8 ms·
A Promising Pill, Not So Hard to Swallow
- Klinky 12y agoI've dealt with IBS symptoms for 17 years. I would love to try one of these pills. Digestive maladies can really hamper a person's life. The digestive system is poorly understood, and there aren't a lot of effective treatment options for IBS & IBDs like Crohn's & Ulcerative Colitis. The treatments which are effective for IBD are often invasive or can have serious side effects.
- jostmey 12y agoSecond that. I would have no problem taking it.
- rollthehard6 12y agoYes, I have relatively mild Crohn's, controlled well with LDN (Low Dose Naltrexone, 2mg daily) but I would love to try this.
- refurb 12y agoAny ideas on how naltrexone works for Crohn's? I have seen a few articles describing its efficacy. I'm just curious what the mechanism of action. Is it through it's mu receptor antagonism or something else?
- 300bps 12y agothere aren't a lot of effective treatment options for IBS & IBDs like Crohn's & Ulcerative Colitis I had IBS from the age of 10 to the age of 30. First off I have to say that IBS is not even remotely comparable to IBD. For most people, IBS is a very inconvenient life-altering syndrome. IBD is often 100x worse, increases the risks of colon cancer and can be life threatening. I wouldn't wish ulcerative colitis or Crohn's disease (IBD) on my worst enemy. Beyond that, I'm not sure why you think this pill would help your IBS. It is specifically meant to treat one particular problem - a clostridium difficile infection. Typically the colon is populated by helpful or otherwise non-harmful bacteria. Clostridium difficile is an opportunistic infection that often takes hold after someone takes a course of antibiotics that kills all the helpful bacteria. The fecal transplant puts back the normal bacteria into your colon, attempting to crowd out the clostridium difficile bacteria. There is anecdotal evidence of fecal transplants helping IBS or IBD but it has not been studied well. Source: http://www.mayoclinic.org/medical-professionals/clinical-updates/digestive-diseases/quick-inexpensive-90-percent-cure-rate http://www.mayoclinic.org/medical-professionals/clinical-upd... I would suspect much of the benefit to IBS from a fecal transplant (or fecal transplant pill) derives from the placebo effect. After 20 years of having IBS, the best cure I found for myself was to eat a lot of dietary fiber and drink a lot of water. I haven't had symptoms of IBS for over 12 years now since doing that. Unfortunately I find I have to eat about 40 grams of dietary fiber and drink about a gallon and a half of water per day. That takes actual work, but it's worth it. Source on dietary fiber treating IBS: http://www.aboutibs.org/site/treatment/diet/dietary-fiber http://www.aboutibs.org/site/treatment/diet/dietary-fiber
- Klinky 12y agoPerhaps you are too distant from your experience of IBS, or your symptoms were not as severe as some, but IBS can destroy someone's life just as well as an IBD can. Someone in remission with an IBD may have better quality of life than someone with uncontrollable IBS. Severity varies by patient, and while IBDs are usually more severe, that isn't always the case. Mentioning the two together does not mean that I am indicting they are equally severe. C.diff, IBS and IBD are all ailments with the potential to be treated via fecal transplantation. The IBS issues I've dealt with have lead to some catastrophic effects. Twice after dealing with stomach flu/food poisoning I developed gastroparesis or severe gastric motility issues. I lost 60 lbs during the first bout in 2006 and 45 lbs during a second bout in 2012. My quality of life was horrible during these periods of time. I basically lost a year of my life each time. Luckily you found a solution for your IBS, many people have not. If simply upping my fiber solved the problem then I would be set, but fiber lead to more gas and pain for me. Probiotics on the market often leave me constipated and nauseated. Even if I stick to a regimen irregularities continue, and my body still seems to ebb and flow. So far regular strenuous exercise seems to help me, but IBS often leads to fatigue. This all happened to me after I went swimming in a river with friends and got ill later in the evening. I may have swallowed river water contaminated with agriculture run off. Nothing has been the same since then. This is similar to many people's stories about IBS. The hope is that the pill would restore whatever was killed off due to the initial illness, which might result in regulation and relief. Yeah it's a shot in the dark and not officially meant to treat ~anything~, but at least it's something with some promise. The doctors over the years haven't had an answer for me. Treatments are also used off label all the time and trials are often very narrow in scope to meet regulatory guidelines. Somehow I think you know this already and are being a bit of a smartass.
- 300bps 12y agoFrom the little you've written here, it doesn't sound to me like you have typical IBS or perhaps even IBS at all. The diagnostic criteria for IBS are here: http://www.aboutibs.org/site/what-is-ibs/intro-to-ibs/diagnosis http://www.aboutibs.org/site/what-is-ibs/intro-to-ibs/diagno... Dramatic weight loss as you've outlined is a sign you're suffering from something more serious than IBS. That makes sense since you list several other non-IBS related disorders ("stomach flu (sic) / food poisoning" as well as gastroparesis). The thing that doesn't make sense to me is why you attribute these things to IBS? If simply upping my fiber solved the problem then I would be set, but fiber lead to more gas and pain for me. There is nothing "simple" about increasing your fiber in a manner to solve IBS. As I mentioned in my original comment, it takes actual work. First, you have to eschew eating anything at all throughout the day that doesn't have dietary fiber. Second, you must gradually increase your fiber intake over a period of a year to avoid gas buildup and pain. Third, you must actively seek out fiber rich foods to eat throughout the day. As I said, there is absolutely nothing simple about it. This all happened to me after I went swimming in a river with friends and got ill later in the evening. Again, I'm questioning why you think this has anything to do with IBS. You don't catch IBS by swimming in a river.
- justifier 12y agoi think the taboo of talking about our shit is one of the main obstacles we face currently in the dialogue on personal and public health because of this public silence i thought for the longest time that the way i shit was just the way all people shit: a roulette roller coaster ride through the whole bristol stool scale once i removed wheat flour from my diet and began eating a quinoa`oatmeal hybrid everything changed for the better it has to be tricolor quinoa because the three colors: white, red, and black; all burst at different rates when boiled what you want is the whites to be fully popped, some reds to be beginning to pop and the blacks unpopped to pass through you like diamonds on a drill bit cook the quinoa, then drop in an equal dose of oatmeal with some water and stir until the oatmeal is as soft as you like it oatmeal alone is a poor rice substitute, but the mix gives a texture that makes the combination a perfect substitute for any meal where you might use rice my body has since thanked me in all those wondrous popsci ways: more energy, better focus, less irratibility i feel better and the difference was noticeable in days
- logn 12y agoIt seems like we could refine the fecal matter further until we get down to the active ingredient(s). Penicillin is made from mold, but we don't get repulsed by that, since it's so processed and pure.
- jszymborski 12y agoThe "active ingredients" are countless of microbiota, not all of which we've seen before. Even if we did know exactly what makes up the flora/microbiom of a healthy and happy gut, we'd likely never be able to get anywhere close to the same sampling and delicate balance that occurs through the natural equilibrium established in our stomachs. Repulsion shouldn't play a factor. People will get used to it. Remember when pig heart valve transplants were a big issue?
- Klinky 12y agoThe active ingredient is "unknown" at this point. Work is being done to figure out which microbes are useful, and in some cases you may need an orchestration of many different types. http://www.hmpdacc.org/ http://www.hmpdacc.org/ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_microbiome http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_microbiome
- the_rosentotter 12y agoWe use something similar when we go traveling, basically tablets made from feces (active ingredient is http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enterococcus_faecium http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enterococcus_faecium), as a probiotic to prevent stomach infections and diarrhea. They are extremely effective and a very good alternative to having to go on antibiotics while on vacation. Available in pharmacies over the counter. On another note I have a pet theory that the increasing prevalence of IBS is caused by the widening use of antibiotics everywhere, both as medicine but also in food production.
- dpatrick86 12y agoWhat country are you in and what are they called? My googling is turning up pet products.
- the_rosentotter 12y agoThis is in Denmark, the brand is Paraghurt: http://www.actavis.dk/dk/products/ParaghurtA07FA01.htm http://www.actavis.dk/dk/products/ParaghurtA07FA01.htm Now that you mention it I haven't ever seen it abroad. Apparently the common alternative is Lactobacillus acidophilus LA-5: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lactobacillus_acidophilus http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lactobacillus_acidophilus Wikipedia lists Chr. Hansen as the manufacturer, coincidentally also a Danish company: http://www.chr-hansen.com/products/product-areas/probiotics-for-dietary-supplements/strains/la-5r.html http://www.chr-hansen.com/products/product-areas/probiotics-...
- vegardx 12y agoWhere on earth do you travel if you have to go on antibiotics, just for traveling? Some people get a little sick from the different kind of bacteria cultures in different part of the world, but not something a doctor would put you on antibiotics for. A lot of people die every year for taking antibiotics they didn't necessarily need to take, so if your doctor prescribes antibiotics for a simple "vacation stomach", I'd change him or her out pretty quickly. [1] [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/17/health/research/popular-antibiotic-may-raise-risk-of-sudden-death.html http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/17/health/research/popular-an...
- JetSpiegel 12y ago"If you can just open a freezer and take out a poop pill, that’s wonderful.” While the pills are not being marketed yet Jee, I wonder why. Selling a poop pill is a proper way to see if a marketer is worth their value.
- SwellJoe 12y agoMost marketers are selling a load of shit already.
- shill 12y agoI would start with the slogan "Eat Shit and Live!" and then fine tune the campaign from there.
- rcaught 12y agoThe number 1, number 2.
- CJefferson 12y agoBelieve me, you would get a queue around the block of people with IBS who would be willing to take this pill if there is scientific evidence that it works.
- api 12y agoAre probiotics bunk? Or do they only include a few species and not the complete biodiversity really needed in the human digestive system?
- ll123 12y agoWe don't even know the complete biodiversity needed for the digestive system
- derefr 12y agoProbiotics contain individual bacterial species, to help people who might be missing that one species, where we know that species serves an important function—they make sense for the same reason people missing one nutrient would take a supplement for that one nutrient (e.g. vitamin C.) The alternative to taking one of these foecal pills would be to take lots of different probiotics, in appropriate portions, over time. This is, after all, what animals do naturally to create gut microbiomes in the first place. (It's hypothesized that this is why we like the taste of things like blue cheese: maximizing gut-biome biodiversity is apparently good for reproductive fitness, so we've evolved to enjoy the taste of things with novel bacteria on them.)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- lesterbuck 12y agoAri Meisel's Less Doing podcast devoted one episode to an interview with an expert in this procedure: Podcast #59 Glenn Taylor - Fecal Microbiota Transplants >For more info visit http://lessdoing.com/ http://lessdoing.com/ Ari's book http://www.lessdoingbook.com http://www.lessdoingbook.com In this episode Ari talks with Glenn Taylor of the Taymount Clinic. Glenn specializes in applying Fecal Microbiota Transplant (FMT) techniques to a broad range of gut conditions. FMT restores normal gut microbiota by implanting Standardized Gut Flora from tested and optimized sources. Listen to how Glenn has seen patients literally cured from debilitating illness such as Crohn’s, Ulcerative Colitis, IBS, Multiple Sclerosis, Rheumatoid Arthritis and other disease simply by restoring their gut bacteria to a normal balance. http://podbay.fm/show/605938952/e/1397717818 http://podbay.fm/show/605938952/e/1397717818
- ilaksh 12y agoI have no problem with probiotics. But this is _not_ an easy pill for me to swallow. Can they please figure out which bacteria are actually important and then I will take that? Instead of eating actual shit. Thanks.
- mabbo 12y agoThe problem is that the answer may be "literally thousands of different types of bacteria". Your digestive tract is a jungle, with more species than man will ever fully know about. When too many of certain types go extinct, the ecosystem breaks down, and bad shit starts to happen (come to think of it, literally). It may take decades to figure out all of the specific species that matter most, and in what proportions. We aren't even certain which bacteria are common to all people, and which are specific to certain cultures / races / geographies / genders / who-knows-what-else. I bet people who eat a lot of KFC have a very different personal biome than I do. In the meantime, here's 'one weird trick' that seems to just work.
- maerF0x0 12y ago>" than man will ever fully know about" The more this works, the more we'll be inclined to study it. We'll know eventually.
- eru 12y agoDepends. Species might come and go, depending on how dynamic the evolutionary environment is there.
- jaggederest 12y agoBacteria evolve faster than we can isolate and sequence them. Even brewer's yeast is discarded after a few generations, usually, since it mutates enough to change the flavor of the resulting beer, and that's in an extremely well controlled environment. Imagine that happening every six weeks in your gastrointestinal tract. Multiply by 6 billion people. I'd guess it's extremely unlikely we're going to thoroughly investigate all of those different variations on the theme.
- cpncrunch 12y agoYet another open-label study posted on HN. The placebo effect will play a large part in every patient treated with this, so how do we know if the pill had any effect over and above placebo? Really, this study is a waste of time and money.
- kevinalexbrown 12y agoIt's a first step. Preliminary studies like this are important: before investing a huge amount of money into proper studies, it's fiscally prudent to take smaller steps. Instead of going straight for the generic criticism, you might ask "what's cool about this study?"
- cpncrunch 12y agoIt doesn't really tell us anything, like all open-label studies (except perhaps whether or not the treatment is dangerous and whether it might provide a benefit). Also it doesn't really cost any more to do a small-scale placebo-controlled trial vs an open-label study. Overall open-label studies just give false hope to people who don't understand science and the placebo effect (i.e. most people).
- ZenoArrow 12y ago"just give false hope to people who don't understand science and the placebo effect" You understand how the placebo effect works then? You'd be the first person in the world that did. As kevinalexbrown said, this trial can be seen as a first step, nobody who read the article could reasonably expect the FDA to approve this tomorrow.
- cpncrunch 12y agoI didn't say I understood how the placebo effect works (although perhaps I have a better idea than many people, as I've written a book about it). What I meant is that - as I pointed out above - this study will have a siginificant placebo effect, and the results should therefore be treated with extreme caution. We still have no idea whether this treatment actually works, and I'm constantly surprised that studies like this continually make the first page of HN. I think the problem is that most people don't know that the placebo effect actually exists (or at least, they forget about it when they read a study like this, or downplay its significance). Even many researchers underestimate the placebo effect, and then we end up spending billions of dollars a year on a useless treatment until someone actually proves that it is no better than placebo. http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/07/upshot/the-placebo-effect-doesnt-apply-just-to-pills.html?_r=0&abt=0002&abg=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/07/upshot/the-placebo-effect-...
- drcode 12y agoI find the framing of this nytimes article to be rather condescending, as if a reasonable person should have a problem with taking such a pill, if it is actually effective. (though the science behind it, in itself, also still seems shaky at this point)
- PaulAJ 12y agoWe're clearly at the very beginning of this. Using someone else's gut flora in the hope that it will sort out yours is on a par with pre-scientific herbal medicine: trial and error, and it often worked, but you don't know why. In the future the medical system will analyse your gut flora and identify the specific mix of strains you need to take to remedy the situation.