8 ms·
Twitpic is shutting down
- ChrisArchitect 12y agolong time coming really. follows long narrative/twitter history where twitter forced it's way into owning the photo content shared on the service....allowing only a few like twitpic to maintain the key aspect 'embeddability/previews'. What still remains interesting to me is that at one point instagram was gaining an incredible amount of speed in becoming the defacto picture sharing service on twitter -- but then they had the spat with fb/insta and twitter stopped the previews for instagram pics. Instagram has a huge community so survived fine, but it could and still could be so much more with twitter integration...but that sanction has never been lifted.
- aaronpk 12y agoActually it was Instagram that decided to stop including the Twitter preview of photos, because "we want images viewed on instagram.com". http://techcrunch.com/2012/12/05/kevin-systrom-on-pulling-twitter-cards-integration-we-want-images-viewed-on-instagram-com/ http://techcrunch.com/2012/12/05/kevin-systrom-on-pulling-tw...
- ChrisArchitect 12y agosorry yeah, you're right. There just seemed to be an air of 'fb v twitter' and content owning about it anyways....and really, at the time anyone will remember that instagram was becoming really popular for sharing pics on instagram + twitter...and then boom. Insta silo'd and twitter aggressively pushing pic.twitter.com native hosting
- b123400 12y agoWhen is Twitter shutting down its API?
- uptown 12y agoSeems they're continuing their aggressive push towards controlling it all. Anybody have recent numbers on 3rd party client tokens remaining? And what happens to clients like TweetBot when they run out of tokens?
- vlucas 12y agoSad news. Just the latest victim in Twitter turning on it's own developer ecosystem. :-/
- smokinjoe 12y agoThey stuck it out pretty long with a good customer base, I personally kept using them even after Twitter introduced the ability to embed images. They just never adapted, I feel like their site design/experience hasn't changed since their initial launch.
- DanBlake 12y agoSo, there is a bunch of info we dont have... But would it not make sense to just rebrand? From a preliminary search on twitter, there is a huge amount of users still using twitpic. Seems like this is a biz that could/should make millions a year with some cost reductions and run mostly on autopilot. Also, what happens to the millions of pictures previously hosted with these guys? Even if you can backup/export all your data, think about all those links on twitter that are going to suddenly stop working. Its basically like a URL shortener shutting down. Shit, send the site over here and Il provide the resources to keep it going. Just seems like such a shame.
- MikeKusold 12y ago> But would it not make sense to just rebrand? Most likely not. TwitPic's only possible exit was an acquisition by Twitter, who has since developed their own image hosting platform. This is the danger of tying your startup to another company that has the power to shut you down. The company that you are tied to needs to either acquire you, or you are at their mercy.
- adventured 12y agoOn the bright side, Noah earned millions in profit with TwitPic over the years (by his own admission). If he has played it smart at all, he's not going to have to ever worry about money. On to the next.
- colinbartlett 12y agoReally? How? With advertising? I guess I am spoiled by AdBlock and didn't know they even made money.
- danbruc 12y agoSound to me like they are trying to see if Twitter is willing to change their mind when they threaten to shut the service down and break all the tweets. Rebranding would be an obvious option but they would still have to keep to current domain alive in order to not break the links. Could they abandon the trademark and still keep the domain or could Twitter just grab the trademark and based on that later also try to claim the domain and maybe restore all the links from a backup?
- saurik 12y agoSo, with three weeks notice, all tweets that have ever been posted that included a picture using Twitpic (which is a remarkable number) will no longer have their picture available? In fact, do we even have three weeks? I just did a search for "saurik twitpic" on Twitter (https://twitter.com/search?f=realtime&q=saurik%20twitpic https://twitter.com/search?f=realtime&q=saurik%20twitpic) to find people who had posted pictures of me, of them for me, or of my products to show to others, and I'm seeing just a bunch of broken images (the few that work, as in the few that still show images on Twitter's website, such as https://twitter.com/MuscleNerd/status/296068187353661440 https://twitter.com/MuscleNerd/status/296068187353661440, are simply a cache from Twitter's twimg.com: clicking through to Twitpic doesn't work). It seems like twitpic is already offline :/. (So like, I was going to go through and try to frantically download images I'd find relevant in the next week, but I guess it is already too late.) (edit:) Even the broken previews are now disappearing (making this both a little less obvious that there is missing content and also a little more barren-looking). I guess Twitter notices the original image is gone and stops trying to render it through twimg.com, so most of the tweets in my posted search result are now just "imageless" (before they looked like this one, which is older enough that I hadn't rendered it yet to get its cache to clear: http://cache.saurik.com/tinyimg/twitpicoff.png http://cache.saurik.com/tinyimg/twitpicoff.png).
- Wilya 12y agoThe upload functionality seems broken right now. The site says my upload went fine, but I can't see the photo. Are their image file servers getting hammered? Weird.
- OzzyB 12y agoThe Twitpic homepage[1] is also 404'ing big time, perhaps it's just a devops issue more than them pulling the plug before the sunset date? It almost seems like they're playing a little hardball and showing everyone what things will be like if they disappeared from the web, which seems to be what Twitter is threatening them with since they're unable to secure the use of their name and yet millions of images are linked based on that (domain) name. Still, we've seen this story before, Twitter doesn't give a fuck about developers now that they have sufficiently used them to build their platform and brand. But, what's funny is, it was the use of "tweet" that Twitter frowned upon for 3-rd party names -- "twit" was considered fine... [1] http://imgur.com/YLOEKEs http://imgur.com/YLOEKEs
- Eiriksmal 12y agoI'd always assumed Twitter had purchased Twitpic a long time ago. Interesting plot twist.
- OedipusRex 12y agoAt what point do you forego patents for the sake of usability. Twitpic has been around for so long and they have tons of media hosted, all of those Tweets are now essentially broken. Twitter should instead foster a relationship with Twitpic. Twitpic is DEPENDENT on Twitter to work, it's not taking users from Twitter at all (other than hosting media). Truly sad to see.
- bellerocky 12y agoThere is no mention of patents anywhere in the post. This has nothing to do with patents.
- eric_h 12y agoUSPTO: US Patent and Trademark Office. P is not the relevant letter here, T is.
- dave1619 12y agoI don't understand why Twitpic would be shutting down. If they are growing and doing well, then why not just change the business name? Or is it that things aren't going well (usage dropping drastically) and they've already been thinking about shutting down or moving on, and maybe this trademark issue was just the last straw?
- shalmanese 12y agoIsn't the entire reason companies aggressively pursue trademark claims against small fry precisely because lack of enforcement leads to weakening of the mark? I don't see how Twitter has a brand confusion case against them since they've obviously known twitpic existed for many years now and haven't asserted brand confusion until now.
- Kayou 12y agoLesson to learn: don't tie down your service and/or brand to an existing brand/service. Otherwise you're both dependent of that service and/or at risk to get sued sooner or later.
- vblord 12y agoThis is a good point. I've heard of many companies learning this point the hard way.
- unclebunkers 12y agoI must not be paying enough attention, because this doesn't make a lick of sense from Twitters side. If I had a company that was willing to host images instead of me, at no cost to me, and no restrictions on me, I would be a barking mad idiot to disrupt this relationship. Unless I was about to sell...
- jmathai 12y agoI don't think it mentions anything about Twitpic as a service. It's only about the trademark. That being said it makes a lot of sense for Twitter want to control the user experience. The cost of hosting low resolution thumbnails can't be a pressing issue for Twitter. User experience and engagement on the other hand.... I'm not saying it's worth sabotaging relationships with 3rd party developers but there's a certain mindset in which this type of thinking makes a lot of sense.
- nathanb 12y agoAre they just playing chicken with Twitter here? It seems odd that, because Twitter are being trademark jerks, they're going to just take their ball and go home. This feels more like attempted blackmail.
- driverdan 12y agoI suspect Twitter's demand is the straw that broke the camel's back. I'm sure Twitpic use has declined significantly since Twitter introduced their own image hosting. The team has moved on to other projects so there's not much incentive to fight it.
- josefresco 12y agoPretty big straw... Not many fully functional and profitable companies can handle a "Drop your trademark or we'll sue" legal demand from a company like Twitter.
- pionar 12y agoTwo lessons: 1. Don't base your entire business on another business' product. Especially one that has had such a hostile relationship with third parties. When the other business decides to discontinue your access to its service, or otherwise change things, or basically copy what you do under their own brand, you're screwed. 2. Don't create a similar name that will give you trouble in trademark disputes. (Seriously? TwitPic? I work in technology, and even I thought they were owned by Twitter, though admittedly, I don't use Twitter much and don't use TwitPic at all).
- brianbreslin 12y agoWhen they launched I remember thinking they were naming themselves that way for 2 reasons: 1. cause user confusion like you suggested, 2. try to flip to twitter itself.
- numlocked 12y agoI believe Twitpic was a 'weekend project' that Noah put together, that grew into a successful business. AFAIK there was not this level of intentionality behind it in the early days. I suspect twitpic was just the most obvious catchy name that came to mind.
- kordless 12y agoA business product that encourages data isolation, control and non-transparency is not a product anyone should ever want to use.
- ihuman 12y agoI don't think those lessons apply well to this TwitPic scenario, since they have been breaking them for 5 years without any problem.
- pionar 12y agoYeah, they do. It's hasn't been 5 years without any problem, it's was 2 years without any problem, and 3 years of being slowly strangled by Twitter. Plus, if the definition of success is "last 5 years", then that's not a very lofty goal.
- runarb 12y agoHopefully somone like the Archive Team will at least manage to save most of the images. Urls used for images and links seems to be sequential numbers.
- TheLoneWolfling 12y agoI just really hope that no-where in the shutdown does twitpic put up a restrictive robots.txt. Archive.org's retroactive robots.txt and all that.
- topynate 12y agoIf Twitter killed the API that would put Twitpic out of business - but how is that worse than shutting it down? They might as well call Twitter's bluff, if the alternative is just as bad.
- throwawayycacct 12y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4315663 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4315663 I guess stocktwits is next on the chopping block.
- jkaljundi 12y agoI wonder how well Twitpic is doing revenue and profits wise and how much that affected the decision? It's hard to believe only the patent issue is the cause here. Open closing down announcements are nice, but should list all the facts and circumstances, not try to spin it PR wise.
- tim333 12y agoI was wondering that - maybe they are losing money and low on cash. There don't seem to be any patent issues - only that Twitter does not want them to register Twitpic as trademark which I can understand.
- poopsintub 12y agoA 2010 interview with Mixergy, the founder Noah Everett stated: "TwitPic is generating $1.5 to $2 million in ad sales on an annual basis, with 70% profit margins. It was roughly similar revenue in 2012. In interview last month, he said his other company, Pingly will revolutionize email. He's changing focus on something that has real revenue potential and possibly good VC?
- dlsym 12y ago> "A few weeks ago Twitter contacted our legal demanding that we abandon our trademark" Guess it's time to abandon Twitter.
- stesch 12y agoAlternatives?
- dlsym 12y agoWell... there is app.net - But honestly I don't think that anyone beyond a certain german podcast-bubble really uses this.
- stesch 12y agoGerman podcast bubble? I'm from Germany and I don't know what you are talking about. I asked App.net about alternative paying methods because in Germany it's not very common to use your credit card. Nothing.
- treehau5 12y agoTwitter has basically lost all my loyalty because of actions against the developers that made them who they are. Whatever the reasons may be, or even if Twitter is "on the right side of the law" I would rather see them embrace this entrepreneurship than go the route of the bigger tech companies and squash any bit of choice. Typically people use third party add-ons because they enhance the experience. What would twitter be like if they banned all the third party services that convert longer messages and post a shortened version on twitter? I can imagine a similar scenario if, for example, reddit decided all of a sudden to threaten the creator of "reddit enhancement suite" or if they decided to shutdown Imgur, which I think that symbiotic relationship was already mentioned here. Time to look for alternatives.
- k-mcgrady 12y ago>> "Unfortunately we do not have the resources to fend off a large company like Twitter to maintain our mark which we believe whole heartedly is rightfully ours. Therefore, we have decided to shut down Twitpic." Is this supposed to be serious? You're shutting down your company because you're stubborn and not getting what you want??
- bubblicious 12y agoProbably a poker move to put pressure on Twitter... If the company is doing well, they'll do what it takes to keep it running, even if it means changing its brand.
- spiritplumber 12y agoThis is why you want to run your own server for this sort of thing... or at least use something standardised and portable.
- tiles 12y agoHere is the relevant Archive Team project for Twitpic: http://archiveteam.org/index.php?title=Twitpic http://archiveteam.org/index.php?title=Twitpic
- biot 12y agoThey're going to pivot and introduce a suite of new services which use the same underlying engine to share pictures across a variety of social media sites: Googpic: share on Google+ Facepic: share on Facebook Instapic: share on Instagram Tumbpic: share on Tumblr Pinterpic: share on Pinterest When interviewed, the founder stated "We plan on filing trademark applications for these new service names and anticipate no further legal issues. It's regrettable that Twitter is acting so unreasonable by taking reasonable steps to protect its mark."
- mikeash 12y agoThey weren't facing legal issues with Twitter, so that last part seems somewhat off base.
- edent 12y agoA year ago I wrote a quick Python script to export all my images. If anyone wants to use it (or improve on it) I blogged about it at http://shkspr.mobi/blog/2013/08/exporting-twitpic-images-python/ http://shkspr.mobi/blog/2013/08/exporting-twitpic-images-pyt...
- hugs 12y agoTHANK YOU!!!! I just used a modified version of your script to download all my data. Again, THANK YOU!!! My version: https://gist.github.com/hugs/fa7892da03ce660c212e https://gist.github.com/hugs/fa7892da03ce660c212e Changes: * Use the short_id as the image filename. * Use https instead of http when downloading the json data. * Save the json data to individiual "page-*.json" files. Quick question: Is it okay to use the MIT license for this?
- edent 12y agoGo ahead :-)
- nilved 12y agoIt's a shame Twitter has become so developer-hostile. When it first came out, I remember the excitement of using Twitter as a host platform for other apps. Now I couldn't imagine writing a line of code that interacts with their platform. It's a nightmare. I wish app.net had been more successful: it was clearly an attempt to ride the waves of that excitement after it'd been made clear that Twitter had jumped the shark.
- korzun 12y ago> It's a shame Twitter has become so developer-hostile Nothing about this is developer hostile. I'm rather surprised this did not happen sooner.
- zhte415 12y agoLink rot
- zyx321 12y agoTo be perfectly honest, I am surprised to learn that twitpic is owned by a different company than twitter itself, which is precisely what trademark law is supposed to prevent.
- msvan 12y agoI think the issue here is that Twitpic's business model is having people leave the main Twitter interface to take them to another domain, where Twitpic can extract advertising money from the impressions. Twitter has image previews these days, which offer a nicer user experience and keep users on the main Twitter site. With Twitter hosting images itself, it makes little business sense for them to continue letting Twitpic make ad money off a feature duplicated externally.
- sp332 12y agoHere's a reminder to please donate to the Internet Archive. https://archive.org/donate/index.php https://archive.org/donate/index.php They have tons of old twitpic pages! http://web.archive.org/web/20140304234132/http://twitpic.com/ http://web.archive.org/web/20140304234132/http://twitpic.com... See that timeline at the top? You can go to any date and browse around. And the Internet Archive is more than just the "Wayback Machine" that lets you browse old versions of websites. They have massive datasets of video, audio, and texts too - check out the examples on the homepage. And you can add your own collections now. https://archive.org/create/ https://archive.org/create/ They just finished ingesting 2TB of public Fotopedia photos before it went down. Do you know how much it costs to store a terabyte permanently? Not an offline backup, but accessible 24/7 forever? About $2,000! Power, cooling, redundancy, and especially dedicated people to keep it all going. https://archive.org/donate/index.php https://archive.org/donate/index.php
- toomuchtodo 12y agoShoutout to Jason and #archiveteam. Great work on Fotopedia, ready to launch DO instances to go grab Twitpic!
- sp332 12y agoI didn't mean to leave out credit to Archive Team :) But last I checked they don't need more help, whereas most of the data they grab ends up on the Internet Archive who really could use the money.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> whereas most of the data they grab ends up on the Internet Archive who really could use the money. Completely agreed. The IA is a treasure, an underfunded one at that.
- theoutlander 12y agoWhy didn't Twitter acquire them instead? Did they try that and fail?
- cwyers 12y agoWhy would they? What assets does Twitpic have that Twitter wants? They built a "better" service on their own. They don't need the brand Twitpic. What's left?
- theoutlander 12y agoThat's true. I imagined more on the lines of a talent acquisition.
- the_ancient 12y agothousands/millions of images form twitter users that could be converted seemlessly in to twitter's in house solution providing a good user experience for their users preventing the breakage of the site and creating a PR problem for them...
- Damin0u 12y agoSo it's time to try this backup tool https://github.com/Stantheman/Twitpic-Backup https://github.com/Stantheman/Twitpic-Backup
- mlacitation 12y agoThanks for the shoutout! Twitpic-Backup is pretty old but will definitely get your images. Props to pcgMongo for today's PR: https://github.com/Stantheman/Twitpic-Backup/pull/2 https://github.com/Stantheman/Twitpic-Backup/pull/2
- CCs 12y agoThanks! It's a straight forward shell script using wget. It just needs twitter handle and working folder name, downloads everything.
- pbreit 12y agoJust change the name already. Jeepers.
- ytwit 12y agoTwitter being dicks... As usual
- _puk 12y agoThey could always go back to twitter and propose dropping the lawsuit if they change their name? Yes I know Twitpic is the brand, but if they were to simply DNS redirect Twitpic.com to ickleimages.com [1](available!) then twitter wouldn't be littered with old broken images, and the company could work on pushing the new brand. They do now support more than twitter after all. If it's a viable business, it seems crazy to throw it away to prove a point that many probably saw as an issue from the outset (That is the use of twit* for a service that leeches off twitter's success). I'm sure changing every single link to serve twittermademedoit.gif would be frowned upon.. but then the company isn't going to exist any more.. disclaimer. I've never used Twitpic before, nor posted on twitter so may be missing something.. [1] http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=ickle http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=ickle
- 83457 12y agoSounds like there is either more to this or this is a strategy. I'm guessing they would like to sell but can't do to possibly of being sued by Twitter over their name. Not so much that Twitpic can't continue but they can't get further funding or bought out due to risk.
- snowwrestler 12y agoI don't get it. Why not just change the name and keep going?
- dkarapetyan 12y agoLets put this in perspective. Some twitter pictures are going to disappear. In the grand scheme of things the people who had the luxury of using this service will survive just fine. Please stop the navel gazing.
- mrjatx 12y agoAfter having both Lightbox7 and whatever Sonys big photo-store/share platform close down and wipe out my high school/college albums I've learned to definitely not rely on any image hosting services. Back then there wasn't twitter or any other good social media and you found things out by visiting the site or through ICQ.
- joshdance 12y agoThis is revealing in 2 ways. 1. Twitter doesn't care about developers. 2. Twitpic wasn't making enough money.
- jacquesm 12y agoNever ever, ever build a service that is 100% dependent on another service that you don't have alternatives for and never use someone else's trademark in order to leverage your business. That's two fatal mistakes in one go, they should be rather surprised that they held on this long. But maybe the 'user outrage' will be enough to get twitter to buy them, though - assuming twitter isn't dumb - that would be a bad move because that would lead to hundreds of copycat attempts.
- jonknee 12y agoThere's more to this story... If I had to guess I would say that it's no longer profitable (or at least, very profitable as it once was) and it's not fun to run an image host (imagine all the trouble that comes with just copyright issues, let alone criminal matters). The founder also has a new startup called Pingly which I'm sure is more rewarding to be working on. On its face Twitpic is shutting down because they won't get their trademark, but they've never had their trademark and have had no problems operating. Twitter isn't suing them, they're just saying they are against the trademark application. They don't need the trademark and it's bizarre to shut your company down for the possibility of being forced to change your name in the future. If Twitpic wanted to continue running they could without any changes or extra work. It's a dead end though, Twitter has its own image service and there is little reason besides legacy to use Twitpic. Here's their traffic situation which should pretty well mirror revenue as it's web based advertising paying the bills: https://www.quantcast.com/twitpic.com https://www.quantcast.com/twitpic.com They're hemorrhaging traffic. Globally there were 85,043,992 visits in the month period a year ago compared to 13,315,016 in the most recent month. That's also just the past year, Twitpic has been on the decline for years and peaked in July 2011 with a cool 280,021,248 visits. Expenses are likely not down nearly the same amount as they have to store more and more images every month (with less traffic there is less bandwidth, but this doesn't count images not loaded on their website). Just in the last month they lost 46% compared to the previous period. It's falling off a cliff. This seems like a good way to get some sympathy on the way out. A rude move to their users though. Maybe Twitter can step in and offer a bottom dollar buyout so that the links don't break.
- e12e 12y agoThis echoes my thoughts when I read the post. Sounds like a clasdic case of simple cloud service losing profitability; answer shut down and screw your users. Afaik the service was free, so I don't have much sympathy for the users; but blaming twitter seems disingenuous.
- sfall 12y agoi saw an article mention noah working on this http://pingly.com/ http://pingly.com/
- talhof8 12y agoIsn't he the guy from Heello?