3 ms·
It's sad to see Ars repeating the old "Firewire failed to beat USB" myth. Firewire was never designed to handle modems, mice, keyboards, gamepads, or other low
by MBCook 12y ago
It's sad to see Ars repeating the old "Firewire failed to beat USB" myth.
Firewire was never designed to handle modems, mice, keyboards, gamepads, or other low bandwidth things; and it never made the move to try.
On the other hand, USB 1.0 was never suited for high bandwidth devices like hard drives, video cameras, and flatbed scanners. If you remember using USB 1.0 hard drives, you remember how amazingly slow they were.
They were designed for different purposes. Firewire never went 'down', it stayed with high bandwidth devices; but USB moved 'up' with USB 2 to better service the high bandwidth devices people were trying to use (like hard drives).
Firewire 400 was usually faster than USB 2, but cost and ubiquity (and Sony's crazy 4-pin connector) meant it was never big with consumers. But in the end Firewire could only hold onto parts of the professional market for high bandwidth devices.
Thunderbolt is the challenger (really replacement) to FireWire. When USB 4 comes out in two or three years are we going to see articles about how USB defeated Thunderbolt because Thunderbolt keyboards never became popular?
Yeah. The Firewire vs. USB thing is almost always used to add an 'opponent' where there often wasn't one. After all, all articles are required to have an 'opponent'. Sure you could talk about how the old ports hung on amazingly long in the PC space, but it's more fun to throw unnecessary punches at FireWire.
But honestly, no one ever sold a Firewire mouse. I would love to see a link to one. I know there were a few Firewire thumbdrives that were supposed to be amazingly fast, but it's not exactly apples and oranges.
- burnte 12y agoWhile I agree that Firewire never went after the low end, it is that very fact why it, in the end, failed. We had a plethora of ports in the olden days, slow ones like serial, parallel, and PS/2, for modems, printers, and input devices, and we even had SCSI ports for external storage, and ethernet jacks for networking. Those days were terrible. We converged into a few physical ports than can do all of that for a reason, and that reason was because we wanted something inferior. The reason was because one port is better for humans. Computers are here to make our lives easier, not the reverse. Firewire was good for external storage and moving large amounts of data (like audio/video) fast, and when USB became as good, while also handling everything else, then Firewire became obsolete, as it was yet another port to take up space and cable to hang on to and lose. USB has greater utility than Firewire due to its flexibility of being a very nearly universal port. USB wasn't necessary invented as a competitor to Firewire, but it's not a myth that it became one, and it won in the end.
- MCRed 12y ago>"USB wasn't necessary invented as a competitor to Firewire, but it's not a myth that it became one, and it won in the end." That is a contradiction. In the end, what defeated Firewire (by supplanting its ports) was Thunderbolt, not USB. Machines with Firewire had USB as well, because they served different purposes and were not in competition. I have some machines with both Firewire and Thunderbolt, and later machines with Thunderbolt. (They all have USB, but nobody is connecting 4k displays via USB.) Edit: Ah, I see this is a lost cause. This is falling into the "everything PC is good and everything Apple is bad" HN narrative. No point in attempting to point out history either, it appears.
- _greim_ 12y agoIt might be a myth that Firewire failed to beat USB as you say but it doesn't seem too far off to say that USB succeeded in beating Firewire. I don't think the article was too far out of bounds in portraying it as a competition.
- lmm 12y agoThere was a brief window where consumer PCs came with firewire ports. There were a lot of fanboy arguments about how firewire was technically superior / faster for hard drives. There were even hard drives that came with both ports - I still have one somewhere. There was a genuine format war in the consumer hard drive space - and USB won it. In a few years will you be arguing that Thunderbolt never really competed with USB because it was never meant as a consumer standard?
- xorcist 12y agoNot just fanboy arguments. You could boot off them just like a SCSI device. This was not possible with USB drives at the time (and is still a messy affair). The performance was very different too. Firewire/i.Link/IEEE 1394 was also the dominant standard for video streaming. Nobody even tried using USB for that AFAIK. Light Peak/Thunderbolt replaced both of these uses for 1394, so I think it's fair to say it is a true replacement for it.
- lmm 12y agoBootable USB may be messy to prepare, but on the user end it largely Just Works. As with many hardware-vs-software things (e.g. RAID controllers), Firewire performance was originally much better but USB caught up as processors got faster. A standard for USB video streaming eventually emerged (at least, I have that option in my kernel), but it's fair to say it was much less popular than 1394. Mostly camcorders (at least consumer ones) became digital themselves, storing data on a filesystem and presenting themselves as a mass storage device.