10 ms·
Breaking up with America
- kelukelugames 12y agoRough. I know a handful of talented developers stuck at a large company because of visa issues. They are too afraid to look for a better job because of immigration.
- lambdasquirrel 12y agoThe U.S. seems much like the late Roman Empire in this sense. Whereas the growth and expansion of the Roman Empire was fueled by its wars and conquests, which brought back slaves and material wealth, the American Empire's growth has been fueled by skimming off the top of the middle and upper classes wherever there's been socioeconomic troubles elsewhere. The U.S. can get away with policy inefficiencies like this because there's so many people who want to get in right now, and it actually works in favor of the Powers That Be, because they can get decent talent that's easy to "keep them in their place" because of said policy inefficiencies. That having been said, the U.S. doesn't going blowing stuff up in Europe to make this advantages happen. For a lot of people, it is a beacon of opportunity. It's not all blue skies and roses though.
- nolite 12y agono, they just blow stuff up everywhere else in the world.. either literally, or politically..
- dredmorbius 12y agoThe US has done its share of economic imperialism as well, just not through colonies-in-name.
- coldtea 12y ago>That having been said, the U.S. doesn't going blowing stuff up in Europe to make this advantages happen. No, just in the third and developing world. In Europe they just push and abuse diplomatically lesser states (up to the point to having supported or even established specific goverments and even dictatorships over the last 60 years) to get the trade agreements and diplomatic support they want.
- billbrown 12y agoEvery time I encounter the way our immigration policies treat various co-workers of mine, I'm ashamed and scandalized. They are the last people to be a "drain on our economy" and they're effectively chained to their jobs, which seems so archaic.
- dllthomas 12y ago"they're effectively chained to their jobs, which seems so archaic." Not just archaic, but wrong. And even if we say "but they're choosing to be here, so it still must be better than what they came from" - which isn't entirely false, but ignores some things - it still means that the rest of us are competing with these extra-abusable workers which some companies might not mind paying a premium for on paper.
- owenmarshall 12y agoReserve some blame for your company: the reason H-1B programs are so widely abused is because industry can't give up cheap labor.
- zabraxias 12y agoThat's an oversimplification since the valley is the leading proponent of immigration reform (yes since the companies there will get better access to foreign workers) but every other developed nation seems to have a more sensible policy like allowing "work status" and not tying it to a specific company. Green cards effectively do that but unless you're Bieber or can afford the $1M investment visa you don't get one on day 1.
- syntern 12y agoGreen card is not a work permit, it is a residency status. People focus on the work part, but with choosing the green card, one is choosing between the US and the rest of the world for a very long time. First of all, it requires you to reside in the US, permanently (hence the official name). You don't move home for longer periods (e.g. years), as getting back in the US is not automatic. I understand that the US sees entering in the US as privilege, but these people usually help the US economy, and not burden it, so there is that. Second, it really limits your options. Suppose you decide to go outside of the US in just a few years after the green card, giving it up, and suddenly, for the rest of your life, whenever you enter in the US, you need to tell you life's story to the immigration officer and why you have applied for immigration status and what happened with it. And if you have connections, properties or investments in Europe, you will be always in limbo whether the European bank will decline business with you based on your US tax status. Going for a green card is a no-brainer for everyone who is going for US citizenship. Everyone else, take a better look on it, before you go for it.
- nilsimsa 12y agoWhere are they located?
- tomwilde 12y agoIt seems like the author is a Briton. As a Swiss citizen I don't understand how anyone from a first-world country would like to move to the USA. It's a downgrade in every aspect. Giving up democracy, social-security, the practical absence of crime for a job in a country where every other Tuesday someone goes on a killing-spree, where people go to the doctor for moar Vicodine, where police will kill you for a donut. Nope. Edit: changed englishman to briton. Thank you, commenters.
- Thrymr 12y ago> It seems like the author is an Englishman. A UK citizen, probably, but I'd not assume that a guy named "McDowell" from Belfast is English.
- kareemm 12y agoAs a Canadian who's lived in many parts of the world, including the US, it's the unbridled friendliness, optimism, hustle, and (generally speaking) caring only what you can do and not where you're from that made living in the US preferable to other countries. The downside, of course, being the trade-offs you mention.
- carlob 12y ago> It seems like the author is an Englishman. Northern-Irish, so technically a Briton, but not an Englishman.
- jwhitlark 12y agoI had a friend of mine who had emigrated from Iran to England, (obtaining English citizenship). After 6 years in England, he came to the US and eventually got citizenship here. I asked him the same question, "Why would someone move to the US from a first world country?" I found his response interesting: "Because in Europe, you stay where they put you."
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pm90 12y agoWhy isn't the author getting another L-1 Visa? Since his company has a base in SF and Belfast, that should be possible, right?
- hlieberman 12y agoL-1 visas are non-immigrant visas, and they require certain periods of absence from America in order to renew them, as well as lengths of employment at the company before you are eligible.
- cylinder 12y agoHe has to have worked at the overseas company for one year out of the last three years for an L-1.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- SeoxyS 12y agoYou could always try for the O-1 visa. When everything else failed me, that's the route I went. I've now obtained an O-1 twice. It costs more, and the requirements are more stringent; but if you are able to get it, it's extremely efficient. The entire process only takes ~a month.
- timtamboy63 12y agoHey! I'm actually going down this route as well. I'd love more information and maybe chat if you have a few minutes. Any chance you could shoot me an email? I'm chintan@capp.io.
- randunel 12y agoGuys, don't go private. Do request and share in the comments please :)
- Synroc 12y agoWhat constitutes as "exceptional" ? I'm worried I wouldn't qualify for that criteria.
- SeoxyS 12y agoThe criteria are outline on: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/O_visa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/O_visa http://www.uscis.gov/working-united-states/temporary-workers/o-1-individuals-extraordinary-ability-or-achievement/o-1-visa-individuals-extraordinary-ability-or-achievement http://www.uscis.gov/working-united-states/temporary-workers...
- mathattack 12y agoWhy not an L1 if you have a job with the same company? Seems relatively easy.
- lordbusiness 12y agoI'm not sure this is particularly interesting for Hacker News? Not trying to troll, and I apologize if I'm way off the mark on this. I don't intend to cause offence.
- tehwalrus 12y agoHi! thanks for contributing to Hacker News. If you don't think an article is HN-material, please use the "flag" link on the post, rather than posting a comment to that effect. You may not see the flag link if you don't have a high enough Karma score yet. Personally, I've seen advanced discussion on US visas on here before, and I would assume that this would be of interest to many in this community.
- lordbusiness 12y agoThank you for the welcome. :-) It's not really an advanced discussion or even jumping off point. It's just one person saying they don't live in the US anymore. And yah, I don't have enough karma. Though it appears I lost a point for positing my original comment. :-) C'est la vie.
- sounds 12y agoBecause HN has a built-in balance of "more upvotes than downvotes," it shouldn't be difficult to get upvotes.
- artmageddon 12y agoIt's not an 'advanced discussion' in terms of technology but we have to face the fact that there are many people who work here in the States and want to work in the states that get hampered by immigration rules. My girlfriend is working on her PhD in CS and has faced huge uphill battles to get into for internships simply because of where she's from. She just wants to work on tech, but the hurdles she has to go through are ridiculous compared to what citizens or even immigrants from other countries have to face.
- timtamboy63 12y ago
- jrmg 12y agoIf you were born in Northern Ireland, you are eligible to apply for the Diversity Visa lottery, if you want to try that route. 'Winning' nets you a green card (yes, this is a real thing; the US immigration system is crazy). There's a low chance of success - looks like 1.25-2% for Europeans, according to Wikipedia. https://www.dvlottery.state.gov https://www.dvlottery.state.gov http://travel.state.gov/content/visas/english/immigrate/diversity-visa/entry.html http://travel.state.gov/content/visas/english/immigrate/dive... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diversity_Immigrant_Visa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diversity_Immigrant_Visa Britons born in other parts of the UK are not eligible. The next lottery takes place next year, applications can be made from October. The only qualifications needed, other than nationality, are a high school education and two years work experience (http://travel.state.gov/content/visas/english/immigrate/diversity-visa/if-you-are-selected/confirm-your-qualifications.html http://travel.state.gov/content/visas/english/immigrate/dive...).
- juggling-engine 12y agoI'm in the exact same situation. I wasn't selected for the H1-B lottery twice in a row, and have to leave after seven years in the US. Oh well, I hear Vancouver is nice :)
- CodeMage 12y agoAre H-1B extensions also subject to lottery?
- potatolicious 12y agoNo, but there is a 6-year limit to being under the H-1B status.
- tricolon 12y agoCan't it be extended for a year at a time as long as a permanent residency application is pending?
- juggling-engine 12y agoI think so, but you can't apply for permanent residence if you came to the US to study. You have to first transition to a diffenrent visa status, usually H1-B. However if, for example, the cap has been full since you graduated college...
- juggling-engine 12y agoYes. They are subject to a lottery when te number of applications exceeds the number of available spots. This has been true for the last couple years, and last year was almost three times over.
- chishaku 12y agoQuestion: How do "free market" proponents support the free flow of (financial) capital across borders but not the free flow of (human) capital across borders? I appreciate any insight/references regarding this topic. EDIT: I know this is a loaded question but I think it hits to the heart of this immigration issue. I trust there are many smart (and civil) members of this community from across the politecon spectrum who could provide more insight on this or related debates.
- icebraining 12y agoThat's a loaded question :) most of what I read by libertarians is supportive of free immigration, e.g. http://bleedingheartlibertarians.com/tag/immigration/ http://bleedingheartlibertarians.com/tag/immigration/
- cottonseed 12y agoThis is economic, not political, but there is a good Planet Money on the economic perspectives on immigration: http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2014/04/02/298383246/episode-436-if-economists-controlled-the-borders http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2014/04/02/298383246/episode-...
- x1798DE 12y agoWhat free market proponents are in favor of free trade but against free immigration? In my experience part of the libertarian ethos is about opening up immigration. The only way I can imagine a free-market proponent who is in favor of free trade holding consistent beliefs which are also against immigration is if they are for immigration from a trade perspective, but against it on some other grounds such as national defense or national identity. You can imagine that the justification for at least the national defense reasoning is that if you let in a lot of people, you'll end up allowing some sort of fifth column or something to develop in the heart of the nation. Frankly, I don't buy any of the objections I've seen to basically unlimited immigration, but there are at least some that are intellectually consistent with a free-market position. You can find a laundry list of anti-immigration positions (many of which are at least intellectually consistent with a free market philosophy), alongside their specific refutations over at http://openborders.info http://openborders.info
- drivingmenuts 12y agoMan, I would love to work in some other country than the US, but getting approval to work elsewhere is apparently harder than getting approval for people elsewhere to get approval to work here.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]