14 ms·
Chattanooga offers residents lightning-quick connections, to telecoms' dismay
- dang 12y agoArticle title changed to (compressed) subtitle to reduce baitiness.
- polarix 12y agoThanks for leaving a comment here indicating the change. This should be standard behavior, if it's not already.
- jawns 12y agoOne way to address the private utility companies' argument -- that a publicly owned utility has a natural advantage over for-profit companies -- is to change the corporate structure of the utility so that it's no longer publicly owned. For instance, it might be converted into a for-profit company, with the city retaining a portion of the shares, or into a cooperative (as many utilities, particularly those in rural communities, are incorporated). In fact, it could even sell off its shares in times of need to finance other municipal needs. If it's converted into a cooperative, it would become 100% member-owned, and any profits would not go to outside shareholders, as with a publicly traded company, but would instead go back to its member-owners in the form of lower costs. The more I think about it, the more I think this is the way to go for other cities of a similar size. Clearly, Comcast/Verizon weren't very interested in laying down their own fiber there if the city beat them to it. And once a utility company (in this case, publicly owned) has an effective monopoly in a certain area, it's going to be hard for others to introduce competing infrastructure. BUT, I would think that the ability to then sell the publicly owned utility would have significant value to the municipalities.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoThanks for touching on the coop model. I think that's a phenomenal way of addressing the muni broadband situation. http://stopthecap.com/2012/01/03/want-rural-21st-century-broadband-form-a-co-op-or-wait-indefinitely-for-someone-else-to-provide-it/ http://stopthecap.com/2012/01/03/want-rural-21st-century-bro...
- Lagged2Death 12y agoOne way to address the private utility companies' argument... The private ISP's argument is a perfect flip-flop and doesn't really deserve addressing.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rrradical 12y agoGenuinely curious-- what would stop Comcast from then buying it and then raising the rates to match the rest of their prices?
- mseebach 12y agoA couple of reasons: 1: A coop generally can't have outside ownership. 2: Before Comcast can buy them, someone would need to sell it. It's not clear why they'd want to sell to Comcast. 3: If they did sell, they then (by definition) have the value of a community-wide network in their pockets. They could use that to build another community-wide network to compete with Comcast (then Comcast could buy that, but...) But more fundamentally, if Comcast had a lot of money lying around for stuff like this, they could just invest it in becoming a properly good ISP that people would actually want to be customers of.
- pyre 12y agoFrom Comcast's perspective, it's probably easier to invest in buying a company that already exists, than to invest in building something that may or may not work. The existing company already has financials that can be evaluated, rather than estimates that may not hold once the risk is taken.
- mseebach 12y agoThe form of investment is irrelevant, and yes, that would be a very reasonable way to invest in getting a quality network. They just don't seem all that interested in making that investment in the first place. When you buy an asset, it's not like you're not paying for the risk of building it in the first place, the risk is just firmly priced into the value of the asset.
- JustSomeNobody 12y agoFrom Comcast's perspective its probably cheaper to simply invest in politicians.
- mseebach 12y agoThe problem isn't the ownership model after the fact, it's who underwrites the risk of the initial investment. Most of the time, when public organizations make bold investments, they're mis-pricing the risk (which is easy to do when you have someone else around to pick up the tab if things goes wrong). In Denmark, the utilities did a fiber-laying frenzy around a decade ago and the business case did not follow through and the consequence was enormous cost to electricity consumers who never had a say in the matter (OK, technically they did through politically appointed oversight at the utilities). I think the coop model for getting fiber to the home is awesome. Nobody benefits more from laying last-mile fiber than the homeowner. But forcing neighbors to invest in the project if they're happy with the state of the art isn't really fair IMO. I've actually been thinking quite a bit of how a provisioning and operations consultancy that would help eg. home owners associations and the like build and run a fiber network and essentially be their own local ISP. Does such a thing exist?
- streptomycin 12y agoI've seen some apartment buildings that buy a T1 line (or whatever) so they can give their tenants "free" Internet included with their rent. That's basically the same thing.
- Scoundreller 12y agoOr they could form their own internet cooperative and do wireless links between apartment buildings and a NOC somewhere in town with the actual downlink. The equipment to do it (Ubiquiti makes some gear that appears quite nice) is getting cheaper by the year.
- pfitzsimmons 12y agoI would love for someone to start a company that could bring fiber to cities via the kickstarter model. Getting the money upfront from customers could go a long way toward mitigating the risk. Ideally the company would be structured as a hybrid for-profit/customer co-operative (so maybe 20% of the shares would be 10X preferred stock owned by the for-profit arm, and the other 80% of shares would be owned by the customers).
- Zigurd 12y agoWhy are investor owned enterprises owed any explanation at all?
- nzealand 12y agoOr define any internet utility as a common carrier to open up competition.
- lutorm 12y agoThe argument that a publicly owned utility shouldn't be allowed to do it because it has a natural advantage is ridiculous -- that's precisely the point! Corporations exist to provide a good to society, and if a public utility would do that job better, then we should obviously be free to choose that model. It's not my job as a citizen to subsidize for-profit enterprise for the sole reason that they are for-profit enterprise!
- abraxasz 12y agoThat was exactly my thought when I read the comment. I would be very curious to know if I'm missing something here, but it seems obvious to me that if a publicly owned company can do something better and cheaper (cheaper not only just for these people but also for the taxpayer, I don't know if that's the case here) then how is that a bad thing?
- tiatia 12y ago"It's not my job as a citizen to subsidize for-profit enterprise for the sole reason that they are for-profit enterprise!" Unfortunately, it is. The numbers are so tremendously bend in favor of "socialized medicine" but it is basically communism and hence, the private model is better. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_life_expectancy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_life_expe... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_health_expenditure_(PPP)_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_hea...
- Alupis 12y ago> The numbers are so tremendously bend in favor of "socialized medicine" There are also a lot of numbers against "socialized medicine".
- SnacksOnAPlane 12y agoFor example?
- 12y ago
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y ago> a publicly owned utility has a natural advantage over for-profit companies So what if it does? I do not think that this should be of overriding concern to us. The for-profit companies are not the only stakeholders here.
- bencollier49 12y agoInteresting, this. I suspect that under the currently-being-dbated TTIP, this would count as State Aid, and foreign shareholders in Comcast could sue the local government for lost profits.
- davidw 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugene_Water_%26_Electric_Board http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugene_Water_%26_Electric_Board has worked pretty well to provide water and electricity in the town I grew up in.
- coldtea 12y ago>One way to address the private utility companies' argument -- that a publicly owned utility has a natural advantage over for-profit companies And why shouldn't it have "a natural advantage over for-profit companies"? Were "for-profit companies" granted a guarantee to have advantage over everything else somewhere?
- bencollier49 12y agoI wonder if the legal issues could be sidestepped by the local utility subletting the data usage of their cabling to, say, Google?
- andrewguenther 12y agoJust to confirm, the article doesn't really make it clear (or I'm just dense), but are they carrying broadband through power lines?
- theandrewbailey 12y agoNo. EPB is fiber. http://chattanoogagig.com/ http://chattanoogagig.com/
- wmf 12y agoNo, I think the electric company built a fiber network to manage their electric grid and then they decided to extend it to homes and businesses.
- btrautsc 12y agoThis is correct.
- pyre 12y agoI guess the real question is then: Does allowing home/business users onto the same network that manages the electrical grid a good idea (from an OpSec point of view)? Does this make it easier to hack the electric grid? What happens to the electric grid when the network becomes congested?
- toomuchtodo 12y agoOne would hope they would be physically segregating the network and using different fiber strands for SCADA vs home/business users. I would be nervous even if it was logically separated using something like vlans at layer 2; you're one bad configuration change away from possibly damaging consequences.
- pyre 12y agoMy thought is that this digs into the idea that they 'just decided to' offer Fiber-to-the-Premises after they realized that they had built a fiber network. Or is this a non-issue (i.e. adding new strands is trivial / cheap once the infrastructure is there or maybe SOP is to just lay lots of strands, because the strands are cheap)?
- na85 12y agoTypical response from entrenched American monopolies: Use the courts to prop up your outdated business model so that you aren't required to innovate.
- e40 12y agoIt's not just lack of innovation. Sometimes there is innovation. It's the protection of monopolies. Comcast has been delivering me good speeds, but they're the only choice I have. That's what they want, it's the opposite of what I want.
- na85 12y agoIn what way does that example illustrate that Comcast sometimes innovates?
- e40 12y agoThe speeds they are providing me are much higher than they were. My point was that innovation isn't the important aspect of this issue, it's the protection of the monopoly. I think we'll all agree that monopolies will tend to innovate less.
- luckyno13 12y agoThe speeds may go higher, but they still are rarely what is advertised. Perhaps they should attempt utilization of advertised speeds, at this point, that would pretty much be innovation. In the U.S. at least.
- briandh 12y agoIt's not that Comcast (or whomever they're licensing technology from) isn't innovating; it's that the reason they're innovating is to avoid more expensive investments in new infrastructure.
- jsz0 12y agoComcast and other major cable MSOs play a major role in the development of the DOCSIS spec. Over the next 18-24 months as DOCSIS 3.1 deployments kick up we're going to start seeing the most dramatic increase for residential broadband speeds since the late 1990s. Within about 5 years it's likely that the majority of people in this country will have access to 500Mbit-1Gbit/sec speeds via cable. It may not be as sexy or headline grabbing as FTTH build outs but it will have a much greater real world impact. It's more evolutionary in most ways than innovative but at this scale that's still quite an achievement. The same basic infrastructure that could deliver only 1.5Mbit/sec in 1997 will be able to deliver you 1Gbit/sec+ by 2017 and by 2025 10Gbit/sec will be quite common. Considering that this infrastructure is not very far removed from struggling to get a clear picture on your MTV in 1985 I think it's worthwhile to give the folks who work incredibly hard on this stuff some credit for their achievements.
- rayiner 12y agoI really don't understand how everyone gets so excited over publicly owned internet infrastructure. Here in Wilmington, they can't get the buses to run within 30 minutes of scheduled time. I don't even want to imagine what the municipal internet would be like. Over in Atlanta, not too far from Chattanooga, the public sewer system has major sections dating back to the reconstruction after the civil war, and dumps untreated sewage into the Chattahoochee after a big rain overflows the system. Municipal infrastructure historically is under-maintained (hard to get people to long up tax dollars for something that already kinda works). It'll be curious to see how Chattanooga keeps up with the upgrade cycle over the next decades. Also, no company wants taxpayer-funded alternatives to their product. Its impossible to effectively compete with a public entity that can tap tax revenue. That angle doesn't really add anything to the article.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoAnd yet, my roads, police and fire services, and municipal maintenance services work very well. Just as with the private sector, you'll be able to find public initiatives that aren't reaching their goals, or are outright failures. Should they not be permitted to compete against the private sector when the private sector chooses not to serve a certain unprofitable market segment? If you're that good at providing services, why as a private business are you worried about competing with an "incompetent" (as you may argue) public sector initiative? Full Disclosure: I fully support municipal broadband, and want a stake driven through Comcast's heart.
- anigbrowl 12y agoThere's no inherent problem with publicly funded services, but they're only as good as the public body that runs them. If you're in a well-run city/county that's great, if you're in a dysfunctional one then not so much. I wouldn't have much confidence if my place of residence (Oakland CA) set up muni broadband, for example, although I'd like to be proved wrong. Large parts of the city government are painfully inefficient.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago
- tim333 12y agoGo Chattanooga!
- malchow 12y agoLoosk like EPB, the electric utility co. in question here, is offering 1Gbps over fiber for $70/mo. https://epbfi.com/enroll/packages/#/ https://epbfi.com/enroll/packages/#/
- hajile 12y agoAlso note that the connection is symmetrical at 1Gbs while most connections greatly favor download and punish upload
- davidandgoliath 12y agoI moved to Chattanooga mostly because of EPB. It's worth noting I average about 900mbps up, and 900 down. During peak hours it's about 900/750, which I find impressive.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mynameishere 12y agoJust out of curiosity, what do you do with all that bandwidth? I'm assuming they block port 80, so I can't really see the point...
- coldpie 12y agoThis is wildly unimaginative. One can do lots of things with massive upload. Super high quality streaming video, over Google Hangouts or Skype, and with Twitch available on every Xbox 1 and Playstation 4. You could have a basically realtime backup system that rsyncs your entire system to a remote server nightly. You can do large asset sharing with remote team members without long download times. Software distribution via bittorrent (Blizzard has been doing this for years) could become basically instant if everyone had gigabit upload speeds. Limited bandwidth is a really, really constraining bottleneck on innovation. It's a crime that Comcast et al get away with limiting innovation on the Internet to support their monopolies.
- nickreese 12y agoThe thing that is left out of the EPB conversation is the amount of federal funding they got. While it does make a good case study, what is impressive is the smaller cities that are beginning to roll it out even in states where laws ban/limit it. Like Opelika Power in Alabama: http://www.opelikapower.com/ http://www.opelikapower.com/. For my startup broadbandnow.com we've been emailing every mayor in the US offering free statistics about coverage, fiber penetration, etc in their local area along with how they can bring faster speeds to their area. So far the campaign is going well, we've emailed almost 300 mayors, but after countless phone calls and email changes with city officials, the disheartening reality is that most cities have 2 options to bring faster interent to their area. 1 - Install their own network 2 - Beg incumbent providers to increase their speed / coverage. I think it's still a few years out, but I'm forecasting a huge slew of crowd funded or community backed providers entering the market to fill the gaps in coverage. (Our goal is to be a part of that movement)
- nickreese 12y agoUpdate: Here is a relevant post outlining the 19 states with laws limiting municipal broadband. http://broadbandnow.com/report/municipal-broadband-roadblocks/ http://broadbandnow.com/report/municipal-broadband-roadblock...
- sehugg 12y agoAlso the funding they got ($111.5 million) was from the DOE under the auspices of building out a "Smart Grid" [1]. Doubtful that a full fiber connection to the home is required for these applications. [1] https://www.epb.net/news/news-archive/epb-chattanooga-awarded-federal-stimulus-grant-for-smart-grid/ https://www.epb.net/news/news-archive/epb-chattanooga-awarde...
- crymer11 12y agoEPB does have a very nice "smart grid" that uses fiber optic lines to connect to stations positioned all over their network that monitor the condition of the connected grid and can rapidly shut off power to a very localized area. They realized that they still had quite a large bit of bandwidth remaining, and decided to start an ISP.[1] 1- This is all based on what I recall from conversations with EPB higher-ups when I spent a day chatting with them for a school event.
- hyperliner 12y agoWhen should the government enter a "private" market opportunity? I think the answer is "Only when necessary to advance the public good." It seems people want to have one model or the other ALWAYS. But it is not that easy. We don't want firefighters being a private business because a house would burn before you can pay for the service. Or police: the service is typically needed where those with least ability to pay live. However, it also does not follow that government should enter, say, into the haircut business or the fashion business. But the simple "threat" that it would be possible should send the message to private participants that service at reasonable cost is expected in some markets. To the extent that access to information and communication is a necessary requirement in the Republic, then it seems to me that it is the government role to ensure this. EDIT: I wonder at what level though. It seems that if the service is necessary, local initiatives have the least chance to be successful. Maybe this is one of those projects where states have a better chance.
- eyeareque 12y agoInnovate or litigate at its finest.
- jrockway 12y ago> "The result is a system that now provides the nation’s fastest broadband" Well, tied for fastest. It only goes up to 1Gbps. Meanwhile, Japan has at least 2Gbps (and I think I saw 4Gbps somewhere, but don't have a source).
- TheSisb2 12y agoKeyword: Nation
- montecarl 12y agoHow does one even make use of >1Gbps internet in a residential setting? Do they sell 10 GigE routers for consumers? Are there any desktops or laptop out there with 10 GigE? I think the answer is no. The fact that you can get a 1 Gbps link to the internet is amazing. This is pretty much the fastest LAN connection you can get. The difference between LAN and WAN will be gone before too long (other than latency).
- tacticus 12y ago>Do they sell 10 GigE routers for consumers? Not yet. But the cost of 10Gbe is dropping quite rapidly.
- jrockway 12y agoRouting even 1Gbps with NAT, etc. is actually a little difficult. But you can drop a 10GigE card into your desktop and get 10Gbps for at least one machine that way. (They seem to cost in the $500 range these days. I'd pay $500 for a 10Gbps link to the Internet. What would I do? I have no idea.)
- jdong 12y agoExcept due to routing 2Gbps in Japan is way worse than 1Gbps in the US for most content.
- krankin1 12y agoI used to live in Chattanooga, EPB was wonderful. My favorite thing about the internet service, my bill was exactly the price advertised (like 59.99). No additional fees, no extra taxes, all of that rolled into the advertised price. It's a little thing, but helped to build trust. Oh, and the download speeds were always as advertised or better.
- minimax 12y agoLike a publicly traded corporation, the utility issued bonds to raise resources to invest in the new broadband project. Similarly, just as many private corporations ended up receiving federal stimulus dollars, so did EPB, which put those monies into its new network. This is kind of a bullshit comparison. The bonds they are talking about are bonds issued by the city of Chattanooga and backed by the revenue of the local electric utility. That isn't something a telco can do. And they are muni bonds so they receive favorable tax treatment (the interest payments on the bond are tax exempt at the federal and state level) which is reflected through lower interest rates (cheaper borrowing costs) for the issuer. So to say that, hey, the local electric utility did a thing that any old telco could do is not realistic. Also the part about receiving stimulus money is really contrived. The utility directly received DOE (Dept of Energy) moneys in a way that none of the big telcos did.
- rosser 12y agoAnd municipally owned utilities can't lobby (read: buy) congresscritters like the telcos can. Life's just unfair to everyone, innit?
- rayiner 12y agoMunicipal workers' lobbies are some of the most powerful in the country.
- rosser 12y agoAnd the workers' union's lobbying abilities are relevant to the utility's efforts to get into broadband how, again?
- rayiner 12y agoWorkers' unions want to drive expenditure towards projects that employ the most public sector workers, not the ones with best ROI. It also drives up the cost of labor relative to private sector entities that can use non-union labor. Labor is a big part of the expenditures on an infrastructure project.
- MCRed 12y agoI am hopeful that this will show people why municipalities granting monopolies to phone and cable companies is a bad idea. I've argued this for years, and many of the people who are now pro-net neutrality, in years past would argue that there needed to be these monopolies, because otherwise the infrastructure wouldn't be built, or poor people wouldn't be able to afford it, etc. In fact, EPB is probably a local monopoly- many power companies are, though that is less the case today than in decades past.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- specto 12y agoMy sister has this and doesn't upgrade to the 1000 service because she doesn't need it, even though it's $12 more than 100. I'm sitting here lucky if I get 11 down .5 up
- kqr2 12y agoOT, but how is Chattanooga's startup scene doing? A little while ago, there was this thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5166034 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5166034 Also, http://noogastartups.com/ http://noogastartups.com/
- tjefferson 12y agoWe posted at almost the exact same time. We're down here in an accelerator right now, and the quality of designers and engineers is incredible. The city is working pretty hard to put itself on the map as a place to start a company, especially on the hardware/additive manufacturing side of things. And there's great beer everywhere, three climbing gyms walking distance from my desk, and dirt-cheap office space.
- tjefferson 12y agoI'm really glad to see EPB getting some good press: they not only took a really innovative step forward with their physical infrastructure, but also partnered with a local accelerator program (http://www.thegigcity.com/gigtank/ http://www.thegigcity.com/gigtank/) to give startups access to their expertise and grid data to help new companies in the smart grid/smart home space. This was the first year they've done so, but I expect they'll continue. Full disclosure: we're www.gridcure.com in the smart grid track of the most recent cohort of the program (Demo Day is on the 29th. Ahh!), and can't speak more highly of the startup community in Chattanooga and the quality of work that goes on here. EPB's been a terrific pilot partner for us.
- discardorama 12y agoOne angle missing in this whole debate is privacy. For example: the USPS, having started as a government agency, has the weight of the law behind it. No one can mess with your (physical) mail. Similarly, I can imagine a scenario where traffic on a municipal-owned fiber network could enjoy some protections that a private operator won't. As an example, ATT is more than happy to bend over and go above and beyond the law to help the feds, hoping for favors in return.
- HistoryInAction 12y agoInterestingly, Rep. Marsha Blackburn (R-Tennessee) introduced an amendment that the House passed banning such local broadband efforts, which require explicit approval by the FCC: http://motherboard.vice.com/read/house-republicans-are-killing-the-dream-of-local-high-speed-fiber-internet http://motherboard.vice.com/read/house-republicans-are-killi... If startups had a Chamber of Commerce equivalent, as Chattanooga's Enoch Elwall has been proposing, our community could effectively push back in a unified political voice through a local organization.
- ekianjo 12y ago> Yet, in an epic fight over telecommunications policy, the paradigm is now being flipped on its head, with corporate forces demanding the government squelch competition and halt the expansion of those high-quality services. ISPs and Telecoms are amongst the industries that lobby governments the most - they are actively fighting against Free Market, so there's nothing about this which is "flipping this paradigm on its head".
- jackvalentine 12y agoThe obvious answer to complaints is to open the network up for wholesale and force the utility company that built it to sell access to it's retail arm for at least the same price as it's charging others.