17 ms·
Mark Cuban: If Your Company Is Moving For Tax Reasons, I'm Selling Your Stock
- nostromo 12y agoPerhaps we should drop the corporate tax rate to zero. It's simply too easy for a global company to avoid them. In the end, small and mid-sized businesses are the ones that get soaked. It currently makes up about 10% of federal revenue. http://www.cbpp.org/cms/?fa=view&id=3822 http://www.cbpp.org/cms/?fa=view&id=3822
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- nkozyra 12y agoI think that's the eventual outcome, as there will likely always be some place with a low enough rate to compel businesses to setup shells.
- antidaily 12y agoYeah. Then, raise taxes for those who can afford it to make that up. I like it. It'll never happen but I like it.
- ericcumbee 12y agoIf we just moved to be inline with the rest of the world that would be an improvement.
- cyorir 12y agoThat could pretty quickly sour relations with a lot of other countries, if we were cutting our own tax unilaterally. Anything like this would preferably be coordinated with other countries. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Effective_Corporate_Tax_Rate_OECD_Countries,_2000-2005_Average.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Effective_Corporate_Tax_Ra... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_tax_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_tax_in_the_United_Sta... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_rates_of_Europe http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_rates_of_Europe
- MrZongle2 12y agoWhat hasn't soured relations between the United States and other countries in the last 15 years? Changing our tax rates seems downright benign.
- Symmetry 12y agoWe could probably just stop trying to tax people in those other countries and they'd be happy enough to forget about the corporate tax thing, speaking of stupid US tax policies.
- jimbokun 12y agoHow do we replace that 10%? According to your link, that would be about $280 billion per year.
- stephencanon 12y agoPresumably by taxing dividends (and possibly capital gains, depending on who you ask) as normal income, and eliminating other quirks of the tax code that overwhelmingly benefit the wealthy.
- patrickmay 12y agoCut spending. Does anyone really think that 10% of what the federal government does can't be eliminated entirely?
- carbocation 12y agoRoughly 100% of people agree with you, just not on which 10%, which is why that plan is prima facie untenable.
- talmand 12y agoAcross the board cuts for any programs with budgets above a certain percentage of the entire Federal budget. Basically a progressive budget cut to avoid small programs getting hit too hard.
- bduerst 12y agoI like your thinking, but there's a sliding scale (15%-35%), just like personal income tax, so that smaller businesses don't get hosed. Theoretically it would also be easy to game payroll and income taxes this way. You could essentially file articles of organization for a corporation with you as the sole shareholder, and have your employer pay your corporation your wages, instead of you directly. When it comes time to take money out, you pay a fat dividend with 15% dividend tax rate, instead of 35% income tax rate. There are of course some exceptions to this and it isn't possible in some states, but it would be possible.
- bradleyjg 12y ago> When it comes time to take money out, you pay a fat dividend with 15% dividend tax rate, instead of 35% income tax rate. If we were to eliminate the corporate tax we'd need to simultaneously eliminate the preferred tax status of qualified dividends and long term capital gains. We'd also need to crack down on wage substitutes (aka fringe benefits). Still think it'd be a worthwhile tradeoff.
- justincormack 12y agoThe dividend tax rate is mainly there so as to avoid double taxation, so it would make sense to remove it.
- tsuraan 12y agoSo, I create a corporate entity that provides my housing, transportation, other major needs. All my income is paid to this entity, which pays no taxes. I, as a biological person, get some basic stipend to cover daily costs, and live comfortably with all my necessities being paid by the corporate entity. How does the state collect any taxes at that point? EDIT: thinking a bit more, I guess sales taxes could still be collected. Could a government function almost entirely off sales taxes?
- karmicthreat 12y agoEven now as far as the IRS is concerned you will personally pay tax on all of those services that were given to you. The IRS doesn't just tax cash transfers.
- tedsanders 12y agoI believe that the housing, transportation, and other major needs would be taxed just like the income they replace. (Or should be, in any case.) This IRS page says that benefits are taxed like income: http://www.irs.gov/Businesses/Small-Businesses-&-Self-Employed/Employee-Benefits http://www.irs.gov/Businesses/Small-Businesses-&-Self-Employ... My mother is self-employed, and there are strict rules about deducting business expenses (like home office square footage) but not personal expenses (like the rest of the house's square footage).
- tsuraan 12y agoAh, very interesting. Thanks for the info!
- aidenn0 12y agoWhat you just described is illegal. A corporation must act as an independent entity, not just be a shell around a single individual.
- pessimizer 12y agoWhat about two individuals, or 40?
- bluthru 12y agoSo not only are corporations super humans that have limited liability and now religious views, you don't want those extremely wealthy "people" to pay taxes, either? I'm open to a "first world tax rate" for corporations, but dropping it to zero would do more harm than good.
- lotharbot 12y agoAs long as the US has existed, there has been corporate personhood. The Supreme Court has argued it in terms of corporations being essentially groups of people acting together for a common cause, and noted that working together should not invalidate the rights to free speech, religious practice, entering contracts, etc. Chief Justice Marshall said it this way in 1830: "The great object of an incorporation is to bestow the character and properties of individuality on a collective and changing body of men." Key cases (you can find them all at http://supreme.justia.com/ http://supreme.justia.com/ ): Dartmouth College v. Woodward, 17 U.S. 518 (1819) Providence Bank v. Billings, 29 U.S. 514 (1830) Santa Clara County v Southern Pacific Railroad Company, 118 U.S. 394 (1886) United States v. United Auto Workers, 352 U.S. 567 (1957)
- caseydurfee 12y agoFunny you didn't quote Marshall's much more famous saying about corporations in Dartmouth College v. Woodward: "A corporation is an artificial being, invisible, intangible, and existing only in contemplation of law. Being the mere creature of law, it possesses only those properties which the charter of its creation confers upon it."
- seanflyon 12y agoTaxes are a great argument against corporate personhood. People pay taxes on income, corporations pay taxes on profit. This is why so many corporations pay no taxes at all. If they want to be people they should pay income tax like the rest of us.
- lotharbot 12y agoFor most people, business expenses are paid by the employer and profit==income, but for some (the self-employed in particular) their business expenses come out of pocket and are deductible. Individuals actually end up paying taxes on profit, we're just used to wording it as income.
- rayiner 12y agoThis is probably the best course of action. The teeth-gnashing over whether corporations should pay taxes should take a back-seat to whether it's practical to require them to. We have to acknowledge the race to the bottom that comes along with living in a globalized world. We don't have the leverage needed to tax these companies, and it's better if they stay here and don't pay taxes than if they move somewhere else and don't pay taxes.
- mseebach 12y agoI agree with you, but I really don't like the term "race to the bottom" - it's is just a fear-mongering term for competition and the inconvenience and sometimes embarrassment that comes with the realization that something you thought you were good at can actually be done cheaper and better. "The bottom" is the best service/price tradeoff (with the desired service level delivered as efficiently as possible, ie. at the lowest price). Ireland luring businesses with a low tax rate and Americans and other higher tax countries complaining about a "race to the bottom" is much more similar to the creative destruction that takes place when say Postgres and MongoDB displace an expensive Oracle DB (and the reactions of both Oracle and high-tax advocates are pretty similar).
- dllthomas 12y agoI agree that "race to the bottom" is often abused when all that is really at issue is competition. However, it is applicable when it's undermining ability to deal with externalities. When the pressure is "who makes their air unbreathable fastest", calling it a "race to the bottom" seems perfectly appropriate and like something we want to avoid.
- snowwrestler 12y agoThat would not actually help small and mid-size businesses, most of whom are organized as pass-through entities and are therefore not subject to the corporate tax rate.
- kazinator 12y agoI'd be in favor of this zero rate, if, at the same time, all "corporate welfare" ended also: no coddling of corporations by the state. Also, no protective measures such as tariffs.
- amalcon 12y agoThe corporate tax is the only disincentive to use corporations. There must be one, or the corporate veil will start to be used for trivial things. We see this already, even with corporate taxes, in e.g. patent trolls or Hollywood films. Small businesses are mostly proprietorships, partnerships, and LLCs anyway, which don't generally need to pay corporate taxes. Mid-sized businesses might be hurt by the corporate tax, though.
- cynicalkane 12y agoThe corporate tax is a terrible disincentive to make money. Wealthy entities that make money are more concerned with relative status than absolute status. On the other hand, the corporate tax is a great way to ensure corporations retain profits instead of paying them out, thereby making the corporations larger. This would all be obvious if people remembered rule 1 of economics, which is that actors respond to incentives.
- dnautics 12y agoThere are plenty of ways to make money without incorporating. I'd much rather eliminate the personal income tax and shift to user fees, and a flat corporate rate (a user fee for limited liability, if you will) and equal flat tarrif. But that's not popular for some reason.
- audunw 12y agoFlat fees/taxes are unpopular because people tend to believe that the capitalist system is inherently unfair. For instance, a rich person who gets $100 can invest all of it, while a poor person must spend it on necessities. (And there are deep psychological drives and practical reasons that also cause most people to spend more irrationally when theyre poor as well) Theres also Pikettys argent that return on capital grows faster than the economy. But there are counter-arguments, and its always good to consider and experiment with new ideas, so believe what you will. But I think people have a prettty good reason for liking a progressive tax, even rich people like this. Personally I think the economy has deep flaws. Like private ownership of natural and limited resources being a thing (which i believe will cause wealth to consentrate in a counter-meritocratic way) and the transfer of money not accurately reflecting the value of intellectual "property" (transfer of money of physical goods, which money is supposed to model, is zero-sum. sharing intellectual products is not). So I welcome new thoughts. But I dont think anyone has the right solutions yet, and flat fees/tax isnt exactly a new idea.
- skywhopper 12y agoYou would have to somehow balance it out against the fact that eliminating corporate income tax would invalidate a lot of incentives built into the corporate tax structure. No more flexibility for the government to encourage capital purchases or otherwise use tax policy as a policy driver. It would also decrease the incentive to invest in their own company because the cost of building a new factory or raising workers' wages or hiring more workers would actually increase. Think about it, if a company were considering giving all of its workers a $5,000 raise. In a world with a 30% marginal corporate tax rate, the actual cost to your company's bottom line of such a raise would be $3,500/worker, because you only pay tax on net income. But with a 0% tax rate, the cost would be $5,000/worker, that's a 43% bigger cost. Plus, presuming that personal income taxes would need to be raised by ~11% to make up for the loss of corporate income taxes, the workers are going to end up a lot less likely to get substantial raises. The benefits of eliminating the corporate income tax are going to have to be huge to make up for the disincentives it would create.
- rthomas6 12y agoI don't know, I think a ~35% boost in profits for all profitable American businesses is pretty huge.
- erichocean 12y agoIf you had $100 in corporate profits now, you'd keep $65 and pay the government $35. If you got to keep all $100 in profits, that's a (100/65 = ~54%) increase, not 35%. So the effect would be even greater. :)
- skywhopper 12y agoSo if the corporation owners get a huge boost in profits, how does that benefit the country as a whole when the extra money is actually less likely to be spent on re-investment?
- rthomas6 12y ago>the corporation owners By "corporation owners" you can only mean "shareholders" for publicly traded companies. My retirement is invested mostly in the stock market, as is most people's. I would benefit, and so would anyone else that owned stocks.
- encoderer 12y agoHonestly most small businesses pay taxes on their members' individual returns. Keep the corporate rate where it is, how about a non-refundable small business tax credit?
- ranran876 12y agoAnother aspect of the corporate tax is that it in-effect is a secret tax. You see how much the gov't takes from you on your pay stubs, or your receipts at the store. But you don't see the effects of the corporate tax. I'd think it would be healthy too move to a model of looking at corporations are simply intermediaries for organizing people. Ultimately the money that flows into the corporation has to flow out either through salaries, dividens or sales - and the money should be taxed at those points. If you tax it in the middle people just end up thinking "oh, well they're taxing the evil corporates, so that's good!" without seeing the dampening effect on salaries and their investments. I understand that it's a bit simplistic, but I think the current model of hidding taxes is parasitic. You look at the insane sales taxes they have in Europe. They keep going up and the citizens don't really perceive it and so there is no push-back. Here in the US, when the sales tax goes up by half a percent people are up in arms.
- Alupis 12y agoI agree, maybe not 0% rate, however, instead of focusing on chastising and ridiculing companies that make [business smart] choices to alleviate their tax burden, we need to focus on fixing the core of the problem that promotes businesses to seek tax relief in the first place!
- sp332 12y agoInstead of 0, how about 20%? Right now the nominal rate for large companies is 35%, but they spend a lot of resources bringing the actual number lower. If we set the rate at 20%, then it becomes unprofitable for them to work so hard to avoid the tax. That means we get two advantages: companies can use that money for actual investment instead of dodging taxes, and the government might actually get more money since companies are dodging less and have more money to grow with.
- eqdw 12y agoPlanet Money did a series on "policies economists would love and politicians would hate". One of their biggest suggestions was "eliminate the corporate tax rate and significantly raise income taxes on the high end". For exactly this reason, as well as what is said here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8087103 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8087103 The more money a company has, the more money they can use to employ people and be productive. The general public usually gets upset at what they see as severe profits to a corporation, but in general those profits aren't being "wasted" on the rich until they draw them out in salaries or dividends. It makes more sense to simply tax them at that point (at least, according to NPR)
- dllthomas 12y agoIt's worth noting that it's not corporate revenues that are taxed but corporate profits. Money that corporations use to hire people is not taxed at the corporate level. That said, "[t]he more money a company has, the more money they can use to employ people and be productive" is still true and relevant because money is fungible. It is just less extreme than if corporate taxes were applied to that money as well.
- Gustomaximus 12y agoOr table this with WTO, G20 or new body to set a minimum tax at a few key points like company tax and income. We're going to see increasingly mobile assets and company structures IMO so a global body working together to set benchmarks makes sense. The alternate seems to be countries will be stuck in a race to the bottom in trying to attract companies & talent.
- manishsharan 12y agoI appreciate the sentiment but that will not mean much. Ethics rarely figures in Investment decisions, which are made on the basis of excel spreadsheets and quant algorithms. If on the other hand you were to find employment for people who found their employers' tax avoidance to be distasteful and wanted to quit to make a statement, then you might be able to make a difference by starving such companies of talent.
- drdeadringer 12y ago> Ethics rarely figures in Investment decisions However, it seems to be a "coming thing". I began altering my investments a handful of years ago to include what I found tasteful not just on return, but on ethics//morals as well. I don't see how this is different from "voting with your feet" or "voting with your dollar". Starving companies of investment and sales are part of the same mixture as starving companies of talent.
- manishsharan 12y agoA significant chunk of investment in the American stock market and real estate is done by foreign investors and funds and hedgefunds etc. These decisions are made primarily based on the spreadsheets ; as a backend software guy in the capital markets and banking sector, I see first hand how automated this decision making has become. I have had score of meeting with Investment and Financial advisors ( for s/w development/testing , not financial advise )and I see first had how hard data oriented these folks are in their decision making.
- elsewhen 12y agoi'm sure you know this, but when you invest in a company, you are actually just buying shares off of some other investor - the money doesn't go 'to' to company (except in IPOs and secondary offerings). of course the stock price can affect a company in some pretty important ways.
- diminoten 12y agoIn order for this to work, everyone would have to hold the same set of ethics, which is not only untrue, but grossly untrue as you span the globe. Otherwise, the varying ethics among people will more or less wash out, even if everyone did act based on a set of ethics in their investing. Voting with your feet/dollars works because it stays inside the realm of utility, and is therefore much more "standard" across the population. A car is useful almost everywhere, for example, but how that car is made might rub different people different ways.
- jahabrewer 12y agoI find it difficult to balance my distaste for corporations that act irresponsibly with my laziness in regard to my investment portfolio. I use a slight variant on the three-fund portfolio (http://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Three-fund_portfolio http://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Three-fund_portfolio). I value its simplicity because it saves me time and gives an acceptable expected return. However, using large total market funds means that I'm invested in so many companies that it would take a very long time to investigate each one for responsibility. Good on Mr. Cuban for standing up here.
- donatj 12y agoI don't understand the whole "If you behave logically as a business we hate you" sentiment. You enact business unfriendly practices business leave. It is the job of a business to make money, the most money possible, at all costs. That is its single purpose existing.
- parfe 12y agoJust because you "behave logically" does not mean you behave morally or ethically. Perhaps you should reflect on why immoral behavior would result in people hating you.
- JonFish85 12y agoAre you saying that a company moving money around in an advantageous way is immoral? How so? Presumably you deduct the maximum amount you can from your taxes. That's what the business is doing: shuffling it's money around in a way that minimizes their costs. Sure, I can see the argument of people who don't really like it, but to say it's immoral seems a bridge too far for me.
- ericd 12y agoThere's a big difference between the government asking you what deductions you qualify for - those are intended under the law - and a corporation making convoluted corporate structures to avoid paying the intended amount of tax. Generally, double irish sandwiches and the like don't pass the smell test.
- talmand 12y agoIf the convoluted corporate structures are legal then they are paying the intended amount of tax because they are following the law. It may not pass the smell test but they are legal. The complaint needs to be placed upon the laws and those write them, not the companies who abide by the law.
- 12y ago
- nickjamespdx 12y agoGo Mark Cuban, I never liked you before today. Thanks.
- wyager 12y agoWhy? I don't understand how businesses are morally obligated not to select the optimal tax environment for them. After all, a very common defense for compulsory taxes is "if you don't like them, you can leave." Is that not what's happening here?
- jimbokun 12y agoI don't understand why Mark Cuban is morally obligated to invest in corporations doing things he doesn't like.
- wyager 12y ago>I don't understand why Mark Cuban is morally obligated to invest in corporations doing things he doesn't like. I never implied he was. I'm curious what his reasoning is.
- seanflyon 12y agoYou are curious why he thinks businesses are morally obligated not to select the optimal tax environment for them. Only he never indicated that he thinks that. Your question should be: Why would Mark Cuban want to encourage companies to stay and pay taxes? The answer to that question is somewhat obvious.
- AngrySkillzz 12y agoThe point is that a lot of companies keep their funds in offshore tax shelters but have their de facto bases of operations in the US. They benefit from the advantages that the US government provides (stability, well-educated workforce, infrastructure, etc.) without paying their fair share of the cost (i. e. corporate taxes), and it's not like they can't afford it.
- briandh 12y agoWhat's missing in your comment, though, is that many other developed countries offer those same benefits, and yet they don't tax foreign-earned income.
- JonFish85 12y agoSo what about companies who incorporate in Delaware? Are these companies he doesn't want to invest in?
- ericd 12y agoThat's to take advantage of Delaware's well fleshed out corporate law, not to avoid paying any taxes. I pay more in taxes to do that, in fact.
- JonFish85 12y agoThat may be some, but a good chunk of companies save a lot of tax dollars by doing this (according to http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/01/business/how-delaware-thrives-as-a-corporate-tax-haven.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/01/business/how-delaware-thri... among others).
- trollian 12y agoOr companies that aren't repatriating their profits to avoid paying US tax?
- mmcconnell1618 12y agoDelaware, Nevada, etc. let you skip STATE tax but your corporation would still be based in the United States and Federal taxes would still be due. If Mark Cuban resides in Texas then the net effect of lower tax revenue in the state of Delaware should be almost zero to him personally.
- vonmoltke 12y ago> Delaware, Nevada, etc. let you skip STATE tax but your corporation would still be based in the United States and Federal taxes would still be due. It's not that simple, and it doesn't allow corporations to skip state taxes. I only know Texas' law in detail, but Texas imposes franchise taxes on all companies "transacting business" within the state. Basically, any company with a physical presence in Texas is considered to be "transacting business" and may be subject to franchise tax. So, if your entire operation is in Texas it doesn't matter if you incorporate in Texas or Delaware, you are going to pay Austin the same.
- Eliezer 12y agoHi! This is the Market Economics Fairy! Just a quick reminder that if virtuous people selling a stock would predictably lead its profits to be temporarily priced lower relative to the rest of the stock market, even a small group of profit maximizers can just swoop in and buy that stock! So this is a completely ineffective strategy for virtuous people to drive a stock price lower! And if Cuban sells the stock after the news of their move breaks, he's already locked in all of the company's expected profit from that move, because the stock will already be priced higher! Sincerely, the Market Economics Fairy!
- busterarm 12y agoHe doesn't care about that. He's not looking at it from the trader's perspective but from the value investors. His actions follow through completely with his intentions here - he's signaling that the equity has lost value. This can hurt the company's value if he builds consensus, whether they lock in the short term profit or not. It's even the subtext of his whole argument: they aren't looking at the long-term consequences of their actions but are chasing short-term gains completely at the expense of their future. Edit: And as much as I align with the trader's perspective on markets, traders tend to blow up and with great frequency...much more-so than value investors.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- zak_mc_kracken 12y ago> he's signaling that the equity has lost value. But it hasn't. If anything, such announcements are followed by a stock value increase since the savings that will result from this move will add up to the bottom line, and the market responds positively to this kind of news. Lay offs are another of these things that tend to drive stocks up.
- busterarm 12y agoEdit: Rephrasing because I worded it poorly. His sell action _right now_ signals that he thinks it has lost value. What happens after that with the stock is independent of his opinion there. Sure, the stock may go up in the short-term because of all of this, but his action now agrees with his sentiment that they're doing something harmful that has effects _in the future_. What happens with the stock price isn't just reading tea leaves, but totally unimportant to the discussion. Whether you think a stock is going to go up or down isn't the only (and at the institutional level not even the most important) reason that you buy or sell a stock.
- neekb 12y agoLet's put it a different way. Let's assume for a second that the taxes are more or less "fixed" and need to be paid. SO - you can have companies participate to a lesser or fuller extent. The rest falls on us as INDIVIDUALS. The moral angle here is that companies shouldn't avoid the taxes of the very environment that enabled them to succeed in the first place. So I think what he's basically getting at is that paying your (corporate) taxes is basically like "giving back" to that system/environment. That's the way I think about it, anyways.
- joelrunyon 12y agoWhat if you believe that the actual taxes are overinflated & used improperly?
- neekb 12y agoThen you just joined a very large club. I don't think that means you shouldn't pay them, however. Also, there are tons and tons of people who complain about taxes but don't do anything about them. Do you vote? Did you ever run for any public position? Did you ever write a letter to someone in a public position making an awesome suggestion, or volunteering your time to help fix the system you think is overinflated? (Just examples, you know what I mean...) Of course I WISH taxes were lower, I love money! But I also believe that despite it's many, many, GLARING flaws... The USA is the best country on the planet, and I want to support that.
- jasonwocky 12y agoMove? Vote? Write your Congressman?
- icebraining 12y agoMove? Isn't that what they are doing?
- MereInterest 12y agoNope. Companies can put a small portion of themselves in a foreign country, then say that that small portion is the most important part. I cannot cut off my big toe, mail it to the Cayman Islands, then say that I should be taxed under their laws instead as a result. That analogous thing would be for a company to stop all business within a country, which is not being done.
- knodi 12y agoCorporations are people.....
- mikepmalai 12y agoU.S. could probably address this issue if they moved to a territorial tax regime. It would bring a lot of offshore cash back to the United States (especially in tech) that can later be redistributed back to investors and the economy via buybacks, dividends, and domestic M&A. The United States currently has a "worldwide" tax system and taxes U.S. companies on income earned both domestically and abroad in foreign countries. The tax on foreign earnings usually isn't assessed until the company brings it back to the United States (you'll hear companies talk about getting hit with a repatriation tax if they bring their "trapped" offshore cash back onshore to the U.S.). Most U.S. companies will try to avoid paying repatriation tax and keep substantial portions of their foreign cash earnings overseas to "reinvest" indefinitely. At this point, the United States is one of the few advanced economies that still taxes its companies on their active foreign earnings (I believe only 8 of the 34 OECD countries use worldwide tax system) and also has one of the highest tax rates. Most OECD countries use a territorial tax systems that largely exempts active foreign earnings from domestic taxation.
- briandh 12y agoThis point is not brought up enough. It is often buried or left out entirely in these discussions. Corporations that invert will not stop paying US taxes. They will stop paying it on foreign-earned income.
- busyant 12y agoUnfortunately, you can always game the system: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-10-05/pfizer-s-u-s-losses-questioned-as-overseas-profit-soars.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-10-05/pfizer-s-u-s-losses...
- Double_Cast 12y agoThis sounds like a tragedy of the commons. Is it feasible to excise tax corporations who move overseas like a tariff?
- danielweber 12y agoBusinesses are fungible. What's the difference between "I'm moving my business overseas" vs "I'm closing down my American business and starting an overseas business?" Trying to catch this is nailing jelly to a tree.
- zak_mc_kracken 12y agoThat's totally going to convince companies to stop doing that.
- vasilipupkin 12y agoI would say it slightly differently: if your company is willing to spend time and resources on the move for tax reasons and if taxes is such a big part of the future expected bottom line, that it's likely the company is not seeing huge opportunities going forward - and that is a negative signal for the stock.
- x86_64Ubuntu 12y agoIt's funny how people behave as if taxing companies is some sort of NP-Hard problem. When in fact, we've done it before, and even during the greatest market expansion in the 1950s-1970s. But no, we should go ahead and give up taxing companies, and allow them to use our courts, our infrastructure, our legal protections as American entities and American natural resources to their hearts content.
- briandh 12y agoInverted companies still pay taxes on US income, it's just foreign income that is no longer taxed.
- walkon 12y agoThe resources they are consuming are for the ultimate goal of satisfying consumer demand in an efficient enough way to profit from it. Are you a consumer? If so, you're an direct and indirect consumer of those resources.
- downandout 12y agoLet's remember that Mark Cuban didn't receive his fortune by making smart investments. He received it by winning the dotcom lottery. When listening to investment advice, perhaps we should listen to people that made their fortunes through smart investing. Public companies have a responsibility to their (rational) shareholders to minimize expenses that have no possible ROI. Taxes are chief among those.
- andyakb 12y agoGive me a break. Cuban is the first to admit that he got lucky in terms of his valuation, but it wasnt his first exit and his extensive writing on business should show that his success was not the result of luck. Further, if it werent for his intelligent investing, he would have lost nearly all of the proceeds from that sale, like so many others did(1). It was exactly his smart investing that allowed him to _keep_ his "lucky" windfall (1) http://investmentxyz.blogspot.com/2006/05/cubans-collar-anatomy-of-famous-trade.html?m=1 http://investmentxyz.blogspot.com/2006/05/cubans-collar-anat...
- downandout 12y agoYou're missing my point. He "made" his fortune by selling a company at a spectacular overvaluation. That's fine, but don't pretend that he turned a few million into a few billion through smart investing. With regard to the moves he made after the ridiculous Broadcast.com sale, all he did was lock in his profits. That turned out to be the correct move, but that doesn't necessarily say anything about his investing skills. It just shows that he realized that he had hit the lottery and wanted to insure his win. Warren Buffett made his money through smart investing. Mark Cuban did not, so I'd rather listen to Warren Buffett and others like him than an opinionated guy that got lucky.
- ken47 12y agoSuch naked ad hominem. Your argument would be much more compelling if you were capable of addressing Mark Cuban's arguments directly.
- 12y ago
- josho 12y agoSo, I guess this means Cuban has no stake in Apple & Google to name a few?