6 ms·
I wish the article spent some time discussing how we can defend against the effects of storms like this. It mentions a 12% chance of getting hit by one in the n
by chatmasta 12y ago
I wish the article spent some time discussing how we can defend against the effects of storms like this. It mentions a 12% chance of getting hit by one in the next 10 years (and I assume that percentage is much higher for a probability space of the next 50 or 100), but makes no mention of potential mitigation strategies.
Can you imagine how disastrous this would be? People would likely wake up without power, and think little of it at first. "Oh, it's a power outage. Better light some candles and wait it out." Then hours, days would pass. There would be no internet, television, or even newspapers to report what happened. We would be reduced to hearing the news from Shakespearian harriers!
I wonder if this would cause mass revolt. What happens when you completely disable modern technology on all of earth? If this is as likely as they say it is, there needs to be some serious research into mitigation strategies not only of the immediate technological effects, but also of the sociological effects.
Edit: maybe not all of earth, as the NASA page compares this to a localized blackout in Quebec. Can anyone comment on the geographical range of damage?
- ars 12y agoTo defend against it you just need a fuse, or a relay. Put one on each transformer that cuts power if it exceeds limits, this would save the transformer and would allow us to restore function pretty quickly.
- chatmasta 12y agoThat seems like a cheap solution that would protect not only against solar storms, but lightning strikes as well. Are these fuses common in transformers? If not, why?
- ars 12y agoI don't think they have them - just watch any transformer fire fueled by electricity. I say "fuse or relay", but for the power levels involved these are NOT simple components.
- growupkids 12y agoI work in commercial electrical power. No they don't. Because they aren't required to. It's all about costs. So unless it's about known risks (read PRA), no they don't protect against it. You need to spend money where the risks happen. Wish I had better news, but hey you protect against "real" risks, like LOOPs, trips, downed trees, lightning, regulators, and floods. Well I guess the quotes are unfair, these things happen often. So these are real things you want to mitigate. End of the world stuff, no one takes that seriously sadly. Also, don't forget a lot of the protective relays are digital protective relays. So even if you have them, well they might not work in This case. So aside from the digital PRs being "better" companies still sell them and few sell the older SD models, so we end up replacing the old solid state relays with digital drop in ones. So even if you have a PR it might not work in this case. And frankly few people in the industry, or with the regulators, takes a geostorm seriously in commercial power, even though they should.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoTypically, your fuses at that scale aren't fuses per se, but mechanical separation of conductors. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PdiJWQmSi0k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PdiJWQmSi0k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e6Ftv3zt-gI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e6Ftv3zt-gI
- gugol 12y agoYes, they are common, they are called surge arresters.
- headShrinker 12y agoHere is a video on high voltage circuit breaker evaluation and maintenance. More then you ever wanted to know I'm sure. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PKXPeTvmVQg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PKXPeTvmVQg These systems are complicated, hard to maintain and expensive.
- hcarvalhoalves 12y agoIt's not "cheap" when you have to install a breaker for each one. For the companies it's cheaper to have a transformer blow up every now and then. It'll only be considered an investment when the damage can out-weight the cost. So it's likely they'll only learn the lesson after the first solar storm hits, unless legislation demands they put it now.
- eli 12y agoI attended a lecture about this a few years back. NOAA has a satellite system to warn us about large solar flares... but it's old and severely underfunded. Which is somewhat surprising, because that 20 minute heads up is the difference between GPS satellites and electric grid components being safely taken offline vs permanently damaged.
- patcon 12y agoYeah, when I started getting involved in web operations tools, and realizing all the levels of redundancy that the big players like Google and Netflix have, it really got me thinking about our hydro and communications infrasture. For instance, Netflix has it's chaos monkey, than randomly kills servers and availability zones and generally wreaks havoc. They set it loose, and learn to keep things operating. I really thinkg it would be a responsible societal effort to introduce chaos monkeys into our archaic infrastructure outside digital. And as for that underfunded satellite, it's sitting in the sweet spot between the gravitation tug of the earth and sun called the L1 langrangian point, where it takes no effort to keep it exactly in place. But we really need more drills to learned whether the hydro/comm infrastructure on one hemisphere of the earth can actually shut everything down in 20 minutes, day or night.
- dandelany 12y agoThe 100-year old underground electric wires running under the street where I work have caught on fire three times in the past year. Something tells me our archaic infrastructure has quite a backlog of existing chaos monkeys to deal with already.
- tedsanders 12y agoThe spirit of the idea is good, but it would not work well for hardware. With software, if something breaks, you restart the servers. With hardware, if something breaks, you have to buy a new one. Throwing chaos monkeys to see which transformers blow up would end up quite expensive. :)
- chucknelson 12y ago
- spacesword 12y agoSounds exactly like the now canceled TV show "Revolution".
- halfcat 12y agoThat's it. I've had it with cancelled shows. I'm no longer starting any shows until the series finale has aired.
- kamaal 12y ago>>no mention of potential mitigation strategies The biggest risk is if you think of it on the very long term, staying on earth is like risking it all on staying on one rock. There are far too many risks, and there is little you can do mitigate them on the long term. The long term solution is to invest money to build technologies to develop inter stellar travel and related technologies to settle humans outside earth. And that really wasn't that difficult to achieve. The problem is we haven't made serious attempts beyond the moon and mars missions. The funding is too limited, and there is no political consensus around the world to work towards these goals. We have become far too busy with wars, conflicts and other pointless spending on earth. While we could have used the money to do something like this. >>Can you imagine how disastrous this would be?.... It can be far more disastrous than you imagine. Loss of electricity and water are just primary effects. There are many secondary effects of these scenarios. No electricity means you can't pump out fuel. Bulk of your critical production[Food/Medicine/Sanitation etc] Will come to grinding halt because of inter dependencies. Expect mass starvation, riots, loss of law and order kind of scenarios. There will likely be powerful groups controlling critical resources required to survive. I wouldn't say its a extinction scenario. But it will come pretty close.
- Houshalter 12y agoIt would be far cheaper to build underground bunkers on Earth, or fund prevention of specific risks like this one. Building a permanently self-sufficient colony isn't just ridiculously expensive, it may not even be possible with our technology for a very long time. And it's still only a last resort. Civilization and everyone on Earth still perishes in the apocalypse. It would take significantly more than this to wipe out humanity btw. Even the worse case scenarios, civilization still recovers eventually.
- seszett 12y ago> Can you imagine how disastrous this would be? People would likely wake up without power, and think little of it at first. "Oh, it's a power outage. Better light some candles and wait it out." Then hours, days would pass. There would be no internet, television, or even newspapers to report what happened. We would be reduced to hearing the news from Shakespearian harriers! > I wonder if this would cause mass revolt. What happens when you completely disable modern technology on all of earth? If this is as likely as they say it is, there needs to be some serious research into mitigation strategies not only of the immediate technological effects, but also of the sociological effects. I really doubt it would be that terrible. It's not like electricity would have completely disappeared for ever (like in this great novel apparently called in English "Ashes, Ashes" [0]). Important things and urgent things like communication means would quickly be operated by emergency generators, so people would immediately have information through radio (and most of the receptors are battery operated), and probably also TV, although they would probably have to go to the local townhall, hospital, school or whatever place would have a working generator to watch it. Cars would still work so people could move around, at least while there are refined gasoline reserves, but refineries would probably be one of the first industries to get powered again anyway. Probably for a good while there would be restrictions on electricity usage, depending on how hard existing plants would have been hit and whether they are fixable or have to be completely rebuilt, but I really don't think it would "destroy life as we know it". I wonder how nuclear plants would handle this, though. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ravage_(novel) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ravage_(novel)
- worldsayshi 12y ago> I wonder how nuclear plants would handle this, though. Yes, could all those aged reactors deal with large scale grid or component malfunction? Fukishima didn't do too well. FUD: Would we have hundreds of Fukishimas on our hands after such event?
- sp332 12y agoA power plant makes its own power, so the grid going down wouldn't affect it. For other components, nuclear reactors have many failsafes. Fukushima exhausted at least 4 that I know of. Since a CME wouldn't cause physical destruction like the earthquake and tsunami did, there's a much lower chance that all the failsafes will fail at once.
- tonylemesmer 12y agoYou could build an oven in your backyard and stock up with a load of wood ;) and make friends with your local livestock dealer. Just have a plan for how you're going to still make money once everything shuts down. Start here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow's_hierarchy_of_needs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow's_hierarchy_of_needs and work upwards.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoHint: you'll need guns. Lots of guns. Cities are stocked with food and water for few days, but once the supplies are gone, you'll have waves of hungry and desperate people radiating from cities to nearby farms and villages.
- aethertap 12y agoI think you're right that guns are probably a necessity to some extent, but I would rather spend the money on feeding my neighbors as much as possible rather than fighting them. I ran some quick numbers on webstaurantsupply.com, and for a simple "donut diet"[1] you can feed 100 people 1800 kCal/day for nearly a month for $1000 (the price of a decent quality rifle where I live). I've been trying to work out a way to organize neighborhood-level basic essentials storages on the cheap, so that people in that kind of situation can afford to take care of themselves until the power comes back on. Food is pretty easy, but water and sanitation are a bit more problematic so far. [1] - just calories to make it over the hump, this is not health food. Ingredients are white flour, white sugar, vegetable oil, and some white rice for the people who can't do the wheat products. Add vitamin pills to prevent deficiency diseases and you can stay functional for a long time at about $0.30/day.
- baq 12y agothe point is, money stops being worth anything in this scenario. you can't eat it and you can't drink it. money is based on trust and when civilization collapses, trust disappears.
- 12y ago