11 ms·
Most People with Addiction Simply Grow Out of It
- iopq 12y agoDoes anyone else find the 1 pixel shadow on the text off-putting? I had to see why the text was blurry on purpose. Found the shadow and disabled it.
- giancarlostoro 12y agoI don't know if I'm the only one experiencing blurry font, but it distracts me from reading anything said.
- talles 12y agoMe too. There is an annoying text-shadow: 0px 0px 1px
- InclinedPlane 12y agoFolks do that because it looks "good" on safari on macs and don't realize it looks horrible elsewhere.
- kyle6884 12y agoyep, gotta love the black text shadow on black text ;)
- xuhu 12y agoBlurry in firefox here, not blurry in chrome (win7, desktop lcd).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- anotheryou 12y agoit's a hack because web-font support still sucks in many browsers. Sadly it makes things much worse in firefox.. It shall smooth out the edges which sometimes are aliased
- talles 12y ago> This is one of many reasons why I prefer to see addiction as a learning or developmental disorder, rather than taking the classical disease view. I always thought that myself but is the first time that I see an article on it. Most, if not all, addiction studies/reports/data/whatever doesn't count the people that overcome their addiction on their own, or at least on their own without causing major problems. I would be really glad if this was discussed more often.
- benbreen 12y agoI've noticed that articles like this almost always fall back on implicit "brain as computer" metaphors: "systems involved in love and sex are coming online," "impact of the drugs on the developing circuitry itself." Anyone know of an article that discusses this? It seems to be everywhere in writings about the brain but rarely acknowledged. As for the article itself - I think it has a valid point but is overly flippant about the risks of addiction and relapse later in life. Just because it's statistically less likely than in youth doesn't mean addiction is a "developmental disorder" as the author suggests.
- calpaterson 12y agoIt's explicitly named in Philosophy of Mind: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computational_theory_of_mind https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computational_theory_of_mind
- benbreen 12y agoThanks for the link - although I'm referring more to the (potentially false) analogy with present-day digital computers as opposed to the claim that the brain is a type of computational instrument, which is hard to find fault with. It's interesting how different eras apply their own en vogue technologies to understanding the mind. (I.e. Descartes and other late 17th and 18th c. thinkers visualized mental functions as clockwork-like mechanical interactions, the 20th century witnessed lots of "brain as factory" imagery, and now we're stuck on the brain as a network of computers).
- gwern 12y ago> It's interesting how different eras apply their own en vogue technologies to understanding the mind. (I.e. Descartes and other late 17th and 18th c. thinkers visualized mental functions as clockwork-like mechanical interactions, the 20th century witnessed lots of "brain as factory" imagery, and now we're stuck on the brain as a network of computers). And each era got better and better models, and closer to the truth. The future eras' models of the brain will look much more like 'a network of computers' than an immaterial soul...
- pessimizer 12y agoThis can't be true if we're still going to use the (useless) metaphor of demonic possession to describe every aspect of substance abuse.
- sp332 12y agoA demon is something scary that lives inside of you. I think it's an OK metaphor.
- pessimizer 12y agoAddictions don't live inside you, they are part of your behavior. edit: really - addictions don't live inside you, perched on your heart, making you do bad things. They are not different than you.
- sp332 12y agoRight. That's why it's a metaphor and not a real demon. It's just as scary as a demon because it feels like you can't control your actions.
- pessimizer 12y agoDemons don't exist, and their mythical properties are ascribed to real addictions. Addictions may not be incurable, they may not be uncontrollable, they may not require exorcism by an expert, they may not have been induced by sin or fed by it, Jesus may not be the answer, etc. edit: really? Happy to accept the downvotes on this one.
- betenoire 12y agoAgain, it's a metaphor. You know, like "I'm so hungry I could eat a unicorn" But unicorns don't exist you say!
- enraged_camel 12y ago
- BrindsleyQuives 12y agoI grew out of my addiction to wanking. I was at it all the time as a teenager. Nowadays I often go up to an hour between tugs.
- Mz 12y agoFYI: I don't entirely agree with this article. But I posted it in part because I seriously loathe the AA "disease" model. My dad drank heavily when he was in the army. He fought in the front lines of two wars. I think he did it at least in part so he could sleep because alcohol helps suppress dreams (and, thus, also nightmares). About four years after he left the army, he swore off alcohol and basically never touched it again. I loathe the taste of alcohol and, for most of my life, rarely have touched the stuff. But I did have a nightcap almost every night for a year at a time when I was very ill and doctors didn't really know what to do for me. At some point in there, it was not unusual for me to have two doubles with dinner -- the equivalent to four drinks. So I imagine I could have been classified as an alcoholic at that time. But when I got some answers and started getting healthier, I was happy to stop drinking. Like my father, I never attended AA, never wrestled with trying to resist temptation or whatever, etc. In my father's case, I think it helped with psychological trauma. In my case, it helped me survive illness at a time when I didn't have good answers and wasn't getting adequate medical treatment. I have read or heard plenty of other stories that look to me like they fit one of those categories. So I think the article oversimplifies things in suggesting it is just a developmental disorder, but I am thrilled to see a piece talking about the reality that most folks drink less as they get older, without getting any treatment. I really, really dislike the AA model.
- aggieben 12y agoIt sounds like you and your father weren't addicted - that sounds great for you! I currently know a number of people in 12-step programs (Christian and secular), ages ranging all over the place, who struggle with it in an entirely different way. For them, waiting for some indeterminate time at which they "grow out" of their addiction is hopeless because they and those around them suffer in the meantime. 15 years is a very long time to wait as you destroy your family and your body.
- DanBC 12y ago> At some point in there, it was not unusual for me to have two doubles with dinner -- the equivalent to four drinks. So I imagine I could have been classified as an alcoholic at that time. But when I got some answers and started getting healthier, I was happy to stop drinking. 2 glasses of whisky a day is not healthy but it's not alcoholism. This is a bit tricky to describe but I'll do my best: let's assume you had two US doubles per day. Wikipedia says that 89 ml per drink. Let's round that up to 100 ml each drink. English public health has a concept of "units" to describe drinking amounts. 200 ml * 40 (the ABV of spirits) = 8 units per day. Recommended safe limits are 3 to 4 units per day (without saving up to binge). You should try to have a couple of drink free days each week. So, 8 units per day is over that level and increases the risks of harm. Looking at definitions we see "alcohol misuse" which include "harmful drinking" and "alcohol dependency". http://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/qs11/chapter/development-sources#definitions-and-data-sources http://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/qs11/chapter/development-sou... > The definition of harmful alcohol use in this quality standard is that of the World Health Organisation (WHO) The International statistical classification of diseases and related health problems (ICD-10): "a pattern of psychoactive substance use that is causing damage to health. The damage may be physical (for example, hepatitis) or mental (for example, depressive episodes secondary to heavy alcohol intake). Harmful use commonly, but not invariably, has adverse social consequences; social consequences in themselves, however, are not sufficient to justify a diagnosis of harmful use". > In ICD-10 the 'dependence syndrome' is defined as: "a cluster of behavioural, cognitive, and physiological phenomena that develop after repeated substance use and that typically include a strong desire to take the drug, difficulties in controlling its use, persisting in its use despite harmful consequences, a higher priority given to drug use than to other activities and obligations, increased tolerance, and sometimes a physical withdrawal state". Looking at the English guidelines for treatment we see that medically supervised withdrawal starts when you're drinking 40 units per day - that would be a one liter bottle of 40% whisky every day. Here's the full guideline: http://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/qs11/chapter/introduction-and-overview http://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/qs11/chapter/introduction-an... And here's the bit for lower end: http://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/qs11/chapter/quality-statement-11-psychological-interventions-and-relapse-prevention-medication-for-adults http://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/qs11/chapter/quality-stateme...
- bkeroack 12y agoI don't dispute the article's thesis, but a significant part of the reason why addiction is skewed so heavily to the young could be because the most severe addicts die from it before reaching an older age. As in, you don't "age out", you "survive".
- InclinedPlane 12y agoThat doesn't add up. By all estimates there are many millions of people addicted to drugs or alcohol in the US alone (as many as 20+ million). If we are to assume that the article's premise that addictions tend to have a lifespan of about 15-20 years or so is due to the fact that the addicts are dying then that would correspond to something like a million deaths per year. In the sub-45 year old population that would absolutely swamp every other cause of death.
- tsuyoshi 12y agoWell, the cause of death for someone dying from their addiction is not always "drug overdose", but things like accident, murder, or suicide, which in fact are the top three causes of death for young adults.
- skinnybatch 12y agoHeart attack, respiratory failure, and other organ failure to boot. Tthe math of determining these "average" lengths of addiction are also troubling. When accounting for individuals that may have been addicted for three years, but died at the end of those three years, are we factoring in 3 years as the length of addiction? Are we weighting it in some other way along a point scale? The very title of that statistic is troublesome too: the length of addiction - it is unclear as to whether the lengths being measured and averaged share the same initial and final endpoints: The length of time elapsed between having no drug problem and recovery? Or, having no drug problem and death? Or, as I suspect a combined average, which renders the statistic useless. I find troublesome that the author of the article (renowned neuroscientist and addiction journalist as cited) suggests that addiction is akin to a habit. The behavior itself is certainly habit, but the addiction lies moreso in the etymology and function of the habit than the actual repetitive behavior. For some, the addiction is distraction, for some escape, for others a sense of identity, and so on and so forth. To prescribe "outgrowing the addiction" as a solution is awfully simplistic, almost suggesting that if an addict could only replace that habit with something else, then all would be hunky dory. Well, in theory, sure. Maybe we can start designing rehab centers like they used to do traffic school - Improv Traffic School, Comedy Traffic School, Bikers' Traffic School - maybe Knitters Rehab: "We'll help you put down that needle, and pick up this one!" or Foodies Rehab: "Stop smoking that joint, and learn to smoke these ribs!" The possibilities are endless. But not likely.
- andyl 12y agoYet another HN article that minimizes the perception that drugs can cause harm. Yes it is true that most people grow out of addiction. But many do not. In my circle I count four dead, many more damaged by drugs.
- mikeash 12y agoI also know some dead and many damaged from drugs. Mostly the legal ones, of course.
- ambler0 12y agoThe article is not trying to minimize the perception that drugs can cause harm. Rather, it is suggesting that we can reduce the harm caused by drugs by understanding addiction in a different way. Did you read it?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- freehunter 12y agoYou don't solve a problem by demonizing it and giving people unrealistic information. You solve a problem by studying the root cause and the effects, and turn that understanding into a sustainable plan. Should we reject any research or analysis into drug problems just because some people struggle with drug problems? Or should we just reject the parts that don't agree with our view of the subject matter?
- pessimizer 12y agoI can count 7 or 8 dead. I know more that died from things other than drugs, though.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wuliwong 12y agoYea but there are a lot more "things other than drugs" than drugs, right? So, your stats make drugs sound very dangerous.
- gameshot911 12y agoI liked the "Make us a habit" newsletter signup prompt at the bottom of a story (and website) about drugs/addition.
- joshmn 12y agoI'm not a psychologist but I've had a pretty fucked up mental state for many years. The same can be loosely said mental illness - for it is just that, an illness. Having said, I'm still waiting on the day that I don't need to reach for my bottle of Vyvanse (Adderall, only exponentially less shitty and more amazing) every morning.
- michaelochurch 12y agoMental illnesses also have this stigma of permanence, and it's also inaccurate and damaging. Plenty of people "snap out" of schizophrenia, or stop having bipolar symptoms, or have a few depressive episodes over a decade and then never again. We don't know why remission happens to some people and not others, but it definitely happens. We just don't understand these diseases very well. (I tend to think of depression and bipolar, for example, as symptoms common to multiple diseases.) Time of diagnosis has a major effect on how your disease is modeled (the term I would use instead of "diagnosed"). Technically speaking, if you've ever had a manic episode, you're considered to have Bipolar I, the most severe version. If you're 28 and had one at 17 and never again... you probably don't have Bipolar I. That could be cyclothymia aggravated by a hormonal or sleep disturbance. It could be a one-off. Perhaps out of a fear of getting it wrong, the medical assumption is that a person who's had one episode is prone to having more. That might be a good policy for doctors (i.e. don't prescribe certain medications to people with histories of depression, or (hypo|)mania) but it's not a great model of how mental illness actually works. Some cases get better with age, and some get worse, and we really don't know why. As addiction is a mental illness with behavioral complications, I'm not surprised. An episode of addiction is something one has to be aware of for one's life, but the treatment (don't use the drug) is something that, evidently, many people follow perfectly.
- rickmode 12y agoIf you grow out of an apparently addictive behavior, doesn't that -- by definition -- mean it was not an addiction? OK, I know the definition of an addiction is that the behavior is having a significant negative affect, but there must be some notion of lack of control too, I would think. I know plenty of my friends in college drank quite heavily. Afterward it tapered off. And some of had quite bad grades during that time. But no off us ended up as alcoholics after college. This was 20+ years ago, so one would assume real alcoholism would become apparent in this timeframe.
- gph 12y agoDo you just read headlines and then comment? I mean the author addressed your point within the first few paragraphs, yet you don't seem to be incorporating any of that into your post.
- rickmode 12y agoI'm believe I'm asking a valid question. I read the article last night when it came up on /r/skeptic. The author describes a sort of adolescent addiction due to underdeveloped inhibitions of those who having reach their mid-20s. The thesis seems to say that some addictions are situational, like the distinction between a normal situational depression and a clinical depression (one that does not trace to a person's current life situation). To restate my question: is what the author describes actual an addiction? Perhaps only those addictions that don't resolve themselves are addictions. So instead of describe the situation as the author does -- some addictions resolve themselves -- perhaps the definition of addiction needs to be refined.
- talles 12y ago> If you grow out of an apparently addictive behavior, doesn't that -- by definition -- mean it was not an addiction? No, of course not. I'm far from a specialist, but I would say that the 'addiction' definition has nothing to do with the ability to grow out of it on your own. Addiction is a compulsive behavior that the individual does despite having the knowledge that is harmful for itself. If you managed to get out of it (on your own or not) you are not an addicted person anymore. But that doesn't mean that it wasn't an addiction.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mayneack 12y ago> But although I got treatment, I quit at around the age when, according to large epidemiological studies, most people who have diagnosable addiction problems do so—without treatment. Looks like he's not claiming that no-treatment was his particular path.
- benbreen 12y agoThe author's a woman, FYI.
- 0x420 12y agoAs someone who struggled with cocaine, heroin and prescription opioid addictions throughout my teenage years, this resonates with me quite a bit, but I'm not sure if I agree with the conclusions the author is drawing. I got clean with no help either - and yet, many years later, I still consider myself "in recovery." I view my recovery as a never-ending process; even though I haven't touched the substances themselves in ages, I'm still dealing with the consequences. Just hearing someone mention one of the drugs in a conversation is sometimes enough to make my mood plummet if I'm taken by surprise. I don't really hang out in environments where they're easy to obtain anymore, but if I ever find myself in one, even though I know on some rational level that I'd never touch them again, part of me is in great distress because I'd have a hard time saying no if they were offered to me. I think these types of articles tend to ignore the longer-lasting, psychologically debilitating consequences of addiction. It doesn't just end with going cold turkey. You need to be able to look at your thought process and identify where you go wrong, and I think programs like AA and NA give you the tools to do that. Obviously, they don't work for everyone, and they aren't foolproof, but I'm of the opinion that they still have some merit.
- ugk 12y agoWell said.
- BigChiefSmokem 12y agoYou don't have answer this but I have to ask, did you find some other less severe addiction to cope - like marijuana for example? I ask because, well, your username.
- tekromancr 12y agoYour name would also imply some level of cannabis use. Also, cartoon racism.
- ChristianBundy 12y agoOh, do me next!
- RickHull 12y agoI take issue with the headline, and I didn't see any support for it in the article -- that people simply grow out of addiction. Treatment or not, we can call that process of reducing one's addictive behaviors growth, but I don't think you can find any addicts -- former or otherwise -- their families, or addiction treatment specialists, who would call that process simple.
- dang 12y agoI don't think "simple" here means they do it easily, but rather that they do it on their own.
- RickHull 12y agoIn that case, it is entirely the wrong expression to use. To simply grow out of something is to primarily yield to natural processes. Babies simply grow out of breast feeding. Toddlers simply grow out of putting random things in their mouths. Children simply grow out of name-calling and toy-hoarding. Adolescents simply grow out of feelings of invulnerability. If an addict primarily yields to natural processes, he simply behaves in complete accordance with addiction.
- jalanb 12y agoActually, speaking as a former addict, I would call it simple. Damned hard, fucking painful, betimes hopeless, ..., but the most consistent memory from my early recovery was the simplicity of the process. There really was only one thing important: stay clean. In my own case I aimed for staying clean for 2 years. And for those two years that was not "the most important thing", it was the only thing that mattered. Other factors helped too (supportive family was next most important), but I think I would not now be clean without the simplicity of that bright line rule of 2 years. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bright-line_rule http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bright-line_rule
- RickHull 12y agoRules may be simple, but adherence to them is not. For some, it may be impossible. Consider the first 2 rules of dating: 1. Be attractive 2. Don't be unattractive The rule for winning is simply to score more points than the other team. Immortality is governed by the simple rule: Stay alive None of these are simple processes, and it diminishes the discourse to treat them as such. I am thankful for your counterexample to my challenge, but I'm not convinced that, if asked sincerely about how you have managed your recovery from addiction, you could possibly sincerely respond: I simply grew out of it.
- ugk 12y agoAs a sober addict I really can't comprehend the "flavor" of addiction the author describes. Most of my addict friends and acquaintances either worked at sobriety or died from using. Actually most died. If someone can just stop, most would simply say the person wasn't actually an addict.
- tjradcliffe 12y agoI've seen this comment about "wasn't actually an addict" or "not really an addiction" in every discussion of this story, here and elsewhere. I'm very curious as to why people say this, because it doesn't seem to add anything to the discussion or take it in any useful direction. I'm not trolling here: I really don't get it, and it bugs me a bit because it seems to distract the discussion from things that might be useful (and I've contributed to that distraction here, likely... sorry.) Consider a similar case: small round blue cell tumours (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1867426/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1867426/). These present identically in routine histology done on biopsied tissue, but in fact consist of four different types of underlying disease. Neuroblastoma was identified in the 1800's. Non-Hodgin lymphoma wasn't fully classified until the 1960's. At no time did anyone say, "That's not actually a small round blue tumour" because that would have contributed nothing to the discussion. If we treat "addiction" as a name for a set of symptoms that may arise from several underlying conditions, some of which can be corrected adequately by an act of will on the part of the individual and some of which cannot, we can start to ask interesting questions like: 1) How do we identify each type of underlying condition? 2) Are there more than two underlying conditions? Is there a more complex, more useful taxonomy? 3) Given the existence of a population that ages out or chooses to stop, are there ways that we can intervene to help them that exploit the specifics of their underlying condition that are different from what has proven to be effective in the population that does not age out and is not able to choose to stop? And so on. All of these are useful, important, valuable things to say. "Then it's not really an addiction" is not.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago
- venomsnake 12y agoI think that most people just get bored/burned out with it.
- wuliwong 12y agoIsn't it possible that the issue is in the difficulty in classifying people as "addicts" instead of concluding that most addicts just grow out of it? The alcoholics in my family do not grow out of it. To a man (or woman) they just deteriorate over the years and it is a very sad thing to watch. It seems possible that what the author had and what my family members have are two different afflictions. >Moreover, if addiction were truly a progressive disease, the data should show that the odds of quitting get worse over time. In fact, they remain the same on an annual basis, which means that as people get older, a higher and higher percentage wind up in recovery. If your addiction really is “doing push-ups” while you sit in AA meetings, it should get harder, not easier, to quit over time. Clearly the author is questioning the progressive nature of addiction but not considering the well known issue of defining addiction. Furthermore, to my understanding the "progressive nature" of the disease is not referring to the difficulty in quitting but rather the severity of the abuse of the substance.
- Dylan16807 12y agoThere may be different fundamental types of addiction but what the author described sure sounded like 'addiction' to me.
- wuliwong 12y agoRight, like the fundamentally different types being: 1. The kind that goes away. 2. The kind that just keeps getting worse. for instance?
- Dylan16807 12y agoIf I get H1N1 flu with pneumonia, I might get worse and die or I might get better, but there's only one fundamental type. You can't reliably classify based on outcome.
- tjradcliffe 12y agoEpidemiologcially, similar symptoms that progress to different outcomes is one of the key tools in understanding the underlying mechanisms of a disease, so to say "you can't reliably classify based on outcomes" is incorrect. Sometimes you can, sometimes you can't, and it is always worth asking the question "how come?" when you get very different outcomes from the same disease-causing agent. In the general case there are four possibilities: 1) the different outcomes arise because of a difference in the individuals involved (this is useful for exploring treatment options: is there any way to make people with bad outcomes more closely resemble people with good outcomes?) 2) the different outcomes arise because of a difference in the disease-causing agent (this is useful when allocating treatment resources and preparing patients if the outcome is likely to be bad.) 3) some interaction between the first two factors 4) some other external factor is at play (you're a smoker, another patient is not.) As I mentioned in another comment, I've done work on cancer genetics where the goal was to find out why some patients with what appeared to be the same disease "simply fell apart" (in the words of one of the physicians) while others lived relatively long and healthy lives). There certainly was a belief that we could classify the disease based on the outcome, and that belief motivated some fairly difficult research, but no one called it unreasonable because we had similar examples in the literature (Kahn's work on small round blue cell carcinoma being a famous case in point: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1867426/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1867426/) So: when you have populations with different outcomes, it is both reasonable and routine to ask if you have different conditions, despite superficial similarities in clinical presentation.
- Animats 12y agoExcept for nicotine. That lasts a lifetime.
- SixSigma 12y agoAnd fructose. http://vimeo.com/30397537#t=40m00s http://vimeo.com/30397537#t=40m00s
- lolo_ 12y agoActually nicotine is apparently not the addictive part of smoking, rather other chemicals in tobacco are. Anecdotally I can confirm I've smoked e-cigarettes quite heavily for a few months then stopped cold turkey and had zero withdrawal or cravings, but I occasionally feel a desire for smoking a cigar quite strongly despite having them at a rate averaging a few a year. EDIT: Not majorly addictive, rather than not addictive at all. [ref]:http://www.gwern.net/Nicotine http://www.gwern.net/Nicotine
- sterlingross 12y agoFrom my experience and observations, most people don't grow out of being addicted, they simply shift their focus of addiction. This often goes unnoticed because there are many people who are addicted to things that the majority of society wouldn't consider an addiction. One might give up an "unhealthy" addiction for a socially acceptable one. Or their unhealthy addiction may simply shift, from one substance to another, or one activity to another, or one interest to another. The more I've observed addiction the more I've realized that we are all addicts. I am addicted to water, yoga, meditation, HN, reddit, coding, etc. I've even come to realize that we are actually addicted to certain types of thoughts or ways of thinking. Addiction to "negative" thoughts is what results in "unhealthy" behavior. I am currently addicted to observing myself for potential patterns of addiction and have gone so far as to create a simple app [1] that in a way takes control of the decision process away from myself. It produces a simple "yes" / "no" response and I'll ask it throughout the day if I realize I have a choice to make. "Do I go to yoga today?" -> "No". The process of giving up control of my decisions was unnerving at first, but the more I practice it, the more peaceful I have become. [1] http://www.holyspiritsays.com http://www.holyspiritsays.com
- matwood 12y agoThe coin flip decision making is an interesting and fun experiment. Sometimes when going out with friends we'll leave all decisions for the night up to the coin. It is freeing and irksome when a choice does not go the way you want.
- sterlingross 12y agoI totally agree. I actually started out using a coin, but I got too embarrassed walking around the store, standing in front of a bunch of choices, and flipping through options. The was one of the motivations to create the app, since it is much more socially acceptable and easier to use, than catching a quarter over and over.
- CPLX 12y ago20-sided dice, bro.
- 12y ago
- vacri 12y agoBy age 35, half of all people who qualified for active alcoholism or addiction diagnoses during their teens and 20s no longer do And half don't. That's still a huge number, and they're not "simply growing out of it" two decades later. "Just wait a couple of decades, you might get better" is a crappy position to take. And "chronic" means "recurring", not "permanent for the rest of your life". You can have a chronic problem that goes away after a while.
- gojomo 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias
- mm_throwaway 12y agoHere is one addiction I wish I could grow out of: benzos and other benzo like drugs such as Ambien (zolpidem). I've been on them for almost 9 years, and they are unbelievably hard to quit. I take them for my insomnia. I don't have to take much (10mg of Ambien for example), but without them I'll lay awake in bed for 8 hours not getting any sleep. I've done all the sleep hygiene stuff such as CBT or forced sleep deprivation, but it doesn't seem to work. I've been through various doctors, and I'm seeing a psychiatrist right now to deal exclusively with the sleep issue. Apparently my GABA receptors are shot from taking these drugs for so long. Unfortunately I have but two real choices: taper quickly from the Ambien and deal with 3-6 weeks of little or no sleep, or do a slow taper with Valium which only has a 20% success rate. Not sleeping for days really, really sucks.
- RankingMember 12y agoHave you tried Seroquel? That stuff is insta-knockout.
- mm_throwaway 12y agoI've tried Remeron (Mirtazapine) which at low doses is a sedating H1 antagonist like Seroquel. It worked for about 2 years and then like an idiot I started playing around with the dosages and it stopped working completely. Thanks for the suggestion though, much appreciated.
- duderific 12y agoI really feel for you. I have experienced bouts of insomnia when I've been really stressed. I got laid off twice last year in a three month span, and even after I found a better and steadier gig, the stress persisted for a few months. Additionally, my wife was pregnant with our first child as I was starting the new job. Over the span of a few months, I would have week long stretches where I might sleep 2 or less hours a night, sometimes not at all. I managed to work through it without using any medication, but it was only time and learning to trust that my body knew how to do the right thing (sleep), without my mind interfering, that eventually righted the ship.
- blacksmith_tb 12y agoThe author asks rhetorically why this is a contentious theory - but it seems like wording alone has quite a bit to do with that. A claim like "many people with addictions simply grow out of them" is already much easier to accept than "most people". Of course, there do seem to be some sorts of addictions, like alcoholism, that if anything correlate more strongly with late adulthood, which makes them resistant to this explanation.
- jessaustin 12y agoA possibly-related book I've been meaning to read is High Price by Carl Hart. http://www.amazon.com/dp/0062015893/ http://www.amazon.com/dp/0062015893/ The thesis seems to be that the entire concept of "addiction" is misleading and inimical to efforts to reduce drug use.
- joesmo 12y agoI couldn't agree more. The myth that addiction always needs some sort of intervention or treatment is quite false, yet it is constantly perpetuated by the media, doctors, and groups like AA/NA. There is a huge interest (and sometimes profits) on behalf of these groups to perpetuate this myth, of course, to the detriment of the people who suffer from addiction. I'm glad to see that the conclusions based on data differ from the uninformed propaganda that typically dominates this topic.
- curioshop 12y agoI smoked a lot of marijuana since I was 23 till about 26. I experimented with cocaine, heroin, MDMA, crystal meth for about a month when I was 25. Heroin was scarily addictive. I remember smoking from tinfoil turned black and mixing other drugs. I stopped because I got asthma and started coughing up blood. It was opiod withdrawl is the worst but I never touched drugs again. Anytime I think about my experience, it sends cold sweat, thinking how I could've done it. This is also good because I know the cold sweats keep me away from every repeating this. Its bad because I constantly think about the health implications of smoking heroin, crystal meth for about one month, and the rest of year smoking marijuana that smelled like febreeze. I hope I'm okay I haven't gone to check with a doctor tho.
- Daghrollo 12y agoMany people I know that suffer from addictions have carried them through to their later life and continue to function as part of society and generally keep their habits to themselves. I do wonder if they have accounted for this in this study. I am not saying they are incorrect but it is just a thought. =D
- girvo 12y agoThat's what happened with me. I'm an ex-heroin addict, clean for two years as of August 30th, after being addicted for 7 years prior. I just had enough... Luckily, Australia has a great support network for my situation, and I can't thank Biala enough for their help. Now I'm kicking ass and taking names :) My only disagreement is that I still think I'm recovering. I think I always will be, and I've accepted that. No rest for the wicked, I suppose. In addition, I took advantage of opiate replacement therapy, as cold-turkey was just too painful at the time (struggling with depression meant that the emotional side of withdrawals was dangerous for me). I'm finishing my taper in two months, after starting on 28mg of suboxone :)
- JacobAldridge 12y agoCongratulations on 2 years clean. Good luck with the tapering.
- adamtucker 12y agoIs Addiction linked to Environment...? Researcher Bruce Alexander of Simon Fraser University conducted an experiment called Rat Park, in 1978. From that wikipedia page: Alexander's hypothesis was that drugs do not cause addiction, and that the apparent addiction to opiate drugs commonly observed in laboratory rats exposed to it is attributable to their living conditions, and not to any addictive property of the drug itself. To test his hypothesis, Alexander built Rat Park, an 8.8 m2 (95 sq ft) housing colony, 200 times the square footage of a standard laboratory cage. There were 16–20 rats of both sexes in residence, an abundance of food, balls and wheels for play, and enough space for mating and raising litters. The results of the experiment appeared to support his hypothesis. Rats who had been forced to consume morphine hydrochloride for 57 consecutive days were brought to Rat Park and given a choice between plain tap water and water laced with morphine. For the most part, they chose the plain water. "Nothing that we tried," Alexander wrote, "... produced anything that looked like addiction in rats that were housed in a reasonably normal environment." Control groups of rats isolated in small cages consumed much more morphine in this and several subsequent experiments.
- Mz 12y agoIn pictures: http://www.stuartmcmillen.com/comics_en/rat-park/#page-1 http://www.stuartmcmillen.com/comics_en/rat-park/#page-1
- ggchappell 12y agoI wonder how much this phenomenon varies from one addictive substance to another. For example, obviously there are a lot of people who remain addicted to tobacco long past their mid 20s. Also, is it possible that some of these people who are considered to have grown out of their addiction, simply substituted one addiction for another? I've heard that the rate of tobacco use among recovering alcoholics is very high. It's true that they're probably better off being out-of-control smokers than out-of-control drinkers. OTOH, I wouldn't say such people have really grown out of their addiction.
- nemo 12y agoUnfortunately 12-step dogma has persuaded a lot of people that addiction is an inescapable fate, an innate disease/magical curse that can only be managed by joining their religious program for life. The worst part of this is that the 12 step myth of powerlessness creates a self-fulfilling prophecy. It's so colored the popular imagination of what addiction is and how to treat it that when the fact that the majority of people who are addicted to some substance do so by spontaneous remission, it seems surprising, even though that's what's normal.
- csorrell 12y agoI feel the same way about the 12 steps. I sat in on a number of meeting when I was younger and it was clear to me at the time that a many of the people there were really involved with the scene because they enjoyed wallowing in self pity and powerlessness. NA/AA gives people an excuse to be weak, and it's often used as a crutch that further enables the "powerless" in avoiding real responsibility.
- smcl 12y agoThis exact subject was covered in South Park in the episode "Bloody Mary": http://southpark.cc.com/full-episodes/s09e14-bloody-mary http://southpark.cc.com/full-episodes/s09e14-bloody-mary Often they layer it on pretty thick but South Park can be pretty incisive satire, especially as many quickly dismiss it for crass\childish humour.
- rando289 12y agoThe author equates "not seeking professional help" with "growing out of it", which I don't think is right. However, he gets a lot right, and links to studies. My personal two biggest problems with 12 step: insistence on believing in a godlike thing and it's dogmatic unchanging nature which ignores science.
- techtalsky 12y agoI'm a little shocked that out of 124 HN Comments (at the time of this writing), no one has linked to or referenced the study in any way. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3227547 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3227547 Did I read it? No, but I read the abstract and intro. Study was about adults addicted to nicotine, alcohol, cannabis, or cocaine. 43k people total, about 12k people with a real DSM-IV diagnosis of addiction to one of these substances. Eventual remission rates for these things were over 90% (except nicotine, which was 88%). The study is interesting, so let's start there. The results of the study surprised me, personally. I wouldn't have guessed the remission numbers were that high. I would have liked to see heroin, meth, or, far more pervasive in this day and age: prescription opiates. It's certainly nice to see good news, and I do consider the study a kind of good news. The study obviously doesn't overstep its bounds or draw any big conclusions. I'm sure the people who actually did the study knew and experienced how damaging drugs CAN be in those 15-25 years before remission. However, then we get to the article. The author runs the site substance.com and has published a book and several articles with a strong point of view about 12 step programs and the way young people with drug dependence are treated in today's society. I do think she's bending the study a little to her own aims, but I do appreciate her call towards sanity. It's a stretch, but I don't think she's being unfair to use this study to support her approach. I don't think soft-selling the total life destroying danger of drug abuse is wise, and obviously it would suck if someone started taking drugs because they read an article or study like this, but it's possible.
- b1daly 12y agoI think the author has an important point to make, which could be helpful for those struggling with addiction and find that the model of the disease and total abstinence suggested by 12 step groups doesn't fit in some. Anecdotally it seems to square with my observations of long time friends. That said, I do think that there "a thing" that has aspects of a disease. The belief structure was created by folks from e early part of the 20th century, so there concept that the disease was a permanent affliction was probably just not correct. I tend to look at addictions as a subset of obsessive/compulsive disorders, which has an additional chemical feedback loop enhancer. Overall, our understanding of mental illness is woefully undeveloped. Most cases are diagnosed by interpretations Of subjective and self reported symptoms. The last time I looked at a discussion of this related to the new DSM, the very low interrator reliability I the diagnosing of mental illness was scandalous. Doesn't mean it's not a real thing though.
- anon_addict 12y agoI was a hardcore IV heroin and cocaine addict for 10 years. Contracted Hep C, did 2 years in jail, and ruined every relationship that I crossed paths with. After dozens of detoxes, jail, prison, several rehabs, and a year of homelessness on the streets of NYC for an entire winter, I had had enough. I moved to Cali and got back to my roots, computers. I picked up HTML / CSS and started learning Javascript. I started doing websites for people eventually I started a consulting business I later sold for a nice chunk. I now have a profitable start-up and was recently offered a CTO position at a Fortune 100 company. I grew out of it. I don't want to get high anymore. It has been 10 years. I don't drink or smoke weed, and have no desire to. I still have addictive behaviors, but it just isnt an option anymore. Posting from a throwaway obviously this is not something I am ready to share at this point in my life but just wanted to relate for a brief moment.
- pestaa 12y agoThanks for your story. It must have been tough, rebuilding a whole life. Good luck.
- erikb 12y agoPeople grow out of it? Seriously? I don't like seeing addiction only in the traditional way of hardcore drugs, alcohol, etc. There are loads of addictions that aren't even recognized by doctors as such, but are quite far spread. Most of all cigarettes (I don't know any person who gets treated for cigarette addiction), sugar, gambling, virtual realities like tv shows or digital games. In Germany I feel over 50% of the people around me smoke. In nerd circles around me over 80% of people are addicted to either sugar, caffeine, or gaming. In my family I even have 2.5 cases of serious alcohol addiction that is neither treated nor recognized by the addicted. And I live in a middle class family. In lower class families it might be much worse. Maybe I misunderstand the article, but I think saying that most people grow out of addiction is way off reality. I'd argue most people on this planet are hooked to at least one thing, and nearly nobody drops their addictions. I personally are certainly addicted to sugar. If I don't get my coloa/chocolate/icecream, I feel tired, hungry, sad, and am sometimes in pain, can't think about something else but sugar, and sometimes even walk long distances in the middle of the night in the worst of weathers to get to a 24 hours shop to buy something, if I don't have something at home. Telling this to doctors just yields them saying I'll get diabetes (or might already have it) if I don't change my behaviour, which is pretty much what I already know. Requesting general addiction treatment or food advisory training is not covered by my health care, they say.
- Stronico 12y agoI think it is useful to separate out the concepts of substance abuse from substance addiction. If the article just dealt with who experience powerful cravings and withdrawals (the most common definition of addiction, and the most useful as far as I can tell) then it would be much more insightful. Instead it seems to equate addiction with heavy use and recklessness.
- fnazeeri 12y agoInteresting point: "The data supports this idea: If you start drinking or taking drugs with peers before age 18, you have a 25% chance of becoming addicted, but if your use starts later, the odds drop to 4%. Very few people without a prior history of addiction get hooked later in life, even if they are exposed to drugs like opioid painkillers."
- vonnik 12y agoStrangely enough, this is also true of religious cults.