles could have prevented much of that.
- phkahler 12y agoBurt Rutan designed a more modern plane, but was turned down because it was too cheap. ARES https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zG9LlHcX8lg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zG9LlHcX8lg
- hga 12y agoIt's loaded weight is around 1/10 that of the A-10, they aren't at all comparable aircraft. The derided elsewhere in this discussion Scorpion sounds like it's maybe 5 times the plane the ARES is, and these things don't scale linearly in terms of effectiveness.
- phkahler 12y ago>> It's loaded weight is around 1/10 that of the A-10, they aren't at all comparable aircraft. If the primary mission is to carry the big gun, then they serve the same purpose. I would bet ARES could have benefited from being a bit larger with better armor, but the price tag was around $1M if I recall correctly, and the small size and composite construction may have given it a smaller radar cross section as well. Part of the weight savings is in the non-hydraulic control surfaces. It's nice that the A-10 could revert to manual control when both hydraulic systems failed, but that raises the question "why have them at all?". Simplicity is has been a major part of designs from Scaled Composites.
- ihunter 12y agoAw, she's not ugly.
- rbanffy 12y agoAm I the only person who thinks it does not look that bad? It has that special elegance that comes from being pure function - it's, after all, a cannon with wings - where no line is afforded if there is not an excellent reason for it to be there.
- WalterBright 12y agoAn airplane that does its job and gets its crew back safe is a beautiful airplane.
- gregpilling 12y agoI live in Tucson, and my house is on approach for Davis Monthan Air Force base. I enjoy being in my backyard watching an air show everyday. The A-10 is quite well liked in Tucson, many people here call it "an all terrain deer rifle" or a set of wings strapped to a big gun. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GAU-8_Avenger#mediaviewer/File:GAU-8_meets_VW_Type_1.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GAU-8_Avenger#mediaviewer/File:... I doubt it will go away any time soon. D-M is one of Tucson's biggest employers, and Senator McCain will want that to keep existing. Also, people in the military who serve on the ground seem to universally love it. It seems like everyone has an A-10 story. As for the replace it with an F-16 argument, I would think the most likely replacement would be a drone version of the big gun with wings. McCain would get behind that, since a lot of drone work is done 60 miles down the road at Ft Huachuca in Sierra Vista AZ. Read about an A-10 getting shot and surviving here http://www.af.mil/News/ArticleDisplay/tabid/223/Article/117270/operation-iraqi-freedom-hero-shares-her-story.aspx http://www.af.mil/News/ArticleDisplay/tabid/223/Article/1172...
- hwillis 12y ago>you hear that pfffff yeah, pfffff. Here's what it really sounds like: http://youtu.be/ZAkzrxN5Jn0?t=20s http://youtu.be/ZAkzrxN5Jn0?t=20s