14 ms·
Stop Changing UIs for No Good Reason
- lackbeard 12y agoI don't use android, but I've been frustrated with pretty much every change to gmail over the last 4 years or so. Not to mention the new Google maps. It seems that some bad designers have gained quite a bit of political power within Google somehow.
- smackfu 12y agoI find the new Google Maps UI to be frustrating. The number of taps to just find directions to something after you search for it seems to be increased, for no good reason. I think it's mainly because there are multiple paths through the app to do the same thing, and some of them are optimized flows and others are not. So tapping the search bar is not the most efficient way to get directions anymore... you should tap the blue directions icon instead.
- computerjunkie 12y agoI agree. I've been traveling into London for the past couple of days and I always feel annoyed just navigating through Google Maps
- jarek 12y agoCitymapper is fantastic in London
- computerjunkie 12y agoThanks, I will have a look at it.
- shekhar101 12y agoMan! Move on. Start using Here maps. I don't know why people are stuck with GMpas when far more superior alternative is available. They have a new android app as well!
- smackfu 12y agoLooks like Here maps isn't available for iOS.
- shekhar101 12y agoWell yeah but at least it's better than both web and Android app of GMaps. Hope they release an iOS version soon.
- bowlich 12y agoIt's ever so slowly getting better. I remember when it first launched I couldn't even do waypoints. Planning a cross-country trip for Thanksgiving right now. In classic I can type "Town A to Town B to Town C to Town D" and it returns a route between A, B, C and D. In the new interface it brings up a list of restaurants in Town A. How can the king of search get this wrong?
- dudus 12y agoIf you just tap and hold on the directions button you can jump a few steps.
- archagon 12y agoI wrote up a rant about Google Maps the other day[1], from the perspective of an Apple user. As a Google Maps user since the start, I've been surprised to find myself reaching for Apple Maps more and more, both on my phone and on the desktop. Despite its flaws, Apple Maps just feels like a much better product in terms of UI and performance these days — and there's still time for them to catch up in data. [1]: http://beta-blog.archagon.net/2014/11/20/what's_up_with_google_maps_these_days/ http://beta-blog.archagon.net/2014/11/20/what's_up_with_goog...
- jongraehl 12y agoAnyone have a hint for using G-Maps (or making a homescreen shortcut) to navigate home address that won't send me to the wrong place, or make me wait, in case of slow internet? This seems fairly basic functionality so I may be missing something. I've even been sent toward a place 30 miles east of home, repeatedly, trying to select the autocompletion of 'home'.
- Zigurd 12y agoTry using old GMail after using InBox. Or hand someone an Android 4.4. phone after they've bought a new Nexus. You will see immediately that the new UI is a big improvement. Articles like this show a lock of imagination. If you can't imagine the shock of looking back at an older design, you can't perceive the benefits.
- throwawayaway 12y agoEven though this point is irrelevant to the article, when you are on the Desktop, you can use a commandline. When you use a commandline the UI and Workflow geniuses do not get to have any input, and then you get less surprises of this nature. When you use a Desktop application, it is easier to keep the software at a version with a UI you like. The trend towards storing your data on other's computers leads to empowering the authors of web programs, so that they don't have to respect your taste in UI as much(among other things).
- fla 12y agoThis is becoming pretty annoying. When buttons disappear or keyboard experience changes, it gets me angry. Not because I hate changes, but because I have no choice and no warnings. I will now think twice before updating my Android system.
- hyperpape 12y ago"There are a bunch of new ‘transitions’ between elements. I don’t know what the battery cost actually is for this, but as a user I just don’t care about cute transitions between elements. I want fast interaction with my mobile device." This is poorly phrased at best. Transitions exist to make it obvious what is happening: e.g. you minimize a window and it zooms into the taskbar/dock, as a visual reminder that it's not gone, just stored there. This kind of thing is even more important with an unfamiliar interface. Are the particular transitions he's complaining about bad? I have no idea, since he just wrote about transitions in general, without specifying any. Not all transitions are good, but writing like they're all pointless suggests that you just don't understand UI (and I'm not a UI person, just someone who reads a tiny bit about it). Edit: Just looked at the formatdoc. Is there a way to quote text without getting those scrollbars?
- Retric 12y agoAt best their training wheels for a UI. As such if you can't turn them off your building a poor UI. Worse, if your UI needs them then clearly your using a bad design.
- hyperpape 12y agoOS X and iOS both extensively use transitions. What's your model of a good UI that doesn't exploit transitions?
- mring33621 12y agoHow about obvious buttons which change shading when clicked followed by instant operation?
- Retric 12y agoHow about the vast majority of games out there. Don't get me wrong there a useful tool and can mask a slow UI, but just becase a cruch is useful to mask problems does not mean you should see more heathy people walking around with them.
- arcosdev 12y agoMeh. New UIs are a game that we all get to play. It is as much about marketing and sales "and staying fresh" then anything. It is just more distraction so we can ogle our devices from a new perspective. You don't want to get stale now.
- mattmanser 12y agoArgh, lollipop's driving me up the wall! Vent time, woo! The thing I'm hating is that they've managed to completely screw up Chrome by getting rid of tabs and mixing them all in with your other apps, in an attempt to force you to use the bloody useless app switcher button instead of making it do something vaguely useful. And the lock screen, what the hell were they thinking? The amount of times I've opened the phone app instead of unlocking the phone is becoming obscene. I often have my phone landscape while using it as a mini-tablet and in that orientation it's easy to do. Perhaps I'm paranoid but I think the screen now locks faster than it used to and I haven't been able to find the setting to slow it down yet, which exacerbates the problem, when you're lounging and intermittently transferring your attention between tv and internet browsing. And the new calendar app only allows you to see 6 hours at a time, so you can't get an overview of your day. The settings app requires some sort of double swipe down that's just plain awkward. Auto-brightness has been got rid of so often you're constantly fighting the brightness of your phone at night. The new notification have to be double tapped, which again is awkward, especially as they register the first tap and then "helpfully" tell you to make a 2nd one. But the first tap is behind a button press of the lock screen so it's actually a triple press. I'm also slightly perplexed as to the home button icon change, to a circle of all things. It actually offends me a bit, it's so tiny and yet completely devoid of meaning. It's different for Apple's circle button as that was a real button, Google's tiny circle just kinda floats there. And the "back" triangle changes orientation for no discernible reason other than the designer obviously wanted to animate something. The new phone app is strange, the buttons are too small, the volume of the button presses doesn't turn down as you turn down the speaker volume. And this is in a day and a half of use. It honestly feels like anyone testing it would have hit most of these issues. I suspect Google's designers then turned round to the testers and said "As designed. Material, you know. It's just a new way", rather than admit they'd screwed up. The worst part is, it's not added anything. I've not come across a single thing yet that I've gone, oh, cool! Not one.
- k-mcgrady 12y ago>> "And the new calendar app only allows you to see 6 hours at a time, so you can't get an overview of your day." Try the 'agenda' view which does exactly that. I was also going to debunk most of your other complaints because I know they're false but I don't have my Lollipop device with my at the moment.
- k-mcgrady 12y ago>> "why is the Compose button a floating button taking up space in my Inbox list" Because it's a button people use a lot and putting it there makes it much easier to get to. It doesn't 'cover' anything. You can scroll the inbox past it. It's a new design pattern in Android and used very well in Inbox imo by making the button expand and show most used actions.
- Siecje 12y agoI have to first trigger the unlock on Lolly Pop and then if I swipe wrong I'm taken to Phone which I barely use. Also the Phone's button to open the keypad looks like the App List button, so I usually hit that by accident. The white background doesn't look as good as the transparent one, in the app list. The space between pages makes the screen look smaller. There are permanent notifications for The Battery save mode and when you Restrict Background Data. It takes me two swipes to pull down to access the settings. Notifications on the lock screen are nice but not enough text is shown.
- debacle 12y agoWe have a huge underutilization issue in tech right now. The strategy seems to be to throw programmers and designers at the wall until they make something that sticks, but a lot of bad decisions come out of that strategy and it's not immediately apparent that they're bad decisions until users complain. This has led to a lot of cyclical design cycles, reinventing the wheel, NIH, etc. It's going to be damning to the tech sector if any of the big players (Apple, Google, Amazon, Netflix, off the top of my head) need to tighten their belts, because they're going to be able to shed a ton of employees without losing a shred of profit or productivity.
- danieldk 12y agoWe have a huge underutilization issue in tech right now. The strategy seems to be to throw programmers and designers at the wall until they make something that sticks, but a lot of bad decisions come out of that strategy and it's not immediately apparent that they're bad decisions until users complain. And it apparently leads to shallow changes. While I am ok with the new design in OS X, there are a lot real problems that I would rather like to see addressed, such as: providing a better filesystem than HFS+, fixing the annoying 'sandbox apps set quarantine attribute' bug [1], making Mail work with GMail, make iWork on par with the old versions again, etc. [1] https://github.com/osxfuse/osxfuse/issues/162 https://github.com/osxfuse/osxfuse/issues/162
- tim333 12y ago>We have a huge underutilization issue in tech right now Ironic given all the articles on the problem getting good people. I guess the trouble is the winner takes all nature of the market means Google can have 1000 spare good programmers while most small tech companies have a job hiring one or two.
- npsimons 12y agoGoogle is aggressive in recruiting; I still get emails from Google[1] asking if I'm willing to relocate yet (I'm not). If small companies want good people, they're going to have to dedicate some time and effort towards getting those people. I've lost three very good techies to Micron recently. Good talent is out there, you just have to know where to look. [1] - I'm not bragging or anything; I was declined an offer after my onsite visit, but that was also three years ago.
- Systemic33 12y agoAs a Windows Phone user, this really resonates with me, because WP has actually been preserving the UI and basic principles it builds on, and only added features as users voiced needs for specific upgrades (like allowing transparent tiles with a photo behind the start screen (effectively a background, but in a non-traditional way. With the exception of Windows 7 -> Windows 8, MS have also kept cosmetic updates to the system, fairly conservatively. The authors critique of OSX is maybe the only thing i disagree with, since I haven't experienced any situation, where more than the cosmetic things changed, i.e. no UI elements changed really.
- edw519 12y agoSadly, this meme is universal through time and space and shows no likelihood of abating. I once had a customer who told vendors, "I don't want maintenance, and I don't want the software I just bought to change, ever." At the time, most of us thought he was crazy. Now I'm not so sure. I'm still sitting shivah for Classic Google Maps, Palm Graffiti, and Windows XP. Sigh.
- throwawayaway 12y agoIt would be quite ironic if the foretold BYOD revolution enables people to be curmudgeonly stick in the muds.
- robodale 12y agoWindows XP - I was most productive on this OS...BY FAR. Everything since has been less optimal. This includes IOS.
- throwawayaway 12y agoWell think about it, now that you have to air gap it to keep it secure it's probably even more productive than before - no time wasted on HN for example!
- merrua 12y agoI'm pretty sure I read of a method that works even with air gap https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2013/10/air_gaps.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2013/10/air_gaps.html
- rogeryu 12y agoI do care about Windows desktop changes. Not for me, but for my mother, over 80 years old, and although she still can handle changes, it becomes more difficult. She's using Windows 7 right now (coming from XP via 2000 and 98), with the classic (grey Windows 2000) design. I hope that stays with Windows 9. I'm very glad we could skip Windows 8. I guess many older people will have these problems, and I can't understand that MS has no clue about the first generation of elderly people using computers.
- throwawayaway 12y agoI got a battery for a nokia 3310 to replace the dead one in my 86 year old grandfather's 14 year old phone and he was delighted not to have to go and learn something new. He's very mentally agile but he recognises a waste of time when he sees one.
- gnuvince 12y agoBusy work: if UI designers did not change everything all the time, they'd all be out of jobs.
- gdulli 12y agoThe problem is that software companies acquire the amount of labor (which is large) that they need to create something but then don't have anything to do with that extra labor when it's finished and all that's needed is maintenance and a reasonable amount of additional upgrade work. So if the company is profitable enough that it doesn't need to lay anyone off, it has the excess labor keep iterating on a product that's already very good and only needs a small amount of labor to keep it ideal. This makes the product worse. Once you see this you can't un-see it. (Also there's the more cyncial explanation that by changing things dramatically you get people to think they need to keep spending money.)
- kaizendc 12y agoExactly, it's mostly busywork.
- Someone1234 12y agoI'd maybe agree regarding the UI/animation. But L has brought some significant improvements (ART, Project Volta, background batching API, et al). So it is a good release inspite of the UI/animation updates. Google Maps and Windows Search are two products that have been over-worked to death. Both were better in older iterations (Windows Search pre-Vista, Google Maps before they went all minimalism-stupid). Google Maps in particular stripped out tons of useful functionality for a long period (My Places seems to appear and disappear every second release, location search history is currently MIA, compass is gone, et al). Windows Search just tried to make it "clever" but instead made it "unreliable." They wanted to add support for everyone file format one by one (and ignore everything else) but instead managed to only support native Microsoft formats well and nothing else at all. File Search in Windows (Vista-8.1) is horrendously poor. Give me Windows 95 search.
- 9point6 12y agoI would say Windows search pre-Vista was unusable in general due to the poor/non-existent indexing and poor support of non-ASCII formats or anything beyond basic file metadata. Microsoft's solution to the not being able to support every file-type under the sun was to allow plugins to provide new types, which work quite well IMO. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IFilter http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IFilter
- TeeWEE 12y agoI thinks this guy is missing the point. Google did uix research and come up with a more usable design philosophy, which makes all apps more consistent. They are now executing those grand-design rules. In the end, apps should be more familiar, and easier to use. The change itself is always frustrating, people who are used to an uix (by learning it), hate change, even if the new uix is simpler.
- zecg 12y agoWell, they can go back to the drawing board and do some more research. This was an example posted here a few weeks ago, by a heavy Calendar user. Look at the old and new app and see if you can answer a common question for a calendar user, like when do I have some free time in the next month: http://imgur.com/a/Qo91p http://imgur.com/a/Qo91p Also, not that it matters, but the old app is 2 MB and works flawlessly, the new one is more than 20 and chugs a bit when scrolling on a quad core processor.
- c0brac0bra 12y agoIt's also become incredibly difficult to scroll properly in the new calendar. I constantly find myself scrolling horizontally when I want to scroll vertically, or vice-versa; it is maddening.
- c22 12y agoIf they put colored sections indicating appointments around the circles in the latter example, as if they were 24h clock faces, it would be even more useful than the first example.
- Al-Khwarizmi 12y agoHow does eliminating the limits between keys improve the keyboard? How does eliminating the small symbols overlayed on the keys (for example I can type "!" by holding the A key) improve the keyboard? I think the guy has valid points, and your post is just an appeal to authority. Sadly it's not only google, it's also Microsoft (Windows 8), Gnome (3), Ubuntu (Unity), etc. This UI minimalism consisting in removing features with no good reason is killing me.
- spindritf 12y agoI'm rarely if ever troubled by UI changes but it took me a good moment before I figured out how to rerfresh your inbox in new Gmail. It's pretty obvious that you need to drag down when there are messages but without any (inbox zero) acting as an indicator, I went through all the options, and only picked the right move by accident. If you're just starting out and don't have a feel for the mobile paradigm, those gestures may as well be magic. Maybe you're simply not supposed to refresh anything by hand any more. Maybe it's supposed to be magic.
- jbb555 12y agoThe new gmail is ok although it has absolutely no advantages over the old one so it's merely irritating they changed it just because they could. Except for the compose button over the top of my text which is really awful and I hate it so much
- stinky613 12y ago> If you're just starting out and don't have a feel for the mobile paradigm, those gestures may as well be magic. Maybe you're simply not supposed to refresh anything by hand any more. Maybe it's supposed to be magic. I agree that this can be a source of frustration. On the flip side, once you're used to it as a global UI pattern you might find certain buttons or indicators to be gratuitous. Now that I'm used to a global back button on Android, I feel totally lost on iOS when I want to go back/up. I'm no longer used to looking for a specific app button for that action because I'm used to it being a system-wide feature. I'm wondering if this will become less confusing once the lion's share of Android phones and apps are using Material Design, as MD recommends that content is refreshed either a) automatically by sync or b) via the drag-to-refresh action.[1] [1] http://www.google.com/design/spec/patterns/swipe-to-refresh.html http://www.google.com/design/spec/patterns/swipe-to-refresh....
- DontBeADick 12y agoI stopped updating all my Google apps ~2 years ago because there were so many asinine, unintuitive UI changes with each new version. A lot of their changes didn't even conform to the standards recommended by Google (e.g. menu button locations). It's almost as if the UI team gets bored and decides to make changes just because they need to occupy themselves. And then instead of testing them with actual users, they just talk amongst themselves about how awesome their new set of obscure gestures and button locations are. I'm afraid to buy a new Nexus because of how bad the application interfaces will probably be.
- zmb_ 12y agoI just updated my Nexus 5 to KitKat. The update forced me to use GMail instead of the Email app, and almost 24h later GMail is still "Getting your messages". None of my email accounts work. Never mind changing the UI, they should start by not completely breaking the key functionality of their applications in their effort to force everyone to use their services.
- rogeryu 12y agoUse K9 Mail.
- pja 12y agoK9 Mail is the traditional answer to this problem. Google never put very much effort into the Android Mail App because they wanted to push you into using GMail. That said, Email still works fine in KitKat - why did you have to switch to the GMail App?
- pwnna 12y agoCyanogenMod! Not only do they include the AOSP email, they built improvements on it as well!
- crumpled 12y agoHave you tried turning it off and on again?
- Clanan 12y ago
- _lce0 12y agoI was anxiously expecting the update, but man that keyword is a deal breaker. Can it be configured as dark themed? The keyboard is a central point for UX, I've already moved away from Samsung for the same reason, and will hold the update if I'm forced to use that keyword
- umurkontaci 12y agoI agree, the new keyboard sucks a lot, there is no visual distinction between the letters and it is very easy to make a lot of typos, it is very painful. Went back to Swiftkey immediately.
- brewdad 12y agoWhat's odd for me is that I feel like I should be making more typos with the new keyboard, yet I'm actually making fewer. I'm not sure if that has to do with the keyboard mapping being more accurate or me focusing slightly more while typing due to the "buttons" blending together.
- ultramancool 12y agoJust install SwiftKey, Kii Keyboard, Swype, etc. Far better for completion and UI in my opinion at least.
- pilsetnieks 12y agoThere are four themes for the builtin keyboard now: - Material Light (the default, the one that's shown in the article); - Material Dark (the same but dark); - Holo White (the old one); - Holo Blue (the old one with blue accents)
- jbb555 12y agoYeah and too many times when you complain about this kind of thing you get accused of "hating change" or some such thing. No, I hate THIS change because THIS change is bad!
- ceejayoz 12y agoDepends on the changes. Facebook's UI revamps have usually been good ones (excluding their "hide the privacy settings" dark patterns), but a certain subset of users complain each time. I've got one friend who's been a member of each redesign's "bring back the old Facebook!" movement.
- paganel 12y agoMore than one year after it happened the new GMaps interface still looks like crap, and on top of that it feels slow, on a Mac Mini with 4GB of memory. I still (don't know exactly how, could be a cookie thing, not sure) manage to have access to the old interface in one of my browsers, and the old interface works like a charm, both in terms of UI and speed. And about GMail, nothing more to say, only that once you've managed to break the "Open in new tab" button and the "Back" button then you have no business doing UI-stuff in a browser. Yes, I know both products are free as in I'm not paying anything for them, it's just that is really, really frustrating to compare them with how they used to behave.
- untog 12y agoFor Google Maps you can click on the help button on the bottom right and choose "Return to Classic Google Maps". The new Maps has come a long way since launch but I agree that it's still very far from good.
- funkyy 12y agoAs far as I remember click "?" mark on the bottom of map window - there is option to change it back to map classics. You can save this as well once changed (small pop up will come out) so it will become your default.
- Bill_Dimm 12y ago
- tomp 12y agoIf only every application was just a backend with a well-defined API and a default UI, then we could have independently sourced UIs that every person could choose (and customize) on demand!
- viraptor 12y agoIn this case - isn't it? Samsung is happy to almost completely change the whole look and feel. HTC has its own additions. Components like keyboards are completely separate apps. Nokia released their launcher. What's missing apart from people actually writing and releasing those independent UIs?
- tomp 12y agoAFAIK, different OEMs just change the system's look and feel (desktop, launcher, keyboards, maybe some built-in apps that are usually crap/adware/spyware), not the UI of the actual applications (e.g. GMail).
- iaskwhy 12y agoOr Chrome with Stylebot. I love to see people reactions when they see how different their sites are on my screen.
- profinger 12y agoI'm so glad someone finally said it! I'm tired of this crap. This applies to physical products too. These companies change their labels so much.. It just makes it more difficult to find and leaves me, as a consumer, confused when shopping unsure that I'm buying the correct product. Yes, things needs to be updated and kept "pretty" but can we keep a base? Or can we agree, at least, to pick something and stick to it?!
- therealmarv 12y agoI really like the new design and it did not changed too often in my opinion. UI design is like fashion for me and when it changes for good (I thing I like the Lollipop design) every 3-5 years this is a good thing. When speaking about productivity and design: So we should all stay on Windows XP because everybody knows it and how to use it?
- acdha 12y agoThis happens every time something changes. Wait for the next release and the same guy is probably going to be complaining about changes to the current UI. One phrase I hear a lot is “The future is longer than the past”. It's relevant here as well – spending all of your time worrying about existing users have to spend a couple minutes getting used to a new keyboard design isn't a good reason not to make improvements which will benefit the millions of people who will never use the old one.
- unterstrom 12y ago>Wait for the next release and the same guy is probably going to be complaining about changes to the current UI. Off course he will. It's his point. He alreadey stated that it is not the ui that is bad. It's the practice of constantly changing things for no good reason that is bad.
- acdha 12y agoYou're both begging the question of whether this was in fact done for no reason other than to change things. It's rather unlikely that someone at Google spent time and money developing something for no reason – that post would have been interesting if it'd actually discussed why things changed and why the reasoning behind those changes was wrong rather than simply assuming it.
- sillysaurus3 12y ago"The future is longer than the past" seems like the perfect excuse to justify pretty much anything.
- acdha 12y agoIf you think it through more, it's only about being excessively driven by fear of change. UI changes inspire a lot of reactionary opposition but once you're looking on a perspective greater than minutes or hours, the big problems usually turn out to be less significant than originally claimed.
- mhurron 12y ago
- packetized 12y agoI wonder at what point it stops being a UI redesign and becomes a psychological experiment.
- chuckcode 12y agoI think it is just a fact of life, it's the same reason that I can't ever figure out how to really use a microwave. They have to make it different this year to "differentiate" the brand. I've learned to live with a lot of churn and reach to buy the products that were built with more care and last.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- remon 12y agoThe problem with arguments like these is that there being "no good reason" is highly subjective. Excessive change is generally better than no changes at all. Things have to evolve and even if we miss the mark every now and then it should always improve over time on average when new ideas are tried and tested.
- PMan74 12y ago> The problem with arguments like these is that there being "no good reason" is highly subjective. Not only is it subjective it's almost certainly incorrect. If you read anything about Google it's clear that they don't make UI decisions without looking at a ton of data, making the changes and testing those changes. What does the author of that post think? A Google designer updated a load of designs on a whim?
- throwawayaway 12y agoNot a whim, an existential crisis. Justifying their existence, cherry picking suitable answers from a ton of data to back that up. Confirmation bias to appear relevant.
- obsurveyor 12y agoJustifying their job too. How do you get marks on your review if the only concrete things you can point to through the year are the bookkeeping of the design world? Also, employee turnover and position changes means that those new people bring their own, "new" ideas that have to be implemented(how else do you "make your mark"?), at the expense of the user comfort/satisfaciton.
- lukeschlather 12y agoWhat sort of data? I can look at data all day, it doesn't mean that I'm interpreting it right. Furthermore, the biggest issues may not show up in the data. I have a 22-month-old Android phone. Google Maps just keeps getting slower and slower. Now it takes 10-15 seconds to start up. I'd really like to know what percentage of the data Google is using comes from phones released in the past 10 months. (Or phones that haven't even been released yet.)
- rectang 12y agoThe user pays a cost every time a UI changes -- but the user also pays a cost if a UI is frozen forever and not permitted to evolve. What are some techniques for evolving UIs at minimal cost to the user?
- shawnwall 12y agoGoogle is making a huge amount of progress in UI and UX; the company has historically been rather mediocre in terms of it's UI and UX, while Apple was always the star. Over the past year or so the roles have reversed, and Google continues making strides towards unifying their applications in a single user experience and ui paradigm that allows for simpler app use, particularly for new users. It's easy to get upset when things change, but keep in mind that change can be positive and/or negative.
- throwawayaway 12y agoThe new gmail interface combined with the fact it logs me in to youtube to watch a video, made me install a cli mail client. Haven't looked back.
- iancarroll 12y agoThe web interface convinently logged you in and you stop using it because of that?
- throwawayaway 12y agoYes, you read correctly. One man's convenience is overstepping the mark pushing G+ for another.
- pjc50 12y agoLogging into youtube will, by default unless you know about it and turn it off, associate every video you view with your G+ profile for your gmail account, so every person you correspond with can look up your video history.
- throwawayaway 12y agoI had no idea it had gotten that bad! Seems my overreaction was justified.
- hahainternet 12y ago
- zipperhead 12y agoSomething about the entire approach Google is taking with Lollipop (and Material Design) just seems off to me. I can see their philosophy but I don't agree with large parts of it (I don't need or want animations to guide me along the path thank you). Overall I'm left with a feeling of a lack of 'grace'. It's just not graceful, which I guess is where the art of UI comes into play. Maybe they will get there eventually, but right now it's still clunky as hell. Even worse, they are dropping functionality along the way.
- higherpurpose 12y agoI agree with the general sentiment; disagree about the specific example (Gmail). I prefer it over the old one.
- emjaygee 12y agoWill you buy the newer products without the newer UIs? I didn't think so, so the manufacturers are motivated to keep changing.
- protonfish 12y agoThe fact that we are discussing this generically as UI Design shows the immaturity of the concept. I can see at least two clear ideas needed to discuss this in a more detailed and rational manner. 1. We need to clearly separate the difference between UI design and UI decoration. Design should be driven by user testing that measures speed and rate of completion of tasks. If every feature of the latest UI is not measured to be a quantitative increase, then it is not a design improvement. Decoration is about being fashionable and has nothing to do with usable, efficient, elegant UI. I see no reason they cannot exist side by side, but today the prevailing policy seems to be that decorating UI in a trendy fashion trumps usability. 2. There needs to be thought about the adoption and transition of users from an old interface to a new one. Right now the philosophy seems to be "Stop whining and suck it up - our designers are smarter than you." This is not reasonable or professional. New designs should be measured not just for usability of new users, but also against users that are used to the previous interface. There are probably many techniques to improve the user experience of UI upgrades but we'll never discover them until we recognize that it is important and spend some time and effort studying this phenomenon.
- throwawayaway 12y agoThink they are too tightly coupled to use HN parlance. Would like to see stylesheets or backwards compatible skins becoming de riguer. Particularly when the program does nothing new.
- Zarathust 12y agoYou get two groups. One uses the old interface and the other uses the radically new shiny thing that might perform better. Surprise! The new interface performs better in selected metrics. Old interface hits the recycle bin and the new one become the norm. This us what seems to be the standard decision process. I would propose the introduction of a third and maybe fourth group where returning users would also measure those selected metrics.
- delinka 12y agoI'm starting to think that this constant change is what will prevent Software Creation from becoming mature (and finally accepted as Engineering.) We don't dwell on a thing long enough to truly explore it's pitfalls and potential. Then again, perhaps that's just the perception from taking a look from too high an altitude. Personally, I'm focusing on the tools I like using; cautiously evaluating newer tools but not the bleeding edge (I like to avoid scabs); making careful decisions about the stack for my latest creation, and then sticking to those choices; in the last five years, I've felt more like I'm doing a Serious Engineering. If other individuals do similar things, perhaps there's hope for industry maturity after all.
- PaulHoule 12y agoAndroid L is the next Windows 8
- incision 12y agoWhat are there, 1B Android users? I'm sure Google would like that to be 7B. I'd wager the complaints of the sort of people who frequent lobste.rs or HN are not representative of the majority of current users and almost certainly not of the next 6B potential users. Overall, it's everything Google said they would do with material [1]. It's fine to dislike these things, I don't necessarily like them myself, but claiming they're simply wrong or "for no reason" is somewhere between angry and lazy. Just a glance at the new vs old keyboard or gmail shows a direction - moving / duplicating interactions toward the bottom right (logical as screens get bigger), breaking out punctuation into discrete keys (presumably logical given the way most people actually type). The overall restyling is adding consistency between apps and particularly between mobile and the desktop. Animations are really valuable anytime someone doesn't come to the table with a complete mental model of how something fits together already. Basically, they're not for you Mr. Programmer. 1: http://www.google.com/design/ http://www.google.com/design/
- lost_name 12y agoI agree with you, but it seems the train has already left the station. I don't use my tablet all that much, but I don't find myself questioning how something is done (that stuff didn't really change), or why things look different (I don't really care). It's just... different, nothing else.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoWhen I help people out with their computers and I run updates (pretty much everyone I go to stay with!) they always complain if there's been a change in the UI at all - "why's that button moved?" "where's my favourites?" "how do I access my inbox now?" "why does it keep popping up that thing?" ... I'd really like to see some respect for this from people like Firefox - "we won't move any major UI elements or update the default skin more than once every 2 years". Of course the marketing is all about the novelty at the moment - steadfastness doesn't count for much in tech circles it seems. With stable UI you can have a less rapidly changing system for users to comprehend; running updates for security fixes shouldn't mean you have to face a new menu paradigm or new default screen or new tab shape or new whatever every few weeks. Seriously. I don't enable auto-update on supported users apps for this reason.
- deafbybeheading 12y agoSome valid points, but GitHub's UI evolution has been phenomenal over the last two years.
- general_failure 12y agoNot really. Placing the clone URL on the side bar and half clipped is quite bad. It's a site for developers...
- zsombor 12y agoOh yeah having six or more horizontal navigation bars was pure pain. Considering how difficult is to effect changes with an established user base, plus the complexity of the domain itself, their new design is anything but cosmetic.
- Akujin 12y agoThey also completely removed the Gallery app and you are now forced to use Google Images. Unfortunately if you disabled the Google Plus app Google Images won't even turn on leaving you with no way to look at your own local pictures.
- Raphmedia 12y agoStep 1 : Have a great UI. Step 2 : Slowly and subtly break that UI. Step 3 : Announce and hype up that you will have a great UI in the next version. Repeat.
- shekhar101 12y agoStarted switching to alternatives after Gmail redesign fiasco. Last nail in the coffin was Google maps 'redesign'. I loved both these products but have now moved on. Luckily for us Here maps is alive and kicking and it's so much better than GMaps! Why are people still stuck with Google Maps, I don't know. Here has everything and more. Real offline navigation! And they have an Android app too!
- rhblake 12y agoThis needs more attention. I was pleasantly surprised to discover that Nokia's HERE recently became available in beta for all Android users (free): http://here.com/beta/android/?lang=en-US http://here.com/beta/android/?lang=en-US Having used a Windows Phone for some time before switching back to Android, the HERE maps app was the one thing I missed the most. Offline support is a must for me and Google Maps' offline 'support' is a joke. (I'm currently in Paris, without mobile Internet access. Google Maps is useless as soon as I leave the house.) OsmAnd/Maps.me do offline properly, but their UIs are lacking and both have serious GPS issues on my Nexus 5. HERE just works great. There are many lovely little features. Like, if I click on a subway station nearby, Google Maps (Lollipop) will show me the name of the station and how long it takes to get there, and if I swipe up it will also tell me the lines going from that station and show some share/depart buttons and street photos. If I click on the same station in HERE, it will overlay the routes of the station's subway lines on the map so that I can at once actually see where they are going. Incredibly more useful, especially in big cities like Paris or Berlin where there can be a dozen subway lines or more. I wonder if small features like these and the whole offline thing reflect where the developers come from? It seems like the Google Maps team doesn't take public transport very seriously, and that they can't imagine people ever being without Internet access.
- shekhar101 12y agoTotally agreed. I don't why it isn't getting fraction of publicity that other less useful and I dare say stupid apps are getting. HERE simply rocks! I will never switch back to crappy web version of GMaps. HERE beats it in both web and Android version. Love it!
- userbinator 12y agoThat keyboard looks somewhat alright at first, and you can sort of see where the buttons are for the most part, but the comma and full stop really makes me uncertain about where the borders between the keys are, and that's not a good thing for a touch UI - it's uncertain enough for people with fat fingers. Is it too much to ask for to have some lines separating the keys? On the other hand, someone will certainly propose that the spacebar should really be completely blank... Wasn't one of the most important UI guidelines for a long time "things that behave like buttons should look like buttons"? The term "mystery meat navigation" was invented to describe the effects of not following this; it's even more difficult with a touchscreen as you cannot "hover" over UI elements to discover if they're clickable.
- Bjartr 12y agoI thought mystery meat navigation described buttons that only non-conventional icons to indicate what they did until you hovered (if even then), thus their behavior was a mystery until you tried them.
- rcavezza 12y agoGoogle is slowly changing GMail to look like their new Inbox product. Instead of making a windfall upgrade, they're starting with small UI changes. Expect more incremental changes until GMail becomes Inbox.
- bluthru 12y ago>why is the Compose button a floating button taking up space in my Inbox list?? There still exists a toolbar at the top for search and navigation. Why can’t the Compose button be there?? YES! That's where you scroll! Why would they put a button there? Oh, I know why: because they painted themselves into a corner by thinking every app needs a cutesy circle button floating with a gross drop shadow.
- Mikeb85 12y agoMeh, I haven't found any of this to be a problem. I was a little confused by the new keyboard, but it works just fine, if not a little better than the previous one. Swiping around the letters still works great for composing words. The behaviour with Chrome and tabs is much better than before, switching through tabs as though they're apps makes a lot of sense, better than switching through apps, then through tabs again, when I just want to see one page... Overall I find the whole UI to be an improvement in Android 5 versus 4.4. It looks nicer, and everything seems just a little bit better. But then again, I've never had a problem with things changing, I'm pretty adaptable.
- paulojreis 12y agoAs someone with experience in user interface design and evalution, I'm inclined to say that these were management or "product vision" - not design - decisions. It is rather unfortunate (but common) that said motives typically override design decisions (some of them empirically validated).
- Shivetya 12y agoiTunes on the Apple side has been the worst of the Mac experience for me. It always seems as if the change is to put me further and further from my music, especially custom playlists and such. Worse, it doesn't retain settings. However like Office is to Windows, it seems Apple's test for new UI ideas, sadly they all seem to make it.
- amelius 12y agoCar analogy: what if your steering wheel was in a different location of your car every couple of weeks? :)
- tim333 12y agoThere's a misalignment of incentive for changing UI. For the designer/manager its great - they can say I was the designer of the cool new whatever UI, put it on their cv, get promoted etc. Much more fun than doing maintenance. $100k value? For the users it's the other way assuming the functionality's the same. They have to spend time relearning the darn thing - say a $5 pain in the arse? Times 10 million users a $50m cost to society perhaps.
- Sakes 12y agoThe above blog has some valid points. But how the hell is it at the top on HN when there is a constructive, informative, and beautiful post about how to create aesthetically pleasing GUIs right below it.... I'm bitching about bitching. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8635082 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8635082
- neuralk 12y agoThey cover slightly different territory. The post you linked is more about the aesthetics of good UI, with a little bit about functionality and UX. The solutions there do not solve or address the problem brought up in the OP here, which is more about UX and the modification of existing user interfaces. For instance, it wasn't the updated graphical style of the keyboard that the OP complained about, but the rearranged placement of keys. That said, both are good reads and complement each other.
- Sakes 12y agoI agree with you 100%. My comment was meant to complain about how the HN crowd was up voting an article which kicked off UI rants in the comments section when there was an article right beneath it with interesting techniques to add to your tool kit. Keyboard complaints though... not sure why they changed that. But the "no good reason" is garbage because there are at least a couple reasons. Google migrating the A team from "gmail" to "inbox" possibly introducing less experienced devs/designers. Google trying to apply consistent UI principles across all applications in order to increase familiarity. When trying to make improvements there should be some room for experimentation / failure. I would expect this community to understand that since it is heavily made up of makers. So, for me, if the OP had titled it complaints about lollipop instead of stop changing UI for no good reason, I would have thought it to be right on. If the commenters didn't rally around it with pitchforks, I would have had no problem.
- tkrupicka 12y agoThe UI changes to android are aimed at making the user interface more standardized across devices, and more intuitive for all users. There's something to be said about that.
- joeyh 12y agoYou know, programs could version their UI's. I was struck in Bram Cohen's interview by how much care he's taken to avoid changing vim's behavior at all, while still letting nice new features be added. In the case of vim, you have to learn about features and enable them to change the UI. That works, but it does mean that the default vim experience for a new user lacks a lot of its cool features, and it can be hard to learn about features. (I only learned that vim has persistent undo from that interview.) Imagine if say, firefox, had a UI version number. New users get the current version, and firefox writes that to its config. So upgrades don't have to change the UI the user has gotten used to. It could prompt on upgrade to let the user try out the fresh new version, and if they don't like it, they could revert back. Even if this were only limited to the "chrome" around the web page (no need to version UI for preferences pages etc), I think it would be a nice win. Gnome 3 sort of did this with its legacy mode, but it's a poor imitation at best of gnome 2. I'm sure that UI developers would hate this. Having to maintain old UI code, or implement pixel-perfect imitations of it using the new UI code. Needing to worry about how to shoehorn new features into an old UI that was not designed for them. Etc. It's much easier to put the cognitive load on the shoulders of the user, who is forced to unlearn old habits, develop new muscle memories, and generally grit their teeth and bear it until the new UI fades into the background and stops distracting.. Just in time for a UI refresh to come around!
- halestock 12y agoBram Moolenaar, you mean.
- joeyh 12y agoAn embarassement of Brams.
- darushimo 12y agoI just hung out with an old friend last week and while he's into his tech, he doesn't work in the industry. he expressed the same sentiment in the last line of your comment. UI versioning sounds like a ridiculously difficult challenge, so difficult that it's worth thinking about more, because most people won't (because it's so hard). I'm gonna take that idea and run with it a bit... A few things come to mind: - Added complexity - apps would have two unique versions at the same time "Oh i'm running gmail 15.2 with UI v 12.0" - I wonder if another ways of achieving something similar is keeping legacy UI by calling it a "theme." While, politically, it might be difficult to get funding for a "theme" over a "redesign," with such an important and widely used application like GMail, it makes total sense to me that there are 2-4 interaction schemas that people could use if they'd like. Maybe "theme" is too weak of a name,--maybe "Schema"? Something else? - What sort of protocol would a "theme" use to improve? Let's say that "we want to keep the important parts of this theme as much as possible, not mess with them, just add this new feature." How universally possible is that, or do a majority of big new features inherently complicate a UI and the mental models of its users? - Getting into the nitty gritty details, though, there would almost inherently be splintering--different themes would have microinteractions and microfeatures that others would not. While that's probably good for the end user wanting to differentiate between them, it would make the "Do we add big feature X?" conversation across all "Theme Teams" AND development even more difficult. - Would the themes themselves have versions? - In a way, themes are already available as versions. Ex: I am running an older version ("theme") of twitter on my ipad because i just haven't gotten around to updating it. but It still works. What would be great is if twitter could allow me to switch between this version and the newest one so I could see if the newest version worked better for me. I could switch back if it didn't. Right now, I can upgrade, but I can't switch back, so upgrading is "switching permanently and hoping for the best." - what are your thoughts?
- codingdave 12y agoKhan academy is the worst offender in my mind. This past summer, it seemed like there was a change in how to navigate around the site every week. And changes to how reports displayed, even how questions were answered... across the board, constant changes. My kids, who range from 5-9, and use it to learn math, had to ask me for help constantly. 2 of my kids stopped using the site,as did I. One still uses it. I went from being a strong advocate for Khan Academy to just a lukewarm user who watches my son's progress... and all because of the excessive rapid UI changes.
- grimman 12y agoAre there any alternatives in the same "range" as Khan Academy?
- codingdave 12y agoYes, there are dozens of choices. But few are free. And although I have no problem paying for my children's education, I have not found a correlation between the cost of online education and its quality. I like Khan's vision - I really like their Mastery system, and their mission system. Frankly, if they worked out all the kinks and had similar mechanisms for all primary education subjects, homeschooling could be done with nothing but Khan. They just aren't quite there yet.
- Mikeb85 12y agoYou know, you could replace Android 5 with 'Gnome 3', 'Ubuntu Unity', 'Windows 8' or 'Systemd' and the discussion would be exactly the same. People just hate change, and will always think the old way is better. I remember when people were bitching about the Start button in Windows 95... Now they bitch about the Start button in Windows 8. Personally, I think all the above items that I mentioned are better than what they replaced...
- akramhussein 12y agoYes. Agreed. I'm fed up of this. One day Hangouts is fine then next day everything has changed...swiped from left to view contacts, now it's a click. Swipe to delete, now its a button...few months later here we go again. Rinse and repeat for every Google app it seems. A friend once said to me "iPhone hasn't changed since day 1, it's still the same stupid square icons, they can't innovate"...I was befuddled. There is a reason things stay the same. They work and users know them like second nature. Unless you have a REALLY good reason to change the paradigm, just don't. Mac OS X and Windows until recently didn't really change that much in terms of usability. Why does Google love to change everything constantly?
- at-fates-hands 12y agoThe funny thing is I just switched from my Windows Phone back to Android and Lollipop and it's been a nightmare. All my friends told me how much better Android would be and this is a nightmare compared to how much better my Windows phone handles stuff like the calendar, multiple email boxes and other things Lollipop seems to fail at miserably now. I'm actually considering going back after less than a month trying to wade through all the changes.
- protomyth 12y agoYosemite should be the case study right behind Windows 8 on how not to change a UI. Spotlight is horrible and harder to use (pop up away from mouse, UI smaller and harder to click). I still want to have a transcript from the meeting that decided the tabs on Safari should now "scrunch" to the right of the active tab instead of all the way to the right. It makes selecting the next tab without closing the current tab a huge pain. I can see no advantage. Let's also add that bugs get introduced / reintroduced and really irritate people. Nothing, and I mean nothing, irritates a computer user when they thought they knew how to do something and now cannot. Then, after finding the way how, it crashes with a bug. Finder for Mavericks and Yosemite is broken with Applescript (doesn't refresh view).
- archagon 12y agoYou don't like the new Safari tabs? Have you tried using your trackpad or mouse wheel to scroll them horizontally? To me, it's the best solution out of all the browsers. Firefox has a scrolling list, but all the tabs are the same size so they go off the screen. Chrome shrinks tabs down until they're illegible. Safari kind of does both, but you can spread them out in an analog way just by using your mouse. To me, it feels great.
- protomyth 12y agoThe scrolling is interesting, but it scrunches the tabs on the left as I add them and then I have extra actions to go to the first tab I opened. I see no purpose in this behavior.
- archagon 12y agoWell, it doesn't do that if all your tabs fit in the window, right? It only happens once you run out of space, and at that point you need to do something.
- protomyth 12y agoyes, and that something is to scrunch the right side not one tab to the left of the left side. Act like every other program on the platform using tabs.
- platz 12y agoRemember when everyone threw a fit because facebook changed their UI? Now, no-one seems to be talking about it. Although this article raises some good points, I'm just not motivated by "it's not what I'm used to / trained myself on" arguments.
- nickbaum 12y agoA few thoughts: * Google has a large and very competent design team. They are not changing things "for the sake of changing them." More often than not, changes are made in response to issues discovered during usability studies. * You are not the user. I am not the user. The designer is not the user. In fact, for a project as large as Android or Gmail, there is no "the user". You're always making trade-offs between power vs. common, new vs. existing users. * Existing users are inherently conservative. By definition they mostly like things as they are or they wouldn't be users. You have to weigh their needs vs. those of future users. A big part of that is understanding how many people are upset about the change (all vs. vocal minority), how quickly they get used to it (if ever), and how you can mitigate this. * Ideally, you want to make "Pareto efficient" changes, that make everyone better off. The only thing easier than doing what you've always done is when the new UX is so easy and intuitive you instantly understand it. * You do not want to version your UI, just like you don't want to make everything a setting. This is a recipe for maintenance headaches, and endless wasted cycles supporting an ever-shrinking minority of users. * This being said, it's very helpful to release a redesign as a beta, and let users switch back and forth for a while while you iron out the kinks. This in itself gives you good data. At the end of the day, design is all about trade-offs. It's very easy to criticize a change because you don't like it, but it's a lot more interesting to think through why a change might have been made. If we're going to be critical, let us be constructive.
- snowwrestler 12y agoGoogle is currently making a number of design changes to bring products in line with their new "Material" design guidelines. These changes may or may not be in response to actual usability issues. The hypothesis is that an overall design consistency across Google products will improve overall usability over time. However, this is still just a hypothesis. It might turn out to harm usability on some platforms while helping on others...or harm usability across the board. Adherence to a standard is not necessarily the same thing as a usability improvement.
- declan 12y ago> You're always making trade-offs between power vs. common, new vs. existing users. Well put. Google is a data-driven company with the ability to test designs over millions of users (although Jakob Nielsen's work has shown that you reach the point of quickly diminishing returns after testing with 5-10 users). I've spent quite a bit of time implementing Material Design for http://recent.io/ http://recent.io/, and then testing the design with normal, not especially tech-savvy users. My impression is that Material Design is a way to simplify and standardize app UIs (to increase app usage overall), and import visual cues from the paper world. It's very thoughtful approach, probably better than iOS, and I say this as someone whose primary mobile device is a new iPhone and who has owned an iPhone since the day it went on sale. But what works for most people may not work for HN power users. Hence the complaints on this thread.
- stevewilhelm 12y agoMobile Phone UX has gone the way of automobile and clothing design: changes are driven by fashion as well as utility.
- brohoolio 12y agoHow is material design for accessibility?
- arikrak 12y agoThey assume over the long term their changes are improvements even if takes getting used to. Though maybe they just need something to do, so they change the design regularly...
- gtbcb 12y agoI feel like startups change their UI too often as well. Yes, it's good to test new designs for conversion, but sometimes I feel like every time I visit a site, I have to completely relearn how to use it. Sometimes I wonder if designers should be contracted more instead of being brought on full-time.
- guelo 12y agoThere was a time many years ago when google gave engineers free rein. The engineers kept coming up with new blockbuster products like gmail and maps, but the designers hated Google. They complained that the engineers shouldn't be designing the products, that the interfaces were ugly and cluttered. Cluttered because they exposed ways to manipulate all the features that the engineers had created. So Google hired tons of designers to fix this, and gave them high level positions to make product decisions. The designers now run the company so we get new paint on the old products. The innovation is only on new designs and interactions.
- 627467 12y agoGoogle/Android have been pushing major UI changes every other version. Why? Who knows. I just gave a Moto G to my mother hoping that upgrading from an Android device to another would smooth the transition but - among other things - she couldn't find how to operate the new Google camera (a primary function for her). Why? Because there's this "trend" of hiding all the GUI with gestures and stuff, despite the fact that displays are growing and there's more screen real-estate than ever. And it's worse that some of these changes are subtle enough that it may even take you a few days to realize why you are so frustrated with your seemingly same phone: buttons have disappeared, borders removed, contrast decreased. Ultimately I feel there's very little respect for the wider audience by today's "pioneers". Here in our bubble we all love novelty, new solutions, new paradigms, but the wider market doesn't care about this. They just want to keep doing what took them a long time to learn to do.
- Animats 12y agoMobile devices are now in the tailfin era, like 1950s cars. Every year, the styling changes, to force users to buy the new model. 1950s people actually used to buy a new car every year if they could afford it, partly because vehicle reliability and working life sucked. Then Japanese cars with higher reliability and lower cost started to compete with Detroit's chrome-laden behemoths. That didn't end well for Detroit. Today, cars last about twice as long as they did in the 1970s.
- WD-42 12y agoDoes anyone use pin unlock on their phones? With lollipop you now have to swipe the screen just to get to the pin unlock. That's an entire extra gesture that serves absolutely no purpose but to take an extra .5 seconds from my life every time I unlock my phone.
- zem 12y agoyep, this is my primary annoyance with the new update
- sjolsen 12y ago> There are a bunch of new ‘transitions’ between elements. I don’t know what the battery cost actually is for this, but as a user I just don’t care about cute transitions between elements. I want fast interaction with my mobile device. In other words, UI animations are literally a waste of time. To hell with the battery, the user's time is the most valuable resource, period.
- phazelift 12y agoNot to speak about the Firefox 29 release, they ruined it, I reinstalled and the old version, still on 28 now..