8 ms·
Where Did Time Come From, and Why Does It Seem to Flow?
- madeofpalk 12y agoMaybe time's just a construct of human perception, an illusion created by...
- bkeroack 12y agoNot to plug them or anything, but I found this course on time, entropy, cosmology, etc. absolutely fascinating: http://www.thegreatcourses.com/courses/mysteries-of-modern-physics-time.html http://www.thegreatcourses.com/courses/mysteries-of-modern-p... I kind of suffered through Physics in undergrad but this makes me wish I took more as an elective.
- frozenport 12y agoThe flow of time is an illusion, and I don’t know very many scientists and philosophers who would disagree with that, to be perfectly honest. Oh humbug! I have seen many proofs that rely on time going in a particular direction. For example, when solving the wave equation for electromagnetics it it is customary to discard anticausal solutions.
- lordnacho 12y agoJust like with control systems.
- noobermin 12y agoI'm not sure what he means by "flow of time" but I don't think he meant what you argued against. I think he's arguing against the notion that time is like some sort of continuum like a river, or like an axis on a map.
- zorbo 12y agoI got the same impression. People are assuming that by 'flow' he means uni-directional, as in the arrow of time. He is talking about the fact that 'flow' semantically implies something that moves, but movement itself requires time. So to say that time flows would be circular reasoning.
- HCIdivision17 12y agoTo be sure, we also typically throw away imaginary roots when factoring polynomials, since they'd represent nonphysical solutions. But the imaginary bits do come in handy for, well, nonphysical solutions, like measuring phase angle. So while I tend to side with you that the philosophy bit is probably unnecessary, I would contend that there may be surprising usefulness in the nonsense solutions (or they're just nonsense; it's hard to tell looking at the future work that hasn't been done yet).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rprospero 12y agoAs I understood the article, he's neatly sidestepped most of those proofs with his definition of "the flow of time". He agrees that certain properties are associated with their direction along the time axis (e.g. entropy increase in the futureward direction, memories are only available of pastward events). Is suspect that he would also argue that throwing out the anti-causal solutions to the wave equation is nothing more that customary, and that Merlin and Chris Nolan would customarily discard causal solutions and keep only the anti-causal ones. What was frustrating for me was that he didn't seem define "the flow of time". I would have defined it as the idea that the universe is not translation invariant along the axis measured by clocks. The truth of that statement is practically tautological, as he already agreed that clocks do measure intervals and that measurement inherently breaks the translation symmetry. Then again, cosmology isn't my field so maybe I'm missing something.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 12y agoThat's the direction of time, which is different from time having an actual "flow" or not.
- pmoriarty 12y ago"Suppose I stand up, twirl around a few times, and stop. Then I have the overwhelming impression that the entire universe is rotating. I feel it to be rotating—of course I know it’s not." According to relativity, isn't the view that the universe is rotating just as valid as the view that you are rotating? It all depends on your perspective, and there is no privileged (absolute) vantage point or perspective. Isn't that so? And if it is so, how can this physicist be ignorant of this? [Update: Oops. I missed the "and stop" bit. That's what I get for reading HN while I'm half asleep. Sorry!]
- rlpb 12y agoRelativity doesn't apply to acceleration. If there were two bodies in the universe, and one accelerated away from the other, it doesn't depend on perspective. Each body is capable of independently determining whether it was the one accelerating, and both would come to the same conclusion. The same applies to rotation. Accelerometers placed on my floor and on my body will detect the difference, and both will agree.
- JacobAldridge 12y agoMy interpretation of that quote is that he is referring to his impression after he stops. That's why he specifically references the stopping. You may be familiar with the experience - twirl around for a little bit then stop, and you will feel like the world ("entire universe"?) is still spinning. Even though it's not. Of course, I may be ignorant of his actual intent.
- rprospero 12y agoSpecial relativity says that there is no privileged perspective with respect to linear velocity, but general relativity showed that rotating reference frames are different, since one frame sees a centripetal forces while the other frames sees a centrifugal/gravitational force. To put it differently, if I pass someone on the train moving at constant velocity, there's no experiment that I can perform which proves that I'm moving while the other person is standing still, or vice versa. However, if I'm in a centrifuge, instead of on a train, then I can figure out which one of us is moving by measuring who is pressed up against the wall and making funny faces.
- sgarrity 12y agoI can't quite get a feel for the background and slant of some of these new web-only publications. I'm thinking of nautil.us and aeon.co in particular. They are science-focused, but lean toward philosophical topics. I can't figure out if they are reputable sources that dabble in more abstract concepts, or if they are some kind of pseudo-science platform for crazy founders.
- gpvos 12y agoI think they're general-interest popular science magazines, with indeed a bit of an abstract slant.
- nautilus 12y agoI'm the "crazy" founder of Nautilus. We are a science magazine, with a multidisciplinary approach. We want to explore each monthly issue topic from disciplines within and outside the sciences, like philosophy. But we are mostly about telling good stories....science with a literary voice.
- tedks 12y agoAeon is overtly anti-scientific in all the articles from it I've read. The trend tends to be to take something scientific, like cognitive biases or the Milgram experiments, use some postmodernist device like Freudian literary criticism or political theory to critique the science, and then conclude that the factual reality is not in favor of the scientific evidence. I think it's just generic post-modernism.
- aaronharnly 12y agoJust to note -- Nautilus is also a print publication! I have their substantial (nearly 200 pages), beautiful (simple and effective layout, thick glossy pages), and fascinating Fall 2014 issue on the table in front of me. I've made a conscious effort to read more physical books lately, because tablets and even Kindle holds too many temptations for my distractable self. When I'm not quite in a book mood, it turns out that a high-quality periodical like Nautilus is still very wonderful, even in our webby world.
- Xeoncross 12y agoDoes time exist outside of space/matter? Isn't time (like darkness) merely a description of a state of space / matter? It was/wasn't here, now it's here?
- mkempe 12y agoTime, like space, is a relational concept -- e.g. the motion of an entity relative to the motion of another, and the position of an entity relative to that of another. Observe that we measure time in terms of the repetitive motion of chosen entities.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoBut very cold entities - almost not moving. The latest 'atomic' clock uses "spin-polarized, ultracold atomic ytterbium". Its not the particle motion per se that's being measured; its fields around the particle, right? Not at all relative motion.
- mkempe 12y agoYes, these electronic transitions are a form of motion, too. Change is not limited to mechanics.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoSure; but to define time as motion, and motion as time, is circular and not very useful. It doesn't explain anything.
- jafaku 12y agoAren't these fields thought to be even smaller particles? Like the hypothetical graviton. So everything could be made of particles, even forces like gravity.
- pmoriarty 12y ago"Of course events in the world follow a directional sequence. Drop an egg on the floor and it breaks. You don’t see eggs assembling themselves." The operative phrase here being "you don't see". Of course, seeing is a matter of perception and perspective. It could very well be that time is flowing "backwards" and eggs are in fact reassembling themselves, but we are just perceiving time in reverse. You know, when I hear physicists try to tackle philosophical problems, it's usually kind of embarrassing. These guys are rarely trained in philosophy and are out of their depth. As Feinman famously said to his own students, "Shut up and calculate." I wish more physicists would follow his advice, and leave philosophy to philosophers.
- MadManE 12y agoShame on you. Nobody should be discouraged from trying to dabble in things that aren't their field. Having the background of being extremely well-trained in one field gives a different perspective than the typical "echo-chamber" of the elite in any specialty. If you know something they don't, why not try to start a dialog instead of criticizing and dismissing?
- JBiserkov 12y agoI second that. Paul Graham wrote about this in "How to do philosophy". http://www.paulgraham.com/philosophy.html http://www.paulgraham.com/philosophy.html
- jafaku 12y agoThat was a great reading, thanks.
- pmoriarty 12y agoPerhaps I'm being too harsh, but I only criticize because they're often given a soapbox (such as in this article) due to the perception that they are specially endowed with the power of "explaining how the world is" to us mere mortals. Well, that wouldn't be so bad if they stuck to explaining the results of their experiments, but when they stray from that on to philosophical subjects, they're really no more suited to talking about that than any other non-philosophically trained layman. It might help if they toned down the rhetoric a bit and make it clear that they're speaking about something that they have no training in. On the other hand, I suppose I should be grateful that they're exposing the general public to ideas they might not have otherwise thought about, even if they do so clumsily and their conclusions are highly suspect.
- igammarays 12y agoWhere it’s particularly striking of course is when people respond appropriately much faster than the speed of thought. You need only think of a piano player or a tennis player to see that the impression that they are making a conscious decision—“that ball is coming in this direction; I’d better move over here and hit it”—couldn’t possibly be. If it isn't conscious thought and motor signals, then what is it?
- Xeoncross 12y agoWe might assume it is faster than the speed of thought. Our mind works with and without our help. The same as our breathing. For example, our mind processes thousands (or millions) of signals coming from our senses without us needing to "think" about it.
- coldtea 12y agoThis dichotomy implies a dualism, as if there's a clear cut "I" and then there's "my mind". In fact, our mind is us, and it working 'without us knowing' is just 'it working without verbalization of our thoughts' which is a different thing I'd say.
- wodenokoto 12y agoIn conscience thoughts and motor signals. I think the point is, that after the match, the player can be asked "what went through you head when..." And they will answer as if during the game they made a conscience judgement of the entire situation.
- cjcole 12y agoAnd when people are asked "what do you think of band X" for an X which does not exist, they may answer you as if X existed. And later they may even forget that they were fabricating and come to believe it themselves. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8519764 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8519764 ("We Are All Confident Idiots") Memory is reconstructive. Memory is aspirational. Memory is an evolutionary adaptation. Memory is lossy and iterative. Memory is an unconscious advantage-seeking collaborator. People are (for whatever reasons) given more credit for conscious decisions than for unconscious reflexes, so it is in their interest to make it seem as if their actions were under conscious control. So memory does that for them.
- ragecore 12y ago"For example, there are famous experiments in which people apparently make free decisions at certain moments and yet it’s found that the decision was actually made a little bit earlier, but their own perception of time and their actions within time have been sort of edited after the event" This would also be the only way to simulate consciousness in AI. Makes total sense. We're AI.
- salimmadjd 12y agoThe question that's always in my mind is if the perception of the flow of time is really just entropy. As long as state A is different than state B we have a perception of time.
- lucio 12y agoI concur. But not just for entropy, for all movements. Time is a human construction to order sequences of events. All our "time" measures are based on cyclics movements. Make yourself a question, if ALL movement stop (include atoms), will time pass? will the arrow of time advance?
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoSure. In a cold vacuum with no atoms at all, those conditions are satisfied (no movement of any kind). But the vacuum continues to generate particle pairs and annihilate them; EM radiation continues to propagate. All on a strict clock.
- lucio 12y agoif radiation propagate, there are movement. Imagine if even particle generation and radiation propagation stops.
- wyager 12y agoYour premise doesn't make any sense. Those things cannot possibly occur. It is generally not useful to consider the consequence of falsehoods.
- dllthomas 12y agoIt is often useful to consider the consequence falsehoods. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thought_experiment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thought_experiment I think this one runs some risk of begging the question, though, so unless we make it significantly more precise we're unlikely to get anything useful out of it.
- skywhopper 12y agoI'm confused why they spent so much time on the idiom of "flowing" time. It doesn't literally feel like it's "flowing", that's just a figure of speech, a metaphor for the fact that in daily life we don't have control over its direction. While the implications and meaning of time in a cosmological sense are certainly interesting, the piece's angle of debunking naive common-sense views of time is a bit too aggressive. In daily life, the common-sense view of time is perfectly rational. Perhaps the audience is physics grad students, I dunno.
- coldtea 12y ago>It doesn't literally feel like it's "flowing", that's just a figure of speech, a metaphor for the fact that in daily life we don't have control over its direction. Huh? The flow of time, and "time passing" is the most universal and common understanding (and feeling) of time.
- skywhopper 12y agoYes, these are common metaphors. They do not describe the actual perceptual experience of the passage of time. To get hung up on what metaphors people use to describe something utterly intangible is silly.
- dominotw 12y agoI highly recommend this BBC documentary Illusion of Time non youtube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4BjGWLJNPcA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4BjGWLJNPcA
- Shaytown 12y agoI found this BBC documentary to be such an engaging piece. It challenges our perception of time. It is difficult to reconcile it with everyday demands of referring to a clock to guide our progression through the day. I highly recommend this documentary as well. Thanks for posting it, I will be listening to it again today.
- talles 12y agoAnyone else kept remembering H. G. Well's The Time Machine while reading the article?
- coldtea 12y agoThe only connection is they both talk about time -- which the article shares with 100,000 other time travel stories.
- xioxox 12y agoWhen you talk about what is the rate of a clock, say, near the surface of a black hole, it’s going to be quite different from the rate of a clock here on Earth. So there isn’t even a common time in the entire universe. Well, isn't there a common time for the entire universe? If we ignore being near massive objects, then observers travelling with the expansion of the universe - i.e. those those who don't see a dipole in the cosmic microwave background (CMB) - then the redshift of the CMB acts as a kind of clock. With the usual cosmological assumptions of isotropy and homogeneity, then there's a big clock for everyone to use.
- zorbo 12y agoI think everybody here is trying way too hard to apply advanced physics to what basically amounts to nothing more than a fluff philosophy article.
- robotic 12y agoI read the book and watched the documentary, "The Fabric of the Cosmos" by Brian Greene. He gave a good explanation of time. Right before the big bang, the universe was in a 'perfectly' ordered state. Since the big bang the universe has become less and less 'perfect'. What we think of as Time is really just things getting less and less organized. [1] http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000XUDGV2?btkr=1 http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000XUDGV2?btkr=1
- coldtea 12y ago>Where it’s particularly striking of course is when people respond appropriately much faster than the speed of thought. You need only think of a piano player or a tennis player to see that the impression that they are making a conscious decision—“that ball is coming in this direction; I’d better move over here and hit it”—couldn’t possibly be. The time it takes for the signals to get to the brain and then through the motor system, back to the response, couldn’t work. And yet they still have this overwhelming impression that they’re observing the world in real time and are in control. I think all of this is pretty fascinating stuff. I see this repeated to point that "hence we are not really conscious" or not really in control of ourselves. But, to me, an obvious answer is that our "thought" is not just the "talk-to-myself" like thought, but also faster unconscious processes, that still weights things and combines our memories and "personality" biases in the decision making, it's just not like an 'inner-dialogue'
- smutticus 12y agoFor those interested in understanding why we conceive of time the way we do, I recommend Philosophy in the Flesh, by Lakoff and Johnson. Chapter 10 deals with Time. http://www.nytimes.com/books/first/l/lakoff-philosophy.html http://www.nytimes.com/books/first/l/lakoff-philosophy.html
- leepowers 12y agoAnd the other thing people contemplate: They think denying the flow of time is denying time asymmetry of the world. Of course events in the world follow a directional sequence. Drop an egg on the floor and it breaks. You don’t see eggs assembling themselves. Buildings fall down after earthquakes; they don’t rise up from heaps of rubble. "Events occurring in sequence" is the same thing as "the flow of time", in my understanding at least. What else does "the flow of time" refer to? I fear there's a subtle point being made that I don't quite grasp.
- colanderman 12y agoThinking about the entropic explanation of the arrow of time in conjunction with the anthropic principle led me to this fantastic FAQ: http://preposterousuniverse.com/eternitytohere/faq.html http://preposterousuniverse.com/eternitytohere/faq.html and the idea of Boltzmann Brains: http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/cosmicvariance/2006/08/01/boltzmanns-anthropic-brain/#.VFAFCPl4ok0 http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/cosmicvariance/2006/08/01/...