7 ms·
> Ulbricht hadn’t sufficiently demonstrated that the server belonged to him, and thus can’t claim that his privacy rights were violated by its search. Wait, wa
by Someone1234 12y ago
> Ulbricht hadn’t sufficiently demonstrated that the server belonged to him, and thus can’t claim that his privacy rights were violated by its search.
Wait, wait, wait. Hold the phone.
So any property which, at the time of a search, hasn't been "sufficiently demonstrated [that it belongs to you]" isn't protected, according to this judge, by the fourth amendment?
So for one example, if you sign up to gmail or Facebook using anything other than your real name, they can break it, conduct a search and then whatever they find is totally admissible in court just because they didn't know who it belonged to?
Isn't it now in the best interests of the police to avoid finding out who something belongs to since without knowing the fourth amendment doesn't exist and warrants aren't a requirement?
Here's what I don't get about this case: The FBI is obviously lying about how they got the information they have. They clearly broke into the Silk Road servers. However they could have certain got a warrant to do so had they just presented what they knew at that time about the enterprise. So why didn't they? Laziness? Incompetence? Or just because they knew they'd get away without it (per this)?
Honestly I hope they fight this case on that matter of law and it gets thrown out. We cannot have the fourth getting chucked out any time someone invokes anonymity, that's not how it was meant to work.
- dietrichepp 12y ago> So any property which, at the time of a search, hasn't been "sufficiently demonstrated [that it belongs to you]" isn't protected, according to this judge, by the fourth amendment? That's not what this means. You can't claim fourth amendment protection on someone else's property: I can't claim my rights were violated because the police searched your car. The court is saying that you have to claim it's your car first before you can claim that your rights were violated by the search. (Well, not exactly. The situation is more nuanced.) To put it another way, the court's not saying that this was legal, or that nobody's rights were violated. The court is only denying Ulbricht's specific claim that his rights were violated, and the denial seems to be based on a procedural technicality. Yes, this is bad.
- TrevorJ 12y agoThis logic seems like it would apply to cell phones which have been subsidized by a contract which continues to exist as well. Aren't they considered to still be legally the phone companies' till you've reached the end of said contract? Bad indeed.
- rosser 12y agoNo, subsidized phones aren't the carrier's property while you're in contract. You're liable for an early termination fee if you break the contract (barring the case of "adverse changes" or the like), but you own the phone — or at least the atoms in it. You still have a reduced "expectation of privacy" in your mobile communications, however, in that you're using your carrier as an intermediary to those communications. Consider pen registers, for example.
- TrevorJ 12y agoI reviewed the legal argument that the CTIA made in favor of disallowing end users from unlocking phones and it turns out I was mistaken and you are correct.
- phkahler 12y agoShouldn't evidence be inadmissible based on how it was obtained? An illegal search is an illegal search regardless of what was searched or who owns it. I'm not a fan of the defendant here, but I am a fan of holding the authorities to the rules. You know it's their job to uphold the law.
- forgottenpass 12y agoThat's just the way it works. I agree with you, but the courts don't.
- dietrichepp 12y ago> I'm not a fan of the defendant here, but I am a fan of holding the authorities to the rules. You know it's their job to uphold the law. Yes, evidence is inadmissible based on how it is obtained. However, there are rules and procedures for how you get evidence excluded from a trial. This is why you pay good money for good lawyers: they know the rules for excluding evidence. I recommend watching the 1992 moive "My Cousin Vinny".
- munchbunny 12y agoThe unfortunate part of all of this is that we're now in a system where you win by paying more money to cover more technicalities than the other guy. Sure, this follows the rules, but it seems perverse to lose on a technicality that is easy to resolve with a "hey, prove you own the server. you did? ok."
- anigbrowl 12y agoBut the thing is the judge gave them exactly that option and Ulbricht's lawyer inexplicably declined to take it - see page 22 onwards. So either a) Ulbright can't prove he owns the server (in which case he can't very well claim privacy rights in something that's not his property to start with), or b) he is not willing to, even though doing so might keep most of the evidence out of trial. Maybe that's because of some super-clever legal tactic they plan to unveil at appeal (although this seems very unlikely, as this is such a basic procedural issue) or maybe it's for some extrajudicial reason, like because it would reveal the identity of some partner in crime who would then seek terrible revenge. Or any other number of other possibilities.
- jamesaguilar 12y agoVery interesting. So, at a minimum, you must disclose that a thing is your property to prevent illegal searches of that thing from being admitted in a case against you. That means that if you can be convicted under either of - thing.BelongsTo(you) - thing.Contents fourth amendment protections will not save you. Am I reading this right?
- dietrichepp 12y ago> Am I reading this right? Fortunately, no. The article explains it better than I could: > That argument may seem like a Catch-22. If Ulbricht were to claim ownership of that server he would seem to incriminate himself. But Forrest writes that Ulbricht could have nonetheless claimed the server in a pre-trial statement that couldn’t be used against him as evidence. “Defendant could have established such a personal privacy interest by submitting a sworn statement that could not be offered against him at trial as evidence of his guilt (though it could be used to impeach him should he take the witness stand),” she writes. “Yet he has chosen not to do so.”
- zo1 12y agoThat sounds completely broken. So he has to "pre-trial" admit to owning the "evidence" or "tool of committing the crime", or something. Thereby admitting "guilt" without it being admissible in court later on. So then, everyone knows he's guilty, because he admitted it, but they can't "prove it" because of a technicality of using that evidence. The reason that sounds broken to me is that he has to first admit guilt in order to defend some "noble" right to privacy that'll allow him to be acquitted. If he does that, his entire life is ruined because he will forever be tainted in the media and law-enforcement as "guilty, but got away due to a technicality". They will never stop hounding him, and will actively put him under their investigation spot-light for his entire life. This applies whether he's actually guilty, or not.
- rtkwe 12y agoThere's one bit that I'm not sure how to read because I'm not a lawyer: > “Defendant could have established such a personal privacy interest by submitting a sworn statement that could not be offered against him at trial as evidence of his guilt (though it could be used to impeach him should he take the witness stand),” It sounds like he could provide proof that he owned the server having the contents of the server thrown out. Then provided he didn't take the stand in his own defense the affidavit couldn't be used. Not entirely certain though.
- X-Istence 12y agoHowever if the government then claims that this server is owned by you, doesn't that then imply that your privacy rights were violated since they illegally hacked into your computer? The government can't have it both ways. Either the server is owned by Ulbrecht and they violated his rights, or the server is now owned by Ulbrecht, and thus they can't prove he is the DPR.
- dietrichepp 12y ago> The government can't have it both ways. Either the server is owned by Ulbrecht and they violated his rights, or the server is now owned by Ulbrecht, and thus they can't prove he is the DPR. It's not that simple. The courts follow procedures for these things: the courts respond to claims made by various parties, and if there is no claim that the evidence is dirty, or if the claim that the evidence is dirty is not proved for whatever reason (even silly technical reasons), then the evidence is admitted. Don't forget that this is only one court. Higher courts could find the judge's ruling incorrect.
- Estragon 12y agoI started to read Alderman v. US after Forrest said that 4th Amendment rights cannot be vicariously asserted. I'm a little unclear on how this works. Could an investigator warrentlessly burgle the residences of two conspirators A & B, and use evidence found in B's place against A and evidence found in A's place against B, all without violating the fourth amendment? How about email accounts? If so, why don't investigations against known conspirators proceed this way all the time?
- bd_at_rivenhill 12y agoSeems like it should be possible for the defense to argue that the prosecution must stipulate that the server was his property, in which case his rights were violated, or that the prosecution must stipulate that it was not his property and that they have no case against him. What is wrong with this argument in a legal sense?
- downandout 12y ago
- debian3 12y ago"That's not what this means. You can't claim fourth amendment protection on someone else's property" Ok, so if you rent a car for 3yrs, then they can search it without your consent because technically you don't own it?
- anigbrowl 12y agoNo. While the car is legally in your possession and you leave it closed, you have an expectation of privacy even though you don't own the vehicle title outright.
- ASneakyFox 12y agoIts still illegally obtained evidence even if the server belongs to him or not. Illegal evidence is still illegal evidence.
- higherpurpose 12y agoThe 4th amendment isn't exactly a "right". It's a limitation imposed on the government. The whole Constitution is. The government is not supposed to conduct "illegal searches and seizures". It doesn't say on the victim's property or whatever.
- Alupis 12y agoSeems the FBI is claiming the servers were his, and he was operating them, so they are prosecuting him. But somehow they aren't his property, and therefore not protected by the 4th? That seems bassackwards.
- larssorenson 12y agoPersonally I find the judge's ruling utter rubbish. It is irrelevant if the server was Ulbricht's or not. If the FBI is trying to use evidence found within the server against him, then they should have to prove that they obtained it legally, whether or not it belongs to another individual or Ulbricht. And continuing on your point about best interests, this would amount to rolling up to random cars parked in a parking lot and having a drug sniffing dog walk around until they find something, then trying to arrest everyone parked around the car.
- trhway 12y ago> And continuing on your point about best interests, this would amount to rolling up to random cars parked in a parking lot and having a drug sniffing dog walk around until they find something, then trying to arrest everyone parked around the car. But that pretty much exactly that FBI and other agencies are doing right now in the Internet. And this ruling puts a legal precedent footing under such behavior.
- rosser 12y agoThis ruling doesn't establish a precedent. If it's appealed and upheld, that would establish a precedent. In the US, trial courts find rulings of fact, and appellate courts find rulings of law. Only the latter create precedents.
- pdabbadabba 12y agoHalf right. Trial court judges make rulings of law, juried make findings of fact. An appellate court can then correct the trial court's legal errors, if necessary. But you're right that trial courts' legal rulings aren't precedential.
- rosser 12y agoYeah, "finding of fact" is a more apt phrasing than "ruling of fact". I thought of that after posting my comment, but felt it was a probably bit fine a distinction for the point I was making. Thanks for the clarification.
- ewoodrich 12y agoSo for one example, if you sign up to gmail or Facebook using anything other than your real name, they can break it, conduct a search and then whatever they find is totally admissible in court just because they didn't know who it belonged to? Based on the third-party doctrine and United States v. Graham [1], even if you used your real name, you would not enjoy 4th amendment protection of data stored on an outside company's server (they would be protected, though). It's fairly well established by the Court that there is no "reasonable expectation of privacy" for information disclosed voluntarily to a third party, as with your Gmail example. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Graham http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Graham
- lucaspiller 12y agoWould the same apply to a server I rent? If not, how is that different from paying for Gmail?
- ChrisAntaki 12y ago> they could have certain got a warrant to do so had they just presented what they knew at that time about the enterprise. So why didn't they? Perhaps they want to set a legal precedent which would require less checks & balances.
- sitkack 12y agoIf the government wants to erode the 4th, shouldn't they go through congress?
- jamesaguilar 12y agoWhat an odd question. "If the government wants to do a bad thing, shouldn't they do it a good way?" Doesn't the willingness to do a bad thing kind of imply that they will be willing to do it a bad way?
- sitkack 12y agoNot really. If you look at the intention of Barack, he totally wanted to codify into law, using normal channels and the full power of democracy the detention, execution and "enhanced interrogation" of WoT suspects. Not sure what is worse. Democratically passing new bad laws or subverting the constitution via underhanded techniques. I guess the former is depressing and the latter shows mal-intent? Burn down the Reichstag or get 3/4 majority to nullify the 4th? I'd argue that it should be a constitutional offense to weaken the constitution using non-constitutional means. Attempting to rewrite the rules of the game during gameplay should get you autobanned by punkbuster.
- Steko 12y ago"The FBI is obviously lying about how they got the information they have. They clearly broke into the Silk Road servers." This isn't obvious at all and the only backing we've seen for this is some butthurt speculation. Meanwhile we know for a fact that the Silk Road IP had leaked multiple times in the months before the FBI claims it leaked to them.
- toyg 12y agoThe two things do not exclude each other. An IP is not a magic key that will open all doors.
- mpyne 12y agoSure, but knowing the actual IP address certainly narrows down which ISP to send a subpoena to in order to image the storage of that server.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoCan the FBI issue subpoenas in the USA, don't they need the court to do that? My reading of the Cybercrime Convention they claimed to use (see my other post) means that if they needed to get a subpoena then they would need to get one before the Convention could be applied to compel the Swedish authorities to perform the search on their behalf. They don't appear to have got a warrant, a subpoena nor any judicial oversight before ordering the initial search and seizure - that appears to break the Convention. Perhaps that's why there's a footnote saying they may have asked the Swedes just for comity's sake, it's so hard to remember! What I'd really want to see to prove their position is the captured packets from their initial probing of the publicly available homepage that include the IP addresses. That would show suggest they were telling the truth [eg when matched with other peoples captures that the FBI don't yet have access to]. I'm going to go ahead and assume that they don't have that data. IMO if they can't produce that data it demonstrates the personnel in court are either completely incompetent in their positions as investigators and should be fired immediately or they are flat out lying; something tells me they're largely competent.
- Natsu 12y agoSee http://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=1688 http://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=1688 for a very readable guide to why they would rule like this. You might find it helpful to start at the very beginning of that section, which is back here: http://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=1373 http://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=1373 EDIT: Also this - http://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=2210 http://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=2210
- higherpurpose 12y agoForget the 4th Amendment - how does FBI even have the "power" to hack into other nations? What's next? NYPD hacking into other nations? (probably already happened, unfortunately)
- zipwitch 12y agoIt's the "fuck the rule of law" technicality. Coming soon, to a police state near you!