7 ms·
Exercising but Gaining Weight
- moonka 12y ago>While this study didn’t track the women’s eating and movement habits away from the lab, it is likely that those who gained weight began eating more and moving less when they weren’t on the treadmills, “probably without meaning to,” Dr. Gaesser said. Without knowing the whole picture, it seems hard to draw any sort of meaningful conclusion. Weight loss is almost entirely diet-based.
- axlprose 12y agoCan someone please explain why this comment is getting downvoted? It is essentially saying the same thing as the current top 2 comments that exercise is not a terribly meaningful contributor to weight loss, and adds to the discussion that certain conclusions in the article may not be warranted given that context, using no inflammatory language. Yet it is almost invisible. What gives HN?
- tomhenderson 12y agoPeople often overeat when they start exercising, either because they're hungry from the exercise, or because they feel can indulge a bit as a reward. My view is that most people should ignore exercise and fix their diet first, only easing in to an exercise routine slowly once they start to see weight loss results.
- moonka 12y ago>My view is that most people should ignore exercise and fix their diet first, only easing in to an exercise routine slowly once they start to see weight loss results. Agreed. In the last few months, I've lost about 20 pounds via diet alone. I'm starting to incorporate exercise now, and it's a lot easier to keep going day after day since I can move easier, so I don't get discouraged as easily.
- teen 12y agoRunning on a treadmill for an hour is about 600 calories. Eating an extra snack before bed can easily be that. To be calorie deficient and lose weight, it is so much easier to eat less than to exercise more. On top of that, exercising more can stimulate your appetite... leading to over eating. Basically you just have to be vigilant with not eating too much. I don't think counting calories is important, but 3 small meals (by american standards) or 2 regular meals a day, with low carbs, no sugar, and low dairy, will drop you to normal proportions very quickly.
- phlosten 12y agoI made massive changes to my diet a few months ago, after being diagnosed with Type 2 Diabetes. The doctor said diet and exercise needed. Trying to keep it simple I didn't worry about the exercise, just changed the diet, the weight started falling off easily, as long as I ate regularly and kept my carbs to what was required. I started riding to work this week. I am so god damn hungry right now. I think if you are really needing weight loss you need your doctor involved. There is so much I have learned through having blood test results etc to work from. My tips if you are interested: * Cut out any added sugar. No sugar in coffee or whatever. Easy way to reduce energy intake. No more soft drink. * Have enough carbs each meal so your body hormones etc are getting stuff to work with. * Stay away from processed foods, keep out of those aisles. * Make exercise a normal part of life and skip the gym. Gyms are demotivational hell holes of despair. Climb the stairs at work, ride the bike, park further away, just go for a walk around the block, walk randomly around the city to explore.
- cschmidt 12y ago> * Have enough carbs each meal so your body hormones etc are getting stuff to work with. Your body doesn't actually need any carbs to function. It can run off of ketones rather than glucose. You might be interested to look into the keto diet, which works beautifully for people with diabetes. You eat low carb, but high fat. The FAQ of /r/keto on reddit is a good place to start.
- axlprose 12y ago
- dnautics 12y agothis is what I would have predicted from the description of the experimental setup. My understanding of human metabolism (which could be flawed, I'm a biochem PhD, not a nutrition PhD) For most people, regular aerobic exercise results in the body more regularly entering starvation mode and saving energy = storing fat. However, I suspect there are people with that signal defective, who can run like crazy and become thin as rails. For most of the rest of people, building muscle is a better strategy for losing weight.
- meepmorp 12y agoStarvation mode in the sense that you seem to intend is a myth: http://examine.com/faq/how-do-i-stay-out-of-starvation-mode.html http://examine.com/faq/how-do-i-stay-out-of-starvation-mode.... Probably. I'm not an expert.
- sytelus 12y agoAnyone with even a rudimentary training knows this fact: Exercise don't help you loose weight. Even the heavy routines burn minuscule amount of calories that would be compensated by just couple of slices of bread. Exercise helps you build cardio and/or muscle strengths which is very different than loosing weight. The only sure shot way of loosing weight is diet control. Just stop eating simple carbs (aka white floor/grain/corn stuff and sugars from non-natural sources) and you can drop weight and keep it that way.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Exercise don't help you loose weight. Even the heavy routines burn minuscule amount of calories that would be compensated by just couple of slices of bread. Exercise helps you build cardio and/or muscle strengths which is very different than loosing weight. Increased muscle mass produces increased resting metabolic rate -- exercise often isn't a short-term help to losing weight, but its a long term help. More importantly, "losing weight" is usually not the real objective, its a proxy measure for improving overall health and fitness, for which exercise is useful, even without weight loss.
- adventured 12y agoExercise can easily help you lose weight. Scenario: you weigh 300 pounds, your weight is fairly stabilized, and you have relatively little muscle and are mostly fat. You're going to lose a lot of weight just by adding muscle through exercise in that case. The added muscle will burn a lot more calories resting, and with a non-inflating calorie intake, your new burn rate from the new muscle and exercise will start eroding your weight. There, I just proved exercise can help you lose weight.
- marknutter 12y agoSo the ones who gained weight were the one who said to themselves "I can have this extra donut, I'm working out now". Fascinating stuff.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jacorreia 12y agoThis study shows a bit of what the general public really needs to understand about personal health: it's very hard to train multiple aspects of your fitness with only one type of activity. Doing cardio makes you better at cardio. Strength training makes you stronger. Diet and hypertrophy improves your body composition. You'll always hear people say "Oh your legs must be so strong from all those marathons you do." Entirely false, their cardio-vascular system is strong. I can virtually guarantee that any moderately dedicated powerlifter can squat more than a long-distance runner (form notwithstanding). Similarly, a marathoner's lean physique is a result of their diet, which they require in order to be successful at running, not because of their training. I really wish that more people would take the time to sit down, identify their fitness goals, and ensure that their lifestyle is focused towards achieving their goals. For most people, all this is taking a good look at your diet!
- rdtsc 12y agoPeople are ridiculously bad at estimating the caloric content of food they eat. We can see the volume of food, feel the weight, taste it but we cannot without practice and training easily guess how many calories it will be. Also people are just as bad at estimating how many calories they would burn by exercisng or walking. We've all heard it -- "I'll need to walk around the block after eating that piece of cheese cake" phrase. I've said it myself many times. Even though I know it will take hours and hours of walking around a very large block to burn it off so to speak. One more thing. There is a negative aspect of exercising in relation to weight that is often overlooked. Because of the pervious 2 points, people who do exercise will rationalize eating more food because "they will burn them off in 15 min on treadmill". Now I am using "calories" here in a simplistic way, but we had long discussions before about how it is not as simple as calories and calories out. It is bit more complicated -- hunger, hormones, insulin level, fat storage rates etc.
- SoftwareMaven 12y agoPeople are bad at estimating calories, but our bodies are really good at regulating them, if you feed it properly. The low fat diet advice has done horrendous things to people's metabolisms, leaving people insulin and leptin resistant. The insulin resistance disregulates the flow of fat through adipose membranes, favoring storage; the leptin resistance disregulates the appetite homeostasis that should regulate appetite, hunger, and weight. It can all be tracked back to the disproven diet heart hypothesis, and the fear of fat that ensued (and became enshrined like a religion).
- thisrod 12y agoFor the purpose of this study, "exercise" means "walked on treadmills ... three times per week for 30 minutes". I'd be cautious about extrapolating the results to more than homeopathic doses.
- mmastrac 12y agoI'll add my single datum here. I lost a bunch of weight using the Hacker's Diet [1] when I was in university. I've occasionally put myself back on it as I get older, but there are two things that I believe are true about the way that I personally lose weight: 1) Losing weight while exercising is tough. I usually choose diet or exercise at any given time (or just light exercise so I'm not completely unfit by the end of the diet). I've had poor luck with exercise to lose weight, but it is very effective for maintaining it. 2) Fasting at the start of the diet -- and only at the very beginning -- seems to be critical to my success at losing weight [2]. Perhaps this has something to do with gut bacteria, metabolism or some psychosomatic factors. I'm not sure, but I basically cannot lose weight without that start. As an aside, I've been very tempted to start an intermittent fast (even while not losing weight!) after seeing Michael Mosley's program on BBC a few years back. [3] [1] https://www.fourmilab.ch/hackdiet/www/hackdiet.html https://www.fourmilab.ch/hackdiet/www/hackdiet.html [2] https://www.fourmilab.ch/hackdiet/www/subsubsection1_3_3_0_3_4.html#SECTION0330340000000000000 https://www.fourmilab.ch/hackdiet/www/subsubsection1_3_3_0_3... [3] http://www.bbc.com/news/health-19112549 http://www.bbc.com/news/health-19112549
- stevebmark 12y agoExercise controls mainly muscle composition. Diet controls mainly fat composition. Exercising to lose weight is a stupid idea. Stop getting your health research from the news. Go read a book written by a doctor.