6 ms·
Every time I see discussion about the nine dash line, I can't help but wonder how it can seem sane to anybody that China should have the water rights to an area
by adventured 12y ago
Every time I see discussion about the nine dash line, I can't help but wonder how it can seem sane to anybody that China should have the water rights to an area ~600 km south of what is blatantly Vietnam's coastal waters (and the southern tip of their land) and just barely north of Malaysia's physical territory.
I know the correct answer is: China doesn't care, and isn't concerned with reason when it comes to the nine dash line. It still boggles my mind.
There is no valid Chinese claim on those waters, there is only who has the military power to dictate terms.
- anigbrowl 12y agoTo quote a Chinese official from a few years ago 'Vietnam is a small country and China is a big country and that is just a fact.'
- melling 12y agoSo, what you are saying is that every time we buy something that's "Made in China", we are fueling the next major military power, which in turn will lead to a major conflict in the area?
- paulrosenzweig 12y agoI'll still likely get the iPhone 6.
- anigbrowl 12y agoI meant it more as a summary of China's strategic philosophy, which seems to be that the weak must inevitably give way to the strong. I don't know about a major military conflict, but China certainly seems to to be adopting a more...experimental posture.
- melling 12y agoWeak is a relative term, right? Vietnam is "weak". How about the other countries in the region? Japan? Russia? I don't think it's called experimental when you flex your military muscle.
- anigbrowl 12y agoOther countries in the South China sea are mostly weak too, other than Japan. The big factor is the United States, due to its treaty relations with other countries in the area like Philippines, Japan and Taiwan. But you know that. I'm calling it experimental because they seem to be exploring their options rather than seeking head-on confrontation in the manner of Putin - I get the sense that China is not sure of its strategic position and is probing to see whether it could establish a 'new normal' without actual conflict. But that's just a hunch on my part, I have no special insight.
- josefresco 12y agoOr... you could say that every time you buy something "Made in China" you're solidifying the co-dependent relationship between the US and China, thereby reducing the chance of conflict in the future.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoVietnam fared fairly well against China the last time they fought over Cambodia.
- jonyt 12y agoIt wasn't that clear cut the last time: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sino-Vietnamese_War http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sino-Vietnamese_War
- xnull2guest 12y agoAlmost exactly the tactic and politics Israel uses. If there's violent conflict, the lesser power is 'terrorist' and this justifies the use of greater militaristic power to squelch the rebellion. If there's no violent conflict the greater power continues to push into the area it wants and plays coy with the politics for recognizing the other state's legitimacy.
- fsiefken 12y agowhy was the above voted down? what's wrong with the parallel with Israel's settlement policy?
- philosophus 12y ago"there is only who has the military power to dictate terms." That's generally how these things work, yes. What were you expecting?
- adventured 12y agoThat's exactly what I was expecting.
- peteretep 12y agoDevil's advocate: if you say the Spratly Islands are Chinese, then the line makes pretty good sense.
- chj 12y agoJust think about Falkland Islands.
- ultraboy 12y agoTerritorial claims is NOT base on distance.Is Hawaii to far to be a state of the us?
- melling 12y agoDoes the US claim all the ocean between the west coast and Hawaii? No, because it's too far from land.
- akfanta 12y agoI am not sure where you are going here. China didn't claim all the ocean either, they want the islands.
- redguard 12y agoAre you Chinese red guard? China does claim the ocean area. See the hilarious map here: http://news.bbcimg.co.uk/media/images/54145000/gif/_54145268__48951920_south_china-sea_1_466-1.gif http://news.bbcimg.co.uk/media/images/54145000/gif/_54145268...
- briandh 12y agoNo. They want the islands as a means to claim the surrounding waters, which which have a lot of real and potential value in fisheries, sea lanes, and offshore oil. The islands themselves are not very valuable.
- BrandonMarc 12y ago... also worth mention: they're not too happy with the US Navy operating freely within the South China Sea, even if the rest of the world calls it "international waters". The red line in the map is what they'd rather keep a powerful non-China navy out of, for both defensive and offensive reasons.
- mason240 12y agoWhat is being unsaid here is that the whole reason China needs those islands is because their territorial waters are completely surrounded by other countries. In order for Chinese ships to reach the open Pacific, they have to go through either Russian, Japanese, Philippine, or Vietnamese waters. Getting these islands mean they get an outlet to open seas.
- ekianjo 12y ago> there is only who has the military power to dictate terms. Yeah, just like the American invasion of Iraq in 2004. Just because they could, despite it being unlawful at all international levels. But hey, Russia also does it, so there's not really any good example out there of a country that does not seize opportunities.
- mikeyouse 12y ago> Yeah, just like the American invasion of Iraq in 2004. The US war in Iraq started in March, 2003.
- ekianjo 12y agoAlright, I was one year off.
- justin66 12y agoThe United States never made a territorial claim to any part of Iraq.
- ekianjo 12y agoWhen you come with a large army, invade the country, remove the local government, and replace it with puppets working for your country's interests, "territorial claim" is just a twist of words.
- justin66 12y agoSorry, but that's stupid on a number of levels. First, territorial claims can be made with or without war, the later of which is (thankfully!) what we're actually talking about with China and the islands. Second, anyone who thinks that the government in Iraq has been a puppet of the United States just isn't paying attention. I get it, you don't like the United States, but you're desperately trying to draw equivalencies that do not exist. It's been a really long time since the US annexed anything. That doesn't make the loss of life that occurs in its small wars any less serious but you cannot talk about international events if you lump everything bad that happens in the world into the same ill-defined category and then use whatever labels you have at hand to refer to that category. Annexation isn't invasion. They might be associated - Russia annexed Crimea after an invasion, after all - but they're not the same thing. If simply using terms properly doesn't move you, then there's this: you can tell a lot about a county's ambitions based on what its territorial disputes are and what it's trying to acquire. In this annexation = invasion world that you're inhabiting, you'd conclude that the United States wants to colonize the Middle East. I assure you that this is not the case. We just want to buy their oil, aside from that we don't give a damn about them. Not saying whether that's smart or ethical or not, but that's the reality.
- est 12y agoThe problem is not China, you should see everyone else's claims. Vietnam's claimed and occupied islands are just as ridiculous as China's. In fact ASEAN could not stand together against China in this case is exactly because every country around South China Sea has conflicting claims. BBC is trying to avoid this as much as possible. Facts are hard, Let's just blame bad China.
- JDShu 12y agoI was very surprised when I found this out. It makes sense though - just like in any negotiation, you don't start with what you're willing to settle for, you start with what you want. In general, there are always two sides to the coin. Where from an American perspective you see Chinese aggression outwards, if you flip the arrows on the map around, you might notice that from a Chinese perspective, the US is aggressively boxing China in.
- HowardMei 12y agoYou nailed the point. The continuous expansion of the Japan-US ADIZ(Air Defense Identification Zone) in east China sea in past decades could reflect a lot of things never will be mentioned in English media.
- akfanta 12y ago> In general, there are always two sides to the coin This exactly. Media blames China for everything that went wrong on this planet, and people believe it without thinking twice. It's funny because as a Chinese, I thought we were supposed to be the only one that got brainwashed.
- trhway 12y ago>there is only who has the military power to dictate terms. officially it is called "international law"
- HowardMei 12y agoSouth China sea had been the traditional 'naval silk road' of ancient Imperial China for hundreds years while both China and the neighboring tribes/countries under tributary system hadn't learned the concept 'nation' from the western colonists. Since 17th century, a few islands had been controlled by various western countries and more had been marked or renamed.But the pirates, armed merchants and provincial navy of imperial China were still the dominant power in the area for a long time. Chinese people totally lost control of it after the Sino-French war which changed the geopolitical status drastically: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sino-French_War http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sino-French_War The nine-dash line stems from the eleven-dash line when ROC was the ally of the US after WWII and was accepted as the transferee of those islands from Japanese army who had acquired them from France/Great Britain. But the ROC were too eager to fight back to the mainland instead of sending naval troops to guard those islands.It just chose one island Taiping as a strong point. The unattended reefs and islands have been occupied by various countries in all kinds of sneaky/funny ways merely in past 30 years after the US-Vietnam war. The validity argument makes no sense in this 'occupy and claim to own' game. Every country is a thief and the biggest is Vietnam whose navy had been more powerful than China's with the support from the former USSR during the PRC-USSR conflict. Maybe the ROC in Taiwan should be the rightful owner according to the arrangement after WWII. But it is too weak to say anything now. The whole history of the area is a vivid example of military power dictates terms.