16 ms·
Let's Build a Traditional City and Make a Profit
- carsongross 12y agoAmen. But good luck getting it past planning. We don't build even mediocre cities anymore because, for the most part, we've made them illegal.
- jamespitts 12y agoWell how about we get in front of city council and advocate for some changes? I've done it in Ann Arbor for a city park and people really do like it when local geeks and other folks not usually going to these meetings stand up and have something to say.
- aperrien 12y agoWhy not make a housing sandwich? (of sorts) Like this: Road/Parking___Housing/Shops___Greenway/Park___Housing/Shops___Road/Parking It costs a bit of land, but the area would be much nicer.
- enf 12y agoMostly because if you're trying to do this kind of thing, you're trying to maximize activity per frontage so that there are enough people on the street to enliven it. If you have public right-of-way on both the front and back of the buildings, you've doubled the frontage without increasing the activity, so the place is only half as alive. In the very center, you might be able to do it; as it gets toward the edges, you need all the activity you can get.
- austinz 12y agoI wish someone would make a serious successor to SimCity - an actual simulator that modeled theories from the field of urban planning and allowed people to experiment with different layouts, policies, etc. This would be a very different piece of software from the vanity building placing games on the market today, and something much more in line with Will Wright's original vision.
- jamespitts 12y agoGreat idea, I've been thinking about this one for years. Maybe the goal would be to make life happier and more interesting on the street-level. I can still see Sim City moving around on the backs of my eyelids.
- bokonist 12y agoI've thought about the same idea. But I do not know how to actually make the simulation a sandbox for interesting experiments, rather than just having the results depend on whatever assumptions the game designer made.
- dropit_sphere 12y agoWhen in doubt, go more granular. Think Dwarf Fortress. Easy to say, I guess.
- saeranv 12y agoThere is a lot of research into the computational modelling of urban dynamics. A good place to start would be Michael Batty's seminal book on the subject: http://mitpress.mit.edu/books/cities-and-complexity http://mitpress.mit.edu/books/cities-and-complexity
- eru 12y agoAt least, you will see how certain micro-assumptions play out when put together in a simulation.
- saeranv 12y agoAgreed. I'm a masters of architecture candidate working in this area[1] and I would add that to engage in contemporary urban theory would require a much more sophisticated urban simulator than is achievable with the current state-of-the-art. Contemporary urban theory goes beyond issues like outdoor comfort and appropriate formal scale (which is what this blog post seems concerned about) to additional issues like hyper and mega-city growth and resource conservation. Taking this into account requires multiple simulations that would be able to model the inherent trade-offs of urban design. Traditionally there has been software like Esri's CityEngine - http://www.esri.com/software/cityengine http://www.esri.com/software/cityengine - which procedurally generates[2] urban geometries based on user-defined typologies and land-use. However CityEngine is just a geometry generator, and therefore far too basic to be used for contemporary design which must also negotiate factors like building daylight accessibility or positioning transit nodes for optimum walkability. A decent urban simulator therefore needs not only a procedural city geometry generator, but also simulators for walkability, building operational energy use and environmental simulators (ventilation, solar radiation etc). MIT's Sustainable Design Lab is developing the first (I believe) serious integrated urban modelling platform: Urban Modelling Interface (UMI) - http://urbanmodellinginterface.ning.com/ http://urbanmodellinginterface.ning.com/. Unfortunately UMI doesn't at this point include a way to procedurally generate urban geometries. A combination of CityEngine (with a much friendlier UI) and UMI would provide the kind of complex simulation environment that I think a realistic urban simulation game would require. [1] https://github.com/saeranv/cactus https://github.com/saeranv/cactus (Almost have a proof-of-concept ready for this). [2] Using a shape-grammar engine - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shape_grammar http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shape_grammar - which operates in a recursive manner and is thus a reasonable imitation of actual urban growth.
- bokonist 12y agoI love the idea of building a city as a startup, and competing with other cities by being a superior product. However, my vision for the perfect city is quite different than OP's. My ideal city: * Density is between 5k-8k per square mile (twice as dense as Palo Alto, half as dense as Cambridge, MA) * The density and layout should support a high walkability index. There should be a grocery store, barber, coffeeshop, pharmacy, etc, within a half-mile to a mile of most housing. * Housing arranged in blocks, with a shared yard for all people on the block. So each house would have a small patio owned by the home owner. Behind that would be a collective yard/green area shared by all the neighbors on the block. This shared area might have a basketball hoop, swimming pool, jungle-gym, soccer nets, BBQ pit or whatever the residents wanted. It would be behind all the housing, and thus insulated from the city. The block should be small enough that pretty much any parent can look out their window and see their kids playing. Basically, any parent should feel perfectly safe just letting their five-year old kid play outside in the common backyard with other kids. * The road system should be optimized around bicycles, scooters, and microcars (like the Carver or Automoto, because bicycles are not so good for older people in the winter). Roads would have two narrow lanes in each direction, a left-hand lane for 25MPH scooters and roadbikes, and a right-hand lane for slower bicycles and roller bladers. Cars would only be allowed on main arterials, driving a car on the bike roads would require a $10 per day special pass. Optimizing around bikes and mini-vehicles allows for getting between point A & B very quickly, but limits congestion, pollution, and the expense of a full-sized car. Things I don't like about OP's dream: * it feels to claustrophobic. I like green space. * walking is just much slower than biking, so I prefer biking. * it is really not pleasant to have both bikes and mopeds using the same narrow streets. One of the least pleasant aspects of traveling in a a classical city core is having the mopeds buzz by you at 20MPH. * row housing looks nice from the outside, but severely limits the amount of sunlight coming inside. I greatly prefer standalone units that have windows on all four-sides. * In general, I think that very dense, old school cities can be more pleasant to visit for a little while, than to actually live in long term. There is a reason why most people in those countries do not wish to live in such housing or build more housing like it. The biggest problem in general with doing a city-as-a-startup is jobs. Due to the winner-takes-all nature of the economy, the highest paying jobs are concentrated in a few metro areas where the big winning companies reside. I'm not sure how you bootstrap the economy of the new city.
- MBlume 12y agoThe article's unreadable without the photos and we seem to have DOSed whatever's serving the photos. Is there a mirror?
- Avshalom 12y agoI suspect it's just as unreadable having to scroll 3-600 pixels between sentence fragments.
- azernik 12y agoNo, the bits I got to before catching up with the image loading were quite pleasant. It works because the images are actually illustrating and adding content; unlike e.g. the pictures embedded in most news stories, which are really a whole separate piece of content that forces you to jump out of the flow of the story if you want to consume them, these are part of the flow of reading the post. Except when they fail to load, unfortunately. Content this size should really be hosted on S3 or equivalent, but the author probably didn't expect this scale of traffic.
- josh-wrale 12y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20140731170715/http://www.andrewalexanderprice.com/blog20130330.php https://web.archive.org/web/20140731170715/http://www.andrew...
- jamespitts 12y agoHis ideas are great! There must be a way to finance the planning and construction of a neighborhood along these lines, or finance the political effort it would take to designate a zone "traditional". In an immediate sense, we can encourage trad neighborhoods by asking city councils to slightly change laws that allow smallness and interestingness to take hold. Let vendors set up stands. Open up alleyways. Close off a few streets to traffic. Another way is to go big and get mega developers to build post-shopping shopping malls that are actually traditional cities. But the big approach has not worked so well in the past!
- forrestthewoods 12y agoFun exploration. I'd love to see something similar but for a city design built around shared self driving cars. I don't put much fundamental value in walkability. I put value in being able to get to a variety of types of things quickly and easily. Keeping those things within walking range of each other is one way. Autonomous vehicles is another.
- zephjc 12y agoThe term "over-engineering" comes to mind when arguing self-driving cars vs walking. Also, cars keep us lazy and fat.
- forrestthewoods 12y agoOver engineering? How so? Self driving cars would be amazing for improving our lives. Simply eliminating wasted time in my commute would be killer. I could spend that time doing whatever I wanted. Napping, reading, or by simply spending 90 minutes of my 8 hour work day on a laptop in an autonomous vehicle with LTE. Blaming cars for people being lazy and fat is itself incredibly lazy.
- arjie 12y agoIt just seems out of place in this conversation. This is about discoverability while you're talking versatility. It's about having people around, being a living, breathing city. While having a network of isolated silos with 45 hour commutes in autonomous vehicles is an interesting idea, it is in direct conflict with the vision espoused here. It'll be hard to reconcile the two.
- peterbraden 12y agoyou could do the same on public transport... Or maybe question why you have the long commute at all...
- zephjc 12y agoI want to clarify that I find self-driving cars an amazing engineering achievement and will almost certainly make roads safer. However, I would almost certainly spend the extra 90 minutes a day in a self-driving car catching up on sleep, assuming the auto-drive was reliable enough to not need human oversight in case of emergency. And this doesn't even address the pollution issue from excess driving. Also, there is plenty of evidence that sitting and driving, instead of walking, affects obesity rates: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/more-time-driving-increases-obesity-risk-study-suggests-1.2725521 http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/more-time-driving-incr...
- siliconc0w 12y agoI really like the original idea of epcot - create a city as a rolling 'city of tomorrow' with rapid iteration on design - the way we approach at lot of things we're unlikely to get right the first time. Say what you want about Walt Disney - epcot as originally envisioned would have been amazing.
- tbatchelli 12y agoChristopher Alexander wrote extensively about humanistic cities in "A Timeless Way of Building", "A Pattern Language: Towns, Buildings, Construction" and many other books. His focus was in studying how people have built villages and cities over centuries, how patterns have emerged and how these patterns affect the daily life of the inhabitants.
- schiffern 12y agoCame here to recommend "A Pattern Language" -- truly a transformative book. The article touches on a few of the patterns it lists, but I think this nascent project would benefit greatly from the author reading it through. For instance, just building narrow streets is not "all we need to do" as the author states. Full text available on Archive.org (but it's worth buying a copy for the illustrations alone): https://archive.org/stream/APatternLanguage/A_Pattern_Language_djvu.txt https://archive.org/stream/APatternLanguage/A_Pattern_Langua...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- femto 12y agoIf you want to found a city, here's a suggestion for its location. It's a crazy pipe dream but here goes: build a city next door to Sydney, Australia, on the other side of the Great Dividing Range. Background: Sydney is a well developed city with a population of 4.5 million. It is built on a coastal basin, bounded by the Pacific ocean on the east, a mountain range (Great Dividing Range) on the west, a river/green belt on the north and national parks on the south, with expansion happening in a south-west direction. Real estate prices are high compared most other cities. To the west of the Great Dividing Range is the beginning of the flat interior of Australia. The first significant town to the west of the Great Dividing Range is Lithgow. Running east to west, the Great Dividing range is delineated by a steep climb at the suburb of Glenbrook, and a steep descent at Mount Victoria. There is a winding highway and railway connecting these two points, so the trip from Lithgow to Sydney is slow. As the crow flies, the distance between Glenbrook and Mount Victoria is about 45km. The plan would be to build a tunnel under the Great Dividing Range, install a high speed train in it, and cut the travel time between Sydney and the west of the range to minutes. Tunnels longer than 45km exist today, so it should be doable from a technical standpoint. The project could be paid for by the increase in land value to the west of the range. As an aside, there are ongoing proposals for a high speed train (HST) along the eastern seaboard of Australia, linking Melbourne, Canberra, Sydney and Brisbane, all major cities. The seaboard is rugged and heavily populated, so some proposals have the HST to the west of the Dividing Range. A new city, to the west of the divide, could act as a junction between a north-south HST and a connection to Sydney, providing a ready made economy.
- eru 12y agoTunnels are crazy expensive. The article's ideas runs into the millions. The tunnel would run into the billions.
- brc 12y agoAustralian HSR will never, ever happen.
- grecy 12y agoI wouldn't be so sure. I believe the Melbourne->Sydney route is one of the busiest in the world for planes. Even if the train follow the existing highway it would do pretty well - it's almost entirely straight and flat.
- rdtsc 12y agoThis might sound very un-enlightening, offensive or jarring to many in this forum, but I actually like my suburban living. I'll be first to admit it is selfish, wasteful to environment (I am watering my plants and grass and mowing it). But when I wanted to buy a home I wanted a home in the suburbs with trees and wide roads and cul-de-sacs and playgrounds and pool and close to work (10min, by car, 30 by bicycle). It is one of those elements that when it came time to put the money on the table I made the decision I would have probably "preached" against in a group of peers. That probably happens often (people say they want green but end up buying an SUV instead of a Prius). This is probably sounding very wrong and boring to many people here who extol city living, enjoy the energy and vitality of the bustling city center. Public transportation, walk-able streets, stores, clubs, coffee shops, restaurants. But I would like that on vacation only for about a week or so. Then I want to go back to my boring suburban home with grass, trees an flowers around. See, I grew up in a city and experienced that. And it was ok. But I like this better. I wonder if there is an element of that -- rejecting the places we grew up and deciding the opposite environment is better for it. I imagine a lot of people in US grew up in the suburbs and many now feel attracted to the city.
- kyrra 12y agoWhy I dislike any kind of housing that gets city-level density: I don't like sharing a wall of my dwelling with others. I don't like hearing people easily through my walls. The suburban sprawl grants that.
- saeranv 12y agoThat could be dealt with by beefing up sound insulation in your party walls. Maybe building code needs to be changed to deal with this, but my guess is you just lived in buildings where the architect/contractor got cheap. ETA: To be fair, the architect/contractor/developer going for the cheap option is pretty common. Especially when it comes to something no one can see like insulation inside walls.
- photojosh 12y agoThat's cheap and lousy construction, not inherent to sharing a wall.
- cjbarber 12y agoOn a serious note, what would the requirements/steps to move towards this be? My guess is some combination of: - Money - Initial pre-committed residents - Habitable land - Management And then the main thing left, is, I believe, approval? Which leads to my questions: - What is the legality? Where is it legal? Where is it illegal? Or if legal, what are the chances/what is needed for approval?
- bane 12y agoYou need a few hundred acres of property and you need to get it zoned appropriately. Then you need to get either investment money, or court groups of developers to build this. Establish a development committee and some staff to bringing commercial businesses and people looking for office space (so the people living there have some place to work). Local county/city transport authorities to build transit links into the development. Ensure they can get into and out of the area cleanly, it won't work if it's an island. Most of your population will be commuting into and out of it no matter what you do. Build it in phases and sell it as you go. You'll need to build the residential sections first (businesses can't survive without customers). Hire an advertising team to draw people in and blanket the region with adverts. Work with local real-estate brokers to hi-light this as a destination they should show all clients during a house hunt -- even people not looking for a place like this.
- azernik 12y agoMost of the examples of "good" architecture seem to come from Japan, so let me chime in that from my little experience of walking through these kind of Japanese streets that they are very pleasant and inviting for traveling in by foot, and mix very well with car and public transit thoroughfares used to separate small neighborhoods/precincts.
- genwin 12y agoJapan's low-crime culture helps a lot to keep such density pleasant.
- polarix 12y agoWould this even be legal, given fire codes?
- zephjc 12y agoIt works fine in a bunch of the rest of the world.
- agersant 12y agoIf you're interested in this topic, I highly recommend this long series of articles: http://www.newworldeconomics.com/archives/tradcityarchive.html http://www.newworldeconomics.com/archives/tradcityarchive.ht...
- andrewfong 12y agoI've always imagined that a "human-centric" city of the future would simply move most of its automobiles one level up or down. Many dense cities already have subways. It'd be expensive but not inconceivable to move all car-width roads into an underground level or onto dedicated skyways, although the latter seems more likely to create issues with lighting and whatnot.
- dasmoth 12y agohttp://www.cbrd.co.uk/histories/underways/ http://www.cbrd.co.uk/histories/underways/
- rdl 12y agoI'd rather have sky walkways above ground-level cars for a lot of reasons; Hong Kong's central district does this quite well.
- CalRobert 12y agoWhy would you need ubiquitous automobiles in a human scale city, though?
- MartinCron 12y agoIn Seattle, we're tearing down a horrible ugly elevated viaduct on the waterfront and replacing it with a deep-bore underground tunnel. It's turning out to be a difficult and expensive mess, but the promise is a much more appealing human-centric waterfront/downtown core.
- cjoh 12y agoI live in a community called Serenbe. (http://serenbe.com http://serenbe.com) which has taken a much different approach to suburban new urbanist development. It's built around an organic farm rather than a golf course, it's got miles of green space and trails, and a fantastic commitment to ecology and the environment -- for example the outdoor irrigation system is built from gray water from the homes in the community. Also: it's got some great restaurants and about 80% of my diet comes from food that's made within 25 miles of where I live now. To get to a restaurant, we take a brief stroll through the woods. Smartest thing I ever did was move here. I've spent my whole life trying to work with governments (mostly federal) to use technology to improve service delivery and if I'm honest with myself, it's been mostly discouraging. But since I've moved here, I've met with the mayor and we're beginning to do amazing things. What makes an amazing place to live, though isn't the lack of automobiles (as the author of this post seems to believe), or great architecture -- but rather an attitude of community. That you all have a shared role in the success of each other's life environment. Human beings are wired for that, and both urban and suburban environments tend to separate us from that.
- bjorn2404 12y agoThis looks really interesting but very family oriented. Do they have real-estate that would be appropriate for single people?
- cjoh 12y agoNo, not yet. They're building a rental property very soon -- http://serenberealestate.com/?property=textile-lofts http://serenberealestate.com/?property=textile-lofts . I suspect this will start attracting some singles. But it's mostly true, you're not going to fire up Tinder and find a date at Serenbe.
- rwhitman 12y agoWow that is fascinating. Your community has a pretty excellent website. Slick design, lots of high end photography. Which means someone spent a lot of money on it. Meaning someone is raking in big bucks by promoting the town. Took a look at real estate prices relative to the area, confirmed - wow 4x higher prices than anything else in the area. Pretty amazing feat of real estate marketing to turn a chunk of rural Georgia into the equivalent of California home prices by leveraging sustainable growth. If developers can build a community like that and turn a profit at the same time that's a pretty promising future
- zephjc 12y agoIt's interesting that a second article from this site has made it to the HN front page. I've been digging into this concept a lot since the first article was linked from here. I think traditional, walkable cities are a great idea whose time is more than overdue in North America. Places like Quebec City are a good example, but what really fascinates me is Tokyo, a behemoth of a city with so much that is walkable with one-way streets and wide sidewalk areas, and you can get to anywhere easily via buses and rail links. All these simple one-way streets, connecting to arterial roads with 1 lane in each direction, connecting to highways, create an absolutely massively distributed road system. If you think i'm exaggerating, pull up Tokyo in Google Maps and pick a spot at random in the surrounding metro area and go to Street View, you will always always land on a one-way road, often with people walking on it.
- tempestn 12y agoI did as you suggested with Tokyo and that is indeed impressive. People walking everywhere. One-way streets really do make a ton of sense for cities.
- alexmayyasi 12y agoThis article on an urban planner's objection to suburbs on financial grounds (most succinctly put as suburbs are a ponzi scheme) is relevant for thinking about why this project is -- relative to a more suburban/sprawl alternative -- less costly than it seems: http://time.com/3031079/suburbs-will-die-sprawl/ http://time.com/3031079/suburbs-will-die-sprawl/
- tempestn 12y agoIf we wanted to build the ideal city and cost weren't a concern, we could really expand on the use of underground for transportation. The best cities for humans tend to have great subway systems, but in theory we could do a lot more. Basically all parking and most arterial roads could be underground, leaving above-ground an almost-entirely pedestrian paradise. Sure, driving in an endless tunnel doesn't sound terribly pleasant, but the idea is to get people from A to B efficiently, then out of the car. Unfortunately building this kind of infrastructure under existing cities would be prohibitively expensive. Under a new town you might be able to do it much more cheaply (which isn't to say cheaply in an absolute sense), but of course the economic incentive isn't there at that point. That said, with services like Uber, and much more so, driverless vehicles, hopefully the desire to bring a car along wherever we go will begin to ebb in the near future, making the narrow street vision described here much less of a compromise. I imagine those times when you need a car to get somewhere, spending some of the time weaving around through carts and pedestrians would be much less frustrating if you can kick back and read a book while it's happening. Even more though, there would be less concern of servicing parking for these sorts of regions, so you could still have a few arterial roads to get in and out, far less wasted parking space, and no need to build underground mazes to accomplish it.
- scoofy 12y agoUnfortunately, putting fuel driven cars underground is incredibly dangerous. One major fire could asphyxiate many people. Even in reasonably small tunnels there have been major disasters: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mont_Blanc_Tunnel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mont_Blanc_Tunnel
- tempestn 12y agoGood point (although you would hope better ventilation could help with that?) Regardless, we should be (finally) seeing more electric cars in the near future (not that they can't catch fire). Anyway, I don't think underground road situations are actually practical, just that it would be nice to use that third dimension more in an ideal world.
- stuaxo 12y agoOK, but not so close to the highway, nobody should have to live there it will be loud and highly polluted.
- atroyn 12y agoThe most jarring thing about visiting the United States for me was the car-centric design of the cities. We lived in an apartment in Palo Alto, and doing the most basic things was impossible without a car - grocery shopping, going to the office, going out for dinner or to a meeting. Even bikes weren't really enough. Eventually we caved and had to pay the extra expense of renting a car through a car sharing site. San Francisco was really not much better - to get there, the only viable option was either to drive or to take the CalTrain - always extraordinarily crowded in the busiest hours, not to mention slow and with long waits in between trains. Getting around in the city on foot also presented an ordeal, but at least MUNI and BART helped somewhat. This added a huge expense for our company that would have been completely unnecessary in other cities - including the rental price and fuel, the car ended up burning about $800/mo on its own. Not to mention the amount of time wasted driving around to get basic things done like visiting the bank or the supermarket. It became clear to me why companies like Uber were making a killing in the U.S - public infrastructure was so badly supported that there is just no way to live without access to a vehicle. I can't imagine what it must be like for the working poor, who must pay for the expense of a vehicle just to subsist.
- epaladin 12y agoAnd many people accept this as if it's the only way to live- it doesn't really get challenged, since a lot of people don't know anything else. After living in Japan I find it crazy. At least I live in an area that has some decent bike paths so I can do stuff that most Americans would consider impossible, like walk 7 miles to the airport...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- sandstrom 12y agoInteresting article, I agree with most of the authors ideas. Converting double-lane streets to uni-directional, and planting trees on the other half + larger sidewalk, would brighten up many streets as well. I suggest using a CDN for the images. It took me ~10 min to load them. E.g. fastly or CloudFront.
- stefs 12y agosmall city in austria, pretty much like described by OP. then a strip mall was built outside the city, cafés, bars and a cinema included. the inner city died out in a matter of months - only the elderly stayed. small mom&pop shops in the city you can reach by foot? sounds nice in theory, but this also means running to 10 different shops, lugging your purchases around for the whole trip. honestly - driving to a strip mall where you can buy everything and store the shopping in your trunk is just a lot more convenient. i mean, as soon as you have to get in the car to do the shopping, the strip mall always wins. i live in a big city and do the grocery shopping per pedes almost every day - but i don't need much (don't have to shop for a 3-4 hungry mouths). it might work as an alternative - for people that are fed up with the car centrist society and actively seek out a place where the community takes its place. i'm just not sure that small, village friendly businesses would be competitive when strip malls are around.
- alecco 12y agoFunny how everybody here doesn't care who their neighbours are. That's at the top of my concerns when moving. I've visited american suburbs and it impressed me as antisocial, selfish and lacking culture. Like a small town filled with nouveau riche.
- restalis 12y agoI feel a little bit of cargo-cult in the article. The fact that someone spends money to go in some crammed place depends on a number of factors like the touristic quality of that place (which is mostly related to its history), on how's it being promoted outside, on how different it is from other places (with a zillion of details that makes the given place it special compared to other ones), and many other factors. The fact that it is crammed may even not be important at all!
- Shivetya 12y agoWell I have two suggestions, go aboard a mega cruise ship to see how you can make an enclosed area look inviting and varied at that. I would aim for an enclosed space even with separation of buildings and such simply because it will allow you to heat and cool it efficiently and have open areas pretty much immune to weather. There are some amazing resorts constructed this way and no reason a whole town cannot be as well.
- dm2 12y agoWalt Disney wanted to do it 50 years ago, it might be good to take some lessons learned from his planning. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Experimental_Prototype_Community_of_Tomorrow_(concept) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Experimental_Prototype_Communit... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sLCHg9mUBag https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sLCHg9mUBag https://sites.google.com/site/theoriginalepcot/ https://sites.google.com/site/theoriginalepcot/ Beautiful renderings: https://sites.google.com/site/theoriginalepcot/high-density-housing https://sites.google.com/site/theoriginalepcot/high-density-... Also, use thumbnails or a CDN FFS. Other planned city resources: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planned_city http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planned_city http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_planned_cities http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_planned_cities http://www-03.ibm.com/press/us/en/pressrelease/44132.wss http://www-03.ibm.com/press/us/en/pressrelease/44132.wss
- Aardwolf 12y ago> Founding our own town is tempting - rural land is cheap You guys in the US are so lucky! Large areas of land all for the taking. In my country, most of the land is built full. Cities and towns do not end, they just touch other towns and the residences continue. What land remains is either designated forest land, or for agriculture. You are not allowed to build residences on those.
- sylvinus 12y agoReally sounds like the author just needs to move to Europe or Asia...
- elif 12y agoLOL his plan is to find buyers of land for $348,000/acre ... That is, the first half of his buyers will make that investment knowing that the neighboring parcels will be mostly undeveloped until a critical mass of them are sold. There is no way to get that off the ground. It is like if nitcoin started at $1000
- logfromblammo 12y agoPublic transit is good. Definitely include it in your city. But what you really need to kill automobile dependence is a way to transport goods throughout your city without a human to shepherd it along. You need to have train cars that can automatically load and unload palletized goods, and a package routing network for smaller items. Your pizza delivery will consist of the restaurant putting your food into a standardized container and pushing the "send" button. When you shop, you send your purchases directly home from the store instead of carrying them with you for the rest of the evening. Cars aren't just for getting to distant places fast. They are also for moving stuff around too heavy for you to carry around everywhere you go. I once bought an air conditioner window unit in downtown Chicago and took it home on the El. That was such a hassle that I became much less reticent about giving up my parking spot afterward. It wasn't long after that when I stopped walking the six blocks to Jewel to buy as much food as I could carry home in my arms and started driving across the state border to buy as much as I could store in my home without spoilage. City simulators that track the movement of people are fine, but they are incomplete if you can't also track the non-people items that also move around and transform within residences and businesses. Food, water, power, clothing, necessities, luxuries, raw materials, sewage, and trash all move around semi-independently, and in most cities, a lot of that moves around in a human-piloted vehicle. Power moves through conductive cables. Drinking water does through pipes. Data goes through glass fibers or conductive wires. Fuel gas moves through pipes. Sewage moves through pipes. But then we have garbage trucks, delivery trucks, and cars moving everything else. Where are the pipes for that stuff? Intermodal containerized shipping changed the world. But you can't exactly manage your household deliveries with a metal box 20m long. But thanks to them, most everything that makes it to your house once fit on a pallet or inside a shopping cart. Construct a container standard around those sizes and make your transportation infrastructure handle the containers, and your city no longer needs postal workers, delivery drivers, solid waste collectors, or anyone else whose entire job is to take things and move them to other places. But something like that is going to be more expensive, and it has to be 99.99999% reliable. You'll need to be a lot more dense than suburban housing to afford that, especially when you have to invent and bootstrap all the tech yourself. Edit: I bet you could probably get bootstrap funding from the logistics command of a national army and trial the system on a military base. What you would likely end up with is a rugged plastic cube-shaped crate with 4-way entry for forklifts and handtrucks, and attachment points for parachutes, chains, ropes, or tie-down straps. That would be your large container. Your small container would probably be a little less than 1/8 the size.
- im_a_lawyer 12y agoYou don't have to build anything or spend a single dollar to reverse this. Simply get the government out of the mortgage market and raise the gas tax to where it's supposed to be. 20% min downpayment @ 6% interest + $7/gallon gas = death of sprawling suburbia.
- slosh 12y agoI want a walking city with no cars. maybe golf carts. If we could just remove all the cars from san francisco I would be happy
- zkar 12y agoIn India, the population density around many streets in the city is very high. As a result, all streets appear traditional human scale though they are not designed for that. http://im.rediff.com/money/2009/apr/28city5.jpg http://im.rediff.com/money/2009/apr/28city5.jpg http://cdn.citylab.com/media/img/citylab/legacy/2012/09/06/RTXMZWE.jpg http://cdn.citylab.com/media/img/citylab/legacy/2012/09/06/R...