14 ms·
In France, New Review of 35-Hour Workweek
- VieElm 12y ago> All told, French workers put in an average of 39.5 hours a week, just under the eurozone average of 40.9 hours a week, according to the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. For comparison, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics the average for Americans in non-farm employment work an average of 34.5 hours per week: http://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t18.htm http://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t18.htm Which is way less than the amount worked by anyone I know or have ever worked with in engineering and corporate jobs. I don't know if this number is so low because of under-employed or part time labor, but I doubt it given the breakdown over the various industries in that table on the bls.gove site.
- Swizec 12y agoTo an outsider, this is what the US workday looks like: * 3 hours driving for no reason * 4 hours working * 6-7 hours fucking around pretending that you're being productive I'm sure there's a lot of fucking around in French (and other European) offices as well, but Americans seem particularly adept at spending long hours at the office while actually working very little. Source: every American I've questioned in depth about their workday. Mainly in Silicon Valley, haven't had the chance to talk to too many others. Source2: A recent-ish poll on HN where the "I actually work 2 hours a day" option won
- efa 12y agoThat's the feedback I got from a German co-worker when I was working in Silicon Valley. In Germany they just work 8 hours. But it's all heads down working. In the US we screw around (talking, surfing the web, etc) much more. But I know from experience that workers in Spain screw around A LOT as well during the work day (and lord the long lunches at sit down restaurants!). So all Europe is not the same.
- nostromo 12y ago2012 German GDP per employee: $43,243 2012 American GDP per employee: $68,374 On paper at least, the US is much more efficient creating value from employees. http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SL.GDP.PCAP.EM.KD http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SL.GDP.PCAP.EM.KD (Both numbers are in constant 1990 PPP $)
- pyrrhotech 12y agoa large part of American GDP is not based on employee productivity
- dkokelley 12y agoCan you expand on this? Do you mean to say that much of American GDP comes from things like natural resources where American employees have the fortune of working to extract? What other factors besides employee productivity and natural resources would contribute to GDP?
- Swizec 12y agoA lot of it is just higher buying power. For example, you can sell SaaS for more in the US than you can in Europe because Americans are simply able/willing to pay more. High GDP is a sort of self-fulfilling prophecy in a consumerism oriented economy. If everyone makes more, everyone can make even more, which results in even more spending and then even more money making and ... you get the idea.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoDoesn't matter if things cost more in the US - the numbers given are adjusted for purchasing power. They represent the fact that in the US, a given worker produces a larger basket of goods.
- vidarh 12y ago
- contingencies 12y agoYou forgot endless coffees, ceaseless yabbering on mobile phones, thousands of telephone meetings and still pointless face to face meetings with external companies so the sales people can pretend to be busy and get out of the office awhile.
- IndianAstronaut 12y agoThe 40 hour work week was meant for labor work, not thinking jobs. Applying that workweek to devs has to stop. One can only think and plan for maybe 3 to 4 hours a day.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoA quick google search suggests that the average commute is 25 minutes, and about 0.2% of the population has a megacommute of over 1.5 hours. For comparison 4.3% work from home. http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/03/05/americans-commutes-not-getting-longer/1963409/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/03/05/america... Unfortunately, I don't believe the census tracks time spent fucking around at work.
- rgbrenner 12y agoYou're not comparing like numbers. Here's the OECD data: http://stats.oecd.org/index.aspx?DataSetCode=ANHRS http://stats.oecd.org/index.aspx?DataSetCode=ANHRS Average annual hours: France: 1489 US: 1788
- jonawesomegreen 12y agoIt has been my experience that the North American 40 hour work week is also a myth in practice.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- diverse41 12y agoThe 35 hours law was implemented very differently for blue collar vs white collar workers. For white collar workers (including software/it people), the law was implemented with a certain number of extra days/weeks of vacation per year, above the standard 5. And each company had it different. So if one talks about the 35 hours law in France about software/it workers, please do not start counting weekly hours. Ask about how many weeks of vacation instead. Accordingly, when I moved from France to the US, for the same company, i lost a few weeks of vacation, but boy, the days were WAY shorter.
- nandemo 12y ago> a certain number of extra days/weeks of vacation per year, above the standard 5. No doubt you mean "standard 5 [weeks]" and not "days", but note that won't be obvious to many of us in less enlightened countries like US and Japan.
- diverse41 12y agoCorrect, 5 weeks. I got up to 4 weeks in the US eventually. The strangest thing for me in the US is how many people are convinced they cannot take 2 weeks at a time, and how many are leaving days on the table each year.
- delackner 12y agoCould you elaborate about the fr/us move causing shorter days? Most u.s. software companies seem obsessed with long hours.
- diverse41 12y agoContext: worked in a high-tech company, no longer a start-up, but still growing very well. In the US, almost everybody had left at 6.30, most people at 6.00 pm. In France, as a white collar, you are expected to work until 7.30 pm minimum, often 8.00 pm, and I was. Still today, my friends in France say that when they try to leave at 6.00 pm for whatever reason, they get jokes like "you're taking half a day off today?" Start time was about 9.00 am on both sides. Lunch break was outside the office in France, at usually 45 minutes long. Usually a bit longer on Fridays, maybe 1:15/1:30 when no pressure. Shorter in the US, at my desk. Maybe just a company thing. The longer lunch with colleagues in France was much more efficient at fixing issues than the 20 minutes at my desk, since we talked shop a lot even though we relaxed. Bullshit work, unnecessary meetings was about the same both sides.
- DanielBMarkham 12y ago"in reality, France’s 35-hour week has become largely symbolic, as employees across the country pull longer hours and work more intensely, with productivity per hour about 13 percent higher than the eurozone average. And a welter of loopholes lets many French employers outmaneuver the law." What concerns me from a public policy perspective is that people vote on politicians and platforms based on some simple, plain-language representation of what they stand for. "35-hour work weeks for all!" is pretty catchy, and I might could be behind it. But then when the policy is implemented, it's done so in such a convoluted and byzantine fashion that I am not longer able as a voter to determine whether it was a good idea or not. So we then begin all these partisan debates over the slogan, when in fact the slogan was never really tried. This is a defect of centralized, complex governments: it really has nothing to do with your political stance or what you support or oppose. I could say the same thing about Strategic Defense Strategy in the U.S. If something is explained on way, supported by the public in one way, but implemented in such a way to confuse what's really going on? The system fails. I think the saddest result of this is watching very intelligent and passionate people debate various positions and policies, none of which ever have any chance to actually be implemented in anything near the terms in which they describe. So it's like watching smart people debate the relative merits of their own imaginary castles. As a programmer, I like it when I code something and it doesn't work. The computer language causes me to express my desires exactly, I must transcribe them faithfully, and even then, sometimes I get it wrong. The feedback loop is quick and honest. Such is not the case in these matters.
- ricardobeat 12y agoHow do we always end up back where we started? It's been shown over and over that the majority of office jobs are not productive beyond 6 hours/day. Hiring more people to "fill in the gaps" is a misunderstanding.
- pkaye 12y agoCan you cite your sources?
- Panoramix 12y agoDo you have the references for that? It's I topic I'm quite interested in.
- mattm 12y agohttp://mrzine.monthlyreview.org/2010/whaples020410.html http://mrzine.monthlyreview.org/2010/whaples020410.html
- ddoolin 12y agoAnd a lot are likely even less than that, from my experience.
- namdnay 12y agoThe problem is that for office jobs in France, the 35h week never became the 7h day. It just became the same 40h week as before, except you get an extra 12 days holiday a year - so not necessarily more productive.
- jedisct1 12y agoOr, in most companies, you don't get any extra day off at all, but you're allowed to take two 15 min breaks per day. Which doesn't make a difference in practice.
- namdnay 12y agoI've never seen that for "cadres" - it's always a day rate ("forfait jour"). Maybe it was for non-cadre office workers? Like call centers or something like that?
- seanstickle 12y agoOnce again, I have to point to the Results-Only Work Environment — http://gorowe.com/pages/rowe-standards http://gorowe.com/pages/rowe-standards. ROWE isn't the only way of doing this sort of thing, but it's a good approach. Companies hire people to produce results, not to sit in an office for a certain number of hours. Given this, stop trying to manage where and when people work, and start focusing on whether they are delivering results. This endless parade of articles about work hours is reminiscent of people discussing the threadcount of the Emperor's clothes.
- tanderson92 12y agoForgive me if I am missing something that is obvious about ROWE, but what is to stop management from shifting the goalposts in a ROWE ? By continuously requiring more from their workforce they are receiving more hours of work from them while being able to say "We do not force set hours, we only require reasonable results from our employees" ? It simply seems easy to manipulate.
- seanstickle 12y agoThat's a great question, tanderson92. Unless you've had a remarkable work experience, you'll find that bad management shifts the goalposts in a 40-hour work environment too. "Work harder, work faster, work smarter!" This behavior is independent of the environment. The advantage of ROWE is that it removes a lot off waste (hours tracking, telecommuting paperwork, microaggressions about hours worked, etc.) and lets people actually focus on the work. If you have executives that want to destroy the company by crushing the workforce then, yeah, no environment will stop them.
- adeptus 12y agoSo what's preventing management from imposing huge amounts of workload when there's no limit to how many hours you work? The usefulness of a set limit of hours is that it protects the employee from work overload.
- 12y ago
- finalight 12y agolet's face it, and deal with it in my country, 44 hours a week is average sometimes, we might even reach 50/60 hours
- e12e 12y agoWhich country is this? How many work(non-vacation) weeks a year?
- finalight 12y agosingapore usually monday to friday but 5.5 working days for some other companies (referring to white collar job btw) so if you just assume it's 5 day week, then it would be 25 working days approximately a month, times 12 would be 300 this year we have 10 public holidays and that's again under assumption that these holidays falls on non weekend (if fall on saturday, it's considered as gone) so 300 - 10 = 290 so ya, that's about that
- yitchelle 12y agoWorking long hours in Singapore is a mindset problem. When I was working there in 2005, it is the norm that the project managers would schedule at 6pm in the evening with the local teams.
- bato 12y agoWhen I was living in France, I thought it was a great idea. As a white collar (so not being bound to the 9 to 5 and sometimes pulling in 36h shifts...), the system worked as such: I would work 5 days a week, and get an extra day off of my choice every fortnight. The results were really great for me and people I knew: I no longer needed to take days off to deal with paperwork, and other administrative tasks, I could finally get an appointment with my banker. I could afford to go to the day market to buy fresh produce. I knew of married couples that would alternate theirs to be on days where the kids didn't have school (traditionally wednesdays) so they didn't have to source someone to watch over the kids on a traditionally very busy day for childcare. Obviously the system is not perfect, but surely as work gets "easier" the way forward would be to reduce hours worked, not increase them...
- zobzu 12y agoi think thats a great point - that said most french ppl i know pull about 45h a week in the tech industry and are "manager" level (but arent actually managers)
- bato 12y agoThat's what most white collar jobs are ("cadre"). They do come with a more favourable termination notice and retirement plan as well so it's not all bad.
- nilkn 12y agoA friend of mine is a chemical engineer at Chevron and he gets every other Friday off. This is in the US. Technically he's supposed to be working 9 to 6 instead of 9 to 5 to make up for it (which amounts to an extra 8-9 hours over the 9 working days from the two week period), but I think in practice it's still pretty lenient. That said, this sort of arrangement seems to be extremely rare in the US, and I think even among oil companies it's fairly rare for desk jobs.
- derf_ 12y ago> That said, this sort of arrangement seems to be extremely rare in the US No, this is pretty common in government and government contracting. It's called an RDO: "regular day off"... more commonly known outside the US as a "rostered day off". When I was a contractor we had even more flexible arrangements: we could work whatever hours we wanted, as long as they added up to 80 every two weeks. Eventually this got abused enough it was cut down so you could shift at most 10 hours between week 1 and week 2, but you could still, say, work just four 10-hour days every week.
- squozzer 12y ago"in reality, France’s 35-hour week has become largely symbolic, as employees across the country pull longer hours and work more intensely, with productivity per hour about 13 percent higher than the eurozone average. And a welter of loopholes lets many French employers outmaneuver the law." So then, what's all the hubbub? Why bother changing something that's obviously ineffective?
- timesizing 12y agoYou're onto something there. The hubbub is all due to a kind of hobby of English-speaking media (=their wealthy owners?) to whack France & its world leadership in lowering the nationwide definition of "full time" amid proliferating worksaving technology - God forbid we should switch from the standard layoff response thus disempowering employees & weakening wages and markets, to trimming hours across the board and maintaining employment and wages and markets = no more complaints about "slow growth" = upsizing despite constant downsizing. As for "ineffective," in 1997 the 35 hours was voted in because official unemployment (UE) reached 12.6%. After the workweek went from 39 to 35 in the next four years, UE was down to 8.6% in 2001 before the US-led recession hit France. Hmm, 4 hrs cut, 4% UE cut. Isn't that what the USA got 1938-40? 44hr workweek in 1938, UE 19.0%; 42hrs in 1939, UE 17.2%; 40hrs in 1940, UE 14.6%. Hmm, 4 hrs cut, 4% unemployment cut again. See Roediger & Foner's history of the US workweek, Our Own Time. The objection to workweek reduction is that it's effective, so it must be slandered energetically - those who talk most about freedom are most scared of it, and financially secure free time is the most basic freedom, without which the other freedoms are either inaccessible or meaningless. Deets on timesizingdotcom.
- Spooky23 12y agoMy wife had a 35 hour job. It basically meant that most people took a 1 hour lunch. Other than less fibbing about 30 minute lunches, didn't have a huge impact based in any other gig she had. My employer allows up to flex days per two week pay period. I don't do it, but it seems to work well -- people tend to come in early and get shit done, and if they need to work on an off day, they can accrue some limited time in compensation. There's always a few workaholics, but the place is very productive with minimal drama around death march work conditions.
- kristianp 12y agoThere is no explanation in this article for what makes the 35 hour week bad, except for weasel words like these: "And critics say the rule is a reason that France’s unemployment rate is more than double Germany’s rate of 5 percent.". The 35 hour rule has little to do with the difference between Germany's and France's unemployment rates. This article is pretty frustrating, it's such a hotchpotch of arguments. Then the article goes on to talk about the underemployed, which is a separate problem.
- Fede_V 12y agoI think the free market does an absolutely wonderful job of creating amazing conditions for workers that are in high demand. For top tier programmers (which are highly over-represented in this forum) working in tech hubs, you can look forward to lots of work perks, smart managers, career progression, and excellent pay. Working long hours in an interesting job with a manager who supports you is usually not that big a burden. Labour regulations aren't really designed for this community. You have to take into account the people who lack the education or aptitude to work a challenging job - and those people will be ruthlessly crushed and exploited unless the government steps in and provides a floor.
- spacecowboy_lon 12y agoExplain stack ranking and PRP then
- Fede_V 12y agoThose are pretty terrible (and I've heard that at least MS finally got rid of stack ranking) but compared to the kind of shit that an employee at a fast food chain has to go through, it's a blissful paradise. Until they were shamed in the mainstream media, Starbucks used to treat employees schedules as linear optimization problems without any regard for the human beings behind them: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/08/13/us/starbucks-workers-scheduling-hours.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/08/13/us/starbucks-w... """Last month, she was scheduled to work until 11 p.m. on Friday, July 4; report again just hours later, at 4 a.m. on Saturday; and start again at 5 a.m. on Sunday."""
- texthompson 12y agoCouldn't Starbucks just add another optimization term that demands a minimum amount of time off?
- EliRivers 12y agoYes, they could do, but then they might have to have another employee or some other such that means they make a little less profit, so fuck the workers, if they don't want the job there's some other sucker who'll thank me for the chance to be exploited.
- transfire 12y agoWhat should "no longer be put on a pedestal" is Work. Work is not a virtue. It is a necessary means to an end. When we go beyond that necessity we become servants to the Economy, rather than having an economy that serves us.
- toddkazakov 12y agoThere is big problem with the employment in France. I spent almost a year there and this is a country where I am not going back. I worked as an engineer in big enterprise at 35 hours a week + RTTs - meaning I am working 37.5 hours but I can take more days off. Everything sounded great before I went there and realized there is double standard - employees vs. contractors. If you are a contractor you have no rights and you are expected to work as much as your manager says. In the end I was spending more than 50-55 hours a week and the overtime I did was not paid accordingly. If I wasn't OK with this I'd be let go easily and there are no laws that protect me. I would not be fired, but I will be transferred back to the contracting company who is not obliged to pay me, if I am not working for a client.
- antoinec 12y agoI'd be really curious to know which contracting company you worked for. What you are stating is not true: when you are transferred back to the contracting company (for whatever reason), if they are still your employer, this company has to pay you. Even if you don't work for a client. This is not that uncommon actually to be in that kind of situation. However, contracting companies are well known to be really hard on their contractors (especially developers), if they saw that you would believe that you wouldn't get paid unless you work free extra hours, that doesn't surprise me that they'd use that. But it would never have happened. In France, work laws are much more in favor of the employee, they would never have gotten away with not paying you.
- nraynaud 12y ago> I will be transferred back to the contracting company who is not obliged to pay me, if I am not working for a client. this is highly suspicious. In France services companies, people are paid in between contracts.
- namdnay 12y agoThe ONLY case where this would be possible is if the OP was self-employed, using a contracting company to get a position with a client ("portage salarial") - In which case they are not employees and hence aren't really in a position to criticise employment practices.
- vegancap 12y ago35 hours? I think I've done that in 2 days!
- PaulRobinson 12y ago1. Introduce 35-hour week rule 2. Allow multiple ways to get around that rule by employers 3. Employers offer zero-hour contracts or don't offer full 35-hour contracts at least 4. Some employees end up working 60 hours/week to make up the difference, therefore not getting the advantages the law was intended to create 5. Note that on average people are working 39 hours/week, not 35, and only slightly behind the 40.9 hours/week average for the rest of the Eurozone 6. Insist all of this is stopping companies investing in France because somehow this makes French people look "lazy" 7. Backtrack and insist the 35-hour rule will remain in place This a law that doesn't work, nobody follows, is bad for the image of France but in fact workers are 13% more productive than the rest of the EU, is threatened with being removed, but will be saved because the lawmakers think it does work and is being followed and isn't bad for the image of France? Right. And this is the country of the deep thinkers and intellectuals? Uhh huh...
- spacecowboy_lon 12y agoBut its the non french international firms that get raided :-)
- vitalurk 12y agoWe just move the the US and profit from our brains here.
- rzwitserloot 12y agoI don't really understand why this isn't more of a political thing. a 3 day workweek seems like a total magic silver bullet to me that solves a tonne of issues: * Happiness index should go way up. * The generation that is heading for retirement around now doesn't really know what to do with their time. If you actually work the full 40 hours a week, and you have a family, then, especially a few years ago, you simply didn't really need a hobby. You could zone out and watch some TV on saturday, work on the home on sunday, and monday is another workday. The problem is: these people end up miserable in their retirement because they don't know what to do with themselves. With only 24 hours of work a week, you WILL find a hobby. * People spend more money when not working, and when money is being spent, the economy is much healthier. * Convenience goes way up; with a 24 hour workweek, work is forced into moving away from a rigid work schedule: You can no longer declare that monday-friday, 9am-5pm are work times and all other times are off-work. That means that people are expected to not work during times which are still considered normal 'work hours'. This leads to expansion of work hours, thus, more convenience (things being open from 8am to 8pm or longer, monday to saturday). This is more relevant for europe; in the US, most things are already open a lot, many things even 24/7. This also means that things that are usually only open on workdays, such as the DMV or a bank or a doctor's appointment can be visited by people without requiring awkward arrangements at work to make time. * Unemployment is solved overnight, because you instantly multiply the job market by about 1.4 (okay, it's not that much, but more than enough to stave off unemployment for a long long time). * It in fact moves the work market dynamic back to a seller's market, which is GREAT: Right now things like automated delivery trucks aren't advancing nearly as fast as it could simply because unemployment is already an issue and nobody wants to deal with thousands of unemployed truck drivers. Automation (which is something we should hopefully strive for; what satisfaction is there in doing a job a machine could easily do?) SHOULD be something we encourage; in practice, it isn't. * Good for gender equality, in the sense that it is much simpler to share child raising duties if the normal workweek is just 24 hours. You can now have a real career without having your kid be raised by your spouse or a live-in nanny. * Good for job mobility, because you now have far more time to think about what you wish to be doing, and more time to do research and even interview for jobs you are curious about. If people start moving towards jobs they like, the theory is that they'll be more productive in that job, so it's good for everybody and great for population happiness. * Traffic jams are cleared instantaneously, and in general this moves work environments towards accepting that colleagues aren't either 'all present' or 'all gone', so even if traffic picks back up, workflows will adapt much faster to accepting that people arrive and leave in staggered fashion. Sure, moving towards an actual 3-hour workweek, especially in a different way vs. the move from 6 to 5 in the past (where EVERYONE got the same day off: Saturday) is a long process, but it's so obviously worth doing!
- jedisct1 12y agoIf you work in IT, 35h/week is something you will never see in France. You will hardly see tech people leave the office before 8pm, 7pm at best. If you leave before, people are going to point a finger at you "taking the afternoon off". Engineers typically have a "cadre" status meaning that they can work 10 hours a day. That doesn't include remote work after getting back home. When I moved to the US, what struck me is that work days are way shorter. Most engineers were gone by 5:30pm. People actually have spare time after work. Sure, there are less vacation days, but at the end of the day, the work-life balance is way way way better in the US.