10 ms·
Introducing EFF's Stupid Patent of the Month
- Ihategod 12y agoAm I the only one that advocates the complete elimination of patents and copyrights?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ArtDev 12y agoI hope so. Have you ever been to China or India? This is the opposite extreme and it is worse. No one invents anything novel. Every product is cheap replica of something else. Its a race to the bottom. Much worse.
- lostcolony 12y agoMan, if that's the only alternative to patents, I wonder how we managed to bootstrap the idea of a patent system.
- sliverstorm 12y agoIt was harder to rip off somebody else's design hundreds of years ago, and the USA has not spent much time without patents. IP is even discussed in the Constitution.
- userbinator 12y agoEvery product is cheap replica of something else. ...and often has improvements that are practically useful. There, innovation happens bottom-up, with incremental changes to an existing product, and there's far more design sharing and competition since exclusivity doesn't last.
- chrismonsanto 12y agoThis is a great idea. If you want to demonstrate just how much software patents suck, you need to be able to point out examples. Yet I've seen many people who try to do so get shutdown with remarks like "you're not a lawyer", "you don't understand patent claims", "if you read this in a Lawyer-Approved Fashion (tm) it turns out this IS a good patent claim", etc. It'll be a lot harder to dismiss examples of shitty patents if their shittiness is endorsed by the legal expertise of the EFF.
- isaacdl 12y agoWow, this a thousand times. It's so incredibly frustrating to have discussions about stuff like this with people who don't have the same knee-jerk mistrust of the patent system that I do. I'm not saying my reaction is right, just that it'll be nice to have something to point too and say "told ya so...". Of course, the people I know who don't think that the patent system is broken are probably the people who don't necessarily know/trust the EFF.
- ArtDev 12y agoJunk patents like this one are are a real threat to innovation, progress and small business in America.
- auxbuss 12y agoJunk patents are a threat to innovation, progress, and small businesses globally.
- aptwebapps 12y agoThey don't have to trust the EFF blindly - they do a pretty good job of explaining what's wrong with this patent.
- loup-vaillant 12y agoMany (most?) people believe in authority more than they believe in explanations. They watch TV everyday, and TV displays a tremendous amount of authority (all those expert guests in suits). "Patents sucks" is a contrarian opinion in this environment. Without a proper-looking authority to back that up, no amount of explanation will ever convince those people. They will just assume there "must be a reason" for this, even if they don't understand it. The alternative is to teach them how to think. This will take time.
- josho 12y agoIn my startup we are knowingly violating two other companies patents and it scares me. The patents are stupid (tagging a photo--ie. circle part of a photo to highlight where something is, and the second is adding GPS data to a record, so that you can find it later). One of the companies is even litigious having field two patent suits this year. The only thing saving us at this point is we are a Canadian company and haven't entered the US market yet. So, here is a concrete case of patents discouraging innovation and competition. We want to enter the US market because the competitors are selling backward solutions. We have an alternative that is 10x better, yet our company could be killed in an instant through one of these patents.
- ChrisAntaki 12y ago> adding GPS data to a record, so that you can find it later You might want to nominate this patent
- smokinn 12y agoIf that's your most pressing concern about expanding the business you should probably consider challenging the validity of the patent if it's truly as obvious as it seems. http://info.legalzoom.com/challenge-patent-21969.html http://info.legalzoom.com/challenge-patent-21969.html
- jfoutz 12y agoOr just abandon the US because the regulation is a pain in the ass. It's not Josho's obligation to keep the US from turning into a technological ghetto.
- fleitz 12y agoNo, don't challenge the patent, minimize infringement, amass cash. Challenge it after being sued hopefully with enough cash to defend yourself.
- zak_mc_kracken 12y agoOr maybe, don't infringe the patent and innovate by creating your own approach to the problem?
- mhlakhani 12y agoGiven the volume of patents out there, wouldn't it be more appropriate to have something like "stupid patent of the day"?
- georgemcbay 12y agoEven with stupid patent of the day I suspect they would have enough content to keep going long after I am dead, even if they only consider patents that were issued up until today... but it would require a lot more effort to find, read, understand and write about them than a once a month thing.
- merraksh 12y agothe original claim 1 [...] had not claimed a computer. The examiner correctly issued a rejection, saying the claim was abstract and thus wasn’t something that could be patented. In response, the applicant added element (g) (“providing a computer, the computer performing steps “a” through “f””). And the rejection went away. I see this happen in peer-reviewed research. A reviewer rejects the paper/patent based on a flaw that is perhaps not as gross but is at least concrete. When the flaw is removed (in this case the use of computer), the reviewer almost has no choice but to accept it. Can't the reviewer reject it for other reasons?
- AnimalMuppet 12y agoDoesn't the recent Supreme Court ruling destroy this patent, then?
- mullingitover 12y agoIs there any kind of logic to granting stupid patents? It seems like if their approval was really harmful to the industry, it would manifest itself in reduced tax revenues. No government wants that. So is the government increasing its revenues by granting these arbitrary technology fiefdoms?
- smeyer 12y agoDecisions can be motivated by lots of things other than maximizing tax revenue. For example, political beliefs/agendas of various relevant parties, lobbying, bureaucratic lock-in, and so on.
- chc 12y ago"The government" is not a coherent entity. The government is made up of many self-interested groups who largely don't care and possibly don't even know about one another. The relevant agency here, the Patent and Trademark Office, is not funded by tax dollars — it's funded by fees from people or businesses seeking patents and trademarks.
- mullingitover 12y ago> The relevant agency here, the Patent and Trademark Office, is not funded by tax dollars — it's funded by fees from people or businesses seeking patents and trademarks. Sure, but their actions have ramifications that could impact revenues. If the patent system was smothering the market and therefore tax revenues, one would think that the government might eventually act in its own interests and legislate a solution. On the other hand, if the current scheme is actually boosting revenues, there might be some hesitation in fixing something that, for the government, isn't a problem at all.
- marcosdumay 12y agoIf you take a look, you'll discover that almost nobody in a typical government even thinks about tax revenues (except when they are paying it).
- locusm 12y agoI wonder what the cost of getting a frivolous patent like this is? Anyone?
- rhino369 12y agoUSPTO fees are about 400 to apply. Another 450 if it's approved. More if you have a ton of extra stuff. The real cost is having some draft it and prosecute it. That's like 15-20k.
- rrggrr 12y agoPrior art is probably this: http://www.rapidremedy.com http://www.rapidremedy.com
- minikomi 12y agoMaybe someone should make a "patent or not patent?" game, where it describes mundane things and you have to guess if it's patented or not.
- x0054 12y agoWow, so by example I should file this patent: Method and Apparatus for Making Lots of Money 1. File an over broad patent by (a) describing an everyday procedure currently commonly preformed by humans and (b) adding "performed by a computer" to your claim. Alternatively, purchase a similar over broad patent from someone else. 2. Identify companies which utilize procedures which may fall under your patent. 3. Identify other companies that may utilize procedures slightly (or even barely) resembling those covered by your patent. 4. Determine prevailing legal fees for a patent defense case in the given area for each of the companies identified in steps 2 and 3. 5. Call all of those companies identified in steps 2 and 3 and threaten to sue them unless they settle for the sum of 80% of the prevailing legal fees identified in step 4. 6. Preform steps 1 through 5 using a computer.
- mjt0229 12y agoI'm sure they'll be hilarious. Hope one of mine isn't one of them.
- higherpurpose 12y agoThere's a great list here they can start with: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/06/chinese-govt-reveals-microsofts-secret-list-of-android-killer-patents/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/06/chinese-govt-reve...
- dewiz 12y agoSomeone please fund EFF and make this a weekly event. If there is a chance of fixing the law, the cost of documenting its flaws is miniscule compared to the millions in damages done.
- scrollaway 12y agoIf you want to donate, just donate! The EFF always puts the money to excellent uses. https://supporters.eff.org/donate https://supporters.eff.org/donate
- coldpie 12y agoStrongly consider a monthly donation, too. Nonprofits really like recurring donations because it gives them a relatively stable funding base to use for future planning.
- netcan 12y agoThey "scan to email" patent they mention at the start is famous largely because the owner is extremely aggressive, they even go after end users. IE, they might sue any company that has a scanner so their list of targets is basically the phonebook. “Method and Apparatus for Indirect Medical Consultation” was issued on June 24, 2014. Presumably there is already a software/companies/people doing this that started before last month. If they are targeted, what happens? IE, if software published before June 24 is accused of violating this patent is there any possible case for it? Would it still cost huge amount of money to defend against this attack? Would losing the claim automatically invalidate the claim?
- edpichler 12y agoIn Brazil you simply can't patent abstract ideas, game rules, techiquies and operation methods, software, math methods, etc, and "ways to do things" like this on the eff.org I'm not sure if this is equal for other countries.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoIs there any way to make challenging stupid patents directly profitable? I would love to see someone figuring out how to make a business model out of it and using VC money to bankroll the process.
- api 12y agoAnother question is why do companies get them? Software and other ephemeral businesses lack physical assets. That's scary to quite a few MBA types, especially those brought up outside this industry. A patent is something that makes software look on the balance sheet as if it's a physical asset that the company holds. It's all an illusion, but it's a security blanket for these types.