8 ms·
It's a real shame because it's really true and really needs to be addressed. We've had these conversations about gamers, about startups, about tech in general,
by freehunter 12y ago
It's a real shame because it's really true and really needs to be addressed. We've had these conversations about gamers, about startups, about tech in general, but when it comes to Linux (and related open source projects) it's somehow impossible to talk about. The community just isn't friendly and isn't inclusive, and that bad behavior goes far enough as to shut down any talk of the bad behavior.
- chris_wot 12y agoI don't know about anyone else, but when I read Linus write: "Of course, I'd also suggest that whoever was the genius who thought it was a good idea to read things ONE F✦CKING BYTE AT A TIME with system calls for each byte should be retroactively aborted. Who the f*ck does idiotic things like that? How did they noty die as babies, considering that they were likely too stupid to find a tit to suck on?" https://lkml.org/lkml/2012/7/6/495 https://lkml.org/lkml/2012/7/6/495 then I don't think I'd ever contribute to the LKML. (p.s. the irony of posting such an offensive post by starring out the u in fuck... does he not see the irony?)
- sergiosgc 12y agoLinus is great enough, and known enough, to be allowed some idiosyncrasies. If you follow LKML long enough you realize these hard language comments do not carry one tenth the negative message a primary read would convey. Note that this happens because you can read it with knowledge of the writer's personality. If it were an anonymous author, your impression would be perfectly correct. No, I know that the standard reply here is that no one is above being polite. I disagree. This is a Linus' flaw, of course, but one we can live with in the context of his hugely positive net contribution.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y ago"Oh you can advocate murder for people you don't like as long as your technical chops are in order" --you
- sergiosgc 12y ago"You can yell bloody murder as long as people know you aren't serious about it"-- really me
- vidarh 12y agoHow you managed to read that into the message above is totally beyond me.
- freehunter 12y ago>This is a Linus' flaw, of course, but one we can live with in the context of his hugely positive net contribution. Said in response to a comment by Linus directly stating that someone should be retroactively aborted (murdered).
- sergiosgc 12y agoBe reasonable. Do you seriously read that meaning into Linus' message? Couldn't it have an interpretation other than a literal one? I know a lot gets lost in written format, but ... come on!
- vidarh 12y agoIt takes an extreme lack of understanding of how people actually use English to believe that Linus was actually advocating murder with the message he made, no matter the literal content. If you seriously believe he was advocating murder, I presume you have reported the matter to the police, as in that case it is a criminal offence.
- fl0wenol 12y agoI think you should be retroactively aborted due to your unrelenting pedantry which serves no one and isn't even amusing. Just kidding, I hope you die in a couch fire.
- tomp 12y agoOn the other hand, I don't consider this bad. Sure, it's offensive, but he has quite a good reason to be upset - reading one byte at a time will be really slow. Could he say it in a better way? Obviously. Could you interpret his words in a less literal way? Obviously. I don't know Linus, but he seems a good, selfless guy, with the best intentions at heart. If he's not politically correct, who the fuck cares? Sometimes I get the feeling that even murderers are more respected, as long as they talk nice. In my opinion the insistence on political correctnes has much more chilling effect than some passionate, if insulting, words.
- kibwen 12y agoI don't think "political correctness" has anything to do with suggesting that someone is so braindead that they ought to have starved to death. Rather, you appear to be using it as a strawman to discredit the notion that we should treat people like decent human beings. As for his "passion", I don't think that resorting to public humiliation is any way to lead a project. Rather, it sounds like an item out of that "How To Minimize Employee Retention" article that made the rounds last week. Linus certainly has many good qualities that have contributed to the success of Linux. He's diligent, he's technical, and he's great at solving problems. But it's important to acknowledge that Linux has thrived despite his abrasive outbursts, not because of them.
- kyberias 12y ago> But it's important to acknowledge that Linux has thrived despite his abrasive outbursts, not because of them. No, you don't really know that! These outbursts may bother you and other people but it is also possible that they have been very, very beneficial to the community. Like it or not, they are a form of humor to many people and that may improve team cohesiveness. I for one think that the reaction to this particular retroactive-abortion-outburst as "not treating people as human beings" is taking things absolutely way too seriously.
- mike_hearn 12y agoIt's really not political correctness to just keep technical discussions calm and non-personal. Meanwhile, consider the chilling effect that kind of attitude has. I know quite a few skilled engineers who would just walk out if their boss talked to them like that, regardless of the merits of the underlying discussion. It's just wildly unprofessional and when Linus does that kind of thing, it sets the tone for all the other Linux-wannabe's who think "great engineers flame people!! i should flame people too!!".
- pekk 12y agoNot to excuse this, but this involved a person with a Finnish name who specifically CC'd Linus complaining about a perceived regression when doing things a wrong way. Note that there is even a phrase about a Finnish phenomenon, "management by perkele," referring to a militaristic managing style which steamrolls dissent with a lot of profanity. Therefore, I doubt that a random person on LKML that wasn't CC'ing Linus to complain about the bad performance of doing things wrong would draw random fire from Linus about his ability to suck a tit. Meanwhile, Steve Jobs was a total asshole to many people, including family, and this has been approved in his hagiography as a condition for his incredible inventions which revolutionized all mankind. If that is true for Apple then presumably it is also true for Linux? Or maybe we should be more uniform in criticizing for people being assholes, rather than singling out Open Source with an implicit double standard.
- jdub 12y agoThere's no double standard here. It's a conversation specifically about jerkish behaviour in the open source world, and merely having this discussion does not ignore jerkish behaviour in other companies, communities, etc.
- philh 12y agoMinor correction: the person who CC'd Linus was Alan Cox, directing Linus' attention to Jukka Ollila's message.
- mwfunk 12y agoI have no idea who these people are that you think celebrate Steve Jobs' asshole behavior. Those are not people who actually know anything about him; those are randos on crappy tech forums if they exist at all. He was an unusual person with many good and bad qualities, not all of which were factors in his success. Usually when people cite Steve Jobs' (or Linus', or anyone's) asshole moments as being somehow constructive, it's because they wish they could act the same way towards the people around them but they can't get away with it due to their own lack of power. It's not an attractive quality for someone to have. It's one thing to be somebody's lousy manager, it's another thing entirely to be envious of lousy managers.
- vidarh 12y ago> (p.s. the irony of posting such an offensive post by starring out the u in fuck... does he not see the irony?) Linus is fully capable of writing "fuck", as evidenced by e.g. [1]. If he stars it out, assume it is a stylistic choice for that particular message. > then I don't think I'd ever contribute to the LKML. If you can't handle a message like that, then perhaps it's just as well. Note the context (though I can appreciate it may not matter to you, and that you simply won't contribute regardless of it): A senior developer who have repeatedly made Linus exasperated by submitting code that Linus have had massive issues with, up to and including unacceptable levels of breakage, appears to have written code so idiotic that it should not even have occurred to him. 1 byte reads with sys-calls is a beginner mistake. Kay was/is not a beginner. He also had at that point had repeated complaints from Linus about the quality of his code, and showed no sign of listening. This conflict eventually culminated in Linus making it clear he'd had enough, and will no longer merge code from Kay until he cleans up his act [2] While I don't think I'd be as caustic as Linus, I can totally understand the level of exasperation that saga must have caused him given the series of issues in question. And at the point of this outburst, nothing appears to have worked: the stream of crap had kept on coming. [1] https://lkml.org/lkml/2012/12/23/75 https://lkml.org/lkml/2012/12/23/75 [2] https://plus.google.com/u/0/111049168280159033135/posts/Kd57G8s1cTD https://plus.google.com/u/0/111049168280159033135/posts/Kd57...
- haberman 12y ago> While I don't think I'd be as caustic as Linus, I can totally understand the level of exasperation that saga must have caused him given the series of issues in question. And at the point of this outburst, nothing appears to have worked: the stream of crap had kept on coming. I don't mean to put words in your mouth, but are you saying that being exasperated is justification to be arbitrarily caustic? There are plenty of open-source project leaders who deal with incorrigible people and do not talk this way.
- cookiecaper 12y agoIt's a style choice, and I think both the choice to utilize it and the reception to it are heavily dependent on the participant's cultural background and upbringing. A lot of people see this kind of message, applied to someone who Really Should Know Better, as a form of tough love and half-tongue-in-cheek way to place extra emphasis on an important message. Some people can form that understanding as the basis of their relationship and continue on happily, able to both give and receive this kind of criticism. To others, it is completely foreign and incomprehensible and they don't see the tongue-in-cheek at all and just interpret it as blatant, outright hostility, which is generally not the actual subtext.
- imakesnowflakes 12y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xk8n-I53Ib8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xk8n-I53Ib8 (Pulp Fiction, Wolf's speech)
- zimbatm 12y agoWhy is is that each time offensive Linus quotes are used only a handful of them show up ? Over the thousands of emails that have been exchanged in the last fifteen years there surely must exist a bigger variety.
- bronson 12y agoThis is a fantastic question!
- meapix 12y agoHow could a person who has 24 hours a day be: 1. very nice. 2. receiver of whatever shit (including good shit) people send. 3. productive. 4. responsible to make a critical system work. 5. a filter of bad code. 6. ... Without offending anybody?
- mcantor 12y ago"Offending" and "verbally abusing" are not the same thing.
- RivieraKid 12y agoAny emotionally mature person shouldn't have a problem with what you've described.
- vidoc 12y agoI'm wondering what kind of world you would like instead? Would you like those mailing lists to be an environment similar to what you have in the mass media, where political correctness and hypocrisy is rampant, and anytime someone crosses the boundary we use words like 'hate'?
- meapix 12y agoNo thanks
- EmanueleAina 12y agoWhy not find a middle ground, where one can say that a patch is incredibly broken and shows lack of attention without resorting to abusive language?
- oscargrouch 12y agoWait.. but what the guy did (whoever is) is really stupid; of the unbelievable type.. Now i imagine that Linus suffer a tremendous pressure to not let any bug pass, cause everybody in the world would eat his liver if there's a smallest security hole in the Kernel Millions of lines of C code, that run in every gadget we can think of, the guy is stressed out; and you have a "code terrorist" do deal with?! Also Linus has a strong personality, everybody knows that; so i dont see this as something bad as its being painted here; And we have to take the cultural background into account; i prefer the German/Nordic tought/transparent way than the hypocrisy/"you are great, but i will stab you when you turn your back" kind of culture (and im from a relaxed kind of culture) I Think this is more of a cultural clash
- RVuRnvbM2e 12y agoThis is why I'm glad that Debian now has a code of conduct. https://www.debian.org/code_of_conduct https://www.debian.org/code_of_conduct