9 ms·
Court rules California employers must pay employee cell phone expenses
- zaroth 12y agoExpense reimbursement is always tax-free for the employee and fully deductible for the company, whereas any increase in compensation from $100k-$150k can carry an effective tax rate over 50% due to progressive marginal rates and phase-outs. Particularly for these types of ambiguous use items, I would expect savvy companies to be maximizing this benefit, not minimizing it.
- Gotperl 12y agoThe cost for an employer gets cheaper as an employee makes more money, not more expensive. There are no increasing marginal rates for employer payroll taxes- just the employee state/federal income taxes.
- zaroth 12y agoIt depends how you measure the cost to the employer. When you're talking about increasing employee compensation in the $100k - $150k range, I look at the total cost to end up with $1.00 in the employee's savings account. The point is that increasing compensation is extremely inefficient in the $100k - $150k range. That's why, for example, US engineers getting raises in that pay range will often find it doesn't change much in their living situation. "I got a $10k raise" but really take-home pay just increased $4500. Often times paying out compensation in cash like this is just too expensive. It's a weird concept that the cost of cash is a curve mostly dictated by tax rates. When the IRS is taking 55% at certain points in the curve, you get much bigger bang for the buck by offering other benefits, like maximizing expense reimbursements. (phone, internet, qualified commuting expenses, food & entertainment, etc.)
- qwerta 12y agoIn Europe it is common to provide car and petrol. However from some point it is perceived as a benefit and taxed.
- pm24601 12y agoI love California. This is the 300th reason why I will never leave the state. It is so good about protecting workers ( when compared to the rest of the US. )
- robomartin 12y agoInteresting point of view. Employers beyond a given scale want to LEAVE California because of just how ridiculous things can be here. And so, you like CA because of your perceived (or real) benefits to employees when, in reality the rules that keep piling up are making jobs leave the state and, in effect, cost employees dearly. In other words, employees are not losing small amounts or benefits here and there but rather their jobs and the ability to maintain a standard of living as everything else in the state ads cost to doing business here. Remember that widely reported employment numbers count minimum wage jobs and highly-paid jobs the same way. In other words one could say that CA is gaining, not losing, jobs yet when you dig into the data you discover that jobs that pay well are leaving and the ranks are being filled by people taking pay and standard of living cuts. It's interesting to come to the realization that the average Joe and Jane has no clue as to what a business equation looks like, how businesses run and how costs and legislation affect numbers. You can't keep taking from people and businesses forever without consequences. This isn't a politically charged statement, this is simple mathematics. Eventually we succeed at killing off our own source of income when they decide to pull-up anchor and move to more reasonable shores (sometimes literally). Both businesses and people have choices.
- Daishiman 12y agoPeople keep saying that and, honestly, compared to what it actually means to see companies leaving countries and regions, there's much talk and little evidence of a substantial change in trends. The big software companies and well-funded startups continue to flock to the state. Obviously not as much as before for the simple reason that the Valley is only so big and living expenses are a very substantial part of the cost, but that has little to do with employee regulation (which is comparatively weak in the US compared to many other developed nations for which, apparently, it ain't much of a problem) and more to do with the cost of living in other areas such as housing demand and infrastructure. Other states and countries should consider that a good working environment, not just in the office but in the protections afforded to employees, is pretty damn attractive for talented individuals.
- WalterBright 12y ago> Consider these factors when building a compliant reimbursement policy [... long and incomplete list ...] Those regulations are micromanaging trivia. Is that really the proper role of government? In addition to the cost of the phones, companies have to hire additional people just to design, build and manage a "compliant reimbursement policy."
- ajross 12y agoThe "role of government" phrasing makes this sound more anarcholibertarian than I think you meant it, but it's really not that notable. The use of "compliant" is a little misleading. This is a court ruling, not a regulation. It just says that you have to pay for your employee's expenses, which is sort of a "duh" thing to me. Companies have "compliant reimbursement policies" for travel and purchasing and client schmoozing already, and this need be no different or more complicated. If employees have to pay for stuff you have to pay them back. That doesn't sound like over-regulation to me.
- dragonwriter 12y agoThose aren't regulations, those are recommendations of how to deal with the straightforward law requiring employers to pay all necessary expenses incurred in the course of employment by the law firm who is using the ruling and the underlying law as a focus of efforts to drum up business. The source article is an information page from a law firm, and the reason they do this kind of information page is as a way of generating business by both (1) creating a perceived need for legal services, and (2) portraying themselves as experts in the area where they have created the perceived need.
- bsder 12y agoWhy is this even an issue? If I were running a company, I'd just give you a corporate phone that the company completely pays for. This seems like a no-brainer. BYOD (bring your own device) always seemed like a non-starter to me. Do you really want your employer to have any access to your personal device? I sure wouldn't.
- gizmo686 12y agoBYOD does not mean the employer has access to the device, it means that the device is used for all work related purposes that would require such a device. In some jobs, that might require giving the employer some control, but that is not nessasary. The main benifits I see are: not having to carry two phones, and having more freedom to choice what device you use.
- darklajid 12y agoBut you can have the cake and eat it too: Company lets you decide what device you want, pays the bill and - allows you to use it privately. I gave my mobile contract to my wife, only use my 'business' phone now. Private calls are explicitly allowed (most calls are free anyway, in this contract). Some common sense is required: Calling a dating line is probably stupid, talking to relatives in somewhere-over-the-sea is out as well. The only 'real' limitation I have is that I should avoid excessive texting (I .. write one sms a month, maybe, anyway. Nothing that concerns me), due to the way the contract works. So: - device of my choosing - only one device on me - I call my friends and family using said device
- FireBeyond 12y agoYes and no. I've heard of multiple occasions where (accidentally, at least - though I'm sure it could be enforced by more callous types) people have linked their phones to corporate Exchange/BB servers. Leave the company and IT duly remote-wipes the device to ensure there's no corporate data left on it.
- icelancer 12y agoEh. When I was doling out benefits, I just paid them a cell phone allotment as part of their petty cash bonuses. No reason to force them to use a specific device.
- danbruc 12y agoWhy does this even need a court decision? How would you defend the position, that you force additional work-related expenses onto your employees but are not required to compensate them?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jfidosa9 12y agoYou do realize employers aren't required to pay gas expenses for employees to drive to work, right?
- maaaats 12y agoThat's a really bad analogy.
- jfidosa9 12y agoAnd how is that a bad analogy? I'm responding directly to his point. Employers aren't required to pay for a host of things that are work related.
- maaaats 12y agoBecause there's a difference between "work related" and "work mandated". How I get to work is my problem (unless its out of office, then my employer pays the extra cost). But if they expect me to use a phone during work they will either need to provide me one or reimburse my expenses.
- jfidosa9 12y agoYou seem quite ignorant about labor laws. If you don't want to use the other analogy, here's another one. Employers are not required to pay for employee uniforms even if they're mandated for the workplace.
- r00fus 12y ago"employers that require employees to use their personal devices to conduct business as a condition of employment will need reimbursement plans or face litigation risk." So what does this mean? Likely not triggered by simply storing my mobile number on the internal groupware contacts card. However, if I'm in services or sales, and I travel a lot - I would now be in a position where I need to be available - would that be considered "as a condition of employment"? Examples would make this a lot easier to navigate.
- kissickas 12y agoUnrelated, but the ridiculous banner on that website takes up half of my screen, and a good portion of it as I scroll down, the purpose of which is beyond me. "We noticed you are in the United States"... no I'm not.