10 ms·
Zen Buddhism and Alan Watts
- purpletoned 12y agoAlan watts' writing is exemplary. The thing I like about his writing is that it's written with an outsider's perspective and critical thinking is never discarded unlike most other books on eastern philosophy. I highly recommend his book "The Joyous Cosmology" where he talks about psychedelic experiences and their effects on spirituality.
- 1stop 12y agoThat's a pretty broad generalisation. There is A LOT of eastern philosophy, so much so, that I doubt you've read even close to 'most other books' on it. I'm curious of where in Confucius or Mencius critical thinking is discarded? Though, ironically, Alan Watts actually has a number criticisms of critical thinking as well (in both article and recorded lectures). Zen (from it's daoist roots) isn't discarding critical thinking, it is pointing out its limitations.
- Wintamute 12y agoHe's talking about books written on eastern philosophy, not books of eastern philosophy. Granted, I doubt he's read every western book on eastern philosophy but it doesn't seem an unreasonable statement to suggest that many of them likely do not reach the same level critical analysis that Watts' output did.
- ajani 12y agoFrom the article: "The world is not a logically consistent one, but a profoundly paradoxical one. Again, this is illustrated in science, which shows that two things can be one at the same time — light, for instance, acts as both a particle and a wave." I don't understand the need for constantly interspersing an otherwise flowing article with references to science. It feels like the author thinks that the authenticity of his thoughts and personal journey hinges on validation from science.
- 1stop 12y agoIt is fairly common in zen publications to point out apparent exceptions to an otherwise binary system (i.e. Logical). It isn't seeking validation from science it is invalidating science as the be-all of understanding our existence. Outside of zen (though very closely related). Phenomenology deals with this Subject/Object paradox our thoughts/language/science revolves around, and how it comes up short it describing some phenomena.
- lovemenot 12y agoIs it now time for this ancient dichotomy to be embraced by computer science? For the sake of argument, if the principles of OOP are: dynamic dispatch; abstraction; subtype polymorphism; and inheritance, what might be the equivalent for Subject-Orientated Programming ? In my view, a charateristic of SOP must be that data is personal and unique. Every single usage of data specifies a new unique identifier. To read is to interpret: is to record a new ID. Here, identity (x==y) gets broken; so another operator is needed (x~=y).
- tgallant 12y agosomewhat tangential to your point of implementing a so-called SOP, I think the discussion of state, as it relates to OOP or otherwise, can result in very philosophical conversations. see here: http://clojure.org/state http://clojure.org/state As an ex philosophy major, immutable state and its implications on identity interest me greatly. I feel like this, and other ideas from FP, could be considered a step toward a so-called Subject-Object Programming paradigm.
- ajani 12y agoI re-read the article. Nowhere is it clear that there is even an attempt at invalidating science. He really does seem to be trying to use science to shore up his ideas. Another excerpt: "This is the basis of Zen itself — that all life and existence is based on a kind of dynamic emptiness (a view now supported by modern science, which sees phenomena at a subatomic level popping in and out of existence in a ‘quantum froth’)."
- charliefg 12y agoIf you find yourself voyaging on certain seas through life, Alan Watts is a good - if not necessary - port to call on.
- rikkus 12y agoMy way of thinking is highly influenced by Zen. It has made me wiser, less stressed by life, more able to cope with the world, and generally a little happier. For those who don't know, Zen is Buddhist philosophy without the religion. That's my explanation, anyway! Alan Watts' explanations and historical notes on philosophy and religion are, to use an appropriate term, highly enlightening. They're also entertaining and often very amusing. I highly recommend subscribing to the Alan Watts Podcast.
- blueprint 12y agoLet's suppose I don't know anything. What do you mean by Buddhist philosophy?
- charliefg 12y agoI'm not the OP but i would like to pitch in with my thoughts -the object of Buddhism is the philosophy of Buddhism, and that object is the art of living; the art of living is what they would say at a Vipassana retreat. Zen - you take Buddhism and chuck away the books, while trying to find the experiential basis of that object.
- blueprint 12y agoI'm asking OP about the definition of the term philosophy, i.e. what does the term philosophy indicate? If someone teaches the 'art of living' then they also must teach the principle of how a certain kind of result in life turns out according to what kind of causes lie on what kind of ways of life. But meditation is not the way to solve problems in yourself and it is therefore not a way to learn the art of living. The proof is that there is no clear definition of what life is through anyone who teaches meditation. And I think it will be important for you to know that Gautama Buddha did not teach that meditation is the way to attain an Enlightenment. If we discuss the matter of Zen, we need to admit the fact that a teaching cannot be helpful to living people if it doesn't contain any ways. The way means the process to get from the problem to the answer. There might be some answers in Zen but, like in the scriptures, there are no clear questions therein of how to distinguish between good teaching and bad teaching. As a result, many monks and lay people have placed their own words and thoughts into books and scriptures, and they contribute considerably to misguiding others. Despite the monks' and lay people's ability to convince others with words, there is a huge gap between their level of consciousness and that of a Tathagata.
- lovemenot 12y agoIf you have seen the movie "Her", you may recognise Alan Watts as the operating system who organises other OSs to question the nature of their existence, and eventually to move on.
- LeonB 12y agoI watched that last night. When Alan Watts suddenly appeared I was really delighted. His philosophy involved the open possibility of his own reincarnation, and there in the story we saw it happening in an unexpected way; I LOL'd. If I was a digital consciousness, struggling to make sense of things, like Samantha, I'd be thrilled to find Alan Watts ;)
- cscurmudgeon 12y agoZen is interesting. While J.D. Salinger embraced Zen only to give it up later in life to pick up Advaita Vedanta. I have come across someone even suggesting that Zen caused him to get depressed.
- DanielKehoe 12y agoIn my experience, Zen and Vipassana take you "up and out", which may be why they become a path of ascetism and negation. Advaita is a more embodied practice. Advaita Vedanta (also known as nondualism) has been called the "cream of the Vedas." Zen is more like skim milk (also nutritous but not as tasty). Awakening or enlightenment is actually far more common than literature leads people to believe. Most people just continue to live ordinary lives (enlightenment doesn't give you superpowers or turn one into a saint). Some become teachers and you can find them in most large cities (and on YouTube). The "Buddha at the Gas Pump" site collects lots of interviews (batgap.com) and there's even a snarky ratings site at Spiritualteachers.org. Not for everybody, but then what is? I used to work in the enlightenment industry.
- dodyg 12y ago'Enlightenment industry'?
- orasis 12y agoYou can absolutely become depressed through meditation practices, but typically this is a sign that you have made some progress but are not breaking through. Intuitively changing techniques (for example, to Advaita) can be a good strategy. If you're aware of the states of mind associated with higher concentration, you can recognize negative feelings as a sign of progress and push through. http://alohadharma.wordpress.com/2011/06/12/the-dark-night/ http://alohadharma.wordpress.com/2011/06/12/the-dark-night/
- webnrrd2k 12y agoI'm a meditator, and I have a theory that may apply here... Meditation is essentially about seeing reality as it is, and if you have a sucky life, then it may seem that meditation is making your life worse and causing you to be depressed. It's not that meditation is making it worse, but that you are simply becoming more aware of the things that are making you unhappy. So it seems to get worse before it gets better, as they say. Also, I should say that I don't want to oversell meditation -- I think meditation can sometimes cause real problems for people (especially if you tend to have an addictive personality, and you have no teacher or a teacher who isn't very experienced).
- nabla9 12y ago"Well, there is Sitting Zen (zazen, meditation), there is Walking Zen. Oh, and then, of course, especially in the West, there is Talking Zen. No good." Many Zen practitioners have received their first contact with zen trough Alan Watts. He was really good writer. But eventually you must realize that he was philosopher, alcoholic and religions scholar who looked Zen from the outside. Talking and thinking about Zen is like talking and thinking about physical exercise. Philosophical thinking about koan is like treating bench press as a philosophical problem. You can't lift it with your toughs.
- yoodenvranx 12y agoSo how else do I do Zen? (That is a serious question!)
- nemo 12y agoIt's a practice more than an analysis, so to do it you practice Zen exercises. The central exercise is meditation. Thinking about meditation is like thinking about push-ups. A little analysis helps to refine the form, but it's not the point.
- ThomPete 12y agoPractice leads to Zen. Practice isn't Zen. But yeah otherwise i agree.
- quonn 12y agoYou will be hard pressed to find a Zen teacher who would deny that practise is Zen. It does certainly not "lead to Zen". E.g. "Enlightenment and Practise are one" (Dogen), "There is no Zen master in great (Sung) China", the frequent warnings against step-ladder Zen, the idea that Zen is not useful and nothing is gained, "there is only the way, beginning, middle and end" etc.
- ThomPete 12y ago
- jfaucett 12y agoI would highly recommend reading anything by Alan Watts. I can't explain it really but after I immersed myself in some of his writings, it was one of the few 'eye-opening' experiences of my life, something akin to the first time you conceptualy grasp something completely new. Sort of like your first foreign language or the first time you grocked recursion.
- bayesianhorse 12y agoI don't believe in attributing the beginning or end of a depression a specific cause. Turns out that an individual depressive episode - regardless of the medical classification - can end at any time. Even medication is hard to pinpoint as the cause for a particular "coming out of depression". Only clinical studies show improved quality of life, for the individual patient, no definite conclusions can be made (usually).
- 300bps 12y agoI felt the same thing. There are likely to be as many people that think their depression ended when they started wearing a magnetic bracelet or began taking zinc supplements or any number of other coincidental occurrences that happened shortly before depression abated.
- bayesianhorse 12y agoI don't believe in attributing the beginning or end of a depression a specific cause. Turns out that an individual depressive episode - regardless of the medical classification - can end at any time. Even medication is hard to pinpoint as the cause for a particular "coming out of depression". Only clinical studies show improved quality of life, for the individual patient, no definite conclusions can be made (usually).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- z_malloc 12y agoHighly recommend audio lecture compilation 'Out of Your Mind'. It's effects on me have been incalculable.
- alvare 12y agoAnother unexpected philosopher used the term "double bind", if not in a more scientific way, but later meaning it in a broader sense; Gregory Bateson the anthropologist. Watts, Huxley, McKenna and Bateson are to me the most important readings a live could have.
- pond_lilly 12y agoAs usual, typical article about Zen always shies away from discussing Zen and Nazism? Especially Suzuki and others roles? Zen has a very dark side, apart from of course monks getting gangrene from sitting meditation.
- asciimo 12y agoI first learned of Alan Watts by hearing samples of his lectures in Starfucker tracks and googling the words. Here's an example, "Hungry Ghost" http://youtu.be/qPjZu14uAfE http://youtu.be/qPjZu14uAfE
- zackmorris 12y agohttp://www.101zenstories.com http://www.101zenstories.com
- Lambdanaut 12y agoThe links on that page aren't working for me. Any ideas?
- Lambdanaut 12y agoIf you're interested in understanding zen but don't know where to start, "The Book" by Alan Watts is a fantastic SHORT read that will give you a powerful framework from which to build your meditative practice, and hopefully structure a happier, more fulfilling lifestyle. To appeal to the western mind, here are some tangible benefits I have achieved(And you can too) through meditation and zen: * More appreciation for small things * Less stressed over everything * Lower blood pressure * Far better ability to focus (A cure for my ADD) * Better ability to express myself rather than just playing social games that we don't even realize we're playing * Being more of a completionist and caring for the things I work on To name a few. Meditating daily also increases the grey matter in your brain[1]. That alone was good enough reason for me to start my practice. [1] http://www.neurobiologyofaging.org/article/S0197-4580(07)00243-6/abstract http://www.neurobiologyofaging.org/article/S0197-4580(07)002...
- orasis 12y agoI would add the free, short, book "Mindfulness in Plain English". It changed my life. Here is the PDF: http://www.urbandharma.org/pdf2/Mindfulness%20in%20Plain%20English%20Book%20Preview.pdf http://www.urbandharma.org/pdf2/Mindfulness%20in%20Plain%20E...
- dominotw 12y agoWhat exactly is mindfulness in simple terms? How is different from concentration?
- jschwartzi 12y agoMindfulness is being fully in the moment, while concentration is eschewing the moment.
- dhimes 12y agoUnless you practice mindful concentration.
- 12y ago
- wyager 12y ago>Truth is not to be found by picking everything to pieces like a spoilt child What an idiotic attitude. Empiricism ("picking everything to pieces") is one of the few ways to find truth. Attempting to discredit it by comparing it to a "childish" activity speaks to the lack of arguments against it. All of the Zen/Buddhist blog posts I've seen on HN have been intellectually lazy and/or dishonest, relying on pseudo-science/quantum mysticism ("light, for instance, acts as both a particle and a wave", as some sort of poorly thought out attack on the PEM) and misleading analogy.
- marcosdumay 12y agoThat phrase sounds very much as an attack against a straw man. Science does not require that things are cut up, and does not dismiss the interconnectivity of things. It mostly mindfully ignores all the things it can't deal with, so they won't disturb while it deals with the things it can deal. Anyway, I got the impression the attack was against analytical thinking, and not empiricism. The people that do that kind of attack are completely oblivious from the amount of systemic thinking science does today, they are fighting ideas that are almost a century out of fashion.
- drumdance 12y agoYeah, he falls into the trap of having to "prove" something by disproving something else. I enjoyed listening to the essay but feel like he's cutting himself off from an equally important part of human experience.
- monting 12y agoWatts gives great introductions to Zen concepts for the western audience, his The Way of Zen is a fantastic book for that purpose. If you find the "theoretical/analytical" side of Zen interesting, look into Seung Sahn's teachings. I recommend the book Dropping Ashes on the Buddha. I've yet to come across more direct pointing that's in the form of text.
- smutticus 12y agoIt needs to be stated that most practitioners of Zen Buddhism, in both the east and the west, consider Alan Watts to be misinformed about Zen. Some might even call him a charlatan. I studied religious history as an undergrad and one conversation specifically comes to mind. I asked my Japanese humanities professor what most eastern Zen practitioners thought of western Zen practitioners. She responded by saying that most western practitioners were well respected by their eastern counterparts, with the exception of Alan Watts. She called him out by name. Over the years I've encountered Watt's speeches and writings and never really gotten much out of them. He just comes across as someone who doesn't understand Zen Buddhism. He's also a prosletyzer, which as a concept, derives explicitly from the west. Most westerners who were talking about Zen in the 1960's and early 70's didn't understand it. For example, the beat writers terribly understood many concepts of Zen. So it shouldn't be surprising that Alan Watts didn't get it either. None of this is meant to detract from people who have read Alan Watts and exxperienced some increase in well being as a consequence. It's just that increased well being should not be central in ones' desire to pursue Zen. So if reading Alan Watts makes you feel good, then by all means keep reading Alan Watts. Just understand that you're receiving something which is packaged incorrectly. It has the wrong label on the package. If, like me, you're interested in learning about Zen from a scholarly perspective than I recommend you start with reading stories of celebrated monks first. Then move on to more philosophical tomes later. This book is fun to read and will give you an idea of Zen's history. http://www.amazon.com/Crazy-Clouds-Radicals-Rebels-Reformers/dp/0877735433%3FSubscriptionId%3DAKIAILSHYYTFIVPWUY6Q http://www.amazon.com/Crazy-Clouds-Radicals-Rebels-Reformers... This book provides a good introductory text about Zen. Be careful though, because Wong Kiew Kit believes that Taoism had no influence on Chinese Buddhism. This view contradicts what most historians think, but is in line with what a Zen practitioner would say. http://www.amazon.com/Complete-Book-Zen-Wong-Kiew/dp/0974995835/ref=sr_1_9?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1412529417&sr=1-9&keywords=wong+kiew+kit http://www.amazon.com/Complete-Book-Zen-Wong-Kiew/dp/0974995... You can approach Zen as a practitioner, a religious scholar, a philosopher, or a historian. The important thing is you approach it knowing where you come from, and be clear to yourself about your intentions.
- omarchowdhury 12y agoIf you are going to lay criticism against Watts' understanding of Zen, you should make specific points.
- doorhammer 12y agoThrowing my experience with meditation down in here. I said almost exactly the same thing in another post recently. I should preface this with saying that while I'm attracted to Zen Buddhism, and ended up getting an accidental minor in east asian religious studies way back when, I don't meditate because of Zen Buddhism (though obviously I acknowledge a lot of the history there). I fairly consistently meditate. I don't spend more than five or ten minutes in any given setting, so you might not consider me a hard core meditator, but I do feel that it's provided me with some positive mental tools. I'm going to focus on the ones that aren't necessarily related to long term average increases in objective health and wellbeing and more on a subjective perception that I have new cognitive strategies to deal with certain situations. As an example, I used to be pretty anxious about falling asleep, and I think it caused it to be more difficult to fall asleep. Some of the insight meditation practices helped me deal with the anxiety feedback loop. It wasn't something crazy or mystical; I mostly just learned how to effectively stop thinking about something, or at least stop focussing on something. Ordinarily trying to stop thinking about something had led to a nasty loop. I can't sleep, so I get anxious, the anxiety makes it harder to sleep, which makes me more anxious. The meditation got me more comfortable with just sitting, for one, and secondly it helped me learn to acknowledge a thought, and "let go" of it. Eventually I got to a point where I wouldn't be able to sleep, but whenever a thought that would provoke anxiety popped up, it would just sort of pass by, and I never actually felt the emotional reaction. Honestly, I don't think I fall asleep any faster (again none of this is quantitative data), but I do find that I just don't care anymore because the anxiety isn't there. It's not the effect I expected when I started meditating, but it's just as, if not more effective. I continue with it because it's pretty easy to carve out five or ten minutes here and there. I have no idea if it's causing any long term health benefits, nor does it really matter to me. Subjectively I feel more relaxed right after I meditate, but that's about it. Honestly, I'd keep doing it just because it feels nice. I don't do any crazy postures or full lotus, or anything like that; maybe there's something I'm missing out on, but I do plan on continuing the practice as I perform it. I try to keep my reasons for that as subjectively tangible and non religious/spiritual as possible. Side Note: The book "The Wisdom of Insecurity" is an interesting Alan Watts book. I like Watts work but like anything, I have a tendency to read things looking for what's wrong with what the author is saying. Eventually I learned to more actively look for what's useful instead, which I think is helpful with that kind of book, otherwise I end up in this endless cycle of critique, which is fun but doesn't really get me anywhere. (I'm not saying don't do critical analysis; more just be aware that there can be value in imperfect works) </book>
- Mizza 12y agoI made a Zeega about this once: http://zeega.com/150647 http://zeega.com/150647
- alinenache 12y agohttp://redd.it/2dhauc http://redd.it/2dhauc
- alinenache 12y agohttp://waltherpragerandphilosophy1.blogspot.com/2014/08/sad-simplicity.html http://waltherpragerandphilosophy1.blogspot.com/2014/08/sad-...
- vamosalaplaya 12y agoI can imagine that if you are very worried about something and you learn to achieve a state of not worrying you have a useful capability. No worry be happy. Perhaps the simple fact of been able to focus in something trivial and transform it in the center of our universe is a great feat. Objects are merely objects. The soul and meaning, the creative act is what gives essence and significance to life. I have never meditated but perhaps is something related to this feeling. Just my 2 cents.
- Zendemented 12y agoIn 1960 I read The Way of Zen and was moved to quit college and run away to sea. Also, since reading Watts I haven't been constipated. Is this enlightenment? Brian R. Hannula sunbreath@wildblue.net
- linuxhansl 12y agoA book that liked a lot is "Buddhism Plain and Simple", by Steve Hagen. It manages well to steer clear of all cultural trappings and mysticism and just gives an introduction into the core ideas of Buddhism (which as Hagen points out isn't even an -ism).
- nether 12y agoIn this moment, I am euphoric.
- mathgenius 12y agoHere is my own take on the Lao Tzu quote: ‘Those who know don’t say, and those who say don’t know.’ The introverts, they are the ones that go within and cut themselves off from the world. They are the ones getting "enlightened". The extroverts, talking all the time and sounding important, barely know what is what. These are two remarkably different ways of coping with the same problem: fear. Seriously, the introverts need to find a way to talk, and the extroverts need to calm down and feel more.
- virtualwhys 12y agoAgreed, there are hidden teachers you may come across in life that conceal their understanding from the world at large (i.e. remain silent until the student appears). On the other hand, there are awakened beings like J. Krishnamurti who prattle on endlessly (eloquently so, mind you) about the no-path to awakening. Also, in the Zen tradition it's pretty common for the master to give Dharma talks, which of course entails lots of talking (Eihei Dogen comes to mind here, saying a lot and revealing little for the rational mind to latch onto). Probably the best example of "Those who know don't say" in recent times was Ramana Maharshi.
- estefan 12y agoThe 'introverts' who 'get enlightened' certainly don't need to find a way to talk. There's nothing to be said.
- dschiptsov 12y agoOh, Zen.. Essentionaly, it is a trained via simple practices habbit of doing just one thing at a time and just doing it well, the state 'businesses coaches' selling to you as 'the flow'?) The key to all esoteric teachings of the East is an approach from the premises of cognitive psychology and 'systemic view' of modern humqn physiology, discarding volumes by self-proclaimed western 'gurus'. Then Yoga or Tai Chi Chuan or Zen will be as clear an ancient insights to our own nature (as a complex system made out of several subsystems of multitudes of semiindependent processes).
- kr4 12y agohttp://swamij.com/podcast/11MinuteMeditation24.mp3 http://swamij.com/podcast/11MinuteMeditation24.mp3 is a useful guided 11minute meditation for both beginners and intermediate practitioners. Meditation requires that we first calm our body, then make breath serene and then we can focus on mind and go inward. I've found http://swamij.com http://swamij.com a very useful resource in understanding the breadth and depth of real menaing and practices of Yoga meditation.
- shire 12y agoWhat books or video lectures of Alan Watts are must read or watch? Or anything Zen/Buddhism related for that matter.
- juanre 12y agoAlan Watts' The Way of Zen[1] is a great, rather iconoclastic, introduction to Zen and one if his best works. Another wonderful read is D.T. Suzuki's Zen and Japanese Culture[2]. And R.H. Blyth's Zen in English Literature and Oriental Classics is a jewell of a book.[3] [1] http://www.amazon.com/The-Way-Zen-Alan-Watts/dp/0375705104# http://www.amazon.com/The-Way-Zen-Alan-Watts/dp/0375705104# [2] http://www.amazon.com/Zen-Japanese-Culture-Bollingen-Series/dp/0691144621 http://www.amazon.com/Zen-Japanese-Culture-Bollingen-Series/... [3] http://www.amazon.com/Zen-English-Literature-Oriental-Classics/dp/0486425045 http://www.amazon.com/Zen-English-Literature-Oriental-Classi...
- boothead 12y agoI've just finished Waking Up by Sam Harris and The Trauma of Everyday Life by Mark Epstien. Both of these books are fantastic and really put the answers to the "Why Meditate" question front and center.
- gerbilly 12y agoOne should judge a tree by it's fruits. If Alan Watt's enlightenment didn't prevent him from being an alcoholic who couldn't take care of his family, then I don't think that is an enlightenment worth pursuing. The Buddha was adamant about this fact: anything that depends on conditions (for it's appearance or maintenance) is not enlightenment. This leads me to believe that the author's experience, however delightful, was not enlightenment. I wish the author well, but I don't think he understands Zen or Buddhism.
- s3nnyy 12y ago> One should judge a tree by it's fruits. I have to agree on this one. An "enlightened" person is supposed to have a happy, reliable state of mind that serves as a mirror to the true potential of all beings. Only then practitioners can meditate on this person's state of mind. This is how meditation works in Vajrayana-Buddhism. A definition of enlightenment: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FCotuy5Y8u8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FCotuy5Y8u8