5 ms·
Misleading headline. Investors are scared of Amazon's persistent lack of profits despite their hugely popular offerings.
by tootie 12y ago
Misleading headline. Investors are scared of Amazon's persistent lack of profits despite their hugely popular offerings.
- adventured 12y agoExactly. Investors are afraid Amazon has found another low profit business to dominate. If they can't yield even a low margin profit at $80 billion in sales - eg 3% Walmart style, or $2.x billion in net income - why would anyone believe they will at $160 billion in sales. Not to mention they're a 20 year old, unprofitable business.
- Touche 12y ago> Not to mention they're a 20 year old, unprofitable business. But they've only been unprofitable the last hand few of years. Before that they were quite profitable. Amazon's pursuit of businesses with high R&D costs is the reason for their current lack of profitability.
- adventured 12y agoThe first half of their existence was spent as an unprofitable business. If 2014 ends up the way it looks like it will, the net losses will outweigh the net income for the life of the business (it nearly does now). The first ten years of their operating life were spent being famous for bleeding prodigious amounts of red ink. That's why the tag: Amazon.toast - it was assumed they would bleed to death without the easy money of the public market and a massive valuation. Here's their net income statement going back to '97: 1997: -$32m; 1998: -$124m; 1999: -$719m; 2000: -$1.4b; 2001: -$567m; 2002: -$149m; 2003: $35m; 2004: $588m; 2005: $359m; 2006: $190m; 2007: $476m; 2008: $645m; 2009: $902m; 2010: $1.15b; 2011: $631m; 2012: -$39m; 2013: $274m They've never been quite profitable. Only one year, 2004, did they show even a modest level of profitability (in part due to one-time gains). The rest of the positive years the margin was between 1% and 4% typically.
- burnte 12y agoYou leave out the fact that they reached profitability years before their business plan called for it, showing excellent and stable growth.
- adventured 12y agoThe fact that their net income imploded so dramatically rather proves the lack of stability. You'll forgive me if I don't trust in the judgment of a business plan built on losing money for two or three decades. They can be a good company, grow to X hundred billion in sales, struggle to ever make money, and that's all perfectly fine - but it doesn't mean they deserve a hyper valuation. Target trades at a mere $38b valuation, and they only generated $8b in net income the past three years.
- TheMagicHorsey 12y agoDude, I don't think the Target comparison is apt. People say the enterprise cloud market is a Trillion dollar opportunity world wide in the next decade. A Trillion dollars up for grabs, and Amazon has a healthy lead in the segment. When you go to an AWS event the thing that stands out is the number of consulting and service companies that offer integration/application services to enterprises based wholly on AWS. I've been to Google Cloud events and its not even in the same ballpark as AWS. The Amazon lead is huge. I think Amazon is still a good buy.
- pzb 12y agoIf I total the numbers you present, they had a net $2.2b of positive income (i.e. profit) since 1997. Small profit as a percent of revenue since 1997, but overall profit. The first quarter of this year had an operating income of $108M and the second a loss of $126M. Are you suggesting that the remaining two quarters will have approximately $2.1b of loss?
- rodgerd 12y agoAnd a lot of their profit is essentially reliant on competing by dodging taxes - their margin advantage to the consumer could, in many markets, simply disappear with the closure of a few sales or corporate tax loopholes.
- ars 12y agoThat's not true at all. Amazon charges sales tax in lots of places and it hasn't really affected them much at all.
- qq66 12y agoIt's affected them quite a bit especially in expensive large items like TVs which are easier to buy locally but have large sales tax burdens. The business is still growing but slower than it would have without sales tax. Best Buy's gains over the last 2 years have been achieved in no small part due to price matching with Amazon including sales tax.
- opendais 12y agoThat used to be true but they have been collecting sales tax the past few years.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoNot charging sales tax in a jurisdiction you have no presence in isn't a loophole, it's an intentional feature at the federal level. States can't legally tax interstate commerce. Amazon is only starting to charge sales taxes in states because they're establishing local presences in those states.
- toast0 12y agoThey skirted the rules for local presence for a long time too. They had an engineering office in California, but were not charging sales tax. The office was a wholly owned subsidiary
- 12y ago
- jgreen10 12y agoThe Amazon profitability figures are a bit misleading. Amazon adds a very big revenue generating chunk of company every year that has enormous value. That's effectively their profit. One day, they could decide to keep money in their pockets, instead of investing it, but share holders would only demand that if they thought they could do a better job at investing than Amazon. The market has had enough confidence in AMZN for it to go up by 275% in the past 5 years, compared to 125% for the NASDAQ. It's not clear whether this shows that Jeff Bezos is a better investor than the market, or that the market currently believes that he is and this will eventually correct itself, but momentum definitely seems in Bezos' favour.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- opendais 12y agoYes, they are going to have to raise their margins at some point and there is no guarantee it can be done without costing them more business than they can afford. AWS is already pricey for what it offers. Raising the margin on Amazon.com's sales requires squeezing suppliers more and raising prices and I'm not sure that outcome will be profitable either.
- ekianjo 12y ago> Amazon's persistent lack of profits This has been addressed several times already. Amazon is effectively making profits on several on its key businesses but is effectively reinvesting most of its profits into new infrastructure, distribution centers and new services. The day Amazon decreases that investment ratio, profits will significantly increase. In other words, Amazon is far from being in the red. They are just massively investing.
- int19h 12y agoSome people want to see healthy EPS growth, and as you point out some patient investors are willing to buy the "reinvesting in accelerated growth" thesis. But everyone is getting tired of AMZN's lack of transparency. Increasingly, buying AMZN is akin to buying the "Bezos is the next Jobs" meme on faith. http://seekingalpha.com/article/2343265-amazon-com-bezos-seriously-testing-investors-patience-and-trust-after-guiding-for-a-big-loss http://seekingalpha.com/article/2343265-amazon-com-bezos-ser...
- epa 12y agoInvestments in capital items are shown on an income statement expensed over the life of the asset. Decreases in investment have no impact on increase in profit (only the opposite is true, increase in investment will add a decrease in profit of 1/n of the cost where n is the life of the asset in years).