12 ms·
After California decriminalized pot, teen arrest, overdose, dropout rates fell
- Zikes 12y agoApparently locking kids up for their own good didn't do much good after all.
- mindslight 12y ago"doesn't" - There's plenty of helpful/entrepreneurial kids still going to jail, and plenty of other drugs that are still harshly criminalized.
- dharbin 12y agoAfter California decriminalized pot, teen arrest, overdose, ebola broke out. Think about it.
- sliverstorm 12y agoNot to mention ISIS appeared. There can be only one conclusion.
- zenciadam 12y agoDropout rates fell, but presenting the data as a percentage change of a percentage is a bad way of reporting the data since the number of students in the system may have changed because of demographics.
- adventured 12y ago14.7% to 11.4% is a pretty solid change in two years, and it was progressive (13.1% inbetween). I wouldn't expect demographics to impact much in two years. The improved / stabilized economy may have had a big impact however.
- neoeldex 12y agoBut it is really overselling the picture. This article is misleading. Numbers, numbers, numbers and numbers... are hard.
- jMyles 12y agoJust as Eric Sterling, Ethan Nadelmann, groups like SSDP, and many other expert advocates predicted. At least in terms of arrest and overdose, it seems so obvious; I can't fathom how people predict an increase in death, disease, and / or crime being caused by ending prohibition. What models are they using?!
- TrainedMonkey 12y agoFear mongering, guilt by association, and common sense mostly.
- MichaelGG 12y agoThe same kind of thinking used when they say things like "without religion, no one would act moral and everyone would just steal and murder". Some people might have a dark side trying to get out and assume these limits are keeping everyone at bay. Or, they've committed to the ideas of these limits in their own lives and are trying to justify it.
- tokenadult 12y agoWhat models are they using?! When I was in law school, I heard a very interesting guest lecture by a law professor from another law school who has studied the history of Prohibition (of selling alchohol) in the United States. People who were opposed to Prohibition, that is people who thought that alcohol should be legal to produce and sell, pointed out that Prohibition greatly increased corruption of police forces in many places. People who supported Prohibition pointed out that alcohol causes many medical harms for many users. The historical record shows that they were both right. When Prohibition was repealed, corruption of local police forces to prompt police to look the other way and not enforce Prohibition went down, but deaths from cirrhosis of the liver and other bad health effects of alcohol went up. I'm on record here on HN (I won't look up the links to previous comments just now) as being persuaded by Richard Branson's argument that decriminalizing marijuana in the country Portugal reduced use, and thus ended up reducing individual and societal harm from marijuana. That country still has court-supervised drug treatment programs (but without criminal penalties) for drug users. As far as I know, Minnesota's de facto policy is much like this. There is a federal law of the land in the United States that criminalizes sale and even possession of marijuana, but there is minimal enforcement here of statutes against possession of small amounts of marijuana. There is a big industry here of drug treatment centers, and people come to Minnesota from all over the world to get clean from drug addictions. If we can devote more law enforcement resources to more serious crimes, and fewer to enforcement of minor possession offenses, I'm fine with that. But I also hope that most people never start to use marijuana at all, and everyone who does use it is careful to get a reality check from sober people on how well they are really functioning.
- josu 12y agoThere is not enough data to draw any conclusions.
- angersock 12y agoThat's never stopped anyone in the drug war before!
- cnvogel 12y agoWhat annoys me the most: They only include one year of data before. So, assuming they would have shown US and California data for, say, 5 years before legalization, and during that time, there would have been a strong correlation between the two, in the numbers shown. And then a sudden split (decrease in correlation) in the two years following, it would have been much more convincing.
- ojbyrne 12y ago"does not lead to any number of doomsday scenarios envisioned by legalization opponents"... of course the real doomsday scenario - poorer employment prospects for Law Enforcement - hopefully will happen.
- Zigurd 12y agoIt's not just that cops make a huge number of useless, insignificant arrests for drugs, there's a whole industry built on top of those arrests: All the prosecutors, judges, clerks, bailiffs, parole officers, prison guards and the whole prison infrastructure. Then add all the retired CJ employees teaching the current policing doctrine in community colleges. That's the edifice that has to be razed to avoid the situation in Ferguson. All of those pseudo-professions have been massively inflated and is a kind of last refuge for men with strong necks and weak reasoning skills. It's subculture, and that subculture doesn't have a beneficial effect on the nation's culture as a whole. All of that employment and wasted activity also shows up in the plus columns for productivity and GDP, warping our ability to compare our economy to other industrial nations.
- jschwartzi 12y agoPlus, because we have a finite number of police, they have zero time to do anything traditionally associated with police, like proactively walking beats. I would be all for adding more police if it meant that each one had a patrol area of less than 1 square mile and they could actually get out and walk it. You see so much more when you walk.
- jonah 12y ago"Think of the jobs" is almost as bad as "Think of the kids" as far as excuses for things go. We see it a lot in the realm of energy production too. LEO or Roughneck can't be the only job these folks could possibly get if there were fewer of those positions.
- Pxtl 12y agoI'd say that "think of the jobs" is generally a damned sight worse than "think of the kids" as rationalizations for bad policy go. Jobs defense is often protecting an explicit waste of resources, while kids at least are worth protecting and tend to break libertarian models of the universe.
- piptastic 12y agoIt seems like California is following the overall trends for the "Rest of the US" (where the data is available). Not sure how much this actually means, if anything.
- tjradcliffe 12y agoThe significance is more that the panic-mongers are wrong. Even if California is just following trend, it means that prohibition makes no difference, so from a social policy perspective you have two choices: 1) Some number of people smoke weed, there are no violent gangs involved in its cultivation and sale, harmless college students don't have their lives ruined by a drug arrest and the security-industrial complex gets smaller while its former minions have to go do something that isn't a deadweight loss. 2) Exactly the same number of people smoke weed, there are violent gangs involved in its cultivation and sale, harmless college students have their lives ruined by a drug arrest and the security-industrial complex gets bigger while its minions suck the life out of the productive economy. Which would you choose?
- Roboprog 12y agoWon't somebody please think of the gangsters! How are they supposed to earn a living now? Imagine poor old Al Capone without a market for expensive booze, how would he have gotten by? This message brought to you by the "Partnership" for a Drug Free America. (never quite clear on who the "partners" are) ... with apologies to Charles Stross :-) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Stross#Merchant_Princes_series http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Stross#Merchant_Princes...
- yodsanklai 12y ago> Won't somebody please think of the gangsters! How are they supposed to earn a living now? It may sound funny, but to me it's one of the few reasonable arguments against legalization (or at least something to think about). I don't know in the US, but where I live (in France), there are a lot of people that live from selling cannabis. They're not Al Capone or dangerous criminals, just poor people that don't have better opportunities. From our leaders perspective, this may be one reason not to address the problem of legalization (that, plus the fact that it's still largely unpopular).
- cracell 12y agoThe producers that are usually referenced here in California are ones that do environmental damage and/or are associated with violent gangs. Few examples: http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/uc_breakthroughs_2014/2014/04/green_but_not_green_how_pot_farms_trash_the_environment.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/uc_breakthro..., http://www.livescience.com/17417-marijuana-growers-national-forests.html http://www.livescience.com/17417-marijuana-growers-national-..., http://www.hispanicvista.com/HVC/Columnist/sosio/060810_Sal_Osio_California_Marijuana_gangs.htm http://www.hispanicvista.com/HVC/Columnist/sosio/060810_Sal_... I haven't seen any data to backup the assertion that legalizing and regulating does hurt gangs and reduce the number of environmentally damaging illegal grows. But that is the general mindset of pro-legalization individuals here due to the media reports like the above.
- sanoli 12y agoWell, here in Brazil they are dangerous criminals and very, very violent, and no, they won't turn into upstanding citizens if the money from drugs dries up. They'll turn into other forms of cime, probably just as violent. However, in the long term they won't be making as much money as now, so they won't have the crazy arsenal they have today (military grade stuff, like rocket launchers, grenades, etc). I find it ridiculous that we keep it illegal, which drives the price way up, which fuels the gangs pockets, so they become heavily armed, and in turn so does the police, and the result is that not a week goes by in some cities where an innocent isn't hit by a stray bullet. In the end, I'd rather have someone die of an overdose because they chose to and ended up (unfortunately) in that situation than to have the whole city hostage to this unwinnable war, and to have people die just because they happen to live in a bad neighborhood.
- whiddershins 12y agoThe burden of proof should be on the people who want to restrict rights, not on the people who want to liberalize. This concept is more or less in line with the spirit of the Bill of Rights, but seems to be curiously absent from common American discourse. Enforcing ANY law, even a seatbelt law, restricts rights and causes some amount of harm. I find it perplexing anyone thinks legalized recreational substance use would actually cause more harm than drug enforcement does, even aside from the metaphysical harm of having your freedom reduced. It is as if the harm inherent in law enforcement doesn't count, as if there are kinds of acceptable and unacceptable violence. Which doesn't seem like a philosophically defensible ideology to me.
- Swizec 12y ago> Enforcing ANY law, even a seatbelt law, restricts rights and causes some amount of harm. In case of seatbelt laws in particular you have a huge amount of proof/data showing that seatbelts save lives both of the person wearing them and other people in the car[1] and there is also a massive amount of proof/data that [a lot of] people are too dumb to wear seatbelts on their own. Therefore an enforced law is required. [1] if everyone in the car is buckled up and one person isn't and you go into a crash, well now you have a 70kilogram projectile flying around at huge speeds and massive forces. Depending on what happens they could easily kill everyone in the car. Bottom line is, never ride in a car with anyone who isn't wearing a seatbelt.
- delecti 12y agoI think the point was that seatbelt laws are relatively unoffensive and yet they still restrict rights, not necessarily that they're unjustified. They started with "The burden of proof should be on the people who want to restrict rights", and I think it's safe to say that the burden of proof has been met with regards to seatbelt laws, for exactly the reasons you specified.
- Swizec 12y agoI just wanted to point it out because I know too many people who have problems with seatbelts. But more in point with weed, I wonder whether we're going to find out if we need those laws or not. The question, in my opinion, isn't so much whether banning weed is bad, but how life damaging is the punishment vs. the thing you're preventing. Being arrested and put in jail for a few years can damage someone's life a lot more than smoking a joint every day for a few years. But at the same time, I have friends who have smoked almost every day for ten years and they have gotten noticeably dumber. Most of them ended up quitting when they realised just how damaging inhaling burning plant matter was for them. So maybe what we need isn't the end of prohibition, but milder prohibition? shrug
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- delecti 12y agoEvery time I see a headline like this my reaction is along the lines of "yeah, sounds about right". I imagine there have got to be people for whom they these headlines are surprising, and that confounds me.
- ams6110 12y agoPot decriminalized, arrest rate falls. Tautology?
- spacemanmatt 12y agoThis is my surprised face.
- fr0ggerrr 12y agoI'm glad Marijuana overdoses decreased.
- madaxe_again 12y agoThe most shocking thing in that article is that the US-wide suicide rate for 15-19 year olds has increased by 11% in a year. When your kids are killing themselves in increasing numbers... you have to wonder if your society is really as healthy and wonderful as you like to think it is.
- neoeldex 12y agoThis article is misleading. Im not agains mariuana, but still. These numbers are distorted. F.i, there isn't a 20% drop of overdose in CA, its only -0.6%. In the US its +0.1%. There is no 11% increase, the 11% is the % increase of the percentage of suicides. In ca, the increase in suicides is 0.5%. And in the rest of the US it is also 0.5%. Really think hard when seeing numbers, you're fooled easily.
- madaxe_again 12y agoWhen telling others they're fooled easily, do check your assertions first, otherwise you look like an ass! 7.8/100,000 -> 8.7/100,000 is an 11% uptick in the number of deaths by suicide. I'm not saying that that's even remotely related to weed. There is a 20% drop in overdose - that's not -0.6% no matter how you shake it - that's -0.6 deaths per 100k - which in absolute terms means the OD rate per cap has shifted from 0.003% to 0.0024% - so actually a 0.0006% change in the overall rate - but a 20% delta. It's -23.3% for 2010 -> 2012.
- tempodox 12y agoLogically, if you stop criminalising people then you get less “criminals”. Makes me wonder how much more senseless laws should be abolished for the greater common good...