13 ms·
Doxxing defense: Remove your personal info from data brokers
- slvrspoon 12y agoyes, like this: https://www.abine.com/optouts.php https://www.abine.com/optouts.php
- doctorfoo 12y ago"Many women gamers and developers, as well as those who support them, have lately come under attack from online trolls" Please don't whitewash the GamerGaters who have also experienced such attacks. (For example, one was "doxed" and mailed a knife with a suggestion to kill himself - which I'd argue a far worse "attack" than any online threats. The anti-GamerGate media of course doesn't report on this.)
- lentil_soup 12y agoWhat about a source for that?
- doctorfoo 12y agohttps://twitter.com/kingofpol/status/525755692318457856 https://twitter.com/kingofpol/status/525755692318457856 Keywords "gamergate knife".
- ceejayoz 12y agoI'm sure all the folks claiming @femfreq made up her death threats will be equally skeptical about this one.
- doctorfoo 12y agoIt's tribal warfare, well done! I'd like journalists to report both claims.
- rudolf0 12y ago"KingOfPol" is known for lying and generally being not too mentally stable, so it's certainly not a stretch. Sarkeesian on the other hand is unlikely to lie about such things, but there was clearly some exaggeration involved.
- mafribe 12y agoWhy is Sarkeesian "unlikely to lie about such things"?
- rudolf0 12y agoBecause she's (sort of) a public figure and if it was revealed she was lying, it would look very bad for her? She also hasn't had a history of lying about such things in the past, so there's no reason to suspect she is now. She is known to have lied about certain other issues, but not in a way that's relevant to threats or harassment. She also doesn't come across as mentally unhinged or malicious. I dislike her, but I don't think she lied about any of the threats. The other person being discussed, KingOfPol, is known for his narcissism and fabrication of stories, so it's a bit different.
- mafribe 12y agoThat's not an exhaustive analysis. I recommend to look at risk vs reward. The risk of getting caught is essentially zero: just use Tor and VPN via an 'unfriendly' third country to send fake threats to yourself, or get a friend to do that for you. Clearly the police is not going to investigate, because all these cyberthreats are obviously not serious. The upside on the other hand ... Sarkeesian made how much last time by playing the damsel-in-distress? Wasn't it over $100k? That's quite an incentive. And then there is the political effect: the mainstream media, for various reasons, will automatically sides with the damsels. I spent quite a lot of time in activists' milieu and I smell attack techniques in a Leninian mould, see e.g. Alinsky's "Rules for Radicals".
- ceejayoz 12y agoIf nothing else, the pattern of harassment and threats made towards not just her, but other women in gaming, are readily verifiable and hard to miss. It's not just one person complaining about this stuff.
- theorique 12y ago@nero (on twitter) was sent a syringe in the mail.
- doctorfoo 12y agoI will optimistically assume I am being downvoted for off-topic rather than further whitewashed.
- eli 12y agoI don't know what "whitewashed" means in this context, but you are definitely off topic and your comment reads like you are trying to justify some pretty terrible actions. The fact that other bad things happen to other people in no way excuses the bad things that happened to female game developers.
- doctorfoo 12y agoIt's the bias in the media. GamerGate supporters are painted uniformly as misogynists. There is a legitimate argument about press ethics, freedom of speech, and whether appreciating an attractive body is the same as objectification. >justify some pretty terrible actions I'm asking that the terrible actions of BOTH sides are reported. There is an awful, hateful minority on both sides, but in the mainstream media, only the terrible actions of the GamerGate side is reported. (And there is surely legitimate argument on both sides, too.)
- makomk 12y agoNot only that, the entire reason harassment against women in gaming is in the news right now is to attack GamerGate. Nearly every article is focused on using it as proof that GamerGate are misogynistic scumbags. It's been a huge boon for every asshole who actually wants to drive women out of gaming - they're guaranteed widespread media coverage about how awful gaming is to women and how their actions represent gamers as a whole, and as a bonus their actions get blamed on people who hate them. Win-win! People have even called for gamers to be forced to use their real names as a solution to the harassment, which would of course make the harassers' lives even easier - but hey, it'd let the people making the proposal bring down social consequences on supporters of GamerGate, so why not? The whole thing's fucking ridiculous.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago
- sp332 12y agoIt's just an example, not an exhaustive list.
- icebraining 12y agoWhere in that sentence are "GamerGaters" excluded?
- doctorfoo 12y agoThey are excluded by omission. The words "come under attack from online trolls" link to a further article that paints all GGs as the very devils themselves.
- blauwbilgorgel 12y agoJust because a data aggregation site does not show your data on the front-end, does not mean they deleted it from the back-end. So now you can charge 50$ for people to search in the "special" data pile, where people took the effort to remove it from the front-end. These data brokers crawl publicly available information. Telling them to remove your data, only slows down the doxxer, it does not stop them at all, since the data was already shared. It is not plugging the leak, it is mopping up some of the water. A false sense of security and a clear sign to the doxxer that you care about your anonymity (so more "lulz" to be had). A proper doxxing is also much more than entering a name in some search engines. Especially hackers do not like to be doxxed. For internet civilians who already put this data out there (on social media) a simple data broker doxxing is a mere reminder that such data is public to everyone, not just friends. Doxxing defense is guarding your anonymity online. Everywhere. Doxxing defense is knowing when to change persona's, and when to log off. That is: If you care about it at all. If you care about keeping your identity a secret online, see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9XaYdCdwiWU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9XaYdCdwiWU (The Grugq - OPSEC: Because Jail is for wuftpd).
- sp332 12y agoSlides from that talk: http://www.slideshare.net/grugq/opsec-for-hackers http://www.slideshare.net/grugq/opsec-for-hackers Edit: and discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5729860 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5729860
- niels_olson 12y agoYeah, this isn't even mopping up water. This is exerting effort to lie only to yourself. The emperor has no clothes and the emperor is you.
- joe_the_user 12y agoYeah, The simplest defense is to completely separate any online persona from your "real" offline persona. Obviously, how separate you make them has to be proportionate to many enemies you expect. But you are an actual public person who is public with their real name, I do not envy you.
- 12y ago
- rl3 12y agoThe fact most of these sites even have opt-out mechanisms, and that they're apparently effective, is surprising and quite nice. Though, I suspect this became the case out of necessity as a result of horror stories and litigation.
- theorique 12y agoHow trustworthy are those mechanisms though? I'm rather skeptical of the "guarantee" of a business whose model is to aggregate huge amounts of "dirt" and let people pay to suppress it.
- 300bps 12y agoThe fact most of these sites even have opt-out mechanisms, and that they're apparently effective, My last name is one that fewer than 20 people in the world have. So doxxing protection and name management in general is very important to me. A few years ago I took about a day and had myself removed from everywhere I could find. Far more comprehensive than this article. In the three years since, I've slowly been added back to all of them. I haven't moved, I haven't added or subtracted phone numbers, I've made no life changes. It just seems like these data brokers remove your information when you ask and then for whatever reason just add it back again. One example: whitepages.com. I was removed from there about two years and then suddenly my name and address are back again. That's just one example that leads me to believe the opt-out at these data brokers is "temporarily effective" at best.
- rl3 12y agoSeems like doing it on a persistent basis is required then, regardless. Admittedly it's a sad state of affairs, but it beats nothing.
- thinkling 12y agoI only looked at Spokeo, the first site on the list in the article. To opt out, you have to give Spokeo your email address, they send you a link, and you click the link to be delisted. Why does Spokeo make it so easy? The only answer I can think of is that they now have your email address and value that. Draw your own conclusions...
- wpietri 12y agoWow. This is an app just waiting to be built. I would definitely subscribe to a service like this. And I would happily give money to a nonprofit who provides this as a free service for women in tech. Developers, start your IDEs!
- brotoss 12y ago>And I would happily give money to a nonprofit who provides this as a free service for women in tech. Hahahah oh wow never change Hacker News, never change.
- wpietri 12y agoAh, the anonymous bro. 10 years later, Penny Arcade is still just as relevant: http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2004/03/19 http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2004/03/19
- muyuu 12y agoWhy not men too?
- psykovsky 12y agoBecause men.
- wpietri 12y agoThis response grates a little. It's so common that it's widely discussed and parodied. E.g.: http://finallyfeminism101.wordpress.com/2007/10/18/phmt-argument/ http://finallyfeminism101.wordpress.com/2007/10/18/phmt-argu... http://www.robot-hugs.com/but-men/ http://www.robot-hugs.com/but-men/ And it's closely related to the "not all men" line, equally mocked: http://www.listen-tome.com/save-me/ http://www.listen-tome.com/save-me/ http://imgur.com/gallery/z5AYz66 http://imgur.com/gallery/z5AYz66 But assuming that you are sincere and just unaware of the context: The reason that I personally would offer to fund this service for women in tech is that diversity in tech is an issue I have been working on for a while. Even though women are a relatively small proportion of the field, those women are a disproportionately large share of those getting abused with things like doxxing. I don't like that and want it to stop. It would be my hope that by offering it widely, it would enable more women to speak up both about tech and about their experience in tech. Which I in turn hope will promote a more diverse and inclusive field. Which I think is a good end in itself, but I also think that means better empathy for all sorts of users of tech, and therefore better products and less systemic waste. Is that helpful?
- ryan-c 12y agoAbine's DeleteMe[1] service will take care of removing you from these sites, though it's not cheap. They will keep re-checking and re-removing. I've been using it for a few years, and it seems to work pretty well. IIRC there was still one site that I had to call and deal with myself. 1. https://www.abine.com/deleteme/ https://www.abine.com/deleteme/
- ghayes 12y agoI would also add Safe Shepherd [0]. We remove your information from the standard data brokers, and also give you guides on how to remove yourself from a large universe of sites yourself. Message me if you have any questions. Edit: The service costs $13.95/mo, but you can get started with a 10-day free trial where we'll kick off all of the removals. You can (fully) delete your account at any time if you'd like. [0] https://www.safeshepherd.com/ https://www.safeshepherd.com/
- tempVariable 12y agoDude, there is absolutely no mention of price, cost , whether it's FREE or NOT anywhere on that site, before I give you my information, and that includes the terms of service copy. I looked and the only headline in the ToS that kind of address it is "You have to pay us in order to use some of our Products". If that is a base-case you start with for new customers, then thanks but no thanks.
- tilsammans 12y agoThanks for adding the price info to your post. Should probably be on the site too. :-) is your service open for non-US people? And will it be useful?
- ghayes 12y agoThe top data brokers are very US-focused, so our service is US-focused. Outside of data brokers, we can the web for your information and have guides on why the site might be exposing your information and what to do if so. This is useful for all people.
- Someone1234 12y agoThe US really needs something akin to the EU's Data Protection Directive[0]. I've seen tons of businesses hide some tiny clause in their T&Cs (page 30, subsection 15, paragraph 11, etc) which allows them to resell your data to whoever will pay. For example the National Geographic Store sold my personal data when I purchased something from them (even with no check-box opt out, etc during checkout), and I've been receiving girly catalogues and credit card applicaton snail mail ever since (with a glaring typo which points right to National Geo's store). I don't really see that happening (the US getting better data protections) as the US constitution is being largely used to protect business's "freedom [to do whatever the hell they want]" rather than individuals/people as was intended. I was really hopeful that when the blackmail criminal-record racket started that that might finally result in substantial changes within the US, but nope. Nothing has changed and the blackmailers still operate. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Protection_Directive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Protection_Directive
- giarc 12y agoI know you can enter email addresses as x+y@example.com where x=your regular email and y=some word/phrase to indicate who might have sold your email. For example, if you register bill+NG@example.com with national geographic, and you find yourself getting to: bill+NG@example.com from spam, you know who sold your info. My question is, do you think companies know this trick and just remove the portion following the "+"?
- marco1 12y agoThat does only work with Gmail, doesn't it? I don't think this is that widespread yet, so few companies (if any) will remove the part after the plus.
- wiredfool 12y agoIt works with many mailservers, on postfix it's called recipient_delimiter. It's enabled on dreamhost as + as far as I know. The amount of spam/phishing I'm getting to me-macromedia@ and me-adobe@ is pretty amazing. Guess I was part of _that_ breach. I'm not sure I'd go through that if I were doing it again. I've got hundreds of those emails out there, and being able to just drop some of them hasn't been the help that I would have hoped for.
- gear54rus 12y agoThe Internet never forgets. No app is going to change that because Internet is de-centralized and de-centralization makes it impossible to know if the data was really completely removed or not. Let's face it: the only way to not expose your personal info is to not share it in the first place (forget silly Facebook, G+, Instagrams and all that stuff). If you've already done that, make sure that whatever you are doing that might lead to doxxing is done with your other identity (although this is hardly fool proof since linking identities can happen in many unexpected places). Worst of all is that that kind of infomation, once it slips, is impossible to contain and you have to cut ties and start over. Relevant: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect
- munin 12y agothis information gets populated without you sharing it. if you pay utility bills, rent, buy a house, appear in court, or other similar acts, those acts get stuck into online databases forever. so to not "expose" your personal information is to not buy things and live in a tent. but be sure not to get arrested for trespassing or vagrancy...
- hyperbovine 12y agoNot relevant. I've never used social media a day in my life. Nevertheless, clicking a few links in this article turned up my full name, age, birthday, every address I've had since I was 14, email address, and convenient links to pages containing that same information for every member of my family. This is all obtained from public records over which you have literally no control if you lead any semblance of a normal life. There should be more legal protections in place to prevent using public data in this way.
- csommers 12y agoThe issue at hand isn't really related to "silly" Facebook, or other "cultural" sites. Unless you straight-up do NOT: own a home, rent, buy anything, go to school, etc. you will have some kind of available public record. Yes, it's true that many people go beyond this with what they make available on social media and that's a definite issue. When people start "combining" excess social media posts, with "outside" known data...that's when you've got an issue. This usually results in people being able to EASILY dox someone due to the social side of things giving out information that is normally "protected"(think maiden name, previous locations, relationships, dob/location, etc.), all of which can be leveraged with public information to nearly total dox someone. At the end of the day, we're in a new "age", where people will have to learn to protect their internet identity, as well as their "personal".
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- grecy 12y agoRather than trying to make it harder for people to stalk/harass/intimidate others by hiding data, why don't we get tough with laws and sentencing? A 5 year jail stint for the next 10 idiots to pull this stunt will reduce the incident rate of this happening a lot faster.
- angersock 12y agoYes, indeed, that's what we need--5 year prison sentences for exercising 1st amendment rights. Preventing the creation of these databases? No, far too difficult to enforce...instead, let's go after the uppity little guys. You've suggested a remarkably short-sighted solution to a very thorny problem.
- grecy 12y agoYou're telling me it's my first amendment right to mail a knife to your home address and suggest you kill yourself?
- logfromblammo 12y agoThe protection prevents the government from denying you the ability to make the threat. It does nothing to prevent them from pursuing a criminal prosecution after you have made it, or to prevent your victim from litigating a tort claim against you for intentional infliction of emotional distress.
- grecy 12y agoI suppose the 2nd amendment prevents the government from denying me the ability to use a gun to shoot someone too... but saying that isn't constructive to the discussion of how to do we stop people shooting each other with guns. Yes, I have the right to threaten someone because it's free speech, but I should still be punished for doing it. (i.e. I have the right to have a gun and use it to shoot someone, but I should still be punished for doing it)
- cowsandmilk 12y agoThere are plenty of sources of information where you cannot opt out. If you own property in Massachusetts, I can find it using http://www.masslandrecords.com http://www.masslandrecords.com , you can't opt out of that.
- hackuser 12y agoThe electricity provider here requires the use of 'smart meters' (that is, if you want to use their electricity). Via smart meters, they can identify what electrical appliances are used in your house and when (and possibly even how you are using them, such as what TV show you are watching), giving them a good picture of everything that goes on in the privacy of your home.[1] There is no opt-out. They have this information on everyone in the state. [1] This is not at all a fringe theory. It's been discussed on HN at least a few times.
- cthalupa 12y ago>(and possibly even how you are using them, such as what TV show you are watching) This seems hard to implement, realistically. I know the theory behind it - they can determine how much power a scene takes to show on a TV. But this is going to fluctuate depending on the brand of TV, the model, and so on. They would need to have data for each scene for each different unique type of TV set, and that just doesn't really seem all that feasible, if you ask me.
- jn1234 12y agoExcept is that information public? That information actually has an extremely legitimate use, which is to better manage peak grid usage and how to optimize that.
- hackuser 12y ago> Except is that information public? I don't think it needs to be easily accessible to the public to be problematic. Many people, including businesses and government, can have access. The electricity vendor has little incentive to protect it, to scrutinize government requests, etc. Recent NY Times articles describe the US Postal Service accepting almost all law enforcement requests for information on their customers. Also, data has a way of leaking ... > That information actually has an extremely legitimate use, which is to better manage peak grid usage and how to optimize that. I do see a benefit to it, but 1) It should be anonymized and minimized. For example, how about aggregating data about usage on my block and storing that? Cleaning it of anything that violates privacy, such as high-resolution individual signals? 2) My privacy is a higher priority than their technical benefits; there's an assumption (maybe not by you) that whenever there's a tradeoff, privacy doesn't amount to much -- this is money we're talking about, after all.
- peterwwillis 12y agoI don't think this is an effective defense. First of all, doxing works the same way private investigators do, so they do not require one-stop-shopping data banks. Social engineering and public records searches usually give you everything you need and are free. Second, if you're coming from the standpoint of a feminist decrying the ails of an oppressive society, you are pissing people off that will be motivated in attacking you; they aren't going to back off just because your information didn't show up on PeopleFinder. IMO, the only defense against doxing is to dox yourself. Doxing is just a form of intimidation, after all, usually done by people who think publicizing some "secret information" will be taken as a vague threat. Make the information public and you remove their ammunition. To me, the best defense against a troll is being completely nonchalant and not giving a shit what they do. Hacked my accounts? Oh well, it's just an account, i'll make another. Sent me death threats? Hey, life is short and we all die some time. The more you show your attackers that you will not be bothered, the more they realize they are powerless to harass you. That combined with reducing one's online footprint in general will break down their motivation and move them to other avenues for venting hate and frustration.
- shadowfox 12y ago> IMO, the only defense against doxing is to dox yourself. Doxing is just a form of intimidation, after all, usually done by people who think publicizing some "secret information" will be taken as a vague threat. Make the information public and you remove their ammunition. > To me, the best defense against a troll is being completely nonchalant and not giving a shit what they do. Hacked my accounts? Oh well, it's just an account, i'll make another. Sent me death threats? Hey, life is short and we all die some time. I am clearly a little less nonchalant than you. But I don't feel all that inclined to publicly post my home address or my kid's school address or scout camp location.
- spindritf 12y agoThe threats of violence are usually empty posturing but there are other serious risks associated with speaking out online under your real name. In the US you can get "swatted"[1], which is an evil twist on usual pizza pranks. It's not far from that to getting shot (or having your dog shot). Then there are basic SEO threats to your good name. And the old "taking information out of the Internet is like taking piss out of a pool." Whether the information is true or not. I don't think this is an appropriate defence though. Sticking to usual good practices of not conflating anonymous personas with your real identity, using a PO box and proxy services (whether for domain registrations or actual network proxies) will be more productive. Not good enough when evading FBI but probably more than fine otherwise. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swatting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swatting
- michaelochurch 12y agoWhat creeps me out is that there are now salary databases that people can use to see someone's prior salary history, job titles, and (in some cases) details of separation. It shouldn't be legal for those to exist, nor for companies to use them. I actually checked myself in one ("The Work Number") in 2012 and it had an accurate title and salary history, which I hadn't made public. Scary, creepy stuff going on. How the fuck are they able to know that?
- ci5er 12y ago> How the fuck are they able to know that? This is a good question, that I'd like to see answered too -- if anyone here knows. On a related (only to me) note: Is there any way that I can set a watcher on your comment to notify me if there is a response to it?
- ilamont 12y agoIt looks like it's part of Equifax, which also does credit reports -- they already have name, address, social, etc. Not sure how they would get the salary info, though, unless the company or the IRS disclosed it.
- ben010783 12y agoI'm just guessing, but they could be using info that was obtained when a user was trying to get a loan. Typically, your info is sent to multiple lenders so you can get the best rate. Somebody could be collecting the info somewhere along the line.
- wl 12y agoIf you have information in The Work Number, it means your employer gave it to them. Employers do this because it allows them to outsource income verification. I know of no way to opt out of it other than quitting. Also, while income information can only be accessed if you consent, collection agencies can get accounts that allow them to see the home address you have on file with them.
- 12y ago
- devindotcom 12y agoThere are a LOT more data brokers than listed here, though it's a decent list to start with. These are small fry in the scheme of things though. You can start working your way through this one if you're really concerned: http://www.worldprivacyforum.org/2013/12/data-brokers-opt-out/ http://www.worldprivacyforum.org/2013/12/data-brokers-opt-ou...
- pasbesoin 12y agoPeople who can afford to are going to begin hiding behind shell corporations. Houses, other assets, etc. will be corporate-owned, with suitable non-descriptive names and corporate addresses. In fact, this is already occurring, although a prime driver has been a form of trust that reduces taxes particularly inheritance taxes. I'm not familiar with what e.g. Hollywood celebrities do, but at a guess many of them are likely also doing something similar. Need to restrict access? Introduce a layer of indirection.
- gcb0 12y agoagreed. most of the data those companies had on my name were from utilities, insurance, etc. and most of them aggregated people with my common name in several states. they had a lot of info, but also a lot of wrong info. all mixed together. i send removals for all entries, mine and otherwise :)
- legohead 12y agoIf any of your personal info is on the internet, it has already been saved where you cannot remove it. This is a personal conundrum I have been trying to wrap my head around, especially as it relates to pictures of my kids I'd like to keep offline (but other people take pictures of them and upload them, and it's too late at that point...) A company I'm familiar with was attacked by a blackhat. He sent the company owner all his personal information including SSN, address, etc. It scared the owner enough to pay off the blackhat, but he also asked the blackhat how he got his information. The blackhat sent the owner a website that you can go to, pay around $4 in bitcoin, and search for anyone's information.
- Joona 12y agoI think just using a nickname (instead of your own name) and not sharing addresses etc is the best way to go. Lirik (a big Twitch streamer) chooses to only use his online alias, and although it's a common question what his real name (or other details) are, no one really has an answer. You just have to put some effort to not leaking information from registrations to sites (and such).
- r00fus 12y agoThis is useless. The only way to defeat mass collection is to poison the well. I always put some fake data wherever it's not legally required. The only issue is where it is required and that is the root of the problem - why is it required in so many places?