10 ms·
I've been mystified how Uber's kept up their "Underdog" mantle for as long as they have. They've raised over $1.5B in investment from some of the biggest compan
by mikeyouse 12y ago
I've been mystified how Uber's kept up their "Underdog" mantle for as long as they have. They've raised over $1.5B in investment from some of the biggest companies, private equity firms, and VCs on earth. I think you stop being an underdog as soon as Goldman Sachs, Blackrock, TPG, KPCB, Google, and Jeff Bezos are invested in your success.
They likely have more cash-on-hand than the cumulative Taxi base they are 'disrupting', they've been caught multiple times sabotaging competitors, they've been outed for dishonest advertising, and have been repeatedly accused of hostile actions toward their drivers. They ignore sensible regulations like maximum hourly workweeks and insurance minimums (do you want your driver working 90hrs/week without liability insurance?) under the guise of fighting the taxi cartel.
It often takes a 'push' to get bad laws changed, and Uber's provided much of that push, but not all laws that restrain business are bad and not all companies that break bad laws are good.
- freehunter 12y agoWhat it boils down to, though, is it doesn't matter how much investment money you have if you're declared to be operating an illegal business and ordered to shut down. At this point, Uber and other ride-share companies are still in that danger zone. They're operating against the law in many cities (mine included, not that I'm complaining), and could be fined or forced to close at any moment. Think it won't happen? It happened to Aereo. Sure, they didn't have as much money and weren't in as many locations, but its a similar vibe: if they closed their doors tomorrow, nothing would change. They might be in the process of disrupting the market, but they haven't won yet. They could lose everything overnight.
- camillomiller 12y agoThat's probably why they're employing such shady tactics. They need the fastest growth they can achieve, in order to become huge enough and making it difficult for the regulator to shut them down by means of law.
- CamperBob2 12y agoThat's probably why they're employing such shady tactics. They need the fastest growth they can achieve, because those new 911 turbos aren't going to buy themselves. There ya go, fixed it.
- mikeyouse 12y ago> the regulator Which regulator?
- dnautics 12y agonothing would change Well, in my market (San Diego), anyways, I am certain the number of drunk drivers would go up, and the bar industry would see a hit in their clientele. I rarely even drink myself, but I don't think twice about calling a Lyft to go out or come back after drinking.
- freehunter 12y ago>number of drunk drivers would go up >bar industry would see a hit in their clientele Back to pre-Uber levels, presumably.
- cm127 12y agoIt'll mean less bars. More bars have opened than closed since Uber has been around.
- altcognito 12y agoFrankly, I'm not sure how the country survived before Uber.
- objclxt 12y agoI haven't heard of many bear attacks since Uber started offering their service either. Must be connected.
- cm127 12y agoI guess I should say that the growth of bars seem to be exceeding the growth of parking lots. Does that mean more people are carpooling or taking cabs? Maybe. But it could also mean Uber has an effect.
- vacri 12y agoMore bars have been opened during the economic recovery after the GFC?
- mikeyouse 12y ago> They're operating against the law in many cities (mine included, not that I'm complaining), and could be fined or forced to close at any moment. This plays into their "Uber vs. The Taxi Cartel" trope perfectly. In reality, Taxi regulations vary by city, state, and country. Uber is now operating in over 90 cities in the US and in 44 other countries. They couldn't possibly be "forced to close at any moment" since their business is legal or at least 'not illegal' in the vast majority of those territories. The "Taxi Cartel" is really several hundred independent locally granted monopolies that exist to attempt to ensure requirements that Uber is going to ignore. The highly profitable airport routes exist to subsidize the requirement that taxis are handicap-accessible and can't discriminate against customers. Medallions were created to ensure that cars were properly maintained, drivers could earn decent wages, and that there wouldn't be reoccurrences of the crime waves against taxis and customers that led to medallions in the first place. Obviously the number of medallions has been restricted to an unreasonably small number in most places causing the terrible service that many are used to. Also fairly obviously, the advent of the smartphone with personal profiles has reduced the crime potential facing the typical cabbie as well as the issues hailing cabs in outer boroughs or less populated neighborhoods. All of that said, it's not like cab companies or taxi drivers are widely profitable. The only public Medallion company (NASDAQ: TAXI) only makes $35M in revenue/year and about 1/3 of that in net income. If the claims surrounding Uber are true, they're projecting close to $2 Billion in net revenue in the very near future. If Uber does indeed take all of the profitable routes, Taxi companies will close their doors. Some might consider that a net win, but consider the Uber app and the demographics of Smartphone owners (http://i.imgur.com/T5JpmQE.png http://i.imgur.com/T5JpmQE.png) and then try and estimate how many Ubers are handicap-accessible. This would only be a net win for the wealthy, young, and non-handicapped, which was the entire point of taxi regulation in the first place. I don't mean to argue that Uber = Bad and Taxis = Good, and there are other options to solve these problems rather than local monopolies and route protection, but the simplistic "Uber vs. Taxis" analysis usually ignores all of the externalities that would accompany a taxi-less world.
- freehunter 12y agoIn my opinion, all it would take for Uber to be shut down is a sufficiently big enough fine for violating the law in one or a couple cities. If they got hit with a $5000 per passenger fine in a major metropolitan area with thousands of passengers, how long with the major investors keep pumping in money? There's little hope of a return on that kind of loss. In my city I thought Uber would be massively successful. I was so excited when they launched. But there are hardly any drivers around, because the police calls up Uber rides and then tickets the driver for operating an illegal cab. No one wants to drive with that persecution going on.
- tomphoolery 12y agoAereo is fighting a much larger battle. It's the difference between fighting a house cat and a sabretooth tiger. The problem with Aereo is not that it is so good for consumers that some people aren't getting "their cut"...it all boils down to advertising. With Aereo, it's no longer truly possible to tell someone how many homes they are reaching with advertising dollars. How are network executives supposed to quantify how much they can charge to advertisers, now that they have even less of an idea of the effect of those advertisements? Also, since Aereo was being considered as on-par with the rest of the CATV providers, why weren't they required to pay retransmission fees? Although I really did believe in Aereo's promise of a better future, and I absolutely think that the future of television is streaming linear broadcasting, I always knew that it was going to be killed off by legislation because the cable industry is SO corrupt that there is literally no room for disruption. On the other hand, Uber is not illegal. It never really was. Taxi cartels are attempting to twist the law to make it sound illegal. But really, Uber is just a dispatching service for limo companies that already exist. If you're talking about UberX, that may be a different story. UberX is not available in all 90 cities that regular Uber operates in, but there are enough cities with just regular Uber service that it won't be a problem if they have to shutter UberX for some reason down the line.
- colechristensen 12y agoThere are bastions of sanity in the world. My city government and Uber worked together to put Uber/Lyft under legal regulation while at the same time doing a small amount of deregulation of taxis to help competition. There was a _healthy_ amount of dissent which made reasonable points and the measure eventually passed. It may be cold half the year in Minneapolis, but I think it makes people a little more reasonable. http://blogs.citypages.com/blotter/2014/07/mpls_city_council_approves_lyftuberx_regulations_blong_yang_casts_sole_nay_vote.php http://blogs.citypages.com/blotter/2014/07/mpls_city_council...
- mikeash 12y agoI disagree, I think business size matters a lot. Uber may not be there yet, but the nature of legal violations changes for big companies. It's like they say: if you owe the bank a million dollars, you have a problem. If you owe the bank a billion dollars, the bank has a problem. Similarly, a sufficiently large business breaking the law is more a problem for the government than the business. Just look at how much trouble e.g. Bank of America got in for all their illegal shenanigans surrounding the mortgage crisis. Uber also has the advantage that they're generally not dealing with national governments, but local ones, who are much more easily swayed by big businesses. One locality might declare them illegal, but they can just drop that market and move on. Or more likely, as happened here in Virginia a few weeks ago, they'll come to some sort of arrangement with the local government and be back in business in a few days.
- wdr1 12y ago> I've been mystified how Uber's kept up their "Underdog" mantle for as long as they have. I see them as the "underground." Granted they have gotten a lot of funding, their primary opposition -- taxis -- are firmly entrenched & cities all over the country have considered various legislation to ban/stop them. In fact, I think it's somewhat silly they're fighting with Lyft. They should be working together to knock back the entrenched players.
- sitkack 12y agoI see Uber as wanting their own future monopoly. They aren't some egalitarian democratic plumb bob making the world better for everyone. They are a national and trans-national transportation monopoly that has deep brand recognition while forcing drivers to play or pray, same schtick as the taxi companies. Why else would Goldman Sachs and Blackrock be involved? Someone needs to make the craigslist of Uber or a Meta-Uber. The fact that many uber drivers are also taxi operators is very telling.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoOr have cities provide Uber-esq services in lockstep with their other transportation services (bus, light rail, etc). Don't we argue always for the last-mile to be a public utility? Same scenario. Whitelabel services can contract with locales, an API is provided that anyone can integrate with, and the city can manage capacity and utilization.
- sitkack 12y agoThis is a great idea. A public clearing house utility for transportation. Seattle just started one of these to integrate public and private parkinglot availability. Why not for personal transit? it would be like the nasdaq of transpo.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoLet the requirements gathering begin.
- snowwrestler 12y agoEvery company is, to some extent, an underdog against governments. They may have more money than taxis, but taxis often have entire local agencies dedicated to their industry. It's extremely difficult to break that sort of captured regulatory structure. The ICC for example was chartered in 1887 to regulate railroads, and was not dissolved until 1995!
- saalweachter 12y ago... are you casting Gilded Age robber barons as underdogs?
- snowwrestler 12y agoI don't understand how anyone could get that from my comment. Could you elaborate? I'm honestly confused.
- corin_ 12y agoHe did go a little away from the topic, but you did (roughly) say that, even if it wasn't the crux of your point. > " Every company is, to some extent, an underdog against governments." Why would "Gilded Age robber barons" be excluded from that statement? And he went to them based on the fact that you also mentioned that period of time (and regulation that affected them). So while I wouldn't have written that reply myself, it's fairly obvious how he got to it from your comment
- snowwrestler 12y agoThey would be excluded because I wrote "is," which is the present tense. The ICC is just a great example of how hard it is to get rid of a regulatory agency, even when it is obviously no longer needed.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wklauss 12y ago> not all companies that break bad laws are good. This to me, is the key of the problem. Yes, the taxi medallion system was broken in many cities and Uber is forcing to at least acknowledge that regulation in it's current form it's not longer useful. But I think that as a company Uber it's not a positive force on the public transportation market. Quite the opposite. I love tu use it when I'm in San Francisco but cannot shake the feeling that we are screwing ourselves long term by supporting it.
- pdonis 12y ago> I love tu use it when I'm in San Francisco but cannot shake the feeling that we are screwing ourselves long term by supporting it. Have you considered not using it?
- crdoconnor 12y ago>This to me, is the key of the problem. Yes, the taxi medallion system was broken in many cities and Uber is forcing to at least acknowledge that regulation in it's current form it's not longer useful. The medallion system was never "useful". It was simply a feudalistic setup designed with the help of regulatory capture to allow private investors to impose a private tax on riders and drivers. Uber is simply modifying the feudal system, placing themselves at the top instead of the medallion owners. Given the range of big investors and political support for the company (that stretches all the way up to Obama), I would guess that it's not even a change in who owns the taxi system - Goldman sachs are probably simply buying up uber stock and dumping medallions on easily duped investors - pension funds and the like, while lobbying their ass off to give Uber a free pass on all this lyft sabotage bullshit.
- rayiner 12y ago> Goldman sachs are probably simply buying up uber stock and dumping medallions on easily duped investors Owning a taxi medallion is like owning a McDonald's franchise. Doesn't exactly make you a Master of the Universe. A $1 million investment in an NYC medallion nets you a maximum of about $75,000 a year: http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2011/10/21/why-taxi-medallions-cost-1-million http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2011/10/21/why-taxi-me.... The average McDonald's franchise nets $200-250k/year, and costs about $750k-1.5 million to buy.
- rayiner 12y agoThe whole "taxi cartel" thing is stupid. It arises out of this really distressing attitude that every dispute must involve "good guys" and "bad guys." Yes, the taxi companies are trying to shut down Uber and Lyft using regulation, but they are just trying to enforce a legal monopoly granted to them by the cities in which they operate. It's a legal right they got in return to agreeing to measures like rate regulation and "common carrier"-esque regulations concerning routes. I personally think most of the taxi regulations are stupid, especially the price controls. But they're not irrational, nor did these legal regimes arise out of nefarious lobbying on the part of taxi companies. Rate regulations, forbidding surge pricing, requiring cabs to serve the whole city, etc, arise from cities treating cabs as a part of the overall municipal transit infrastructure. The "last half mile" of transit, as it were. I don't think regulated monopolies are a good idea, but they're certainly a common solution when it comes to industries that resemble public infrastructure. Given that the taxi companies were granted monopolies as part of a larger regulatory regime, why are they "evil" for trying to enforce that privilege in the face of companies like Uber taking the high value routes out from under them, using techniques like surge pricing they aren't allowed to use?
- dmix 12y agoAs you point out, most people are critiquing the state intervention for being woefully outdated and not inline with market economics (as they always seem to end up being overtime thanks to technology). No-one really thinks the Taxi companies are the "evil" ones because they were handed monopolies on a platter then got comfortable and fat with their position. If the local administrators have the power to hand out monopolies, they should also have the responsibility to retract it when it no longer makes sense. A repeated and long-delayed failure to do so is harmful to society, whether or not it was had good intentions at the beginning doesn't absolve it of criticism now.
- serve_yay 12y agoIt's a bad law, but as people point out downthread, breaking a bad law is not in itself a good deed, it is simply a neutral one.
- hkmurakami 12y ago>I've been mystified how Uber's kept up their "Underdog" mantle for as long as they have. Companies intentionally market themselves to mislead in ways that are beneficial to them, in terms of image. One example is Hyundai, which walks the fine line of modeling its logo and style after Honda to draw off Honda's goodwill with customers (I think that this is quite smart). I wonder how much Uber has invested in its PR status to keep this underdog image.
- anthony_d 12y agoI agree with the idea of what you're saying, but Hyundai vs Honda seems odd to me. I've owned and liked 2 Hyundai but really don't understand why people buy Honda's.
- crdoconnor 12y ago>I've been mystified how Uber's kept up their "Underdog" mantle for as long as they have. They now have a guy from the Obama campaign (David Plouffe) working on their PR.
- uptown 12y agoHe must be really good considering he hasn't even started yet. "David Plouffe, the former campaign manager and White House adviser to President Barack Obama, is taking his political secret sauce to Uber late next month as senior vice president of policy and strategy" http://www.politico.com/story/2014/08/david-plouffe-uber-campaign-manager-110149.html http://www.politico.com/story/2014/08/david-plouffe-uber-cam...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wellboy 12y agoIf Uber is already this evil now, what things can we expect once they go into ground transport in general with self-driving cars? I don't want to trust a nefarious company to drive me and my kids around! How can their investors, of which some are excellent startup investors, be fine with this. Is there no guidance at all??