9 ms·
Miami is drowning while the powers that be look away
- socrates1998 12y agoInteresting read, but I am not sure how it will all play out. If the rise in sea level is gradual, then I think there could be decent solutions. If it happens fast, like in a 3-5 year span, then it will get ugly, housing prices will crash and people will leave. Crazy, I hope we get more progressive politicians in South Florida to help mitigate the damage. And this isn't just for Miami, this is for most of Florida from the Treasure Coast all the way down to the Keys, and including the Gulf Coast (Fort Myers, Naples, Tampa). There could be 7-10 million people affected.
- zmanian 12y agoThis seems like a tremendous failure of efficient markets at the moment. The market has high confidence information that the value of land in Miami will diminish towards zero in the near future. There should be brisk trade in derivatives betting against the 10-30 year land value in South Florida. There should be massive downward pressure on land values. Seems bizarre to me that this isn't happening.
- jgh 12y agoA quick browse through the comments will find you a bunch of people who apparently live in Miami but don't think that there will be sea level rise because they don't think global warming is happening.
- presidentender 12y agoCan we short real estate?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wheaties 12y agoNot directly, no.
- adventured 12y agoBasically yes. You can buy ETFs that are short real estate. You can short real estate ETFs that focus on various real estate specialties. If you think the Florida real estate market will be destroyed, you can focus on local, public real estate companies and short them.
- presidentender 12y agoBy what mechanism does the ETF go short on real estate? Stocks are fungible, so borrowing shares to sell them makes sense, but I just can't make sense of the mechanism for real estate.
- dustcoin 12y agoThe ETF could short REITs (Real estate investment trusts) that hold Miami property.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- hollerith 12y agoThe efficient-market hypothesis implies that housing prices in South Florida are lower than they would be if sea level were guaranteed to stay the same. And nothing in the article contradicts that. In other words the downward pressure from the prospect of sea-level rise is probably being cancelled out by upward pressure from other factors -- e.g., the fact that Miami is an important nexus of flows of money and talent from and to Latin America.
- pbh101 12y agoTwo more notes: 1) In addition to there being many non-monetary factors in a housing market, as hollerith mentioned, housing markets are also generally not very efficient compared to others. 2) Any bet that land prices will plummet for this reason (this is something a hedge fund would do) would have to calculate the 'risk' of massive intervention when/if the problem gets to the unignorable/still-fixable-even-at-enormous-cost stage. If presented with the choice of "evacuate south florida" v. "here's a very costly plan to save Miami," I think America would choose the latter. I live in Amsterdam, and I've (apocryphally, quick googling didn't reveal the number) heard that over the centuries the Netherlands has spent ~1 trillion inflation-adjusted dollars on its water management system. "Rationally"—and very simplistically—speaking, these people "could" all go live somewhere else, but that's not how the world works. (Nor should it, IMO, but off-topic)
- mikeash 12y ago$1 trillion over centuries isn't really a lot. What's the total worth of Amsterdam? Seems like a sound investment.
- zmanian 12y agoMy understanding of the situation is no one has even proposed a "very costly plan to save Miami." This is Venice on an accelerated time scale. Miami pales in comparisons proportionate wealth and power when Venice started sinking in earnest. I'd be very reluctant to short Manhattan real estate because protecting Manhattan from higher sea levels is merely an engineering challenge and affordable relative to NYC economic output. Manhattan is basically made out of granite. South Florida on porous limestone. Miami seems f'd to me.
- pbreit 12y agoMaybe because the risk, as expressed in this article, is a tad overblown? For example, I've never heard anyone talk in feet when it comes to ocean levels.
- mikeash 12y agoReally? Quick wikipediaing shows projected sea level rise by 2100 to be a couple of feet, albeit with a lot of uncertainty.
- refurb 12y agoLet me guess! Sea levels will rise 2 ft +/- 2.5 ft right?
- mikeash 12y agoThe projections are all over the place (thus why I was so vague) but I don't think they went quite as far as to have error bars that went into the negatives. Not that there's anything wrong with that.
- MaysonL 12y agoMore like +5/-1
- gerbal 12y ago+5/+1 more like. The sea will rise, but it's just a question of how much.
- krakensden 12y agoIt's pretty reasonable to bet that when the shit really hits the fan, the billions necessary will arrive. Democracies are procrastinators like that.
- ars 12y ago> The market has high confidence information that the value of land in Miami will diminish towards zero in the near future. > Seems bizarre to me that this isn't happening. The obvious conclusion is that either the market does not believe the high confidence information, or that they are sure that people will do something before anything bad happens.
- onedev 12y agoSo this is why LeBron left....
- poopsintub 12y agoBazinga? The picture of the street with water in it was actually from tears of fans.
- CapitalistCartr 12y agoLiving in South Florida is enlightening. It is a Latin American City. Locally, it is called the capitol of Latin America; you can catch flights to any Latin American countries from there, even when you can't get a flight between those countries. I am a Florida native; in my life I've seen this state go from just under 4 million people to almost 20 million. Most of the people live on shored-up sandbars, filled-in swampland (me), and made land. Miami is a huge, economically vital sprawl that isn't going anywhere. I saw the devastation of Hurricane Andrew firsthand, and that didn't slow anything down. The landowners, shopkeepers, and powers-that-be aren't in denial; they understand just fine.
- pbh101 12y ago"Infrastructure buildout lags population growth" is a way less sexier story than "Miami will not exist soon because Republicans." I too would bet that Miami isn't going anywhere because entrenched interests (that is, the city and its population) won't let it. My comment below neglected the insufficient infrastructure as a factor. It's one thing for someone to say that "X phenomenon is going to occur." It's another to uproot your life based on that assertion.
- kenrikm 12y agoI'm originally from Miami born and raised (Live in SF Now) and I have skin in the game, I own a house in Miami. However this piece is largely fluff and fear mongering, Miami has always flooded, The city of Sweet Water would be completely flooded every few months until they finally put in proper drainage after 20+ years of the same thing. The problem is poorly thought out city planning over the last 40 or so years, not a recent sea level rise.
- kephra 12y agoA good part of Netherlands is below sea level. Just build dikes like the Dutch, and the problem is solved. But I guess the people in Miami would protest against those dikes, when their houses are no longer water front, but behind a dike.
- mikecb 12y agoDoes the Netherlands get hurricanes?
- smackay 12y agoSometimes, http://dutchcommunity.com/2012/05/24/the-1953-watersnoodramp-flood-disaster/ http://dutchcommunity.com/2012/05/24/the-1953-watersnoodramp...
- iamtew 12y agoWe do. Maybe not that often, but it do happen. There was one in October that made a lot of damage here [1], but also two days ago (albeit not hurricane) there was a storm that flooded large parts of Amsterdam [2] and killed on person. [3] 1: http://www.cbsnews.com/news/hurricane-force-storm-batters-northern-europe/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/hurricane-force-storm-batters-no... 2: http://www.at5.nl/artikelen/131015/honderden-meldingen-van-wateroverlast-door-noodweer http://www.at5.nl/artikelen/131015/honderden-meldingen-van-w... 3: http://www.at5.nl/artikelen/131014/storm-eist-een-leven http://www.at5.nl/artikelen/131014/storm-eist-een-leven
- m4x 12y ago
- mschuster91 12y ago> Astonishingly, the population is growing, house prices are rising and building goes on. The problem is the city is run by climate change deniers Well then, let those who are foolish enough to disbelieve science then just drown. The government is supposed to protect people, sometimes even from themselves... but this stupidity people are showing is beyond believable. To those wanting to flee: sell your property to denialists, move off somewhere safe and laugh your behinds off when you see the denialists realizing that not even God can help them any more.
- SoftwareMaven 12y agoFigure out who underwrites flood insurance and see if you still feel the same.
- dmritard96 12y agoMy dad ran much of the planning for Broward County (one county north, home to fort lauderdale) until he retired a few weeks ago. There are a lot of dynamics at play in South Florida which make this very complicated and obviously an impending disaster. The first is that while Broward County is progressive and has been proactively dealing with and planning for sea level rise, Miami Dade county has a very large Cuban voter base which tends to sway the politics more center if not altogether right. I always postulated that this is mostly a reaction to the communism that they immigrated away from however it is my opinion that the newer generations will slowly move more to the left (granted, this phenomena is probably larger than just SoFla's cuban population). As the article mentions, most of South Florida is built on top of limestone (calcified reefs from a previous geological period). The water table is only a few feet below the surface hence there are at least two major reproccusions for sea level rise. In older neighborhoods (Hollywood, anything east of the Atlantic Coastal Ridge [what I95 is built on]), a high tide + rain typically stalls the drainage system with water flooding streets and homes. A second major problem is that the Biscayne Aquifer, the water supply for the millions of people in South East Florida, is experiencing salt water intrusion due to higher sea levels. You can think of the aquifer as sort of a dome with its highest point farthest inland and as the sea level rises the dome is getting skinnier. Even while I was growing up, they were decommissioning water well fields because of the salt content starting with the most coastal and moving inland. Inland suburbs in Broward like Sunrise are then selling their water to the other municipalities for a killing but at some point even they will have issues as the aquifer becomes squeezed. As far as development and the housing market, a big driver of change for the middle class housing market I believe is going to be insurance. Wind storms and the accompanying flooding are eventually going to make living there more expensive and insurance policies less affordable. Another issue will likely be tourism as it is largely tied to its environment. As the everglades experiences rapid salt water intrusion, the reefs continue to be bleached due acidification, and mangroves migrate inland slower than sea level, the productive estuaries might become less productive for popular sport fish and commercial species. Another major industry in South Florida is the boating industry which has tons of demand generated by fishing, scuba, and general ecotourism. As those generators are put in jeopardy, there will without a doubt be a ripple throughout the economy. Lastly, county governments (which are the most substantial government players in South Florida) will begin to experience issues because their expensive properties closest to the water are the biggest contributors to the tax base. As those low lying areas are flooded more frequently, there is a very real possibility that the value of all the mansions lining the streets and canals drop. My view of South Florida is rather bleak but even if Miami Dade and Broward manage to figure out sea level rise, I doubt the Florida Keys have much of a chance. Time to figure out how to short real estate. And Lebron left
- Debugreality 12y agoIt's much easier to believe abstractly or understand the problem from afar. In Australia we have a lot of advertising to highlight the dangers of disasters to try and counter this psychological phenomena. I expect people will continue to try and work around the symptoms of global warming long before they start to work towards a real viable solution.
- xenadu02 12y agoHere in America, we always do the right thing... After exhausting all other options. The sea level rise will take decades to play out. We know exactly how it will go: Conservatives will continue to deny climate change is happening, everyone will procrastinate, then worsening flooding will force action. When the maps of the US must be redrawn to exclude the submerged land, only then will Conservatives begin to admit climate change is happening (while denying they ever denied it). This is as expected, because the current corporate masters will be dead and not required to pay any taxes to implement mitigation measures (aka the system works as designed)
- cpeterso 12y agoIf significant climate change is countered by programs endorsed by liberals, then conservatives will point to that success and say "Nothing happened because climate change wasn't real." If climate change and sea level rise do happen, even if their results are lessened, then conservatives will say "This was an act off nature; nothing could be done to prevent it. Liberals' attempts to stop it were a waste of money and just an excuse to raise taxes on rich people. All these bad things that are a result of climate change are actually the unintended results of the liberal's programs."
- nroach 12y agoThe federal flood insurance plan carries some of the blame by disincentivizing responsible construction. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Flood_Insurance_Program http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Flood_Insurance_Progra...
- dan_bk 12y agoIt reminds me of the "boiling frog" - if you turn the heat up slowly (i.e. climate change) the frog won't react.
- SixSigma 12y agoExcept even frogs aren't that stupid and get out.
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoFascinating - much quicker than I supposed. For me there are three lessons - one humans still love cities for good reasons and will keep to them if possible. Two most major cities are coastal (fucked) or river (property close to the river is fucked the rest is salvageable) and three remote working and water rises will deal a double whammy to traditional commutes and workin practises, spreading city life to some combination of suburban and city In short, I think i will buy land in Toronto and Greenland
- thespace123 12y agoFullstack javascript/html/css dev looking to get out of Miami, lol. HELP!