32 ms·
Uber Executive Suggests Digging Up Dirt on Journalists
- dang 12y agoBuzzfeed stories are normally penalized, but we take the penalty off for major stories. We've done that here. HN tends to frown on media controversy, but since this story seems destined to be above the line in any case, it may as well be the original source. We've demoted the other posts on the same story as duplicates.
- bcantrill 12y agoTo say that this is "media controversy" borders on the absurd: this is entirely inappropriate and indefensible behavior from a top executive at a top company -- and it raises all sorts of legitimate questions about corporate culture and how companies internalize public criticism. You use the passive voice when you say that "it seems destined to be above the line" when in fact it is above the line because many in the HN demographic feel that this story is important. In this case, HN's strange paternalism is going to cause this discussion to happen three separate times in three separate threads. Can the HN community really not be trusted to decide what we think is important?
- Bahamut 12y agoIt's disrespectful that the community cannot allowed to at least see the stories we want to see bubble to the top, good or bad. There are good lessons to be learned in all of these issues, moreso than a lot of articles that bubble up to the top here.
- potatolicious 12y agoEhh, I can see where dang is coming from - some moderation is needed in order for the community not to descend to Reddit levels of intelligibility. That said, I do agree that painting this as a "media controversy" is grossly off the mark. This isn't your usual (somewhat entertaining) mud slinging between trashy bloggers, this addresses real misbehavior by a real tech company. Imagine if Glenn Greewald and Snowden were treated as merely "media controversies". The Asshole Problem(tm) is becoming a huge, gigantic, glaring issue that will only get bigger. The deafening silence from our industry whenever deplorable behavior like this surfaces is itself worth addressing. This especially includes the usual deafening silence from investors (including YC) whenever their companies are caught doing something overtly evil.
- Bahamut 12y agoI agree that moderation is necessary, but it needs to happen at the comment level, not the post level.
- tptacek 12y agoHN has always been moderated at the post level, from the beginnings of the site. If it wasn't, the site would be flooded with fluffy recaps of whatever current event story was making people angriest right now, and there would be no place for stories about Linux on solderless breadboards and Latex-like math programming languages; instead, we'd get HuffPo, Buzzfeed, Pando, and ValleyWag's take on whatever the controversy-du-jour was, day after day.
- Bahamut 12y agoSo there's no place for reasoned discussion on topics that are clearly of interest to many here? That sounds like a poor excuse for improper moderation. Some level of post level moderation I can understand, but to the degree practiced here, you might as well have sanctioned curators instead of moderators for that - at the least, it'd be far more accurate, and far more transparent. Instead we get a heavyhanded version that allows a few to destroy possible reasoned discussion by squelching it as a side-effect of this rationale, and instead we get lots of topics that don't really foster discussion, are often not interesting or important (even to those intellectually minded) - there are plenty of banal articles on startups that get upvoted and end up on the front page, but no similar policy gets instituted simply because they are "not controversial", and yet they take up the same space, and certainly are less fulfilling. The process is opaque, and I know I'm not the only one here who has questioned this. There are sometimes situations where flags are deemed inappropriate, and yet the effects don't get raised when moderators even acknowledge when the flags were incorrect.
- tptacek 12y agoI guess my point was, a cri de coeur at the end of 2014 probably isn't going to change a policy that has been in place since early 2007. You are effectively arguing with the premise of the site.
- ams6110 12y agoThis is not corporate culture it's politics. Personal destruction has been near the front page of the playbook since about forever.
- SamReidHughes 12y ago> In this case, HN's strange paternalism is going to cause this discussion to happen three separate times in three separate threads. Can the HN community really not be trusted to decide what we think is important? If you're interpreting mods' behavior in maintaining this site as paternalism and think a set of randos voting on articles that attract their attention is an entity to which the verb "trusted" could even be applied, you are completely out of touch with reality.
- dang 12y agoI'm a bit confused, because this comment mostly seems in vigorous agreement with what we actually did. We restored the story to the front page, where it still is. But let me try to address your concerns as I understand them. The posts were obvious duplicates, so we did the routine thing and demoted all but one of them. It's true that we didn't merge the threads (which we've recently begun doing in many such cases), but IIRC that's because most of the discussion in the other threads at that point was about why they weren't the Buzzfeed story. Did I get that wrong? If so, it was for the mundane reason that at 1 A.M. I was tired and less meticulous than I try to be. By "seems destined, etc." I meant that many people here obviously cared about the story. "Media controversy" doesn't strike me as absurd at all, but let's not quarrel over wording; let's seek each other's meaning instead. FWIW, my personal opinion is that, assuming the story is accurately reported, it's outrageous. But it's our duty to try to factor personal opinions out of moderation decisions. You seem to be complaining that HN's front page isn't decided by votes alone. It never has been; it has always been a blend of voting and curation. Voting alone would cause HN to be dominated by outrage, gossip, fashion and promotion. That would kill the site. [1] I dislike that fact as much as any HN user, and probably have more reason to dislike it. But there's no question that it's true. It's so true that it's an interesting question why it's true, given that this is a community of smart people, and I even have a whole theory about it... but I'll spare you. 1. I'm just echoing what tptacek already said in this thread, as well as regurgitating what I've posted dozens of times, but it does seem necessary to regurgitate.
- just2n 12y agoThe entire point of clickbait sensationalist journalism is to get people fighting about non-issues. A guy who landed a probe on a fucking comet was forced to apologize in tears because he wore a shirt that these same people disliked. Now even the MSM is pointing out how ridiculous that was. He was called sexist, exemplifying why women don't work in STEM. They just found evidence of organic matter on the comet. This is groundbreaking. But the fucking shirt. Scientific achievements don't generate the clicks and outrage like sensationalist "fuck ethics" journalism. Let's make HN about sensationalist articles about shirts and off-hand jokes at private dinners. Why not just unmod all of the websites that do this routinely. This is hardly as big as half of their "stories", and then let the front page be covered with stories that sit there for 2 days because they have 3000+ upvotes? This place has become a more toxic version of Reddit. Oddly, this story isn't on the front page there, or even on the front of /r/programming. Or even in the first 4 pages. I guess they're doing something better. How about we take it a step further and ban positive mention of Uber, since it seems the majority here hates Uber for one reason or another, even if they're mostly uninformed (and yes, quoting BuzzFeed or PandoDaily as fact makes one uninformed) or do so because someone poked their feelings. Maybe next we can ban gendered pronouns and require people disclose their full names, place of employment, and home address, because anonymity is the cause of online toxicity. We definitely need to lower the downvote bar to 0 so that new people can immediately begin downvoting anyone they don't like or disagree with. Let's see how deep this rabbit hole goes.
- just2n 12y agoThis isn't a major story. It's an out-of-context clickbait dressed recount of a hypothetical story painted by a frustrated man at a private dinner. If there was a criminal suit filed along side the allegations made, perhaps you'd have a major story. This is just another in a long line of hit pieces that seem to have no basis in reality.
- grayarea 12y agoIt's OK for frustrated people to threaten children now?
- just2n 12y agoThere's nothing in this article alleging that. There is someone in the comments here who has been vehemently anti-Uber on other social media who makes the claim, though. Let's get facts before we throw around slanderous accusations. Or even apply some basic reasoning.
- morganvachon 12y agoI'll respectfully disagree. There's nothing "hypothetical" about it, the guy laid out a budget and a game plan for targeted harassment and intimidation of journalists who dared to write negative press. There were multiple high-profile witnesses, and after it all came to light, he called and then emailed the journalist he threatened, to apologize profusely. This is just one more event in a long history of Uber being an extremely bad actor. They use dirty tactics to try to run their competitors out of business instead of competing on their merits, they treat their drivers and riders like shit, they gleefully flaunt their ability to track anyone, anywhere, any time and use it against them. Now they've gone on record (his emailed apology puts the entire affair on the record, no matter what he thought during the dinner in question) admitting that they are willing to harass, intimidate, and even threaten the lives of journalists and their families. In short, this company is ran by a bunch of sociopaths who think they can do no wrong. It's going to bite them in the ass, and I hope sooner than later.
- just2n 12y ago
- justinv 12y agoPersonally, I've stopped using Uber because of the lack of the company/management's lack of ethics. Lyft comes off as a much friendly, consumer-focused company & frankly, my experiences have been better in a Lyft than an UberX. Also - I'm not one to usually browse Buzzfeed, but this was their story to break, so props to them for getting it out there.
- VieElm 12y agoThere's also Sidecar, it's pretty great. It is usually cheaper and let's you select from available drivers. You see their price upfront.
- timjahn 12y agoSidecar is a joke in Chicago. They have only 2-3 drivers available at any time, wait times of 15-30 min, and 98% of the time they refuse your request anyway. I fully expect Sidecar to just give up in Chicago any day now.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rhizome 12y agoI think we all know what a lack of ethics gets you in the business world: more money and power.
- Eric_WVGG 12y agoThe thing that’s crazy is that Uber’s service is terrific. They can succeed quite handily in the market without resorting to this sort of bullshit (like that crazy caper where they asked drivers to make phony ride reservations on competing services). I think Yglesias has the right take — the very qualities necessary to make an legally-grey service successful are going to become antithetical to them succeeding as a normal, law-abiding, “legally white” service. http://www.vox.com/2014/11/18/7240295/uber-privacy http://www.vox.com/2014/11/18/7240295/uber-privacy
- 12y ago
- Asparagirl 12y agoAttempting to blackmail the press if they challenge your company's PR? Specifically targeting parents' worst fears by threatening to reveal details of the location of their children? Openly rifling through the location metadata of another female journalist, a customer of theirs, without her consent? Implicitly saying they'll leak customer data of Uber customers who are journalists, the kind of thing that can potentially endanger sources and compromise whistleblowers? These people are scum. Uber was a neat app, but I have PLENTY of alternatives these days. I opt out at airports, I donate to the EFF, I don't use Uber or any other app that targets people's privacy and actively threatens the freedom of the press. (Oh, and like Sarah Lacey, I'm a mom of young kids too. Reading that article induced such a shudder of horror, and will likely do the same for any parent who reads, or even hears about, that story. Uber has done major, major damage to their brand on a visceral level.)
- nhangen 12y agoIn all fairness, Paul and Sara have been on an absolute witch hunt, seemingly angry because of Travis' capitalist ideals. I'm not going to defend the guy that made these comments, but I've heard enough from Sara and Paul to know that Pando has waged war on Uber, and should not be surprised that they've ruffled some feathers. Pando also shares a common investor with Lyft, so there's that...
- api 12y ago... then Travis is playing right into their hands and feeding the troll. Personal flame wars on the net are one thing, but involving your company in that shit? The minute you take money and hire other people it's not your personal sandbox. This 4chan crap should at best come with a huge "my opinions are my own" disclaimer and should never involve your company.
- eli 12y agoActing like an ass is not necessarily a zero-sum game. But that doesn't change the fact that publicly musing about going after someone's family for revenge is totally unacceptable.
- 12y ago
- joelrunyon 12y agoI get the competitive nature that Uber's taken against Lyft / Sidecar, but this seems like the worst thing yet.
- justinv 12y agoAlso, it was Travis who said “We’re in a political campaign, and the candidate is Uber and the opponent is an asshole named Taxi," Well, it seems we have come full circle. Who's the asshole now?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- PhantomGremlin 12y agoThere is another recent HN article. It links to a Pando post by Sarah Lacy, the journalist being threatened. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8622187 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8622187
- makomk 12y agoThere's also previous discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8622403 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8622403
- unohoo 12y agoSomeone @Lyft PR needs to be on this stat. I've hardly seen Lyft take any advantage of fuckups like these by Uber.
- philwelch 12y agoWhat makes you think these hit pieces against Uber aren't Lyft's PR in the first place?
- unohoo 12y agothis one doesnt seem to be. an uber svp was talking directly to buzzfeed editor.
- hessenwolf 12y agoIt's a complicated decision: whether or not to get into the smear war. I have more respect for Lyft if they don't.
- forgotAgain 12y agoSome things are just too radioactive to touch.
- ropman76 12y agoIf your competition is doing something really stupid, all you have to do is get out of the way...
- protomyth 12y agoThat would be the worst idea. They should stay far, far away and not say word one. You do not ever get involved in controversy if you can help it. Say a word and get you and yours investigated by those looking for a follow-up story.
- sbuk 12y agoNot necessarily a bad idea... Edit FWIW, I personally do not and refuse to use Uber. I think that they are vile. But... I find that too many journalist hide behind 'freedom of the press' when they are axe-grinding. A lot of online tech reporting that I encounter is knee-jerk reaction and factless click-bait. Personal blogs, where you'd expect to find this behaviour, in my experience tend to be far more credible...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bhouston 12y agoI can see how being assholes, intimidating the press, undermining rivals via dirty tricks, and other such behavior, can maximize shareholder value. So maybe we just have to accept that this is the new normal and we should all focus on how we can play dirty tricks on our competitors, how we can intimidate the journalists who have written bad stories on us or haven't covered us. Where does the strategy to use intimation via oppo-research stop? Can we apply this to any dealings with politicians, angles, VC, policy makers? I bet it can be effective in these areas as well. Maybe a company's strategy to "force outcomes" should be a required slide in all pitch decks now? I wonder if Uber stops at just using intimidation in less developed countries where things are rougher and governments are more pliable than in the US and Canada? If there are few limits to Uber aggressiveness and they have money, you can easily pay people in a lot of developing nations to improve outcomes in a large variety of "creative ways", and you can easily distance yourself from how those outcomes are achieved. It does seem that Uber teaches us that this is the new normal and if we are not doing this, we are not maximizing shareholder value.
- pjc50 12y agomaybe we just have to accept that this is the new normal No we do not; this is the time to push back on it. Otherwise, as you say, you end up making the country more lawless and less developed by sending the thugs round to "achieve outcomes".
- SyneRyder 12y agoYou can still compete by just being better. Stories like these definitely turn me off Uber, but for all the people saying "just use Lyft or Sidecar instead"... neither service is available in my country yet, let alone my city. But Uber is here. Uber (for me, so far) has been far superior than local taxis, and it's all low hanging fruit: credit card billing, email receipts, comfortable cars, GPS tracking & ETA, friendly drivers who don't harass you, tips included in price, global business accounts, discounts & perks. Local taxis don't offer any of that, they're not even trying. Maybe Lyft & Sidecar offer that, but they're not in any of the cities I travel to globally. The world is not just San Francisco. Make a damn good service first. I can't switch to your service if you won't even offer it to me.
- 12y ago
- just2n 12y agoWhy is this here? This is a non story. All I see in this article is that someone was ranting in a conversation that was entirely assumed to be off the record (they go to great lengths to justify talking about it, as if private dinners require contracts of nondisclosure). I find it beyond hilarious that here Buzzfeed stands appalled that someone would joke about hiring people to dig up dirt when they find their way into private dinners and report every unsavory thing said in confidence and without context, essentially writing off that context as "this is never appropriate." Does anyone else see the outrageous hypocrisy here? One man is joking about something because he's frustrated with poor media coverage (which is arguably of questionable ethical validity) while Buzzfeed is actually doing that thing and now everyone here on HN is joking about how terrible Uber is and how they've distanced themselves. This is HN. This is gossip about a man's frustrated rant at shitty media coverage. It's a non story and is totally off topic. If there was evidence he had hired people to dig up dirt with intent to blackmail, extort, or otherwise coerce people, we could be talking about criminal proceedings. But seeing as there's no mention of any criminal wrongdoing, this is complete and utter trash, and they know it. Another in a very long list of reasons never to read Buzzfeed. I'm not here in a position in support of Uber because I literally have no idea what is and isn't fact. If every article negative of them is as misguided and useless as this one, I can't possibly hope to form a coherent and well informed opinion about a company. Definitely not based on clickbait headlines and opinion pieces without solid evidence of wrongdoing. You can hate Uber for all the valid reasons you can find, but getting angry at someone for expressing frustration is truly next level pathetic. This clickbait shit. What the fuck. Some people are linking a Pando article, which says, as a direct quote: > Earlier this evening, a bombshell story by Buzzfeed editor-in-chief Ben Smith proves the reality is way worse than anyone on our team could have expected. In reference to this article. You can see why this shit can't be taken seriously. Referring to garbage like this article as a "bombshell" or "proof" of activity is completely divorced from reality.
- venomsnake 12y agoOff the record is privilege given by the journalist at its own discretion, not a right.
- DanBC 12y ago
- blackdogie 12y agoDespite being an impressive company, generating sales, growth fast, expanding internationally, it seems that these founders are a little immature. This isn't the first story about the lack of ethics of the company, and if I was them I would worry about this potential shift in widespread support. Today's shining light can easily be changed into the tomorrows demon. Maybe they could spend $1M on PR to improve the image.
- onion2k 12y agoMaybe they could spend $1M on PR to improve the image. Or spend $0 and actually improve things in the company so they don't need PR to tell people they're not horrible.
- general_failure 12y agoWhy bother when people continue using it? Trust me, people will continue to use it as long as there is a value add - cheaper, better etc. In general, nobody cares about what happens behind the scenes.
- QuadDamaged 12y agoJust looking at my uber rides, I am pretty certain Uber could already infer some interesting facts about my life. Cross-referencing with geo-data, time, and weekly occurences, I am pretty sure Uber could infer who's in my social circle, and under which category (coworker, wife, arm-candy...) The day Uber links its userbase with Facebook we are doomed.
- blackdogie 12y agoSeeing as Uber now has distinct ties to Google, I doubt that they are an acquisition target for FB.
- rhizome 12y agoI have to wonder if this guy is executing a David Plouffe strategy to take a severance payout and become a lobbyist. That's one way people wouldn't know any developments from this were driven by Uber.
- kubiiii 12y agoAre there legal reasons why this SVP does not apologize to the journalist he specifically targeted while recognizing he threatened her and regreting it?
- caractacus 12y agoHe did. He called her (though she has no idea how he got her number) and asked to speak off the record. No, really. He did. "Hey Sarah, I realise there's this massive story blowing where I threatened to wage war on you and your family and I know you're a high profile journalist in this area but can we just have a quick friendly chat off the record?" Scroll to the bottom of her article: http://pando.com/2014/11/17/the-moment-i-learned-just-how-far-uber-will-go-to-silence-journalists-and-attack-women/ http://pando.com/2014/11/17/the-moment-i-learned-just-how-fa...
- kubiiii 12y agoThanks, the parent link did not mention this. His email reads like something sincere. Still confused why he did apologize on the phone. Harder to CCI your CEO on the phone maybe.
- ddalex 12y agoUber is just not a nice company, they skirt laws around the world, and do very shoddy business.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- casca 12y agoWhile in SF earlier this month, I noticed that people were using Lyft and Uber interchangeably and given the consistent stories about Uber's management, it seems likely that people will switch to Lyft as a primary option with Uber as a backup. It's quite possible that Uber will create the market by and then be eclipsed by other players who are less unethical.
- bhouston 12y agoThere is not enough general awareness of Uber's assholeness in the general public to have a meaningful effect. That may change but it hasn't yet.
- thesystemis 12y agoI am surprised not to see the word misogynist on this page. Here, a SVP is not only threatening a reporter and her family (which is truly repugnant) and reporters generally, he's also discussing sexual assault in such a trivializing way: "He said that he thought Lacy should be held “personally responsible” for any woman who followed her lead in deleting Uber and was then sexually assaulted." The top comment on this page talks about a "visceral" feeling, I had the same one. I had the same feeling I had when I heard things like Todd Akin (a politican in the US) talking about "legitimate rape." Do we really want people like this shaping our future?
- andy_ppp 12y agoUber has now been deleted from my phone. I hope others consider doing the same.
- caractacus 12y agoDitto.
- fown9 12y agoI took 2 uber rides this morning; I just uninstalled Uber and installed Lyft. They have the same amount of cars down in here in San Jose.
- onewaystreet 12y agoLyft only exists because Uber cleared the way and they continue to benefit from Uber doing the hard work of fighting the taxi industry and regulators. If you don't want to be a hypocrite you will need to walk.
- drivingmenuts 12y agoIt just so happens that in almost every possible industry, there are some who clear the way and others who benefit from them clearing the way. Some of them even manage to do it without threatening reporters.
- rikacomet 12y agoOn a side note, Uber should also sue all those companies piggy-backing on its name, dragging its name down. What I mean is, that every other month, I'm seeing a case of "Uber-for-X", like Blowhorn, is a startup that claims to be uber for mini-trucks. What is happening is that, UBER is still going through its real challenge and hasn't established itself as a household name, like Microsoft, Apple, Google. Lot of people are still critical of its intent (including me perhaps), and its ultimate success, but these small startups that are piggybacking on its name are making matter's worse. Most of these Uber for X startups, are not going to succeed, generally speaking, and when a start-up fails, brand value gets hit as people associate "failure" "didn't work" "not so good" with that name. Uber in that sense, is taking a hit on its brand name due to failure of other businesses (which I think is a bit unfair).
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y agoThat's called "getting disrupted."
- spindritf 12y agoI cannot treat complaints from journalists about digging up dirt seriously. This has essentially become their job. Were was this criticism when some guy's personal phone calls were broadcasted and dissected? When Gawker was buying people's sex tapes? And not months ago, although then too, last week[1]. This is the world you created. Enjoy. EDIT: And if you're downvoting, I'd love to hear why. [1] http://defamer.gawker.com/somebody-is-selling-an-usher-sex-tape-are-you-that-som-1657908238 http://defamer.gawker.com/somebody-is-selling-an-usher-sex-t...
- king_jester 12y agoBad behavior by some journalists doesn't justify personal attacks by companies against journalists.
- spindritf 12y agoOne can hope that once it happens a few times, journalists will maybe rediscover the basic ethics of their profession. Right now, they simply seem to demand a monopoly on digging for dirt.
- caboteria 12y agoJust one more shining example that the easiest way to be successful in business is to be a sociopath.
- Panino 12y agoWhen Godaddy came out in support of SOPA, after a string of other obviously bad actions, I thought for sure it would harm their business. It didn't. Unfortunately I don't think this Uber story will be different. Most people don't take a stand on anything (unless it involves consuming even more fast food, like a Chick-fil-a "reverse boycott").
- selmnoo 12y ago> When Godaddy came out in support of SOPA, after a string of other obviously bad actions, I thought for sure it would harm their business. It hurt them enough to reverse their stance on SOPA in mere hours. Have you been to godaddy.com lately? "Internet freedom!" is actually one of the things they advertise on their page. Now, I too was hoping in those days that the company would just die... and that's unlikely to happen to Uber as well, considering that dollar is kind and a lot has been given to Uber by so many investors. The best you can hope for is a massive firing of executives at the top, since that's where a lot of toxicity seems to be coming from.
- qeorge 12y agoChik-fil-a lost at least one customer for life - me. I have not eaten their food since the story broke, and I never will again. Uber just came to Raleigh, NC where I live, and I was pretty stoked to try them out. Not gonna happen now - I'll stick with Taxi Taxi.[1] [1] http://www.taxitaxiofraleigh.com/ http://www.taxitaxiofraleigh.com/
- theorique 12y agoI'm ethically opposed to Chick-fil-a's stance, but I like their sandwiches. Most of the time I don't eat them, but every once in a while, the beast takes over and I have to eat.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoI just ask at the counter "Is this hateful message day? I don't want to endorse your hateful message." If they say no, then I order a sandwich.
- 12y ago
- nailer 12y agoMisleading headline, from article it wasn't in any way a serious suggestion.
- ghshephard 12y agoIt now reads, "Uber Executive Suggests Digging Up Dirt on Journalists " which is exactly what he did. (Actually, he even went further and said it would be acceptable do so)
- nailer 12y agoHe 'suggested considering' this at a dinner party, and 'Michael at no point suggested that Uber has actually hired opposition researchers, or that it plans to.' according to Buzzfeed - they're trying to imply it was a serious suggestion while actually sticking to the facts, which imply it very much wasn't. It's fascinating.
- pja 12y agoLooks like it's time to a) uninstall Uber and b) subscribe to PandoDaily.
- bakhy 12y agoUber's only purpose and meaning is exploitation. Yes, the app is handy, but it's no disruption. The disruption is in destabilizing the taxi cooperatives and weakening the drivers' position. We should all cut the crap, there is nothing to be surprised by here.
- cwkoss 12y agoDestabilizing taxi monopolies is a very positive societal disruption. I don't know where you're from but here Uber is half the cost of a cab, better service, and they actually have clean cars. If you don't think they're disruptive, I'm not sure how you define disruptive.
- bakhy 12y agoRead my comment again, that's more or less exactly what I said. Except I do not see such a simple black and white picture. Taxi monopolies have formed to enable the drivers a better bargaining position. Uber is achieving lower prices by destroying this, and as we can see, once that is done, nothing stops them from turning the tables and driving the price too low for the drivers to survive. The drivers are not their employees, and so not their responsibility. That is the core of their model. I think they're a little more disruptive than needed, basically :) Taxi monopolies easily grow into a problem. They overprice the rides and stifle the market. But this can usually be sorted out through political action, through opening competition, all without automatically destroying all semblance of security for the workers.
- ghshephard 12y agoI would love to know if http://blog.uber.com/applepay http://blog.uber.com/applepay means that Uber won't be able to track who they are taking to various locations. That alone would be a big win for Apple Pay.
- teacup50 12y agoThat's not how Apple Pay works; other than using a proxy CC# and hiding your info from the actual sales clerk, Apple Pay isn't more private than magstripe cards — merchants can still identify you, and it actually adds another party to the transaction: Apple.
- thinkling 12y agoApple claim that they get no data about individual transactions, at least not in a way that can be tied to specific customers.
- teacup50 12y agoRead the claims more closely (or read the relevant emvco spec). They don't claim to receive no data, they only claim to not track you.
- ghshephard 12y agoHow does the merchant identify you? My understanding is that, unlike a credit card, you don't share your name with them during an Apple Pay transaction. Also, Apple is not involved in the transaction beyond selling you the hardware which hosts the secure element.
- teacup50 12y ago> My understanding is that, unlike a credit card, you don't share your name with them during an Apple Pay transaction. If you check the EMVco specs (they're a doozy! http://www.emvco.com/specifications.aspx?id=21 http://www.emvco.com/specifications.aspx?id=21), merchants still receive your name. The only thing that tokenization provides is a proxy card number. > Also, Apple is not involved in the transaction beyond selling you the hardware which hosts the secure element. That's not actually true; if you read the fine print (or the emvco specs), you'll note that they can track a lot more than they might claim to. https://www.apple.com/privacy/docs/iOS_Security_Guide_Oct_2014.pdf https://www.apple.com/privacy/docs/iOS_Security_Guide_Oct_20... They disclose up-front: "Apple may receive anonymous transaction information such as the approximate time and location of the transaction, which helps improve Apple Pay and other Apple products and services."
- ingenieros 12y agoYou know what I find the most disturbing about this whole story?? "He also sits on a board that advises the Department of Defense"
- anigbrowl 12y agoYeah, that jumped out at me also, and is likely to give the story legs considering the pushback against sexual assault in the military.
- dreamweapon 12y agoThe executive, Emil Michael, made the comments in a conversation he later said he believed was off the record. In a statement through Uber Monday evening, he said he regretted them and that they didn’t reflect his or the company’s views. They "don't reflect his or the company's views?" How can they not be 100% reflective of his views? And how can we possibly take anything said by anyone at the executive level at Uber seriously at this point?
- baxterross 12y agobecause his comments have been twisted out of control
- Edmontonian 12y agoThe most recent Pulitzer Prize winner for journalism (Glenn Greenwald) says journalism is an "adversarial" process. However, adversarial is by nature a two way street. Journalists who go digging into the lives of people and businesses need to be prepared for adversarial response. If I'm a business owner that's being investigated by a journalist, I want to find out the who, what, where, when and why. I am entitled to investigate the people who are investigating me. journalism startups are businesses. they make money by investigating businesses like uber. Uber is entitled to investigate in return
- mikeash 12y agoUber is not entitled to investigate by delving into private details of people, though. And just because Uber happens to hold that data doesn't mean they're entitled to grovel through it for whatever purpose they feel like. If a journalist gets into a fight with a hospital, should that hospital be entitled to use the journalists's private health records to fight back? I say, of course not. Uber is in the same position qualitatively. Of course, in the case of the hospital it's actually illegal while for Uber it's probably not, but that's just because the law on privacy is way behind the times.
- TheCowboy 12y agoTo what extent are you "entitled" to "investigate" into the personal lives of journalists and public critics? If your goal is not to intimidate, what purpose does it serve and accomplish? Freedom of the press is important and is part of the Constitution. Journalists can investigate a business even if you think they shouldn't. Looking into the financial ties of journalism is game. But the industry and business of journalism is not the same as someone's personal life, their sexual preferences, children, family, etc.
- just2n 12y agoTo what extent are you "entitled" to "investigate" into the personal lives of entrepreneurs and people building real value. If your goal is not to intimidate, attack, or slander, what purpose does it serve and accomplish? Freedom of speech and self publication is important and is part of the Constitution. Entrepreneurs can investigate shady journalists who seem to have a bias and who are crossing ethical lines even if you think they shouldn't. Looking into the financial ties of companies is game. But the industry and business is not the same as someone's personal life, their sexual preferences, children, family, etc.
- ascendantlogic 12y agoAs long as the valuation keeps going up, the VC's will keep making excuses and looking the other direction. Remember, profits make everything all better.
- giarc 12y agoI live in a city where Uber was/is trying to break in. Council has been very vocal that these actions by the Uber executive is harming their chances. I would say that their chances of being given approval is dwindling and they will lose this 1.3 million citizen market.
- wpietri 12y agoActually, Uber is about ethics in tech journalism.
- meepmorp 12y agoThank you for that.
- metaphorm 12y agoI think its abundantly clear at this point that Uber is an immoral company with a greed driven management team that has no ability whatever to properly think about the social consequences of their actions. Or worse still, perhaps they deliberately pursue malfeasance, as was suggested by the executive who made the comments discussed in this article.
- ssully 12y agoJust deleted uber from my phone and installed lyft. This kind of behavior is unacceptable.
- tedks 12y agoI hope all the people commenting with pitchforks in hand have also never said (or have been alleged to have said) anything at a private dinner between friends that could be construed in any way to be similar to these remarks.
- wpietri 12y agoThis was not a private dinner between friends.
- webXL 12y agoHere we go again, more Uber drama. The only reason why this is a story is the (pardon the term) disruption of a protected industry, and the misplaced attention on the supply-side. Consumers are awash in convenience and choice right now, but the media and the politicos protecting the industry are ignoring that and going after the biggest member of the disruption so that it can be controlled. I'm sure there are sleazy execs at Uber, but if the media pointed its glare at any other similar-sized company, I'm sure it would find them there, too. Uber may have more because it has grown so fast. It would behoove of them to start cleaning house so that this type of story doesn't kill the golden goose.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Thesaurus 12y agoI didn't know BuzzFeed was allowed on HN. What a fucking joke.
- softdev12 12y agoThe most interesting thing to me about all this is that the tech media is probably about 50 percent responsible for pushing out tech start-ups to the wider world. If you go back and look at the beginnings of companies like Twitter (blogged about by prominent bloggers) and Facebook (published by the Harvard student newspaper), the initial snowball effect to get these companies going is largely based on journalists pushing these startups to their readership. And now we have the case where a company that has successfully navigated the hardest part of the cycle (becoming a big enough snowball to be self-sustaining) that they can turn around and challenge the journalists. It's like a child who has grown up and now comes back to challenge the parent. Fascinating in an abstract general way.
- microcolonel 12y ago> A senior executive at Uber suggested that the company should consider hiring a team of opposition researchers to dig up dirt on its critics in the media — and specifically to spread details of the personal life of a female journalist who has criticized the company. Is it at all relevant that the journalist is female?
- ripb 12y agoIt's totally irrelevant to what happened but totally relevant to the current mainstream narrative of women versus men. It allows them to take something non-gendered and create an absolute shitstorm from it.
- microcolonel 12y ago> A senior executive at Uber suggested that the company should consider hiring a team of opposition researchers to dig up dirt on its critics in the media — and specifically to spread details of the personal life of a female journalist who has criticized the company. Is it at all relevant that the journalist is female?
- omouse 12y agoThe US government, FBI and NSA don't mind doing that, why should Uber and other companies obey the law if federal agencies refuse to? /devil's advocate.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- drivingmenuts 12y agoIf I say: "I wish that guy/girl would get exposed" - that's a pretty non-specific statement. You can laugh that one off and it can be spun all kinds of ways. If I say: "I should dig up dirt on that person" - that's much more specific, but not always. It's harder to ignore and it's far more difficult to put a just-kidding spin on it. If I say: "I should spend a million dollars and hire four researchers to dig up opposition research on this person to expose their private life" - that's pretty damn specific. You can't unsay that. There's no way to spin that that it doesn't sound like a threat, especially if it's known, or at least believed, that you have the resources and connections to pull that off. Michael may be a guy who was just spouting off in frustration without thinking first, which is fine - it happens from time to time. But he's also in the top tier of a very valuable company and he's paid to pay attention and be on his toes. And he wasn't. He then tried to laugh it off by saying "he doesn't think that way". Well, it came from somewhere in his brain. There weren't any flying monkeys dropping notions from the sky; no random inspiron from a long-dead galaxy just collided with a neuron and LOL I SEZ STUPID STUFF. He screwed up badly. He needs to be held to account for that and harshly, because that idea is out there now. It might not be acceptable now, but sooner or later, given enough repetition, it will become acceptable.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- cjensen 12y agoThe context was a CEO in front of multiple reporters. A CEO's words always matter; when spouted in front of reporters, there are no do-overs.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- downandout 12y agoWrong. The CEO didn't say this. If you're going to skewer a whole company over something stupid like this, at least get your facts straight.
- chrischen 12y agoA better idea is to reveal potential special interests or personal biases of the journalists, especially if it compromises their professional integrity.
- cseelus 12y agoPublicly considering such STASI tactics for me is the last nail in the coffin, I'll never use a product of this strange company. (I'm from Germany, maybe we are more sensitive to such threats)
- iblaine 12y agoPoke a bear with a hot stick and you might get bit. I don't see what the big deal is.
- crpatino 12y agoThis was closer to being growled at. "Getting bit" is more like the robber baron sending half-a-dozen of pinkertons to your home, and neither you nor your family is ever seen again. And the big deal is that is very much on the public interest to not see the days of the pinkertons come back again, so the bears have to be trained and get used to being poked at.
- cwkoss 12y agoI think this article is relevant context- Sarah Lacy is a professional troll: http://www.cnet.com/news/journalist-becomes-the-story-at-mark-zuckerberg-sxswi-keynote/ http://www.cnet.com/news/journalist-becomes-the-story-at-mar...
- peterjancelis 12y agoI think making comments this stupid as a SVP is a fireable offense and I can somewhat see how the "family" mention makes Sarah Lacy worried about her children, but I totally don't get where this gender angle is coming from in this story. I don't read any of that in the original comments by Emil Michael.
- xorcist 12y agoThere's been a number of negative articles about Google during the past years. Some for good reasons, some for bad. Some honest, some paid shills. Imagine Larry Page saying: We'll sift through whatever data we've got on you and see what dirt we can find. No need to imagine the threats against family. No need for any of the more nasty details. Just the basic premise, but in the setting of an established Silicon Valley company. Done yet? No. Because you couldn't. Because any serious CEO worth their salt simply wouldn't. And all those of you whose natural reponse is to defend these people, please imagine yourself doing it for Page as well. Would you, really?
- Dylan16807 12y agoIf someone high up at google or facebook threatened to sift through the data they have on me, I would be worried. If they said they would hire external investigators, I would not be more worried than if any random person was going to do so. Did I miss something, because I'm pretty sure this story is the latter scenario. They're both bad actions, but only one is an abuse of trust and/or resources.
- xorcist 12y agoBoth. The article talks about how he accessed the data they had on a journalist, without explicit persmission from the person in question. Not only is it not nice, it shouldn't even have been possible without logging this against a ticket number at the very least.
- hero454545 12y agoThis story is plummeting suspiciously fast from the HN front page...
- onewaystreet 12y agoIt was only on the front page because the mods put it there. Buzzfeed is a penalized site and this story is getting flagged. Normally it would be on page 10 by now. The mods can't hold it up forever, though, so now it's falling.
- dang 12y agoThis story has been on the front page for 24 hours.
- lettercarrier 12y agoWe used to laugh when our CEO/Head went to extremes to put customers first with things like creating a "Customer Bill or Rights." We thought it was overreaction after some glitch or dumb one-off call center rep violating PC correctness. But now I think Uber should get a transfusion. All rides free New Years Eve and Halloween. No ride will ever cost more than $X (should not be hard to figure out - with an * too) To show good faith, ride once, the next is on us (for x weekend). Publicly terminate knuckelheads ("Jimmy the Greek") [1] Establish & Invite consumer, safety and the driver community to form an oversight group to ensure Uber holds itself to community standards. My Luddite world has no idea what a Uber is, but they sure know how to ask and find out. New things to my Luds come from hearing human voices - asking neighbors/friends is still #1. Nothing out there now says "Uber has cleaned up its act" First impressions have to be disproven and last the longest. [1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WzB7IsmOegE http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WzB7IsmOegE
- general_failure 12y agohttp://pando.com/2014/11/17/the-moment-i-learned-just-how-far-uber-will-go-to-silence-journalists-and-attack-women/ http://pando.com/2014/11/17/the-moment-i-learned-just-how-fa... http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2014/11/18/sarah-lacy-uber-emil-michael-opposition-research-smear-campaign/19229117/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2014/11/18/sarah-lacy-ube... All this overreacting and exaggeration is getting to me. Such terrible writing and she really is going overboard with all this.
- baxterross 12y agoLet's call it like it is. Yellow journalists are going to stop at nothing to smear any company with a libertarian founder.
- jarnix 12y agoI won't use Uber (I live in Paris), because of what they did with Lyft, because some executive harassing a woman (story of yesterday on hn), because of this story as well. There are a lot of competitors who do not have their hands that dirty. I'm using Chauffeur Price here, never had to complain.
- imgabe 12y agoSo they would investigate the journalists's private lives and publish all their embarrassing details in order to cause drama and controversy to further their own goals. You mean like the media does with every public figure, ever? Like the media is doing with this exact story right now?
- johnsmith32 12y agoIt seems that most are commenting on why Uber executive shouldn't be doing this. But none has viewed this from Uber's perspective. If your startup was being threatened by a brown-nosing bonus-loving trigger-happy reporter, what are you going to do? Publish a press statement? Hire more reporter to spread positive propaganda? A cost-benefit analysis would show it is simply cheaper to hire a hitman to take her out. Before you argue with me over ethics and human rights, this isn't the first time a company has did this. Do a google on volkswagon and Glaxo-smith klein cost-benefit analysises and they are equally expedient. So why our society allows large corporations to trade capital for human lives while we condamn a startup for doing the exact same thing?!?
- jongraehl 12y agoAs wrong-footed as Uber appears lately, don't take buzzfeed's word for anything. Dishonest trash-talking + a financial conflict of interest. Headline-baiting 'journalists' trying to steal attention+emotion for profit w/ gossipy attacks do need to consider their own glass house, especially when their sole productive output is stirring up drama. Being agnostic on the Uber CEO's character (don't know him) I'd caution him to stop giving material to a nascent angry mob and those stoking it.
- Umn55 12y ago"I opt out at airports, I donate to the EFF, I don't use Uber or any other app that targets people's privacy and actively threatens the freedom of the press" Freedom of the press cannot exist under capitalism, who controls the hiring and firing and owns the organization controls the information.