8 ms·
Chinese economy overtakes the U.S.’s to become the largest
- graycat 12y agoApparently if count numbers of cups of coffee, okay. But if count number of Cadillac cars or equivalent, number of three bedroom, two bath houses or equivalent, etc. apparently not. If compare GDPs at the present exchange rate, the US remains way ahead.
- tomp 12y ago> These calculations are based on a well-established and widely used economic measure known as purchasing-power parity (or PPP), which measures the actual output as opposed to fluctuations in exchange rates. So a Starbucks venti Frappucino served in Beijing counts the same as a venti Frappucino served in Minneapolis, regardless of what happens to be going on among foreign-exchange traders. > PPP is the real way of comparing economies. So, it's not entirely clear if China is really the biggest economy, or just by using an accounting trick called PPP GDP. Sure, maybe a Chinese middle-class person can buy more Beijing Frappucinos than a middle-class person in Minneapolis, but the disparity in foreign exchange rates still means that an American coming to China can buy more Frappucinos than a Chinese person coming to the USA.
- kozhevnikov 12y agoSubstitute Frappuccino for a burger and it is the Big Mac index. http://www.economist.com/content/big-mac-index http://www.economist.com/content/big-mac-index
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoIronically, Big Macs are on sale right now for 10 kuai in Beijing.
- nothrabannosir 12y agoNice. Maybe not in China, but some countries force McDonald's to lower their BigMac price to hack that index. The Wikipedia page mentions countries doing this, and, seeing the quality and price of Big Macs in some places compared to other Mc burgers, it's not surprising. E.g. the Argentinian one was half price of everything else, it was an awful burger, meat covering half the bun. And it was never advertised, only conspicuously tucked away at the bottom of the menu in a corner of the shop: http://i.imgur.com/MbCaZnG.jpg http://i.imgur.com/MbCaZnG.jpg How's it in China, compared to other burgers?
- Thimothy 12y agoAh, Argentinian creative economics. I follow their developments from time to time just for the amazement value, this one is new for me, thank you. For those curious, here is an excellent article about its history, worth the read: (Paywall) http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/778193e4-44d8-11de-82d6-00144feabdc0.html http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/778193e4-44d8-11de-82d6-00144feabd... (Google cache version) http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:eFrFcG7iOKIJ:www.ft.com/cms/s/0/778193e4-44d8-11de-82d6-00144feabdc0.html+&cd=1&hl=es&ct=clnk&gl=es&client=firefox-a#axzz3L1MkHN00 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:eFrFcG7... And another one with some of the juicy parts: http://www.businessinsider.com/a-timeline-of-argentinas-sordid-history-with-default-2014-7 http://www.businessinsider.com/a-timeline-of-argentinas-sord...
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoThe bigmac in China is about the same in quantity to the states, it's normal price is just slightly cheaper than the USA version. Now if they would just give me a second packet of ketchup for the fries and ice in the drink, I might not feel like I'm in a third world country.
- happyscrappy 12y agoTry going into a Greek owned restaurant in the US. They give you the greasiest food possible and don't want you to have any napkins.
- fractalsea 12y agoIn my experience this is a terrible metric. The demographics that McDonalds is marketed in different countries varies enormously. I find in Western countries it is seen as unglamorous, cheap and quick food. Whereas when I was in India, for example, it is much more expensive than cheap food you can buy there, and therefore is seen much more as a nice place to go with your family (or girlfriends/boyfriend), and it tends to be middle class people who go there. I was trying to think of a good alternative product for this index, but I really couldn't think of any single product that is marketed at exactly the same demographic in each country, as well as having comparable market penetration, and being desired by people to the same degree.
- hrktb 12y agoCoca cola could fit the bill
- justquest 12y agoThis a good explanation, but I have to point out that for this particular example (being able to buy Frappucinos in China because they're cheaper), the opposite is true. Fun fact: Starbucks is significantly more expensive in China than in America, even if you use the currencies at their current exchange rates. Not fun fact: I live in China, and I like Starbucks.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoBeijing?
- justquest 12y agoI actually haven't been to a Beijing Starbucks, but in Shanghai, Hangzhou and Ningbo, Starbucks products are markedly more expensive. I imagine that for Beijing the same would be true. I suppose I shouldn't speak for China as a whole, as I haven't been to Starbucks all over the country.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoThey are probably the same price. I was just wondering if you were in Beijing. They have Starbucks almost everywhere now, even my wife's hometown in southern hunan.
- dagw 12y agoAre there any local coffee shops that sever 'western' style coffee? And if so are they also more expensive than Starbucks in the US. Also what is the local equivalent of a cappuccino and what does that cost. PPP generally deals with equivalent goods and not identical goods, especially when the goods have to imported at great expense to one country. I mean even here in Sweden Starbucks is a good 50% more expensive than your random local coffee shop, so Starbucks probably isn't the best comparison to make.
- nothrabannosir 12y agoYes, and they are, also, ridiculously expensive. A (awful) capuccino can easily cost 30 kuai, where a very nice plate of rice with bacon and garnish from a low-end shop will cost you 10. The entire drinking coffee outside game is just shockingly expensive in China. At least I haven't found the cheap ones. 1 us ~= 6.15 kuai
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoFrappuccinos are more expensive in Beijing than Seattle (I know, I have a habit...). Actually, many things in China are more expensive than in the states: if you want the "lower cost of living", you have to be willing to endure the "lower standard of living" that is possible in China without as much stigma as in the US. If you want a nice apartment, nice safe food, decent education for your kids, a car, medical care, you've got to pay more dearly for it.
- tomp 12y agoWhat about compared to NY? Also, it might make sense to compare Starbucks in China to a non-us company in the US. Midn you, I understand that PPP does matter (e.g. products imported to both China and USA, such as German cars, will probably be priced lower in China than in USA precisely because of PPP difference), but nonetheless it's just one way of measuring the size of economy, not necessarily the right one.
- simonh 12y agoAll other things equal, german cars are going to cost as much in China as they do in the USA because China gets no discount because of it's weak currency, in fact when buying abroad it works against them. They still need to pay the germans just as much hard cash as americans do. The advantage PPP gives poorer countries is that goods that depend on domestic labour, which is very cheap, get to be equally cheap. Any goods or services that don't depend on that cheap pool of domestic labour don't get that benefit. German labour in Germany isn't cheaper to buy in China than it is to buy in the USA, so PPP is irrelevant. As an aside, German cars are actualy vastly more expensive (up to 2x or 3x for high end models) to buy in China than in most countries due to severe import taxes, but the base cost of buying the car from Germany to ship to China would be about the same. [Re. Some BMWs made in China - in which case they're not really German cars]
- coob 12y agoBMW manufacture some cars in China.
- jvm 12y ago> So, it's not entirely clear if China is really the biggest economy, or just by using an accounting trick called PPP GDP. There is no objective way of measuring the size of an economy. Imagine some hyper-simplified economies where the only asset produced is computers. Economy A sells 1000 Apple IIs* per year at $3k each. That means it has a nominal GDP of $3m. Economy B sells 1000 Retina Macbook Airs at $1k each, for a nominal GDP of $1m. Which is a bigger economy? Nominal GDP says Economy A is bigger: more dollars traded hands. PPP GDP says Economy B is bigger, since Retina Macbook Airs are much more than 3x better than Apple IIs, so the value being produced is greater. But of course this also means we have to define PPP, which is extremely challenging in the context of any modern economy. It gets even crazier: Economy C, the government pays workers $5m total to dig unwanted ditches. Nobody gets a computer. In terms of nominal GDP, Economy C is bigger than Economies A and B.
- crdoconnor 12y ago>It gets even crazier: > >Economy C, the government pays workers $5m total to dig unwanted ditches. Nobody gets a computer. Because GDP is not nor was it ever meant to be a measure of how great your country is. It is simply a measure of the total volume of transactions (which correlates to wealth but is far from being the same thing).
- jvm 12y agoCertainly Nominal GDP is a measure of the volume of transactions. However, PPP-adjusted GDP is intended to be a measure of national income in real terms, or put another way, the amount of value actually produced. Which is how people often intuitively think of GDP.
- crdoconnor 12y agoUm, $5 million to dig a ditch still means no value produced even if it was PPP adjusted.
- jvm 12y ago
- AmirS2 12y ago>Sure, maybe a Chinese middle-class person can buy more Beijing Frappucinos than a middle-class person in Minneapolis, No, this isn't what's being said as the number we're talking about isn't per capita. I guess you could read it as approx 4.3 (1.3bn / 300m) middle class Chinese people, between them, can buy more Beijing Frappucinos than a single middle-class person in Minneapolis ... (of course this still isn't true as GDP is still only a crude proxy for individual income, it really measures the total of a particular subset of all _transactions_ in the economy).
- tkubacki 12y agoobviously that's why so many Chinese multimillionaires relocate to US.
- FireRabbit 12y agoWhether it is or not doesn't really matter. The Chinese economy has been doubling every 10 years or so since 1980. So if it isn't the world's #1 now, it very soon will be.
- kokey 12y agoThe same was said about Japan when it was on the up.
- davidw 12y agoChina is 1 billion plus people. They have a large role to play in the world economy unless they do something really stupid or terrible. They were the largest economy in the world throughout much of history, if I recall correctly.
- vorg 12y agoFrom the Sui (late 500's) to the mid-Qing (around 1750) most historians seem to say they were, though it's hard to say whether the Han (220bc-220ad) or the Roman Empire was "larger".
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoChina goes up and down throughout history. Many Chinese seem to believe that China can only go up now, just like Chinese real estate prices.....
- vorg 12y agoMaybe you've seen the "China 2049" adverts that popped up everywhere around China a few months ago promoting, among other things, an equal standard of living with Western countries by the 100th anniversary of the republic's founding. I guess they're designed to keep Chinese motivated to grow the economy further.
- crdoconnor 12y ago
- legitquest 12y agoWhy does total GDP matter so much? China has over a billion people. A much more accurate metric is GDP or even PPP GDP per capita. Only when China has 3x larger economy than US economy will it be of the same size per capita to the U.S.
- czr80 12y agoOn a per capita basis the US is currently 10th (Qatar, Luxembourg and Singapore are the top 3).
- justquest 12y agoI like your name. I imagine, you would have signed up as legitquestion, but legitquestion was too long, correct? -justquest :)
- legitquest 12y agoYes :) I signed up just to ask this one question!
- tinco 12y agoBecause on the global power scale it doesn't really matter if half your population is starving or not. And if you want to compare the peoples wealth, remember the one percent rule. How much richer does the US have to be for its bottom 50% to be as wealthy as The Netherlands' bottom 50%? It's all numbers games, this number is about global economic power, the sort that could have all sorts of real (nasty) consequences.
- simonh 12y agoIt's not at all about real global power, it's about domestic economic capacity. As soon as China tries to start exerting it's economic muscle abroad, it has to compete on international terms which means adjusting costs to take advantage of domestic costs doesn't matter anymore. For example, does China's GDP at PPP 'equality' with the US mean it can fford as many nuclear submarines as the US, as many aircraft carriers? As many advanced state of the art stealth bombers, fighters, tanks, spy satelites and naval bases? No, it doesn't, all it realy means is it can afford as many roads and bags of rice as the US. As soon as China starts investing in, developing or buying international standard technology and eqipment it has to start investing or spending international standard capital to do so, and PPP doesn't help anymore. Even in the case of 'soft power' such as financial support and investment in other countries, that has to be done in foreign currency. Suddenly the domestic purchasing power advantage of the Yuan becomes an equal and opposite disadvantage.
- pmontra 12y agoThis is a ranking about PPP. There are about five Chinese persons for every American. The sum of their income will keep getting larger and so will their economy. GDP and economic output don't automatically relate to how well people live but they do relate to the influence a country has over the world. If we care about how happy people are in their country then maybe we should look at http://www.oecdbetterlifeindex.org/ http://www.oecdbetterlifeindex.org/ There is no clear number 1.
- gardarh 12y agoThat's a really clever site, seems like an elaborate way to say "It depends" when the question is "What is the best country in the world".
- muyuu 12y agoIf housing in the UK is a 6/10 I don't want to know how are 4/10s or worse.
- disputin 12y agoAgreed. UK housing is a third world problem in a supposedly first world country.
- Tyrannosaurs 12y agoInterestingly if you put in the cliche American free market priorities (jobs, income high, safety, work life balance, environment low, everything else in the middle) the US does come out top (as opposed to high but not top on a more even measure). The same things seems to happen if you put in the sort of priorities other countries are generally believed to hold (so put in the environment, satisfaction, work life balance and so on and the Scandinavian countries leap to the top). So if there is any truth in the cliches, countries do seem to optimise for what is important to them. Which I guess is what you'd hope happened. As an aside there doesn't seem to be too much you can do to stop Australia being a great place to live - they don't have a slider for "Deadly animals".
- 12y ago
- ternaryoperator 12y agoFor comparison, using the more traditional measure of an economy's size, nominal GDP, the US economy is about 2x the size of China's. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nominal) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nomi...
- kokey 12y agoHaving moved between developing and developed countries recently, I was reminded of what GDP in PPP misses. It's even cruder than how inflation is measured through CPI or RPI. In one country it might be cheaper to get services that depend on a lot of labour, like restaurant meals, cleaning and tailoring, but in another country you can walk or take public transport to the restaurant or tailor without the fear of being the victim of a crime. You can buy ketchup for cheaper, but it is not necessarily as safe or hygienic, it won't have seals under the cap in the store, you won't have as many options to choose from, etc. I think in a globalised world and especially when you look at commodidity prices, PPP is good to measure if people have 'enough' to live on in a particular location but for comparison between countries it's pretty meaningless.
- autokad 12y agoyeah, and if china balanced to the US in real terms, all that industry they sucked up would flee thus dropping them right back down
- duckingtest 12y ago>but in another country you can walk or take public transport to the restaurant or tailor without the fear of being the victim of a crime That's unrelated to the prices. 3 relatively poor countries are in fact much safer than the US [0], and all safer ones are poorer than US. >PPP is good to measure if people have 'enough' to live on in a particular location but for comparison between countries it's pretty meaningless. The overwhelming majority of living costs are local (especially food production), so PPP is a very good measurement. Prices of electronics and oil aren't that important for day-to-day living. You seem to ignore the fact that, even in PPP, the average Chinese is really poor. It's just that their standard of living is $12k poor, not $7k poor. [0] http://www.oecdbetterlifeindex.org/topics/safety/ http://www.oecdbetterlifeindex.org/topics/safety/
- yarou 12y ago>Yes, when you look at mere international exchange rates, the U.S. economy remains bigger than that of China, allegedly by almost 70%. The irony is that the US has been running up debt for decades upon decades. The US economy is equivalent to someone that has an unlimited credit line, who pays absolutely nothing while continuing to spend lavishly. This article does not bring any new information or shed any light on the truth about our global economy, such as the creation of externalities that deprive human beings of basic rights. All this article does is present an old narrative (the financial news equivalent of race baiting). Grab the datasets yourself, do your own analysis, and don't listen to yellow journalist rags like this which are clearly promoting an agenda. GDP, PPP, etc are metrics which have a low signal-to-noise ratio, because the speed with which capital moves renders any units to measure economic output meaningless. USD is still the reserve currency for most of the world (at least for the countries who account for the lion's share global economic output). Even if that were to change to RMB or [insert fiat currency], the current corrupted system will continue to exist and exploit. Do yourself a favor and become educated about cryptocurrency. Learn why this current global economic system is corrupt and a new form of enslavement. Then you'll realize that we don't need central banks. You will realize that you are not a child that needs to be constantly monitored by a nanny state. And so your enlightenment begins.
- jsprogrammer 12y agoJust curious how you think the US economy could expand without increasing debt. My understanding is that the amount of transactions occurring is dependent on the amount of money in circulation. The amount of money in circulation is directly dependent on debt through the fractional reserve banking system. Under the current system, the only way to 'grow the economy' is to increase the volume of transactions or use money creating transactions (bank loan).
- NoPiece 12y agoMoney is created via debt, but the economy expands when people create things of value.
- 12y ago
- throwawayaway 12y agoThink the current dive in oil prices is only going to accelerate that trend too!
- jeroen94704 12y agoI don't really understand the fascination with nominal GDP, be it in US$ or PPP. Those numbers are heavily influenced by the size of a country's population, which according to wikipedia ranges from something like 100,000 all the way up to 1.3 billion. That's four orders of magnitude! That's like comparing a Formula 1 car and a Peugeot 107, and then deciding the guy in the Formula 1 car is a better driver because his lap times are faster.
- velik_m 12y agoI find the analogy slightly ironic, since the best driver in formula 1 is indeed determined not only by his own skill, but also on the basis of his car quality.
- austinz 12y agoBecause each set of numbers measures a different set of things. Singapore and Luxembourg may have a larger per capita GDP than the U.S. or China, but the absolute size of their economies is far too small to allow them similar amounts of military or diplomatic influence compared to the larger countries. Likewise, a small country where everyone earns a lot of money is more attractive a market for a company selling luxury goods than a country where the total GDP is thinly spread across a large but destitute population.
- melling 12y agoWhere's India on the list? It's as big as China. The point is that since the 1870's the United States was bigger, even with a large population difference. It's certainly noteworthy that China has caught up, or the U.S. is falling behind.
- throwaway1592 12y agoI read a lot of comments about the "Calculation" It really doesn't matter how you calculate it. China is the number one economy and American is on its way to becoming Japan or worse Greece. Having a been in China a lot its easy to see why. China is really striving to be number 1. They are setting a goal and accomplishing it. American on the other hand is mired in Bureaucracy and lack of vision for what we want to do. Therefore we can not make progress. When we have goals we accomplish them. What to end foreign dependence on fossil fuels. We are making good progress towards that end. American needs to think bigger and accomplish hard near term goals. We need to stop saying by year 2030,2040,2050 and think we want to do this in the next 4 years. China as many advantages of US. The things that people say are a disadvantage (Population & Government) are an advantage over the US. If i was able to be president this would be my stance: - Immigration. - Pay tuition to a 4 year college and graduate. Greencard. Increases intellectual horsepower - 3 million Mexicans. Greencard. Increases manpower - Energy - by 2020 50% of all electric will be generated by non-fossil fuels. 2025 80%. - 2025 be the #1 export of oil and coal - Budget. balanced by 2020. - Military. halved. - Education. Spending doubled. - Healthcare. free - Taxes. flat - Infrastructure 7% GDP What will be the big goals be: - Moon by 2030 a sustainable colony. - Mars by 2040 a sustainable colony. - Mars by 2050 100,000 people - Population 500,000 by 2040
- userulluipeste 12y ago"- by 2020 50% of all electric will be generated by non-fossil fuels. 2025 80%." "- 2025 be the #1 export of oil and coal" That's interesting, especially seeing these goals being put together! "- Infrastructure 7% GDP" How did you come to this number? Keep in mind that infrastructure costs depend on a lot of factors, like expropriation of private property, building new infrastructure and up-keeping the existent one in a number of more or less accessible places, development of new infrastructure technology and a lot more. China got a lot of these for almost free: it can afford to expropriate at ridiculous prices, it builds infrastructure with cheap labor and materials (bought at home market prices), it got its hands on new technology cheaply from abroad through various tricks (versus developing it from scratch), and so on. There's a lot to talk about infrastructure and resources allocated to it, and 7% may or may not be the answer. "- Moon by 2030 a sustainable colony." "- Mars by 2040 a sustainable colony." "- Mars by 2050 100,000 people" Moon and Mars are not fit to be inhabited by humans (for their gravitation being inappropriate, if nothing else). "- Population 500,000 by 2040" You wanted to say 500,000,000 maybe?
- mrfusion 12y agoI predict this story is going to become another "voyager leaving the solar system" type of thing. By one measure or another this is going happen once or twice a year for the foreseeable future.
- melling 12y agoWell, we've been watching for the last decade as the predictions were made. Now they are coming true. Many people denied that it would happen and China would be another Japan, for example. We should be observing history at its slow and steady pace. As India and China lead the world within a century, the United States will have to learn to fit into its new role farther down the ladder. We could be the Great Britain of the 22nd century.
- ende 12y agoHardly. China's growth is already sputtering. China will go the way of the Asian Tiger. This is catch up. What's far more concerning is imagining a country the size of China undergoing the current meltdown in Japan.
- austinz 12y agoYou mean Celtic Tiger? China's growth is 'sputtering' because the government is starting to make the sort of reforms that everyone said they needed to make to move growth away from being driven by debt-funded infrastructure spending, but were too scared of making because of the short-term costs. Now that that's happening, the media narrative has shifted to "economic growth targets dropped 0.5%; economy in imminent danger of collapse".
- melling 12y agoThe American economy sputters too. I'm not sure exactly what you're saying. Can you be more precise and give a time period?
- known 12y agoAbout 100 million people in China are surviving on less than $1 a day http://www.chacha.com/gallery/6490/15-things-china-doesn-t-want-you-to-know http://www.chacha.com/gallery/6490/15-things-china-doesn-t-w...
- _almosnow 12y agoBeware of China. They are not America. They must be evil. And while you're at it, check out "The 10 Ugliest Celebs According To Amanda Bynes". What a terrible choice for source.
- icebraining 12y agoYeap. They've been raising millions from poverty each year, and they're finally down to less than 8% earning less than $1.
- andyidsinga 12y agoi think its a little childish that the first pic in the page is a pic of a bank with a bunch of garbage in the front. not-so-subliminal msg...
- ArtDev 12y agoBased on local purchasing power, so the title is misleading. "Yes, when you look at mere international exchange rates, the U.S. economy remains bigger than that of China, allegedly by almost 70%."
- desireco42 12y agoRegardless how you measure, they are HUGE. And getting bigger at rate we can't match. I wish them all the best. This doesn't diminish size of US economy. I think this opens up more opportunities for all of us.
- arbuge 12y agoThose 200 years dominated by Britain and the USA as described in the last paragraph are not yet over, if you add their economic output together again...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]