5 ms·
Microsoft seized the domains in order to discover command-and-control servers of a few botnets. Now... whether or not Microsoft seizing another legitimate comp
by Alupis 12y ago
Microsoft seized the domains in order to discover command-and-control servers of a few botnets.
Now... whether or not Microsoft seizing another legitimate company's property without any notice is legal/ethical is another question (one that probably should get more attention).
- joe_the_user 12y agoWhat is the justification of this post being pretty severely downvoted? It's not intemperate or off-topic as far as I can tell. Go ahead and downvote me too for metacommenting but it seems like slaps being handed out so freely just degrades community by making people reluctant to comment.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wfjackson 12y agoYour parent poster did a :s/M$/Microsoft on that comment before you read it. Edit: They then replied to your post with "I was wondering the same thing", before reading my post and deleting that comment.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jabits 12y ago"M$" is a shorthand for "Microsoft" - is not just shorthand, it's a sophomoric statement with commentary. If you don't know that, use words and phrases you understand.
- icebraining 12y agoMicrosoft seized them by court order, I don't see how was it without notice or how could they have done it illegally.
- Alupis 12y agoYes, the question was along the lines of, why is Microsoft seizing other company's property, even with a court order... sounds to me like Law Enforcement should have done the actual seizure, even if Microsoft is consulting for them. And there was no prior warning to noip.com -- they woke up one day and their domains were seized. They only found out why after the fact -- and, given the nature of free Dynamic DNS services, it's very unlikely noip.com was even aware that a botnet was using their services (the justification for the seizure). And, I can't help but feel Microsoft could have obtained the same data by politely asking noip.com -- nobody likes to harbor botnets (and we have no reason to suspect noip.com of trying to do so). Seems domain seizure was heavy-handed at best.
- xorcist 12y agoThe big question is how the court could rule in a dispute between two US companies, by seizing the defendants domains without even hearing the defendant. How is that possible in a state of justice? How anyone dares to run a company in a state where you are not allowed to defend yourself in court escapes me. I can not believe this is the normal legal process. There must have been some extraordinary circumstances that I am not aware of. I would be very interested to hear what they are. (Given that Microsoft probably hasn't got more legal rights than anyone else, could No-IP do the same to Microsoft? Surely Azure is the host of a few of them C&C servers.)
- Alupis 12y ago> I can not believe this is the normal legal process. It's not. > There must have been some extraordinary circumstances that I am not aware of. Possible, but so far, the case is mostly sealed (refer to the above statement). From what we know, Microsoft identified some botnet(s) using noip's service as part of their infrastructure. Nothing points to noip knowing about the botnet, so we must assume until we know otherwise that they had no knowledge. This leaves us with a US company waking up one day to find their property seized by another US company, supposedly with the backing of a US court. > Given that Microsoft probably hasn't got more legal rights than anyone else, could No-IP do the same to Microsoft? Probably not -- Microsoft has a history of helping Law Enforcement track down botnets -- in the past they have literally marched into data centers and seized all the servers from a company without their knowledge (they even did this overseas outside of the US once). It's unlikely if noip were to bring suit against Microsoft, that it would go anywhere. (It's as scary as it sounds when a private company is leading Law Enforcement, instead of the other way around).
- Retr0spectrum 12y agoWhy would the command-and-control servers even need a domain name? Surely the IP could just be used directly?
- Alupis 12y agoProbably, but in this case, somehow Microsoft discovered they were using the noip.com's Dynamic DNS service... perhaps the Control servers "floated" around on the net and Dynamic DNS discovery was the best option?
- Nickoladze 12y agoThe entire purpose of no-ip is so a server can keep the same domain easily while their IP changes (Dynamic DNS). I'm guessing that these servers were either rapidly changing IP addresses or being brought online/offline quickly and Microsoft wanted to locate them by hijacking no-ip so those servers told Microsoft directly when they were changing IP address. Just a guess.
- MBCook 12y agoThat would tie you to a single IP address (or range) that could easily be blocked or taken down.