6 ms·
> If Facebook scans my chat logs, […] their TOS permits them to scan my chat logs. Your language betrays your cognitive dissonance. It it not your chat log.
by teddyh 12y ago
> If Facebook scans my chat logs, […] their TOS permits them to scan my chat logs.
Your language betrays your cognitive dissonance. It it not your chat log. It was never your chat log. You typed characters into Facebook’s chat log, and the chat log is Facebook’s. There is no “permitting” needed. When you use Facebook (or Google, or whatever), you live in a glass house, an aquarium, with overseers who do not consider you a person with integrity, but more as a kind of pet to be inspected and analyzed at will. Facebook distracts you with “privacy settings”, but those apply to other pets in the aquarium, not its overseers. It might be discomforting to think of yourself as a pet in an aquarium, but you have chosen this yourself, by using Facebook.
The question if Facebook is permitted to scan your chat logs is therefore meaningless; there is no such concept. Facebook “scans” all its chat logs, all the time. (That’s why they have their chat logs.) The “privacy settings” have nothing to do with actual privacy from Facebook — like Monopoly money, it has no validity outside the tiny world of its own. Like “deleting” things, it appears to you to delete things, but does not actually delete them as far as Facebook is concerned — it is all logged and saved, forever. I could go on, but I’d better not.
(The same goes for Google and all the other cloud and social services.)
- 1ris 12y ago> The “privacy settings” have nothing to do with actual privacy from Facebook — like Monopoly money, it has no validity outside the tiny world of its own. See also: People who believe they can disable the face recognition.
- brador 12y agoAlso people who belive Chrome incognito mode means Google does not know what you're typing into that address bar and that there's no history or log of what you just visited.
- XorNot 12y agoIncognito mode is as upfront as possible that websites can record what you type. It's not what incognito is about, or meant to be about.
- sp332 12y agoIt's not "websites" that record what you type, but Chrome itself that sends every character you type into the address bar back to Google.
- UweSchmidt 12y ago> It it not your chat log. It was never your chat log. You typed characters into Facebook’s chat log, and the chat log is Facebook’s. But... that's just a cynical observation of the current, wild-west-style situation of data abuse. Society will slowly grasp the significance of what's going on and restore some sanity, ...right??
- teddyh 12y agoI am convinced that it will only happen if we succeed in making it a political issue. No one company or service can fix this, since all the incentives work towards more surveillance, not less. This type of so-called collective action issue is what politics and lawmaking exist to solve, so it is there a solution must be created.
- vertex-four 12y agoAt the least, those of us who actually care, but don't have infinite amounts of time to admin a LAMP stack, email server, XMPP server, and whatever else, will eventually be able to run Sandstorm[0] on a home server and be done with it. (I'm working on an appliance distro which will set this up more-or-less automatically.) [0] https://sandstorm.io/ https://sandstorm.io/
- kentonv 12y agoHey, I'd like to hear more about this "appliance distro". E-mail me? (kenton@sandstorm.io)
- freshhawk 12y agoBut the best we can ever do is make it "wrong" with some non-perfect level of enforcement. They will always have the ability to do what they like with the data they have control over.
- conradfr 12y agoIs it then a regression then from telephone and postal mail times ?
- teddyh 12y agoYes, because with postal mail (a.k.a. snail mail) it was both technologically hard to open and scan mail without detection, and expensive to employ the number of people necessary to do it. With phones it was not hard at all technologically, but still expensive to employ people, and it was also rather expensive to record and store the data thus obtained. Today, the technology to scan everything and keep it forever is trivial, and storage is very cheap.
- zanny 12y agoPGP is a thing, that makes your mail mathematically impossible to open by brute force. And you can self host your own XMPP servers or use any other peer to peer chat client like SIP.
- teddyh 12y agoAnd encrypted snail mail has been a thing since ancient times. So what?
- rosser 12y agoCall me when that's something my mom can do. She needs secure communications too.
- zanny 12y agoHave her sign up to a secure XMPP provider and communicate over that. Or host her an XMPP server on your end she can use. It is as simple as register -> use an xmpp messenger -> secure communications.
- torrent-of-ions 12y ago> Facebook distracts you with “privacy settings”, but those apply to other pets in the aquarium, not its overseers. Indeed. I have argued before that the "privacy settings" are actually harmful. You should be making everything publicly available, because why would you give facebook access to this data but not your friends? Unfortunately this is contrary to what most people think. Of course, facebook doesn't actually allow users to make all the data available, in fact it's not even available to the user himself.
- dantheman 12y agoYou give your doctor information you don't give your friends, you give your telephone company information you don't give your friends. There are reasons to give private entities information that you don't want shared with the world.
- rayiner 12y agoAbsolutely right. If you SSH-ed into my personal computer and started typing into a file, everyone would laugh if you claimed that what was in the file was your data. You're not doing anything different when you type into Facebook. If it quacks like a duck its a duck. Its data that sits on their systems, that you have no legal or contractual protection over. Its not your data, its their data. You're just the one generating it. Folks desperately want to deny the physical nature of cloud services, and pretend that its the same as storing something on your hard drive at home. They want to believe that the software abstraction that shows local and cloud documents together is real. But you can't will away reality.
- teddyh 12y ago> If you SSH-ed into my personal computer and started typing into a file, everyone would laugh if you claimed that what was in the file was your data. You're not doing anything different when you type into Facebook. Actually, I disagree on that detail. An account on a Unix computer, accessible by SSH, is a known thing with known cultural implicit privacy guarantees. I have servers, which I can certainly call “mine”, with users, who have SSH access. I would absolutely not consider any file they type into to be “mine” — it is theirs.
- rayiner 12y agoThose are just expectations. They're not anything you can beat someone over the head with, and as such are illusory.
- Beltiras 12y agoThe ethical sysadmin may think like that but the owner of the box has sudo (by proxy by replacing said sysadmin with a pliant one). Data then belongs to the box owner.
- jlgaddis 12y agoI certainly agree with you and I feel the same way but we aren't corporations (well, I'm not and I'm assuming you aren't either). I host e-mail for many others on my personal mail server and the only times I've looked at someone's mail was to troubleshoot an issue (and that just involved grep'ing to find the right file (maildir) and then examining the headers).
- swat535 12y agoyou have taken a highly condescending and counterproductive method of argument. You list neither the specific provisions in the TOS, nor does you cite any law or custom to validate your position. 1) messages sent through chat are not specifically covered by Facebook's TOS, as such, the individual's premise that it is is false 2) whether or not the content is Facebook's property is irrelevant, privacy laws in QC forbid publication of this content under most circumstances (exceptions being public safety etc finally, anyone who honestly thinks anyone working for Facebook has any occupational need to look at their chat logs has a rather inflated opinion of themselves
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- teddyh 12y agoActual publication of anyone’s chat logs is not what anyone is reasonably concerned about – it is a diversion. The real thing which Facebook does is total information analysis of everything about everybody, storing this analysis internally, and making the results available to unknown numbers of external parties, or alternatively allowing external parties to specify analysis algorithms to be specified, run them internally, and report the results to external entities. None of these things involve publication of any actual content provided to Facebook. Also, the idea that the danger is that Facebook employees should read any chat logs is also a straw man argument – a distraction. Nobody except straw men actually puts forth this as a major problem. You would have been right to dismiss it, except that nobody made that argument. To be fair, it might happen, but the scale at which it even could happen is by definition limited, since Facebook cannot have that many employees with the time and inclination to do it. The real issue is the above procedure of eternal storage and analysis – on behalf of external parties and/or for internal use. Your arguments are highly diversionary, and seem to be aimed at confusing the issue.
- swat535 12y agoFacebook has the ability to scan and monitor chat logs and this is not prohibited either by their TOS or provincial law (for Quebec at least). However I am not sure you realized that I took the discussion a step further by pointing out, although I admit I should have made this clear to begin with, that the concept of ownership of the content of said logs can be divided into several different aspects. There is the intellectual ownership (the ideas contained in the logs), there is the right to consult and have access to the logs, there is the publication right etc. These rights are also independent of one another, someone may have the right to consult the logs, but not to publish, or may have the right to publish, but only once someone who has the right to consult this information has given it to them Also, it bears mentioning that simply claiming my argument is a straw man argument without actually telling me how that is so does nothing to show that it is so the issue of ownership was discussed in the first half of my commentary where i mentioned that Facebook's TOS allowed them do do what was described as such I addressed and confirmed OP's position I then added that there were implications with what was being discussed and proceeded to give an example. Taken alone, yes it would be a straw man argument on my part, however, the point behind my commentary was to show that the practical damage that could be done by such a practice as monitoring and storing the information of chat logs would be minimized by the fact that not everyone can consult and publish that content