7 ms·
Scots, What the Heck?
- fideloper 12y agoMy sister lives and works and Scotland on visa (we're American). She (and others in her position) are worried that this passing may well end up with her visa not getting renewed or cancelled as they are UK viasas rather than Scottish ones. Could be interesting times for ex-pats living in Scotland!
- christop 12y agoIf it passes, Scotland won't actually become independent until 2016, so there's no worry there. But in any case, there would be no reason for Scotland to make the existing UK and European standards stricter, especially for people who were already legally in the country before independence.
- scottmcf 12y agoThe plan is for Scotland to honour all current visas. Any reapplications/extensions/etc would then just go through the Scottish system thereafter rather than the UK system. The intention is also to make immigration to Scotland easier and more forgiving, and expand the number of visas granted, not tighten up the rules. http://scotreferendum.com/questions/i-am-living-in-scotland-on-a-uk-visa-what-would-happen-to-me-at-day-one-of-independence-would-i-need-to-get-a-scottish-visa-straight-away/ http://scotreferendum.com/questions/i-am-living-in-scotland-... http://scotreferendum.com/questions/what-will-an-independent-scotlands-policy-be-on-immigration-how-will-it-be-different-from-the-rest-of-the-uk/ http://scotreferendum.com/questions/what-will-an-independent...
- k-mcgrady 12y agoAFAIK an independent Scotland would be more open on immigration, plus independence will take several years to sort out, so I wouldn't worry.
- Finbarr 12y agoAs a Scot living in the US, I'm curious to know what's going to happen the other way around. I'm concerned about what will happen to my British citizenship in the event of independence. It seems like Scotland would introduce its own citizenship and passport with independence, but it is unclear what would happen to existing British passport holders of Scottish descent. If the answer is dual citizenship, I wonder how this will affect the availability of public services over time. For example, as a holder of both passports, would I be free to pick and choose which country I draw a pension from, get healthcare from, and pay tax to? For me, there are too many unanswered questions. Currency is the tip of the iceberg.
- sparkzilla 12y agoYou are not the only one with this concern. Despite being out of the country for a long time I would prefer to keep my British passport. I'm also annoyed that I don't get a vote on whether my nationality will change.
- peteretep 12y agoWhy would your nationality change? You would simply gain an option on another nationality.
- sparkzilla 12y agoI am British and have a British passport. If there is a Yes votes I will have to change to a Scottish passport, which I believe will have less value, or an English passport, which is not my identity. Neither of those is a good choice. Ex-pat Scots, whose nationality will be affected by the result, were specifically denied the vote, while English people and other nationalities, including Germans and other Europeans living in Scotland, have been allowed to vote. Complete insanity.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> I am British and have a British passport. If there is a Yes votes I will have to change to a Scottish passport, which I believe will have less value, or an English passport, which is not my identity. Er, no one has proposed that England become independent of the UK -- if Scotland leaves, you could have a Scottish passport or end up with a British passport. The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland -- comprised of England, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland -- without Scotland will still be the United Kingdom of (most of) Great Britain and Northern Ireland -- comprised of England, Wales, and Northern Ireland.
- tbatchelli 12y agoIndependence is a tradeoff. On one side, they'll put the issue of not having currency and other downsides, on the other hand they'll put the benefits that they see fit. Krugman's argument might be sound, I don't know, but I don't think it's the only argument.
- k-mcgrady 12y ago>> "Independence is a tradeoff" People seem to forget this and focus on a few individual issues instead of the bigger picture. In the end nobody really knows what will happen. I feel both sides have failed at answering people's questions but that's mainly because they don't know the answers to a lot of them. The decision either way will be majorly uniformed. I think for a lot of people it will be a question of 'I don't like the way things are and this is a way to possible change that'.
- sparkzilla 12y agoHope is not a policy.
- k-mcgrady 12y agoI didn't say it was.
- msabalau 12y agoAnd, of course, if they are independent, they'd have the ability to delink their currency from the pound later, even if that isn't their intent at the moment.
- christop 12y ago> And it wasn’t just Spain, it was all of southern Europe and more. Even euro-area countries with sound finances, like Finland and the Netherlands, have suffered deep and prolonged slumps. I hadn't heard of troubles in those two countries before before, though I'm sure like pretty much every country in Europe — or indeed the world — they didn't go entirely unscathed during a global financial crisis. Scotland, the UK as a whole and other western European countries aren't exactly in the depths of recession and unemployment that have been happening in Spain and Greece, for example. Note the lack of mention of Norway (not that it's a eurozone country), which is in an incredible financial position with a $900bn fund made up primarily by saving a portion of oil revenue. While Norway has had 15 years to amass this huge fund, this is the model that Scotland would like to follow — as after independence it would have control of its north sea oil and gas revenue. > In short, everything that has happened in Europe since 2009 or so has demonstrated that sharing a currency without sharing a government is very dangerous. What happened was dangerous, though arguably the use of a shared currency and central bank helped countries support one another. In any case, the most likely outcome in the case of Scottish independence is a currency union with the rest of the UK, in a similar manner to the Euro. If the Bank of England denies Scotland the use of its assets, it will also have to forgo Scotland's share of the liabilities, essentially wiping out Scotland's share of UK debt. So it's unlikely that Scotland's currency would be completely separate in any case. All in all, while there are naturally unknown factors, there are plenty of reasons to seek independence and just in terms of economics — even excluding oil and gas revenue — an independent Scotland would appear to be in a good financial position.
- jacquesm 12y agoThe housing market in NL all but crashed and is still just about limping along. In some provinces the situation is pretty dreadful. The funny bit is that the prices haven't dropped all that much (because people are psychologically much less likely to take a loss on a property than they are to cash in on a profit, a big factor in this is that they'll end up with a remaining debt to the bank after selling the house which is definitely not always an option). So the market simply froze with asking prices holding relatively steady and sales dropping to near zero at some point. As of late there is a bit of a recovery depending on the area you look at.
- icu 12y agoI expect this to be a wealth transfer event and personally I am going to make some cheeky One-Cancels-the-Other Order (OCO) bids and cheeky offers on the pound and on publicly listed Scottish companies, especially financial stocks. I expect price action will likely surge upon confirmation of where this vote will go and I'm betting I'll be able to make a profit from this event. In my experience the market always overshoots upon 'risky' events and reverts back to the mean. I would be interested to hear if anyone else sees this vote the way I do (or doesn't)?
- fidotron 12y agoI'm an English person that lives in Quebec, and going from what I know growing up in the UK and what I have seen here with the current polling I'm convinced not going for independence will work out worse. The reason is markets really hate uncertainty. Given a close but non-final referendum the result isn't certainty: it's potentially decades of uncertainty. Quebec has had this for over 30 years and it's destroyed the place. (To be clear, I don't think Quebec should go independent now, but if it was going to 1980 was the time). Independence has many unknowns, but a lot of them are of the kind where solutions mysteriously won't be available until the problem actually presents itself. For example, the Scottish EU question is a lot of bluffing on both sides, but you can't help thinking the reality will prove to be a lot less exciting. After 5-10 years it will settle down a bit, but if the status quo is preserved with the potential for another one you can watch all the businesses hedging their bets with stuff going south of the border for decades to come, while the economy in the north becomes even more dependent on the public sector, which is a recipe for trouble. As a result I don't think anyone taking too strong a financial position based on this coming out one way or the other is particularly wise.
- icu 12y agoRight I get what you're saying but this isn't a long term trade, I'm looking to set up a sort of 'jack in the box' trade where if price leaps up or leaps down I'll catch the ride and then cash out. I expect this trade will be done in a day. For example, I remember being in NZ when Air NZ (publicly traded national airline) was in financial trouble and their share price was tanking. As soon as I could I bought up loads of shares on the (correct) assumption that the NZ Government wouldn't let the only national carrier go bust. Sure enough the NZ Government announced a rescue package and I made some good money. Thankfully I had the good sense to bet on Uncle Sam in 2008 and made a killing in options. My point is that sometimes politics makes for 'wealth transfer' events in the market.
- midhir 12y agoInteresting article. Worth noting that Stiglitz is more bullish about the economic possibilities for Scotland after independence - though I understand he's an advisor to the Scottish Government. I'll be glued to the count on the 18th anyway.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- scythe 12y agoI think it would have made more sense for Krugman to frame this as an argument for a new Scottish currency: his point is that * a currency union without a political union is bound to cause problems if you wait long enough * history shows us that nobody is willing to fix the currency until it's too late So it would be better if Scotland avoids starting on the wrong track by simply creating a currency. As he states, though, the Scottish secessionists are bound and determined to go the wrong way... (Side note: Labor productivity is lower in Canada, but something tells me that working hours are shorter and vacations longer...)
- thret 12y agoI thought that odd too: surely lower labor productivity in a prosperous nation is a positive indicator of a higher quality of life.
- api 12y agoCanada has a lot of oil and other natural resources in proportion to its population. I suspect this underwrites a lot of their high standard of living vs. labor intensiveness. I'm not sure nations that don't have that kind of cash cow can do what Canada does.
- guyzero 12y agoWorking hours and paid vacation days are roughly similar between Canada and the US. Canada is no France. Specifically, Canada ranks 3rd last in paid vacations: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/canada-ranks-3rd-last-in-paid-vacations-1.1306523 http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/canada-ranks-3rd-last-in-paid-... Average annual hours worked, per worker: Canada, 1706; US, 1788 or only 4.5% less, compared to France at 1489. (http://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DatasetCode=ANHRS http://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DatasetCode=ANHRS)
- alistairSH 12y agoScotland can't create a currency if they desire to join the EU. Current rules don't allow any more UK/Denmark-style currency exemptions. It appears that Scotland's options would be: - retain the Pound Sterling, not sure about EU membership - Euro, with EU membership - new currency, but without EU membership
- StefanKarpinski 12y agoPaul Krugman is so much better when he's being rational about economics than when he's on yet another tirade about how bad Republicans are – whether one agrees or not, it's just uninteresting. This is similar to how Richard Dawkins is utterly brilliant when he sticks to evolutionary biology but kind of insufferable when he crusades against religion.
- grifpete 12y agoYou're entitled to your opinion on his crusades against religion. But let's bear in mind that there are those of us who consider religious irrationalism a key challenge of our age, nationally and internationally, and hence that such a crusade is important.
- dllthomas 12y agoSome of us have sympathy for his cause and still think his writings on evolution (out of a sense of "check out how amazing and exciting this stuff is!") are overwhelmingly better than his writings on religion (even if we frequently appreciate snark).
- droopyEyelids 12y agoLet's also remember there are people who believe that insults and condescension are the least effective ways to help someone see they are acting irrationally, and that attacking a group of people's shared identity is the worst way to work with them on the substance of the challenges of our time.
- MarkPNeyer 12y ago> attacking a group of people's shared identity is the worst way to work with them on the substance of the challenges of our time "when we insult their intelligence and mock the things they hold sacred, they fight harder against us. maybe we should try something different?" "are you crazy? they're bad guys. they believe what they want, regardless of what empirical reality says. now let's do the exact same thing again, maybe it will work better this time."
- supernova87a 12y agoThis whole debate is ridiculous, much like Texas perennially threatening to defect. No way that the UK would let Scotland leave with the oil revenues. There is that other article that points out that if Scotland defected, the Shetlands (oil revenues) would have an equally good claim to leave Scotland too. Then what would Scotland be? The sucking welfare hole that swallows a huge amount of UK tax money, without any more tax money to support it. I.e. the poor backwater of a frontier country it once was...
- glomph 12y agoThe current UK Government has agreed to honor this referendum.
- alistairSH 12y agoNot only did the Edinburgh Agreement indicate that the UK would honor the results, but the UK government also explicitly granted the Scottish government the right to hold the referendum (constitutional issues would normally be a power reserved by the UK parliament).
- stormbrew 12y agoParliament may not bind its successors.
- glomph 12y agoThe government isn't going to change before the referendum.
- stormbrew 12y agoThe principle doesn't just apply to changes of government, it means that a commitment by parliament is only good so long as parliament consents to that commitment. It can be changed or overruled at any time.
- 12y ago
- fennecfoxen 12y ago> But Canada has its own currency, which means that its government can’t run out of money, that it can bail out its own banks if necessary, and more. An independent Scotland wouldn’t. And that makes a huge difference. Works for Panama, Ecuador, and El Salvador, all of which use the dollar. Worked for plenty of successful governments on the gold standard throughout history. And it works for every state and city and other regional government. It's really pretty partisan and tendentious to suggest that governments playing games with the currency is a fundamental tenet of governance. Just because your favored public policy techniques make use of currency manipulation doesn't mean a nation can't do without it, Mr. Krugman, even if the Scots are pretty far to the Left.
- peteretep 12y ago> Works for Panama, Ecuador, and El Salvador, all of which > use the dollar. Scotland! You too can have the economy of a Central American state! (Scotland's GDP: $216 billion, Panama $36b, Ecuador $84b, El Salvador $23b)
- ef4 12y agoScotland was ground zero for the industrial revolution and has had relative peace within its borders for centuries. Those other three countries all experienced coups in living memory, and didn't seriously start industrializing until at least a century later than Scotland. Those factors are more than enough to explain a factor of four or five difference in GDP.
- tormeh 12y ago>Worked for plenty of successful governments on the gold standard That's just wrong. I'm sorry. Just Google it or something.
- fennecfoxen 12y agoBasically every government in history used commodity money for millenia. (Perhaps I should have said "using commodity money" instead of "on the gold standard". That was inexact and inaccurate.) And yes, it turns out there are problems with such systems, like recessions. Fortunately fiat money administered by a wise and knowing bureaucracy, like in the United States, renders your economy totally recession-proof!!! cough cough and if there IS a recession you can just bail out all the banks and everything will be magically better!!! cough hack gaaaaag Anyway, the problem with commodity money (or the gold standard) is price instability when the real price of gold rises or falls because of wild swings in the supply or in national economic output. If you're Scotland and your number one trading partner is the rest of the UK and they do a half-decent job at price stability and your government holds lots of GBP, borrows in GBP, and issues bonds in GBP... well, you don't really end up having that class of problem.
- WordSkill 12y agoKrugman is a known idiot, I have far more interest in what coherent thinkers such as Joseph Stiglitz have to say on the matter: http://www.scotsman.com/news/politics/top-stories/scottish-independence-stiglitz-attacks-no-camp-1-3520079 http://www.scotsman.com/news/politics/top-stories/scottish-i... In common with literally all my foreign friends who, like me, have chosen to make Scotland their home, I am mystified that there is any question of rejecting the chance to become an independent country. I do understand that change can be frightening but, on every level, the prospects for a modern, self-governing Scotland are clearly better than remaining as comedy bit-players in an exhausted system designed to serve the needs of another country's hereditary elite? The United Kingdom was not chosen by the Scottish people in 1707, it was a stroke of royal power politics. Today, the UK is still pre-occupied with protecting the privilege and private wealth accumulated by the top 1% during the age of empire and is, therefore, laughably unfit to steer our entire population towards the opportunities of the future. Can my Scottish friends not sense that something is wrong when the No campaign keep hammering the same obvious psychological buttons, do they not see this for the slick marketing campaign it is when Alistair Darling and the entire UK media straight-facedly suggest that oil is a curse, because of price volatility, rather than the blessing every other country considers it to be? Is it not insulting when they suggest that, alone among all the peoples of the world, only the Scottish are incapable of democratically determining what is best for them and acting in their own best interests? Even if Scotland did not have extraordinary natural resources that most countries would, quite literally, kill for, a rich diversity of resources that, per head of population, very few countries in the world can rival (http://pbs.twimg.com/media/Bwh9F9LCcAAKBSV.jpg http://pbs.twimg.com/media/Bwh9F9LCcAAKBSV.jpg), there is something much more important, and this is what I, an Irishman who has lived in Scotland for 12yrs, and ALL my foreign friends here - Canadians, Australians, English, German, Americans, Thais and French etc - can see so clearly: A people who gain the chance to govern themselves, who become the masters of their own destiny, they grow. They cast aside of the feeling of being second-best, they lose the bitterness, the chip on their shoulder. Whatever the challenges a small nation might face, nothing is as important as the feeling of pride and self-worth that come with being a first-class citizen in your own country. This isn't just some abstract, wishy-washy point about feeling good; the future we are heading into is one in which self-confidence, the ability to believe in ourselves and our abilities, will be a fundamental driver of business, trade and innovation. It is vital that Scottish children take on the world with the same natural self-confidence as children from Oxford or London, that they be the ones taking chances and setting up companies, not the ones deciding that, on balance, it is probably best to play it safe and aim for a dull but secure job. Forgive me, but I must be frank: the Scottish character has been affected by three centuries of playing second fiddle to England, there is more than a smidgen of self-hate and self-destructiveness in the Scottish temperament, and the self-harm that George Monbiot writes about (http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/sep/02/scots-independence-england-scotland http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/sep/02/scots-i...) is likely to manifest itself spectacularly on polling day. That is why the No campaign will keep remorselessly pounding away at those deeply embedded fears and self-doubts right up until election day, because fear is how you hold people down. They will keep pretending that it is about Alex Salmond, while conveniently ignoring real issues, such as the fact it was Scotland's oil which made Sterling a petrocurrency, propping up its value during the Thatcher years and allowing London to become a world centre of finance, all while lying about how much oil they were extracting. None of this is secret, it is all there in government papers released under the thirty-year rule: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/this-britain/how-black-gold-was-hijacked-north-sea-oil-and-the-betrayal-of-scotland-518697.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/this-britain/how-black-... ... and this is how the last gasp of empire looks: keep jock in harness by somehow persuading him that he needs the English rather than the other way round. This is the system, it has been perfected over centuries, it is insatiable and, no matter what they or their local sock puppets say, it does not have your best interests at heart. I think the No campaign will win. Despite the recent dramatic gains by the Yes side, I believe the No campaign, with the entire weight of the London press and the BBC behind them, are tapping into rich and reliable reserves of self-doubt in the Scottish psyche. This saddens me greatly, as I believe the eventual realisation of what has been thrown away will only further poison the Scottish soul. Despite having been sold to the electorate as a bulwark against change, the United Kingdom will change beyond recognition in the coming years. English politics will continue to be driven rightwards by the UKIP agenda, regardless of what the Scottish people want, and we may well find ourselves out of the European Union anyway, courtesy of The Daily Mail. Certainly, the age of austerity and privatization will continue to drive down the "Barnett formula" money you are supposedly receiving in return for your oil propping up the London Exchequer, but more devastating will be the growing sense that, yet again, the Scottish have blown it, losing the one chance you had to disentangle and discover who you really are.
- beloch 12y agoThe linked article draws a bizarre comparison between Canada and Scotland, should it secede from the U.K.. First of all, Canada has nearly seven times the population and vastly more land. Second, Canada's "relatively small" economy is merely the #11 largest in the world in terms of GDP and three quarters the size of the entire U.K. (and 31% higher per capita). Third, Canada never really seceded from the U.K.. Although Canada has been independent in practice for over a century and completely independent in law since patriation in 1982, Canada's symbolic head of state is still the British monarch. Canada never had to fight or vote for independence. We just gradually wound up that way. The relationship between Canada and the U.S. does have some superficial similarities, but Canada's status as a different country has always made relations between Canada and the U.S. substantially different than between Scotland and the U.K.. The situation Scotland finds itself is almost completely different from anything Canada as a whole has ever gone through. The more interesting parallel is between Quebec and Scotland. Quebec's population is 50% larger than Scotland's and its land area is vastly larger, but it has held two referendums on separation from Canada and has threatened to hold others several times. Here are some lessons we've learned: 1. Baseline support for separation is Quebec is well below 50% most of the time, but separatists have chosen unusual periods when separatist sentiment is at a peak to hold referendums and campaigned hard for a victory. In these separation referendums, the advantage clearly goes to the separatists. 2. The terms for a successful separation vote have been and remain unclear. At the time of both referendums, federalists and separatists had extremely different ideas about what percentage of the vote would be necessary to actually carry out separation. Since then a "clarity act" has been passed, but all it states is that a "clear majority" is required. If it looks like Scotland might reach 50% plus one, then the U.K. and Scotland had better have a clear stance on what that will mean! 3. A separatist government was responsible for composing the referendum questions in both of Quebec's sovereignty votes. These governments can and will choose tortuous, unclear phrasing to get as many extra votes as they can. 4. Everybody has different ideas of what separation would actually entail. Would Quebec keep a portion of federal property (e.g. Military equipment)? Would they assume a proportional amount of the national debt? Would they be allowed to use Canadian currency/passports? Would English centers (e.g. Montreal) and native bands that wish to remain in Canada be permitted to separate from Quebec and remain with Canada? The list goes on and on. Federalists will make separation sound as scary and punitive as possible while separatists will make it sound as harmless as possible. The trouble is, people voting in the referendum don't really know what they're voting for except a start to the negotiations! 5. Business interests loathe political instability. Referendums and separatist governments with draconian language laws have significantly retarded Quebec's economy over the years. I would suggest that, whether they separate or not, it would be in Scotland's best interests to pass a law stating how long it must be before the next referendum on separation can be held. If this is not done, separation will remain a constant uncertainty. 6. Separation threats haven't been all bad for Quebec. Due to Canada's practice of transferring funds from wealthy provinces to poor provinces, Quebec has received substantial funding that has helped make up for it's lagging economy. Their separatist governments have also used the specter of separation to extort concession after concession out of the federal government. If Scotland votes no, it's a safe bet that the U.K. government will be pandering to Scottish interests for generations.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- api_or_ipa 12y agoKrugman's article dialect borders on the offending. The point he was making can be easily summed as the peculiarities of the macroeconomic Trilemma[1]. If Scotland honours the pound, then it must either lose monetary independence or restrict capital inflows. Every country must make this decision, whether they are in an economic union or not. Scotland's situation is interesting because effectively, a fixed exchange rate situation with Britain will mean less monetary policy mechanisms for Scotland to play with. Of course, it can always attempt to maintain economic stability with fiscal policy; it suffices here to say they have their individual purposes. Krugman is a very well known advocate of monetary policy, especially in the 2008 recession. For this reason, it's clear he has a disposition towards favouring his own tools of choice. Of course, for being a left wing economist, it isn't difficult to see a possible reason why he favours monetary policy: it devalues currency, taking more from those who hold large cash balances. Economists, like all other professions, should strive to be fair and balanced in their articles. Krugman's article is certainly not balanced. [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impossible_trinity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impossible_trinity
- tptacek 12y agoWithout sticking up for Krugman's article, which I'm not qualified to judge, isn't he capturing some of that "fiscal policy" level when he talks about Spanish austerity?
- MarkPNeyer 12y ago> a possible reason why he favours monetary policy: it devalues currency, taking more from those who hold large cash balances i understand that logic, but currency devlauation ends up making things worse for pretty much everyone but the extremely wealthy. in a deflationary economy, all you have to do in order to prepare for the future is just spend less than you earn. that's it. the savings will be more valuable in the future than it is now. in an inflationary economy, not only must you spend less than you earn, you must now take on risk just to maintain the value of what you already have. the entire financial system exists because for most people, investing (choosing loans or investments) requires more resources and knowledge than they have on their own. you're _forced_ to play a game you don't really understand: picking companies to invest in. most people who 'get it' will tell you to just buy and hold - but all of that would be totally unnecessary if currency were deflationary or just kept its value. of course, the extremely wealthy have much more money to invest, and can spend their whole lives managing their portfolios, because working isn't necessary for them. they benefit from the increased flow of cash into investment markets, enabling the existence of a financial industry that is necessary to service _everyone's_ 401(k) and pension fund - because "spend less then you earn" isn't enough.
- mkehrt 12y agoMy very cursory reading on the subject indicate that polls have shown that Scots truly expect a major economic downturn if they secede; however they may be willing to bear that price if it will free them from a government they feel does not represent them. So, this isn't really a useful commentary on the referendum; they know the economic issues but might not care.
- panarky 12y agoIf you want to geek out on the politics of Scottish independence, Charlie Stross has just the thing. http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2014/09/the-referendum-question.html http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2014/09/the-refe...
- Zigurd 12y agoScots don't want to be dragged into America's next war. That's probably reason enough.
- blueking 12y agoCome on Scotland STAND UP !!!!!!! Go Scotland !!!
- dimitar 12y agoI'm surprised that there is so much controversy about this article - nothing Paul Krugman has written here is outside the mainstream in international economics, in fact it can be taken out of a textbook (in fact the author has written a very popular one on the subject). The point or the article is simple - you are going to have a new set of problems to work out, please think about them, don't assume the best possible outcome. I didn't see a radical policy proposal that could possibly offend anyone. A lot of people seem to dislike the examples - but this is just nitpicking to show off.
- peteretep 12y ago> I'm surprised that there is so much controversy about > this article You must be new to the debate about Scottish independence on the internet.
- collyw 12y agoJudging by the way the UK as a whole has been run for the last 7 years, I think staying part of the union is the worst possible outcome.
- kiliancs 12y agoIf we accept that nations (that is, communities of people with a feeling of belonging to the same group that share history, culture, language, traditions, etc.) exist, then we must accept that they should be considered equal in the same way people are considered equal: they should treat each other as equal and should care about the wellbeing of each other. They should look for their own wellbeing, but consider the common good of all nations to be even more important. Given these principles, the world should encourage nations to take care of their own issues and reach the maturity and capability to function economically and advance culturally and socially, and to interact with the rest in spirit of cooperation; they would provide the means for that. This would be, in my opinion, one of the requirements to ensure lasting peace, as well as a potent boost for the world economy. The alternative is that these nations are not recognized or only partially recognized, and that they are unable to manage their own issues the way they wish, and to have their own voice in the world, for so many of the important matters are global nowadays. Ignoring them will always lead to growing instability, as these nations and their aspirations will not disappear -and if they do, that would be a loss for humanity. We have the tools of democracy to achieve this peacefully. The editorial of the NYT a few days ago[1] talked about the value of achieving this democratically. Xavier Sala-i-Martín, economist at Columbia University, often explains a story that makes the same point (I tried to improve Google's translation a little): "What if an alien interested in bringing democracy to its planet suddenly appeared in our living room and asked us how do we earthlings make collective decisions? Surely we would explain that to choose our leaders, we vote; that to pass our laws, we vote; you to decide how public money is spent, we vote, and to set taxes, we vote. If, suddenly, the galactic sir stood in front of a world map and told us: "I guess you also vote in order to change the borders on this map, right?". We would have to embarrassedly respond: "No, the borders can be changed only by fighting". Given this bizarre revelation, poor Mr. green would turn green (if that was not its original color) and would run, exclaiming that we are barbarians."[2] [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/04/opinion/scotlands-identity-put-to-a-vote.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/04/opinion/scotlands-identity... [2] https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&tl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.caffereggio.net%2F2012%2F11%2F17%2Fel-col%25C2%25B7lectiu-wilson-de-xavier-sala-i-martin-en-la-vanguardia%2F&sandbox=1 https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&tl=en&u=h...
- ggchappell 12y ago> In short, everything that has happened in Europe since 2009 or so has demonstrated that sharing a currency without sharing a government is very dangerous. The above, I think, is the interesting content in this article. Whatever Scotland ends up doing, the larger questions of how the world of the future ought to be organized are important ones, and the above principle looks like one that is worthy of some thought.
- kiliancs 12y agoAgreed. It seems impossible at the moment, but we should ask ourselves what the ideal situation would be and work to get there: what about a world government (democratically elected) that respects the diversity and autonomy of all nations (including Scotland, Catalonia and any others through the democratic application of the right to self-determination) with a global currency?