11 ms·
What a disgusting dark pattern to be put to use in public transports. I don't think this can be classified any other way than a scam. Sure, they scam you out o
by scrollaway 12y ago
What a disgusting dark pattern to be put to use in public transports.
I don't think this can be classified any other way than a scam. Sure, they scam you out of a couple of dollars, but they do it on a massive scale and at the expense of thousands upon thousands of people.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wdewind 12y agoNo, the point is to incentivize people to keep their cards, ie: conserve. It's a good thing, just like the charge for a new card. I'm a New Yorker, so at least some of us like it.
- yahelc 12y agoTo be fair, it's a less relevant tactic now that they charge $1 for the card itself. This is essentially seigniorage.
- tomp 12y agoThe correct way to do that is to charge a deposit for a new card. That's how London's Oyster cards work, although it's a scam in other ways (to get the "deposit" back, you need a proof of address, i.e. if you're a tourist, you can't get the deposit back (except on some specific tube stations)).
- Someone1234 12y agoThat wasn't my experience. I just went to a ticket desk and they not only gave me my deposit back but also the remaining balance on not one but two cards. Wasn't a hassle at all. That was at the underground Victoria station ticket counter.
- shawabawa3 12y ago> to get the "deposit" back, you need a proof of address, That's only for registered cards. Which makes perfect sense, because they're registered to an address to prevent people stealing them and returning them for cash
- tomp 12y agoThat's a rather bad argument; that's like saying you should only be able to use cash that is registered to an address, to prevent people from stealing it.
- randyrand 12y agoThat actually sounds like a decent idea. Bitcoin is already this way. All "cash" is associated with an address. To use that cash you need to be the owner of that address.
- schoen 12y agoPretty different senses of "address", though! A street address or a cryptographic key.
- randyrand 12y agoYeah, it's an interesting comparison. For the Oyster card, you just need proof that you live where you say you do. For bit coin you just need to not lose your key. Similar purpose. Different execution. note: lose as in someone steals it.If it's totally lost the money is gone, as we know.
- shawabawa3 12y agoI don't understand your comment. You don't have to register your card. If it is unregistered and someone steals it there is nothing you can do to recover any money on the card. You can choose to register it, in which case you can transfer the balance to a new card in the case it is lost or stolen.
- wdewind 12y agoMTA does both. Serious question: what difference does it make? I have a hard time understanding the outrage here.
- tedunangst 12y agoGovernment taking money -> instant outrage.
- coldpie 12y agoNo, it's because you're forced to pay for services not rendered.
- seanflyon 12y ago"forced"
- gknoy 12y agoThat's frustrating for rare users (tourists, etc), but seems optimized for the regular traveler. The rare user might prefer to buy Exactly One (or two or four) tickets, as they know they won't use the excess. This is similar to the frustration of a first-time user at the bay area ferries, where the process of registration, app installation, etc, is much less convenient than most parking. The regular user, however, doesn't care as much about the initial overhead, as the convenience outweighs the overhead. A remainder balance on the card is less frustrating than for a tourist, as they know they're going to fill it up again. That said, it would have been nicer if the transit company had phrased pricing in terms of Number Of Rides, rather than dollars (dollar amounts made up): 4 rides ($10.42) 10 rides ($21.37) 50 rides ($90) 100 rides ($180)
- esrauch 12y agoIt is still strictly worse for the repeat riders if they get a card valued at 10.41 than 7.91. The only reason for the city to even allow someone to do it is to underhandedly get more money when someone inevitably loses their metro card.
- randyrand 12y agoGot my deposit back as a tourist. No problem. Had to give them my address as you said.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoWhen I last travelled to London, with kids, I was researching how to get an Oyster card. I'd used one before but borrowed from relatives in London, that wasn't going to work this time. So I assumed I'd need a "tourist" Oyster as I wasn't a resident. But when I looked in to it as a tourist you had to book well in advance so they can post a card to you - whilst if you ignore the "tourist" offering you can just pick up the card at your arrival station (Victoria for me, very easy, was from a machine IIRC). Also the charges seemed higher for tourists somehow and there seemed to be difficulties giving the card back and getting a refund - I could see no reason to have a tourist Oyster. One of the kids travelled free, with me, as it happened which was great. The only problem is that the automated turnstiles wouldn't let us through separately without us paying twice (for which we'd need a different Oyster) and I got "munched" on a couple of occasions one of which gave me a very sore back, it was quite vicious. Traveller beware!
- dblacc 12y agoIn the situation you are travelling with a kid who is eligible for free travel, rather than going through the barriers you should've just spoken to the the person on duty. Theres always at least 1 person standing by one of the barriers that would let you through.. takes like 5 seconds longer but doesn't involved getting munched :)
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoNot always, I looked. I imagine if you're familiar with the stations you can do that without being stampeded, getting lost, etc..
- citizens 12y agoThe cards expire ~one year after the first purchase. At that point you'll have up to two years to transfer the balance to a new card. I don't see the conservation. - http://web.mta.info/metrocard/problems.htm#expired http://web.mta.info/metrocard/problems.htm#expired
- jrockway 12y agoIt is weird how frequently the cards expire. I was quite surprised to visit Tokyo and have my Passmo card still working after not being there since 2009. (They expire 10 years after the last use.) Octopus cards never expire, as far as I can tell. The US is, not surprisingly, way behind here.
- greenyoda 12y agoMetroCards are so cheaply made and thin that you'd be lucky if you can actually use one on a daily basis for a year without it becoming mangled or unreadable. The MTA probably enforces a one-year expiration to avoid the expense of having to deal with massive numbers of complaints about unusable cards. Because of the unreliability of MetroCards and MetroCard readers, the MTA is planning to phase them out in a few years and replace their card readers with equipment that can directly read contactless (RFID) credit cards.
- randyrand 12y agoThey already charge $1 for the card so why would you throw it away even when it runs out of money? Your comment makes no sense.
- thedufer 12y agoThat's a fairly recent change. The fare thing described in the article drastically predates it.
- jgalt212 12y agoThe police want you to keep the same card so that the citizenry are easier to track. Fill up a card 1,000 times with cash and just one time with a credit credit and your entire transit history through the system can be found.
- greenyoda 12y agoHowever, if the police arrest a suspect, they can still find their transit history by examining any card they have in their possession, regardless of how it was bought. So if you plan on committing a crime (or just don't want to be tracked), you should buy some low-denomination MetroCards with cash at random locations and discard them immediately after passing the turnstile. And you should leave your cell phone at home too, since that also leaves a trail of where you've been. Don't drive to the scene of the crime either, since you might be identified by one of the NYPD's license plate scanners (or a red-light or speeding camera, or an E-ZPass toll scanner). And if you manage to avoid all those pitfalls, you might still get identified by one of the thousands of surveillance cameras around NYC. It's getting very hard to travel anonymously in NYC.
- g12u 12y agoNot sure where the scam is. At a glance it doesn't seem to be exploiting some kind of rounding bias past a threshold. It just happens to keep a strange remaining balance that you keep anyway. Nobody throws away the cards anymore because now it costs a fee to get a new one. So you end up always spending the money you put in.
- thevdude 12y agoTourists probably don't.
- freehunter 12y agoMy apartment complex does something similar. Rent can only be paid online, and paying via Visa, MasterCard, Amex, etc costs $45. Discover costs $55. Even eCheck costs $1.95. Yes, this is on top of the cost of rent. So a $1400 rent becomes $1445 if I pay by credit card, leading to an extra $540 per year for the privilege of paying rent. They don't accept cash or check in person, so you have no choice but to pay the fees.
- nodata 12y agoWhat about bank transfer?
- freehunter 12y agoWhen I've asked, I was told the only options are what is listed on their website. The suggestion is eCheck, as it's cheapest. Additional fees (including the common "plus tax" at the store) are a scam and should be abolished. If that were the case, the MTA issue in the article wouldn't matter.
- randyrand 12y agoThe problem is your landlord wants your full rent amount and it depends on how you pay them. If you pay through a medium with fees, I'd argue you should pay those fees. It should be made apparent how they accept money and what the associated fees are before you sign your lease. That's the only malice I see.
- nodata 12y agoThe landlord should build the fee into the price for the cheapest method of accepting payment.
- xyzzyz 12y agoApartment rental companies in the US don't usually accept wire transfers (which is crazy itself), but they usually accept checks, and fortunately you can write an exact amount on a check.
- joemi 12y agoIn addition to incentivizing the re-use of cards, there's another good reason no one seems to have pointed out: the MTA needs money to keep the fares as low as $2.50. They have a history of not making enough money, and everyone in NYC gets in a rage whenever the fare has to be hiked up. So if they're able to make some extra money off of tourists, for the benefit of all the regular New Yorkers, that's fine by me.
- JackFr 12y agoAs a New Yorker and a long-time subway rider, I get in a rage because I perceive the MTA to be mismanaged. Though performance of the system improved noticeably in the 90's and beyond the MTA keeps notoriously obscure books, and seem incapable of budgeting and planning. I understand that fares will go up for a number of reasons, but too often the MTA finds itself in the hole to a few hundred million bucks and cannot explain why.
- bravura 12y agoThey have a history of not making enough money Except, you know, when they discovered that they had an extra $1.9B dollars (surprise!) http://jalopnik.com/nycs-mta-finds-unexpected-1-9-billion-still-raising-1423319174 http://jalopnik.com/nycs-mta-finds-unexpected-1-9-billion-st... This has happened in the past too, where they magically discovered a surplus. I'd have to dig for the reference. They are terrible at bookkeeping is one reason New Yorkers hate the MTA.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- moogleii 12y agoI'm a little skeptical of the arguments made by this article, even though I really enjoy the enthusiasm behind it. I've been using an unlimited for almost always, so I'll have to verify the refill options at the machines, but I know you can refill your cards with an arbitrary amount at the manned booths. Also, in conjunction with the good counter-points being made by others here, let's not forget his points rest upon free money. Without that bonus, he'd be a dollar short, not 5 cents. In fact, with option 3 (the $39 one), he literally received an extra subsidized ride. $39/2.5 is 15.6 => 15 rides. But with the free bonus he is able to take his 16th ride. I suspect this has more to do with poor UI, than anything else. Take a look at the Citibike UI if you're not an annual member. You will have less hair after having used it. Makes the MTA one seem glorious.
- anamexis 12y agoIndeed, the whole "never ascribe to malice that which is adequately explained by incompetence" bit. I think there's a strong likelihood that the numbers 9, 19, and 39 were chosen because with the $1 card fee, they make nice round multiples of $10. Put a $20 bill in, get a $19 card.
- stonemetal 12y agoThat is great when you are buying the card new, but why do that for the refill screen? Surely the typical rider refills more often than buys new, so you are going to make change more often than you would with round number charges for all transactions.
- thedufer 12y agoThat's a completely different screen. I usually use unlimited, but I'm pretty sure it has the expected 10/20/40 amounts (each with the +5% "bonus").
- eric_h 12y agoI switched back to a money card from an unlimited a while back. This is correct. I can't recall if it's 10/20/40 exactly, but they're all multiples of 5, for sure.
- moogleii 12y agoI can't edit my original reply anymore, but after checking out the machines for myself in person, I really do think the author only outsmarted his own OCD. You can refill your card with a credit card with any value greater than or equal to a dollar using the "Other Amounts" UI path. Machines will also take coins as small as 5 cents. People in the booths will take any amount. In most cases, that should allow you to zero out your card or come really close if you really wanted to. Knowing that, I feel his points rest on confusion based on historical pricing changes and the 5% bonus. First off, the bonus. For my purposes, I will call it "free", but as one response was so happy to point out, nothing is truly free, but I won't debate whether something should be provided at-cost or not here. However you feel, $2.5 is the price for one ride, and anything below that from the perspective of the buyer is essentially gratis. Assuming the bonuses were not there, for all three default payment paths, you would have $1.5 remaining. And hey, the lowest amount you can refill with happens to be a dollar! $1.5 + $1 = $2.5 = one perfectly balanced card. Now for the price change. Cards were free, so essentially you really were paying for a balanced amount that would leave you with no remainder. Again, ignoring the bonus, you were essentially putting $10, $20, and $40 on your card - all values perfectly divisible by $2.50. Now cards cost a dollar. That's a different debate, but that explains the $1.5 pre-bonus dangler. He goes on to mention, "If they really wanted to fix the issue, they could ask “How much do you want on your MetroCard” instead of “How much do you want to pay”. But don’t count on those changes coming to a MetroCard Vending Machine near you anytime soon, given how lucrative the current set up is." But prior to the one dollar surcharge, that is essentially what it was doing. It's been updated to reflect the dollar surcharge, and it has always elected not to show the final amount + bonus. Including the bonus would be just confusing, especially if you were trying to pay with cash/coins. "Oh hey, I want $10 to be on my card, including the bonus." "Okay, please enter $9.524" Yes, that's right, it's not an even $9.5. 10 / 1.05 = 9.5238~ If there's any "answer" here, it's that they wanted the cheapest/smallest amount of software updates that they could get away with using their original software/ui.
- walshemj 12y agoyes that's how I top up my oyster card (the uks equivalent) if I need to top up I put whatever change I have with me on the card gets rid of all that heavy 50p's and pound coins
- qwerta 12y agoYou call it scam? What if you would have to buy card and pay 20$/month just for heaving it?
- benguild 12y agoAgreed. When I'm in NYC I calculate this as if I want to get to a zero balance like the OP did.