9 ms·
Eleven countries studied, one inescapable conclusion – the drug laws don’t work
- noonespecial 12y agoI suspect they work just fine, its what they are actually supposed to do that most people are unclear on. I'm not quite tin hat enough to think that they were actually created for these purposes, but I do think they've stabilized on a sub-optimal local maximum where the general populace is complacent because they feel like "something was done" about those awful (counterculture) drugs and they laws themselves have become broadly useful to the political class for all sorts of reasons that have nothing at all to do with the reality of drug use on the street. So here we sit. It will take substantial political force to budge off this local maximum point.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 12y agoExactly: article: there is no direct link between being “tough on drugs” and tackling the problem. Well, what problem is that? If we define the problem as "property crime and collateral violence", then those tough-on-drugs laws directly cause the problem, beyond the shadow of any doubt. That is the problem that anyone reasonable cares about, not what "immoral" things other people are doing to their bodies.
- zo1 12y agoIt's only a problem so long as it's framed with the question of "should, and can the state fix X". If, however, you state it in state-free terms such as "is there anything wrong with an individual stranger potentially harming his/herself?" then the answer is pretty obvious. It's much harder to justify things against an individual without the state. E.g. "Those bums down the street repeatedly use drugs, and I think that will lead to them damaging my property / harming me. I'll go ahead and hire some security guards to prevent them from taking drugs, or beating them up if we find out they have drugs on them." Disclaimer: I'm an anarcho-capitalist.
- boyaka 12y agoI've been having similar thoughts about the purposes behind the prohibition being misunderstood. There are many effects that the war on drugs is having, and the people that are executing the process are more aware than any of us what those effects are. As a clueless civilian, I have been attempting to come up with some completely conjectural ideas about what those might be: - Strengthen law enforcement through constant practice, and provide revenue to supporting companies - Siphon money from one industry (drug trade) to help support the government and therefore support other industries that it feels are more beneficial to society - Stigmatize unproductive habits, conditioning society to more productive/controlled behavior, incarcerating individuals who resist to make the society seem more productive overall I'm sure there are many intentions that are well known that might overlap with what I'm suggesting, but I think the main point is that the war on drugs is not for the purpose that most people assume: to eliminate drugs from society. I think in a lot of ways it intentionally has the opposite effect. Also I think if society would have tolerated alcohol prohibition that the government would have been happy to keep that going as well for similar reasons.
- rayiner 12y ago> Also I think if society would have tolerated alcohol prohibition that the government would have been happy to keep that going as well for similar reasons. See my comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8542155 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8542155. In fact, at the time prohibition was proposed, alcohol taxes made up fully 1/3 of federal revenue. The money and moneyed interests were aligned against prohibition, not for it. I think a lot of people look for ways to get around the fact that when you give people self-determination as a group, they might vote for things you don't like with no nefarious undertones in play. The simplest explanation is this one: I don't vote, my mom does. There are more puritanical people who simply don't want to live in a society that condones drug use than the opposite. It's just like how when people in arab countries got the opportunity to vote, they voted-in conservative Islamic governments. Sure they are opportunists taking advantage of those tendencies, but at the end of the day, you have to grapple with the real fact that people have ideas about what their societies should look like, and democracy means that they get to carry those ideas into fruition.
- 001sky 12y agoIn ths US, drugs are basically the opiate of the masses. In particular, minorities. The drug laws are basically the rich white people saying: heads I win, tails you lose. As such, nothing will change. Nobody runs faster from a school with minority over-represenatation faster than a (white, affluent) liberal in an expensive zip-code.
- jacquesm 12y agoDrugs are not opiates, opiates are drugs.
- JetSpiegel 12y agoThe parent was quoting Marx, come on!
- adventured 12y agoI think you're clearly wrong. The 'war on drugs' is coming to an end right now. It's almost universally recognized as a failure. The majority of Americans have decided it needs to end, and as such it is ending. Obama has ordered his DOJ to stand down. The momentum that is already underway cannot be stopped. At this point it's merely a matter of the time it takes for every state to tumble into line, one after another. And as the US is moving rapidly toward that, the rest of the world is as well, and that lock-step will make sure there can be no reversal. So the US goes, the rest of the world will quickly follow, since it was the US war on drugs that was largely responsible for pushing the existing drug criminalization system globally. Every conservative I know these days supports either legalization or decriminalization, having come to the understanding that the approach that has been used for 40 years does not work. You can celebrate. It's an early, but great victory for justice and liberty.
- 001sky 12y agoNo, i'm clearly reading the data. You're simply speculating. The drugs laws are widely used as pretexts for minority supression. The issue being discussed is the broader sociological function of the drugs laws: namely, to keep the elites in power, to elevate the value of their real-estate, and to provide a weak negotiating position for the under-priveledged in the labour market. The same people that want to run away from the kids of black people are the same as those that want to throw the parents in jail (for petty drug offences and trivial parole violations). http://www.businessinsider.com/kent-brewster-analyzes-atherton-police-blotter-2013-8 http://www.businessinsider.com/kent-brewster-analyzes-athert... http://paloaltofreepress.com/living-in-palo-alto-while-black/ http://paloaltofreepress.com/living-in-palo-alto-while-black... http://www.insidebayarea.com/dailyreview/localnews/ci_11034532?source=rss http://www.insidebayarea.com/dailyreview/localnews/ci_110345... Today, African-Americans are also more likely to spend time in prison for drug related offenses than their white counterparts. According to the Sentencing Project, African-Americans make up 12% of the nation’s drug users, but represent 34% of those arrested for drug offenses, and 45% of those in state prison for such offense as of 2005. Of course, there's plenty of white collar drug abuse running rampant in high-rent neigborhoods. To wit: http://dealbreaker.com/2014/10/jefferies-exec-sage-kelly-employs-unorthodox-approach-for-landing-clients/ http://dealbreaker.com/2014/10/jefferies-exec-sage-kelly-emp... Clearly there is a demand for low-level discretionary powers that can serve the social-sorting priorities of those with wealth and power. The drug laws fill those roles today, and whether we like it or not, there seems to be "a demand" that they serve for some people well beyond their "literal" or statuatory meaning.
- baddox 12y ago> I'm not quite tin hat enough to think that they were actually created for these purposes There doesn't have to be just one purpose. I think a lot of supposedly progressive legislation comes out of a union between genuine well-intended progressives and the special interest groups which will benefit from the actual version of the progressive legislation that ends up getting passed.
- jpmcglone 12y agoI wish Singapore was part of the study. I think generally, drug laws do not 'work' (by work I mean, it doesn't stop people from doing drugs and in many ways it probably gets them into situations to commit crimes not related to drugs), but I'm curious how much the study would have been thrown off by Singapore's results.
- jsnk 12y agoI think Singapore honestly remains as a serious anomaly to political science. Defacto one party government with extremely illiberal policies and yet the people are happier, more educated and more well off than many other countries that have liberal democracies. What's further more surprising is that it remains very multiethnic and yet the people get along with others just fine unlike other parts of the world.
- drcross 12y agoI have not been to Singapore (but I have been to Hong Kong which I think is similar) but I think the impression is that small city states operate more like those mentioned in Cryptonomicon, specifically, you agree to abide by their rules when you enter the city. If you dont like them you are free to leave. This concept that you don't actually own the place you live but are more a temporary citizen makes you more flexible to bend to their rules.
- jpatokal 12y agoActually, a rather prominent study a while back found that Singapore is the least happy wealthy country on the planet, losing out to eg. Iraq, Haiti, Afghanistan, and Syria. http://edition.cnn.com/2012/12/21/world/asia/singapore-least-happy/ http://edition.cnn.com/2012/12/21/world/asia/singapore-least... Singapore is also multiethnic, but it's quite resolutely not a melting pot. The heavy hand of the government is keeping a lid on a lot of tensions, not all of them obvious to the casual observer (Singapore-born Chinese vs mainland Chinese, etc). Last and not least, Singapore's wealth distribution is extremely unequal. It scores well on raw GDP per capita etc, but the poorer parts of society compete directly with foreign labor working in slave-like conditions(+), and thus work extremely hard for paltry salaries. (+) Quite literally, especially in the case of maids: it's not uncommon for them to be on duty 24/7/365, not allowed means of communication and physically locked inside the home when their masters are away.
- click170 12y agoDrug laws aren't supposed to stop people from using drugs, and that hasn't been the goal for a while now. The goal is to give them a reason to request military-grade toys, and to give them a "reason" to use said military toys despite not being in a war zone. Their thinking (perhaps correctly) is that if they don't use it, they'll lose it. And this is before we consider lobbying of the for-profit prisons who are literally trying to have innocent people thrown in jail. (0) (0) http://blogs.wsj.com/law/2011/02/22/judge-found-guilty-in-cash-for-kids-case-mother-of-child-not-pleased/ http://blogs.wsj.com/law/2011/02/22/judge-found-guilty-in-ca... Edit: Corrected the link, my mistake.
- jiggy2011 12y agoFWIW this article is about the UK where we don't usually have these issues.
- aidos 12y agoYou were downvoted for this an I'd like to hear the reason why. Ignoring the UK / US argument, it does feel like there's a lot of effort pumped into "fighting" drugs when it's fairly obvious it doesn't do anything to stop drug use. Which does call into question the many people who have full time jobs analysing and enforcing this work.
- adventured 12y agoAs though the government's prison system isn't for profit. Of course it is. That's exactly what all those jobs, tax dollars, and slave labor represent. The for-profit prisons are nothing compared to the money being generated by the government in "non-profit" prisons. It's a small fraction of the prison system in the US. The government puts innocent people in jail in numbers radically greater than the for-profit prison system; this spans everything from dirty cops, dirty prosecutors, dirty judges, and the government's drug war - and the government has been doing it to the tune of millions of innocent people put in prison over decades. And yet somehow the tiny corporate prison system is the big concern, it's laughable.
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoI am genuinely interested in knowing how we go from here to there. Alcohol for example after prohibition - what was the transition from illegal to legal like. Did more people drink suddenly? What organisations sprang up to legally manufacture and distribute? Where the mafia still involved? Saying "decriminalise" is all good - but if at any point in the supply chain we dip into the underground market we shall not escape the violence and control of crime. So are there plans for movin from prohibition to open market?
- drdeca 12y agoOne idea that I have not thought through well, and don't know what the consequences would be, would be to instead of possession of sale of the drugs being illegal, making it so that, for some collection of other crimes, if the crime was committed in a way related to the drug, the penalty for the crime would be greater. The idea I was thinking is that this would create a disincentive to have the crimes and the drugs related, and might cut down on "drug crime" more than just removing the ban on the drugs? I believe I've seen some say that even where a drug is legalize, there still remains a black market for that drug in that situation in order to avoid taxes on that drug. If tax avoidance had a greater fine if caught if money from (non medicinal) drugs was involved, would that perhaps discourage sellers from not paying taxes on the income, and as a result reducing the black market type stuff? I don't know. I am not saying that I support this idea, its just an idea I thought was interesting. I don't know what one would reasonably/realistically expect the results to be. Does anyone have any ideas as to what results would result from such a law?
- aidos 12y agoCountries, like Portugal have had a lot of success with just changing the issue from a criminal issue to a health issue with regard to possession. If you're caught with quantities that imply you're dealing you still end up in trouble. I'd imagine that if you allowed sanctioned selling of drugs you'd create a fair market and crime around it would quickly vanish. Unfortunately we live in a world where we may never see an experiment like that come to fruition.
- deleted 12y ago
- cnp 12y agoI believe the very very first step is to move certain drugs out of Schedule I and into proper categories that are consistent with science, thereby freeing doctors and researchers to study --and subsequently, destigmatize-- proper medicinal use. MDMA holds great potential in treating PTSD; Psychedelics with addiction and depression, and so on. Once this step is made I feel a proper, less fear-based discussion can be had regarding the dangers of recreational use and abuse.
- rhizome 12y agoAs a matter of fact, the scheduling of cannabis is under the gun right now: http://blog.sfgate.com/smellthetruth/2014/10/30/tables-turned-government-prosecutors-forced-to-defend-pot-prohibition-in-federal-court-thursday/ http://blog.sfgate.com/smellthetruth/2014/10/30/tables-turne... Some good history in there. Note the circular benefit to law enforcement: Schedule I prevents testing for medicinal qualities, so the government gets to try arguing that it can't be a medicine because it's not FDA approved. These people are the glue that hold the gears of progress together.
- cnp 12y agoExactly. Once medicinal qualities can be explored further the "Reefer Madness" that the country has endured for the past fifty years can be toned down. By understanding what we consume we are effectively reducing fear, and by reducing fear, undue harsh penalties can be understood to be what they are -- an overreaction. Its only a matter of time, but I feel for those millions who have been jailed, and continue to be jailed, during the debate.
- 54hgfhjhg 12y agoHow does this even make sense? Japan has a "zero tolerance policy" on drugs and one of the lowest drug related death rates in the world (extremely lower than decriminalized Portugal). http://www.worldlifeexpectancy.com/cause-of-death/drug-use/by-country/ http://www.worldlifeexpectancy.com/cause-of-death/drug-use/b... And guess what? Singapore has even tougher drug laws than Japan and a lower drug related death rate than Japan. What am I missing here?
- josu 12y agoJapan could just be an outlier.
- 54hgfhjhg 12y agoNot exactly. There's also Singapore, Saudi Arabia, Vietnam, Malaysia, China (all countries with extremely strict drug laws and far lower drug related death rates than Portugal)
- smoe 12y agoAccording to this list, Colombia has fewer drug related deaths than any of the countries you mentioned, Sierra Leone about the same as Japan and the Netherlands is below Saudi Arabia. I can't find the source of this list or any comparable ranking. But except for some countries, this lists seems completely random to me or is using not comparable numbers from each countries in/official statistics
- pessimizer 12y agohttp://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/asia/executions-hit-new-high-in-chinas-drugs-war-712544.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/asia/executions-hit-... This is about 72 people being executed in a single week in China for drug offenses. http://www.aljazeera.com/news/middleeast/2014/08/saudi-beheads-four-men-smuggling-drugs-2014818184317907443.html http://www.aljazeera.com/news/middleeast/2014/08/saudi-behea... The question is whether shooting, beheading, or letting people die in prison for selling or doing drugs counts as a drug death. http://www.ihra.net/files/2010/07/09/IHRA_DeathPenaltyReport_Web.pdf http://www.ihra.net/files/2010/07/09/IHRA_DeathPenaltyReport...
- rayiner 12y agoThere's a really good mini-series on PBS called "Prohibition" that gave me a totally new perspective on the Drug War: http://www.pbs.org/kenburns/prohibition http://www.pbs.org/kenburns/prohibition. The ban of alcohol in the United States was actually a triumph of democracy over moneyed interests and the government. At the time, alcohol manufacturers had tremendous political power, and excise taxes on alcohol made up about 1/3 of federal revenue. What made prohibition pass legislatures around the country was a concerted effort by devoted constituencies: Christians and women. Indeed, one of the primary drivers of women's suffrage in the United States was prohibition--alcohol was seen by many leading suffragists as being at the root of social ills like domestic violence. One of the most interesting charts I've seen with regards to the modern drug war is this one: http://www.people-press.org/2013/04/04/majority-now-supports-legalizing-marijuana http://www.people-press.org/2013/04/04/majority-now-supports.... My recollection of childhood, of school assemblies with adults shrieking "Just Say No!" wasn't wrong. When I was a kid in the early 1990's, the popular position was in favor of keeping marijuana illegal by an almost 80-20 margin. This is a country that couldn't agree on anything (in 1992, they voted for Bill Clinton over George Bush by a 43-37 margin), yet they almost all agreed that marijuana (we're not even talking about harder drugs) should be illegal.
- gizmo686 12y agoI wouldn't call prohibition a triumph of democracy; just a different kind of failure mode for democracy. There was a relative minority of the population that wanted prohibition and were able to form a very effective "lobbying" effort, otherwise known as destroy any candidate who was against prohibition in the primaries. It is the same type of thing we see today in issues such as gun control, where we have massive popular support for one side of the issue (increased background checks), but it is still politically dangerous to pursue it because of a powerful lobby.
- 001sky 12y agohttp://www.gallup.com/poll/179045/less-half-americans-support-stricter-gun-laws.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/179045/less-half-americans-suppor...
- obviouslygreen 12y agoInescapable? Sure, if you ignore sample size. There aren't enough countries period, and I don't think they're all similar enough in meaningful ways, for any subset to be considered a representative sample for just about anything. I don't know enough about the debate to form an educated opinion one way or the other, I just can't stand hyperbole like this, especially when the underlying assumptions are so fundamentally flawed. Edit: And over all of eight months. Wow, yeah, now I'm convinced...
- spacemanmatt 12y agoThe American prohibition is working exactly as intended.
- nraynaud 12y agoI'm wondering: did we measure thievery law against drug law? Do law against theft work better than laws against drug, and would there be a call for repeal if that was not the case? I'm ok with changing the laws on drugs if it's good for society, but I want an honest assessment, not pure advocacy (and well, I don't smoke pot, but I drink beer, and I understand that people who smoke pot have a right to freedom as much as me).
- mheiler 12y agoMaking drugs legally available in pharmacies would lead to: (1) organised crime looses a large chunk of its business, (2) no need for dealers to advertise to new users, they won't get the business anyways, (3) drugs would have medical-grade quality control and likely be cheaper than on the black market, (4) drugs can be taxed and this money can go into prevention and medical care, (5) users are less likely to need to commit crimes to support their habit, (6) resources in law enforcement get freed for other things. The ethical question is if drug use would go up and thus a legalise-drugs policy would be guilty of leading people down a bad and potentially deadly path. If the article is right that won't be so.
- DanBC 12y agoOrganised crime would target the legal-drug supply chain. Counterfeit medication making its way into legitimate supplies is already a problem. When you tax something you create a space for the illicit market. See the UK for one example where very many cigarettes are counterfeit. And criminal gangs don't just sell real but untaxed product; they produce counterfeit product which can be more dangerous than the actual product. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-sussex-16786358 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-sussex-16786358 (I am strongly in favour of decriminalising all drugs)
- waterhouse 12y agoI think there's already a problem with low-quality, impure product being sold on the street w.r.t. illegal drugs. If the drugs were legalized, people would at least have the alternative of buying them legally from a large drug store with a reputation to protect. I imagine the problem you describe would not get worse under legalization. (Found one source on street drug purity: http://www.drugscope.org.uk/resources/faqs/faqpages/how-pure-are-street-drugs http://www.drugscope.org.uk/resources/faqs/faqpages/how-pure...)
- DanBC 12y agoThat's a great point: I would much rather buy 5% amphetamine 95% sugar from a licensed seller than whatever the hell I'm getting on the street. While contamination with rat poison is mostly a myth contamination can produce nasty results. Anthrax in injecting heroin users: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-18981196 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-18981196 Glass microbeads in cannabis: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/staffordshire/6386311.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/staffordshire/638...
- miguelrochefort 12y agoLaws don't work.
- camelite 12y agoIt might be true they don't work but do we really want the likes of Big Heroin, Big Cocaine and Big Marijuana like we have Big Tobacco? That would be a disaster. I think it would have to be totally government run to avoid that extreme danger. I wouldn't even want it to be possible for the government to get any tax revenue from it. Perhaps all the profits could go to an addiction prevention charity. Probably politically impossible though.
- kaeluka 12y agoWhat's wrong about state run/controlled? Just like you control pharmacies.
- privong 12y ago> It might be true they don't work but do we really want the likes of Big Heroin, Big Cocaine and Big Marijuana like we have Big Tobacco? That would certainly be better than what we have now. Big Tobacco does not kill people in turf wars over who gets to sell where, so I think Big Heroin would be an improvement over cartels and gangs. Maybe it is not the perfect solution, but Big Cocaine is likely going to be better than warring black market factions. An issue with the government running it or taxing it like crazy is that behavior can still support a black market due to artificially high prices. There's a black market for cigarettes in NYC[0], driven by the high taxes. The government running things is not a silver bullet. [0] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/04/03/cigarette-smuggling-new-york-_n_5041823.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/04/03/cigarette-smuggling...
- sigzero 12y ago"Portugal decriminalised drugs. Results? Use by teens doubled in a decade with nearly a fifth of 15 and 16-year-olds using drugs." Laws might not work but there has to be some kind of strict control mechanism in place.
- JabavuAdams 12y agoIs it that the drug laws don't work, or like so many things, that people don't understand the incentive structures? They're obviously working for many groups. They only don't work if we take the goal of the drug war at face value.