4 ms·
Why do they always make these experimental child-driven schools for the "bad" children? The truants, and the misbehaved. Why not try it for the "best" children
by ars 12y ago
Why do they always make these experimental child-driven schools for the "bad" children? The truants, and the misbehaved.
Why not try it for the "best" children? Those who have a real desire and ability to learn, but don't necessarily fit in in a regular school.
Provide classes, and let the child decide which to go to.
Give exams, but don't record the grade - just give it to the child so they know how they are doing.
- lordbusiness 12y agoMontessori is built specifically on these principles, and is widely adopted [citation needed ;-)] by parents of gifted kids who struggle with the grind of the regular school systems. (At least, in the western world). Also, home schooling is growing in popularity in many progressive countries, largely to cater to child-led learning.
- lodewijkadlp 12y agoMontessori turned into regular education when it touched regulation and general stupidity. Nothing left of these principles.
- hamai 12y ago(Engrish ahead...) I have great memories from a Montessori School I went to as a kid. Spent most of my childhood education there. It was a big house, each room was dedicated to a subject and students would change rooms, big shared tables and very few students per room. I also don't remember grades or at least no focus on it. When I got to a normal school it was one big room packed with tiny individual chairs, all classes happened in that room, everything was easy, suddenly I was a "top student" and grades were a carrot to chase after. I didn't turned out exactly a Noam Chomsky but I find it funny he had this same experience while going from an alternative education to a traditional one. I think he talks about it in this interview: http://www.chomsky.info/interviews/20130326.htm http://www.chomsky.info/interviews/20130326.htm
- DanBC 12y agoGovernments are not brave. England has about 17,000 primary schools and about 4,000,000 primary school children. (ages 4 to 11). This group would be amazing for randomised controlled studies of teaching methods. But teachers hate being told how to teach[1]; parents would not like the idea that their child is getting the placaebo teaching method[2]; and governments are not brave enough to try it.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoWouldn't the control group get the current standard curriculum and teaching methods. You're not looking for changes wrt non-teaching, you're looking for changes compared to the current pedagogical form. There's much to learn from non-school based education but I doubt most of it can be applied with the financial constraints we have [in the UK]. [I'm guessing you missed some links there.]
- alexhawdon 12y agoComparing children in some new study against the general population of mainstream children is the general approach we use and it's fraught with problems. The studies are often small sample sizes of children who are often opted-in by their parents and the teaching is done by better than average teachers with lots of support and involvement from the institution who designed the study or otherwise stands to gain from its successful outcome. All that is generally revealed is that children whose parents are engaged in their education being taught by good teachers and that are aware they are in a 'special' group do better than average. Unsurprisingly the methods don't scale very well.
- saraid216 12y agoYou know, the only time I've ever heard the term "brave" applied to a large group of people is when the group in question is an army.
- untog 12y agoMostly because the existing system works out pretty well for the "best" children. True, they might not be taxed to their full extent, but they will still be top of their class and progress to university. And, not to sound too cynical about it, the parents of the "best" children tend to be very involved in their children's education, and might resist an experiment.
- DanBC 12y agoI'm not sure you can say that. And especially not of the schools of the 1970s and 1980s. A lot of academically minded children would have been very poorly served by those schools. People getting to university would have been the children of upper and middle class parents who had money to afford private schooling or tuition or coaching to get into good grammar schools.
- ZeroGravitas 12y agoI think they are using a recursive definition of "best" to mean those who succeed under the current system whereas the original question posted seems to be defining "best" as the misfits who fail in the current system despite (or indeed because of) their aptitude.
- jtheory 12y agoI went through school always near the top, academically, but I wouldn't say I was well-served by the school system. My wife had much the same experience, though rather worse than mine; she very clearly remembers loving doing math with her older brothers when she was small, but schooling managed to replace that with almost a phobia of anything that looks like math. Now we have small children, and they're obsessed with reading/writing, numbers, and creative play just like we were as kids -- so they're far ahead of their age group, generally -- but we've kept them out of school so far. We're trying to figure out a path for them through the available educational options, and we're strongly inclined towards more experimental approaches.
- tormeh 12y ago
- blueskin_ 12y agoI assume it's the (sometimes valid, sometimes false) assumption that many of the 'bad' children are actually too intelligent/talented and get bored because school moves too slowly for them. Admittedly, it is definitely the case for some children, but the majority of 'bad' ones are just too stupid/lazy instead.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoI disagree. I was one of those kids who was singled out for special education because I was "too stupid/lazy"; but it just turned out I was really bored. I bet our imposed labels just adversely effect these kids until they "match our expectations" and are basically lost forever. In my case, it took until high school, or even college to "break out" of the label.
- corin_ 12y agoDefinitely both types of "too stupid/lazy" exist, but your single data point doesn't say anything to whether you're the 1 in 100 or the 99.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoActually, kids are born with lots of potential that are basically wrung out of them as they "develop." The public education systems in most countries were designed to create obedient factory workers, after all.
- ska 12y agoThe thinking is something like: A bright kid with a decent social support system may not find a place in the schools, but will make a place forthemselves outside that system. A kid who is struggling to read at grade level, who comes from an impoverished and/or abusive social network - this kid may have two strikes against them before they show up at all, and warrants the extra effort to try and help lift themselves out of there circumstances.
- Udo_Schmitz 12y agoA.S. Neill actually talked about that in a book. It’s the parents that mostly prefer traditional schools and only consider alternatives when something goes wrong with their kids.
- skylan_q 12y agoThe aim isn't a good education, it's a 100% graduation rate.
- dnautics 12y agothey did. I went to such a school (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hb_woodlawn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hb_woodlawn). It was a public 'magnet' or 'charter before the concept of charter' school. My class was 70 students. Although being in Arlington meant "solidly middle class", among some notables (modestly achieved, not super-famous) from my graduating class (1999) include: Stephen Ridley, who is CEO of xipiter, the company making USB condoms which have been featured here. Fabian Bouthillette, former assistant to Gore Vidal and author of "Gore Vidal's last stand" (http://www.amazon.com/Gore-Vidals-Last-Stand-Initiation-ebook/dp/B00JVCF8FU http://www.amazon.com/Gore-Vidals-Last-Stand-Initiation-eboo...), Adam Berninger founder of a advertisement and design firm, and Naomi Uyama, world champion swing dancer and band-leader. Steven and Naomi got to where they were without finishing (or in Naomi's case ever going to) college, which is funny since H-B always was proud of its college matriculation rate. 5 entrepreneurs out of 70 isn't that bad, I think! (I'm 90% of the way to being "modestly achieved")
- Htsthbjig 12y agoCalling a person "bad" children is a label. Have you seen the dog whisperer in witch Cesar Millan takes "bad"(behavior) dogs and make the good ones? Well, with people it is the same. My mother was teacher an volunteered to help poor children in her spare time. She made lots of bad children become "good" ones, even becoming brilliant engineers, doctors or teachers. Basically she become their mother and gave them lots of love and care(and time, lots of time). It is personally very rewarding but also incredible extenuating. Our family experience tells us the main reason a kid behaves bad is because she does not care. Imagine that your parents are drugs addicts. There is no money on the house even for the basics because for a drug addict the only important thing is getting drugs. Your parents don't care about you. You know they don't love you, drugs really fuck your brain. Imagine your mother is a whore that loves to sleep with lots of men. You have a new dad every two weeks. Imagine you are sexually abused by your uncle, or your father comes drunk every day and hits you. This happens a lot. The people that suffers this couldn't care less about math or the rivers in the world. In the US they simply put this people in jail, where they learn from other prisoners and become more and more dangerous.US has the biggest(absolute and relative) incarceration rate in the world by far. The first thing you have to do is create a "safe net" for those kids before they are interested in anything else.