6 ms·
Flash Professional CS5 will build native iPhone and iPod Touch applications
- abyssknight 17y agoThis is epic, and I don't think everyone realizes what this means. Developers will be able to just... export. The revenue model for Flash games used to be: free + advertising. With this move, those same games can be released on the app store and actually charge money, or fall back to the advertising model. Its a simple way for developers to cash in. The funny thing, and this is what makes very little sense, is why did Adobe do this at all? There's no doubt that little feature cost them some serious cash, and for what? To make Apple rich?
- allenp 17y agoI'm sure Adobe's motivation is to make money selling licenses to software developers. If I remember it is about $700/seat for this software. In terms of their cost, it would make sense that Apple did some of the heavy lifting on this as part of an agreement to keep Flash off their devices. Unity is another example of a company doing this same thing and making money at it too.
- eob 17y agoI'll second that. Adobe wants to become an alternative platform for the iPhone. Right now it's Objective-C or the highway. I can't stand JavaScript (and therefore ActionScript) but, as an iPhone developer, watching this video made me think, "gosh, I should start learning flash". Objective-C is a nice language once you get used to it, but I can't imagine that it could compete against Flash in animation-heavy programming tasks.
- cakesy 17y agoNo it isnt', there are plenty of languages you can program the iphone in. Straight off Apple supports C. Then a lot of people have added support for other languages. All these have been advertised on here.
- bemmu 17y agoNot only that, but since those devs get their Flash apps distributed to portal sites, they can easily advertise the iPhone version inside their games. I'm quite sure a link to buy the app for your phone will be much more compelling than a random interstitial ad.
- dpcan 17y agoThey had to come up with SOME reason for folks like me to upgrade from CS4 to CS5. CS4 is already so feature-rich I probably never would have upgraded. Add this little gem, and well, here's my $400-$700. Done.
- wallflower 17y agoOne of the first apps written in Flash and cross-compiled to Objective-C native in the wild of the App Store: http://www.flashcomguru.com/index.cfm/2009/10/5/iphone-justletters http://www.flashcomguru.com/index.cfm/2009/10/5/iphone-justl...
- barredo 17y agoThis is nothing but good. Let's see if Apple likes it. Didn't Apple dislike the iPhone apps made with .Net+Framework?
- drawkbox 17y agoThere are like 5-10 top apps built with Unity3D such as Zombieville USA that is Mono based and cross compiled. So in short, now they love them because they make money from them (30%).
- eob 17y agoYeah this is good for everyone. However it might be bad for Flash's chances in MobileSafari, however. Apple wants to funnel people through apps, not web sites. If they can make the argument that the iPhone supports flash because you can compile to native format, it might take the heat off them w/r/t integrating Flash into Safari.
- bprater 17y agoSeems like a huge opportunity for folks who are fluent in Flash/AS3 and haven't had time to jump on the Objective-C bandwagon. It's likely that since it's compiled down, it'll run faster than interpreted Flash! Great move by Adobe! (I'm curious if Flex will work.)
- pcestrada 17y agoI would expect Flex to work as well since it's basically an actionscript GUI library written on top of Flash. There is a mxml compiler that takes your Flex gui code and converts it to a SWF. And it sounds like LLVM takes a SWF and turns it into Obj-c code so I think it would work.
- mmilenko 17y agoPretty sluggishly for now, they say http://labs.adobe.com/wiki/index.php/Applications_for_iPhone:Developer_FAQ#Can_I_use_the_Flex_Framework_to_create_content_for_the_iPhone.3F http://labs.adobe.com/wiki/index.php/Applications_for_iPhone...
- zackattack 17y agoI'm calling it now: ECMAScript will be the most important language over the next three years.
- simonw 17y agoThe problem is ActionScript is pretty far from the EMCAScript you get in browsers - ActionScript was based on a proposed standard for ECMAScript which was later abandoned, so it's pretty much a different language now.
- zackattack 17y agoFair enough. Probably true for AS3, which seems to superficially resemble Java. One of my hobby projects (HipHopGoblin) uses a bunch of AS2, which I find very similar to JavaScript.
- iron_ball 17y agoAS3 is quite similar to Javascript also -- you can't do as much with the prototypes, but it still has closures, allowing a functional style; and everything's essentially an Object with properties, allowing a dynamic style. You can turn off strict mode and it won't do compile-time type checking, or you can type specific signatures as "*" and they will not be type-checked. This means you can do all the duck-typing you like, instead of defining a Java-like interface. One of AS3's goals was definitely to become more like Java, for whatever reason, but almost all of the new Java-y-ness is optional.
- jswinghammer 17y agoThis is true regardless of this latest development.
- wallflower 17y agoAdobe is using LLVM. There is no runtime. +1 http://www.adobe.com/devnet/logged_in/abansod_iphone.html http://www.adobe.com/devnet/logged_in/abansod_iphone.html
- xal 17y agoThat's some amazing work. Adobe must have dedicated the A-Team to that task.
- moe 17y agoNever understimate Adobe. Despite their misguided stabs towards DRM (oh god when will they learn) they have some good engineering there. PDF, Photoshop, Flash, despite all their flaws and sometimes dubious origins, wouldn't have dominated their respective markets for decades if there wasn't also at least a bit of quality engineering in each. ;-)
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- ed 17y agoI don't know why parent is being modded down. Adobe has some fucking mind-blowing engineers, especially on their core teams. Advanced technology labs is putting out parc-quality work in the field of graphics.
- bonaldi 17y ago"There is no runtime" Ah, so they got Flash on the phone by taking away the bit that makes it suck bells. Good job, Adobe. Amazing what you can do when Apple forces you to not to be craptacular.
- stcredzero 17y agoThank goodness they aren't as bad a case as AT&T. I'm still waiting for some Apple-y goodness to rub off on them.
- bprater 17y agoLooks like it'll have all the AIR bits-and-pieces in it. So you'll get database/filesystem access, etc.
- oliverkofoed 17y agoMonoTouch (monotouch.net) is exactly the same approach for .NET instead of Flash.
- ujjwalg 17y agoIn short: no Mac required for developing iPhone apps. flash games which are extremely easy/quick to develop can be ported into iphone apps. Conclusion: iPhone app development prices will go down the drain for most of the apps. There will be millions of apps on the appstore. Prices of apps will go down further. WOW!!!
- elai 17y ago.99 is the minimum you can go, so iphone apps wont get cheaper. Flash games tend to run really slow even with beafy core 2 duos, so I'm wondering if the performance will translate for smartphones.
- cakesy 17y agoI guess you didn't watch the video? The apps appeared quite snazzy, I am sure they used open gl es for them, so there is no reason they should be. I hate flash, but I hate dealing with open gl even more. Maybe I will have to look into this.
- georgekv 17y agoWhile development costs may drop, it's hard for most app prices to drop any further as Apple has set the price floor at $0.99 cents.
- axod 17y agoFree + email harvesting/advertising/spam?
- davidalln 17y agoPerhaps, but I think this is too cynical. You forget about the cost of Flash (assuming you're being legit), the cost of being able to put up stuff on the App Store, how potentially difficult it is to adapt the application to the iPhone, and how annoyingly stringy Apple is about bugs. This will surly shoo away a large amount of amateur Flash-ists. Plus, you're forgetting that the market is already diluted. The only apps that make it are those which get advertised heavily or a big blog discovers and writes about it. Therefore, these "million of apps" will hardly make a difference in how difficult it is to make significant money developing iPhone apps. The App Store is not going to become Newgrounds, I promise.
- rimantas 17y agoWill it work as well as Flash now works on OS X? If so, then thanks, but no thanks.
- cakesy 17y agoWell, you could watch the video. Seems to work pretty well. I hate flash, but compiled flash might just be ok.
- mattyb 17y agoWow, so owning a Mac will no longer be a requirement for iPhone development, as Flash Professional supports Windows also. Even MonoTouch requires an Intel Mac.
- allenp 17y agoThis would be pretty great - but I'm not sure what Adobe has planned for signing the app (and if they can take any of the pain out of that process it would really make life a lot easier).
- allenp 17y agoSo a few questions in my mind - what does this do to wait times for getting apps into the store? How much stricter is Apple going to be on non-conforming UI? I really think Apple will impose artificial controls on the market to prevent it from bottoming out and flooding their top tier producers - or perhaps finally make a AAA section for the store.
- bdittmer 17y agoDid no one else anticipate this? Lots of other people have been doing this for awhile (mono foundation, unity, gambit scheme, etc.). Is this a game changer? Yes. It opens up the door to tons of developers. Will applications written in actionscript still have the same shortcomings as the other aforementioned languages? Probably. Looking at the AS apps in the store right now they all have larger than expected file sizes. Additionally I don't see any of them taking advantage of any of the latest API features rolled out in iPhoneOS v3. Each time Apple releases a new iPhone OS version (with all of the API changes/additions) all of these tools need to be updated and re-released. Moral of the story? If you want to take advantage of the latest API features and remain on the cutting edge of iPhone development it's best to stick with objective-c.
- 9oliYQjP 17y agoBefore everyone gets too excited over this, admittedly very cool technical achievement, how will this affect the look and feel of apps making use of it? Games always tend to use completely custom UIs, so this will be a neat tool at the disposal of game devs. But how will business apps feel? Will text boxes be CocoaTouch-based or some Adobe-proprietary text box? These things tend to matter in achieving a consistent look and feel to users. I've never preferred Java apps on either Windows or Mac OS X to native ones, primarily because they are only ever 95% of the way there in providing consistent look and feel. There's always something that is just off ever so slightly.
- alex_c 17y agoEven if CS5 won't include it at launch, I'm sure it's only a matter of time before there will be a full-fledged library of "iPhone-like" controls available. Besides, Apple can be as anal as they want about interface consistency before they approve something to the App Store, and they're probably not thrilled by this. They can use the interface excuse to great effect if they choose, to neutralize the effectiveness of this tool by simply rejecting many Flash apps.
- smhinsey 17y agoIt will be interesting to see how Microsoft reacts to this. I am in the early stages of planning an application that might have a rich client component. Since the rest of the stack is .NET, it made a lot of sense to look at Silverlight, but now that I could potentially deploy the same code to an iPhone (and probably other mobile platforms as well) with minimal extra effort, it's hard to recommend Silverlight.
- guelo 17y agoSo after all of my investment and time learning the Cocoa Touch platform these flash guys come in with 10+ years of crappy code and inundate the app store without even having to reference count their objects. There goes my consulting business :( If it's been hard getting noticed in the app store imagine what it's going to be like when every flash app in the world is ported over.
- wensing 17y agoThis makes us at Stormpulse really happy, since our map is written in ActionScript, and people have been screaming for an iPhone app.
- nirmal 17y agoI sure hope IndestructoTank is ported right away. One of my favorite games and I think it us well suited to iPhone gaming.
- radley 17y agositting in multi-touch session at AdobeMAX... yes, for iPhone. Will check out the AIR session (for "mobile") on Wed. A lot of sessions that were titled "for Mobile" have changed to "for iPhone": http://arno.org/arnotify/2009/10/max-2009-adobe-air-2-0-and-iphone-support/ http://arno.org/arnotify/2009/10/max-2009-adobe-air-2-0-and-...
- zhyder 17y agoThe FAQ is pretty informative: http://labs.adobe.com/wiki/index.php/Applications_for_iPhone:Developer_FAQ http://labs.adobe.com/wiki/index.php/Applications_for_iPhone... I especially found this useful: <quote>Which native iPhone APIs and functionality are supported when using Flash tooling? The following native device APIs and functionality are supported: - MultiTouch - Screen Orientation - Saving images to Photo Library - Accelerometer - Geo-location - Cut / Copy / Paste Can applications take advantage of hardware acceleration? Yes. In some cases, the rendering of Flash content will be hardware accelerated. We will publish more information on this when we release the public beta.</unquote>
- senthilnayagam 17y agoI doubt if people can build apps on windows "yet" until there is official blessings from Apple itself application signing and testing on iphone simulator, phone provisioning and developer profile for iphone, debugging, profiling all need a mac, xcode and friends the machine shown on the video was a mac
- timdorr 17y agoI think the biggest thing people are missing here is one of the best advantages: Demos! Currently Apple doesn't give a way to distribute demo copies of software. But if your app is already a Flash project, you can export that to the web in a trial form for people to play and test out. We've had videos and screenshots, but this is a much more effective way of selling. Check out an example: http://www.muchosmedia.com/justletters/ http://www.muchosmedia.com/justletters/ All you've got to do to build a demo is export to SWF instead of IPA. Easy cheezy.
- neovive 17y agoThis is a significant development and seems to be win-win for both Adobe and Apple. It will be very interesting to see how this plays out and if iPhone App development in Windows/Flash is as seamless as Adobe is claiming. But if it is, along with the support for RTMP, Remote Shared Objects, AMF, and SQLLite, it could be a big boost for Adobe.