6 ms·
It was a bizarre choice to throw the album into everyone's library, rather than just feature it on the iTunes front page as a free download. They probably wante
by baddox 12y ago
It was a bizarre choice to throw the album into everyone's library, rather than just feature it on the iTunes front page as a free download. They probably wanted people to discover the album faux-serendipitously, but I feel they showed a profound lack of understanding of (or disregard for) people's music listening habits and preferences.
- tpurves 12y agoThis. The whole thing could have been handled so much better so easily.
- ivraatiems 12y agoYou are certainly right, in my opinion, but I think that it's even more important to note how tone-deaf this move was in light of the recent iCloud leaks (I'd argue, in fact, that all of Apple's recent press conference was similarly confused). Nobody wants to think about the idea that Apple can do/see anything they want at any time to our music collections and phones. Even if that isn't strictly true, and even if they probably wouldn't, it's a perception that's being confirmed by recent events, and this stunt re-enforced it.
- jedmeyers 12y agoSince when was it proven that the leaks were due to iCloud vulnerabilities? There were a lot of allegations, sure, but no hard evidence. If someone guesses your GMail password and leaks your mail - was it a GMail leak?
- ivraatiems 12y agoIt's not proven, but honestly, that doesn't matter. This is all about public perception. If it feels like Apple did something wrong, they might as well have, at least as far as their PR response ought to be concerned.
- gress 12y agoNot only is it not proven, it is proven false. But, I totally agree that this U2 move was absurdly ill considered.
- ivraatiems 12y agoApple of all companies supposedly knows the value of appearances (see, for example, their purchase of Beats). I think maybe this was a "too much Kool-aid" kind of moment, where they just forgot that not everyone sees their services like they do.
- gmu3 12y agoWhere was it proven false? I saw them say it wasn't them, but that's not really solid proof.
- gress 12y agoIf there is no evidence, and they have stated that it wasn't them, anything else is malicious innuendo. Google recently stated that the 5 million sets of Google account credentials were not stolen directly from them and only 20% of them were valid. Is this also 'unproven'?
- chmars 12y agoSpeaking of 'free download': The album was shown as purchased in the iTunes Store app but there was no way to download the files, i.e., to have the album in my own library instead of just the ability to stream it via the iTunes Store. A well-known BitTorrent search engine let me solve the issue.
- micampe 12y ago> there was no way to download the files This statement is not true.
- MBCook 12y agoDepending on how your preferences are set in iTunes it may now show up in your music lists even though you 'own' it. I ran into that myself.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ssmoot 12y agoIt'll show up in your Purchases list in the iTunes Store though. You can download it from there. At least I'm pretty sure that's how I got it. IIRC clicking the "Purchased" button actually took you there.
- MBCook 12y agoI turned on the 'purchased in iCloud' content to my library, found the tracks, and clicked the 'download from cloud' button that shows up next to them. My first reaction to all this was "Cool, I'll give it a try". I found it in the iTunes store and it said 'Purchased' and... I couldn't download it. I waited 2 days before trying again to figure out how to do it. Very odd.
- seanflyon 12y agoYou're right, it only appeared as if there was no way to download the files.
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoWhat does this decision, vetted by dozens of executives I imagine and definitely by Cook himself say about our Cloud-ified technological lives? Its just crazy to me that they can just throw music into your collection without even asking for permission. There's something really arrogant about Apple right now. I'm not sure what other word could possibly describe this. What boggles my mind even more is that U2, for all its popularity, is a poorly aging nostalgia act. Heck, I'm an old Gen-X'er and I barely remember their heyday with the Joshua Tree. Tweens and Millenials probably only see them as a band their parents listened to. There's really something off-putting about this. If it was Kanye or something, I could see the appeal, as he's popular now and has a wide-range of fans, but U2? We've long outgrown stale classic rockers and music popularity is very much not this monolithic structure anymore. If anyone should know this, you'd think the guys who run iTunes would.
- joezydeco 12y agoMy gut feeling is that Cook & Company wanted to be able to pull a Jobs-like move upon announcement "The album is completely free to everyone and IN YOUR IPOD RIGHT NOW" ...especially since everything else announced was a wait (for the phone) or WAY away (like the watch).
- baddox 12y agoI personally don't find it as sinister as you make it sound. It's mostly just a user interface/experience issue. I don't see much relevance to privacy issues or the cloudification of life.
- snarkyturtle 12y agoDid you completely miss the hundreds of nude celebrity photos taken from the cloud two weeks ago?
- baddox 12y agoI'm not referring to that situation. I'm saying that I don't find any particular relevance of the U2 situation to the celebrity photo scandal.
- roc 12y agoI honestly think it was accidental. It looks like a classic case of a simple executive decision that appeared so trivial as to skip a careful consideration of the implementation. Which isn't to excuse it: it was very un-Apple-like. And it certainly wasn't the only un-Apple-like turn last week.
- vlunkr 12y agoI kind of thought people in the tech community were just overreacting, but I've since heard plenty of people who don't follow tech news complain that it was creepy or weird or something similar.