14 ms·
Living in a Fool’s Paradise
- Mz 12y agoExcerpt: To fully understand what’s happening here, let’s zoom out and take in the wider picture. San Francisco is a relatively small part of a much larger nine-county metropolitan area of over seven million people. Within this area, governance is fragmented at the county and city levels and it is served by a slew of separate transportation agencies, including six separate but overlapping bus agencies and four regional rail or light rail agencies. There are three major airports, run by separate agencies, and while regional housing policy is supposed to mandate that all municipalities provide their respective shares of housing demand, based on employment patterns, this is often undermined at the local level. Public policy is often not coordinated in any meaningful way at the regional level.
- greggman 12y agoThere are at least 10 separate train companies running 40+ lines in Tokyo and yet that seems to work for them. JR, Tokyu, Seibu, Eidan, Toei, Odakyu, Keio, Tobu, ... I'm too lazy to look them all up. There are probably as many bus companies as well. On top of that in Tokyo there are 23 wards each with it's own laws, taxes, etc. What's special about California? Why does it work in Tokyo with 25 million people (or maybe it doesn't?) and why doesn't it work in the bay area with only 9 million?
- Plasmoid 12y agoI would argue California has a huge Somebody Else's Problem field. Much of California public services are provided by local taxes. I'm not sure about Japan, but if it's anything like Canada then much of it provided at the state or federal level. Add in things like Prop 13, "Pay for government?! That's Somebody Else's Problem", and you end up with huge incentives to externalize your costs. Schools are cheap if all your workers live somewhere else. Low-income assistance is easy if the cheapest place to live is $2000/month for a room-share. Most of the local legislators are home owners and decreasing costs by increasing supply will directly hurt them and their paper gains.
- tsax 12y agoYou must be a neoliberal, Koch-funded corporate stooge, amirite? Everyone knows private companies can't run essential services.
- WildUtah 12y agoThe counties and wards of Tokyo don't have the power to impose discretionary zoning on landowners. In fact, they don't have the power to impose any of the kinds of abusive and harmful zoning and parking requirements that are universal in the Bay Area. [0] Japanese zoning and urban development policy are set by the central national government. That policy is considered the gold standard for simplicity and promoting quality development by planners everywhere in the developed world. If the quality and honesty of government urban planning that Japan has could be transplanted, life in the Bay Area would improve immensely. No amount of land scarcity or Google shuttles or rising demand or offshore Chinese corrupt officials parking money or anything else would be able to make things unaffordable if local governments were good, honest, and effective. But quality government is simply not possible with the current politics of California. [0] http://urbankchoze.blogspot.com/2014/04/japanese-zoning.html http://urbankchoze.blogspot.com/2014/04/japanese-zoning.html
- jpatokal 12y ago> That policy is considered the gold standard for simplicity and promoting quality development by planners everywhere in the developed world. Nnnno, they're not. In fact, Japanese zoning -- which, incidentally, is set at the federal, prefectural and local level -- is widely regarded as batshit insane. For example, there's a giant garbage incinerator right in on the northern side of central Tokyo (Ikebukuro); taxation makes "used" houses nearly worthless and thus encourages building new cheap crap; draconian building restrictions make Japanese apartments tiny; the well-intentioned "sunshine laws" have all sorts of perverse side effects like making it well-nigh impossible to build tall, high-quality residential buildings in the city center but encourage tall but cheap, crappy ones in the middle of nowhere, etc etc. This Nomura Research report is an excellent read: http://www.nri.com/global/opinion/papers/2008/pdf/np2008137.pdf http://www.nri.com/global/opinion/papers/2008/pdf/np2008137....
- xorcist 12y agoTokyo is not comparable to anything else, really. It works because everybody values that things work out for society. In that environment dissent such as NIMBY is indeed troublesome but never blocking. If one local wards would take decisions to enrich itself to the cost of others the system would break down. It wouldn't last a day in California. That said, there are some problems there too, such as the aforementioned quintillion public transport lines. (Source: a few friends who moved there)
- sytelus 12y agoWho says it works for Tokyo? It's one of the most miserable cities in the world as far as housing is concerned. It's so bad there that they have to start opening new types of hotels for couples to have sex because most couples are forced to live in shared tiny apartments. They have even pushers to pack as many people in trains as possible.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoSeven million people in a nine-county metropolitan area isn't very metropolitan at all. The Bay Area's fundamental problem is that it wants to combine the business growth and jobs of a major urban center with the countryside luxury of exurbia -- and you can't.
- dennisgorelik 12y agoDallas/Fort Worth metro is doing exactly that: combining the business growth and jobs of a major urban center with the countryside luxury of exurbia.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mturmon 12y agoBoom is a small, high quality journal put out by UC Press. The whole issue of Boom this quarter is devoted to the San Francisco tech influx, and it is excellent (http://www.boomcalifornia.com/2014/06/summer-2014/ http://www.boomcalifornia.com/2014/06/summer-2014/) They have articles from both pro-growth and anti-growth people, including Rebecca Solnit, whose piece on Google buses in the February LRB really touched a nerve.
- mturmon 12y agoI submitted the Rebecca Solnit interview in the same issue a few days ago here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7957573 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7957573 Solnit is of course anti-development, whereas the editorial stance of the issue is generally pro-development.
- michaelochurch 12y agoThe "Manhattanization" argument always struck me as odd. How is a mess of ugly, uncomfortable five-story buildings (at ridiculous prices) superior to an 80-story tower of modern housing? Sure, the tower is more prominent, but it frees up space for parks and makes housing cheaper. These people should either have the courage to say, "We're trying to keep housing costs artificially high and rob people" or get out of the fucking discussion. Manhattan is expensive, but relative to the local job market, it's cheap. It has its problems, but it's relatively smartly designed. San Francisco is expensive, relative to the job market. Even in California, it's almost impossible to crack $175,000 doing real work, and every corrupt official in Asia has bought housing in SF and the Valley, driving prices into the millions. California seems to insist that it is building the future, and yet it lives so much in the past.
- maxerickson 12y agoIt would be interesting if you would post roughly how many corrupt officials you believe there are in Asia and approximately how many housing units they each purchase.
- eru 12y agoLooks like a figure of speech to me.
- maxerickson 12y agoIt was less ambiguous last time they posted it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7926038 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7926038 Edit: And another time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7964831 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7964831
- dictum 12y agoI believe he's referring to this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7963678 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7963678
- michaelochurch 12y ago
- gojomo 12y agoCan we outsource our regional land-use governance to the Chinese Communist Party? We need much more housing and transit, fast, and they're the pros. Gains from trade!
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoAh, no. Unless you like shoddy toufu housing.
- zghst 12y agoYeah no thanks. I wouldn't want them building over historical artifacts or putting up apartments that will fall apart in 10 years.
- eru 12y agoYou should outsource to the People's Action Party.
- Uehreka 12y agoFinally, finally, finally. An article on Hacker News about the whole San Francisco housing thing that doesn't assume that you're familiar with the issue and have picked a side. After all the rhetoric I've read about, say... "the defeat of the proposition to prevent the blockage of construction on the waterfront proposed by the cool NIMBY elitist outcasts who are driving up housing prices to keep out the cool rich tech outsiders who are ruining this city" ...it's nice to have some history and context about what's actually going on. Thank you.
- damncabbage 12y agoThis is also an excellent (and very long) piece that does the same: http://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/ http://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/
- rtpg 12y agoSo Google can't build property in Mountain View, what about building another campus outside of the Bay Area? Maybe an hour south of Mountain View or something, where they could still recruit in the area. I imagine Google's thought about this more than I have though. >that workers in the technology industry do not belong here and are not the type of people who are supposed to be in San Francisco. It is a strangely unprogressive attitude for this open-hearted city. It's always ironic to see how people in 'rejected' subcultures tend to reject outsiders as well ( this happens way too much in tech as well).
- Plasmoid 12y ago>So Google can't build property in Mountain View, what about building another campus outside of the Bay Area? Maybe an hour south of Mountain View or something, where they could still recruit in the area. Google is doing that to an extent. They have a lot of campuses world wide, mostly due to their acquisitions. It also decreases the amount of sway an individual municipality has over their growth and operation, which isn't a bad reaction given how much MV is mucking around with them.
- hindsightbias 12y agoMaybe after the first dot-com boom and all those evictions before the bust, their standards got a little lower.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- digisign 12y agoCome to Los Angeles. It's not perfect, but the weather's better, economy broader, there's more space, its downtown is improving every year, and building up (in several places) is encouraged. Even the long neglected Metro is seeing investment.
- lolwutf 12y agoThis. I'm fleeing SF this year for LA. The socioeconomic struggle has finally become, to me, unbearable + the rents too damn high.
- eclipxe 12y agoI recently migrated from the Bay Area to SoCal (Orange County) - I'm seeing this sentiment more and more in my peer group. (BTW - I'm hiring engineers down here in SoCal if anyone is interested in the migration - contact in profile)
- muzz 12y agoBusinesses however are doing the exact opposite-- they are expanding and hiring within the Bay Area.
- rdtsc 12y agoFor the longest time I didn't even know LA had a Metro. I guess I just went there to visit friends/family and we ended so much time stuck in traffic it really got to me after a while. (Usually visit a week at a time). One day the friends had to work and suggested we take the Metro around town. Except that Metro didn't seem to go where we wanted to go. We opted for a bus. It worked out ... ok, the bus ended up stuck in traffic just as well as the other cars. With that level of traffic, unless there is Metro and it is effective or some other public transportation system, I would go crazy. (Note: I haven't visited SF so not comparing it with, maybe it is just as bad there).
- digisign 12y agoI don't do traffic either. Been lucky I guess, but I have two strategies that have worked out. One, live in walking distance to work. Two, work remotely from a walkable neighborhood.
- skybrian 12y agoI was surprised that he said that the Marriott Hotel was ugly, as if this were a widely-held opinion. I haven't heard anyone else say that, and personally I rather like it.
- ak217 12y agoI agree, Marriott is one of the more beautiful high-rises in the city. Maybe he meant Marriott Union Square. Or Hyatt.
- ryandrake 12y agoI want to know who's living in these places. I work in a fairly senior role in a well known South Bay tech company (you've heard of it). I live in Livermore. (For those of you not familiar with the Bay Area, Livermore is so far away from everything, it might as well be Nevada.) Why do I live in Livermore? Because I can't afford anything within a 20 mile radius of Stanford. All over the Peninsula (and the areas in Santa Clara county you'd want to live) are dotted with $1.5M single family houses and $4,000/mo apartments. Summoning the voice of Jerry Seinfeld, "Who are these people? Really, who are they?" They can't all be stock option multi-millionaires can they? I'm doing pretty well for myself, but I can't afford to live anywhere in basically two counties. What do these people do who can afford to live down there? The Bay Area is going to eat itself soon. There's just no way this housing situation is sustainable? What is the end game? Is this going to turn into Elysium? How will normal people survive here without affordable housing?
- null_ptr 12y agoWho are these people? Probably in their 20s, high paying job out of school, don't give a hoot about saving money and just live it up while the going's good. I can't imagine anyone else going for $4000/mo apartments. Or, multiple people sharing a place.
- d23 12y agoI'm extremely confused as to how people aren't able to find anything for less than $4k/mo. It didn't seem all that unusual to find places for mid 1000s if you're sharing a place and not living downtown, and this is when I was looking less than a month ago. I ended up going with a 2.7k place downtown to myself, junior 1 bed. It's more than I wanted to pay initially, but 4k minimum seems like a bald-faced lie.
- sytelus 12y agoArticle doesn't say 4K is minimum. It says 350 sq ft is going for $2000 and 1 bed room apartments near Twitter headquater is going for $4000. If you are sharing for mid-1000s then total cost of apartment comes to ~3500 which is quite inline with what article says. BTW, where I live, you can get 3 bed room apartment with a garage and view of mountains for $1700 and commute of < 0.5 hr to major tech companies. And I thought THAT was too high.
- declan 12y agoThis BoomCalifornia.com article is well-written but misses a pretty big point: these are in large part choices that SF bay area governments have made to limit new development. The article does discuss SF, true, but SF has only perhaps 10% of the area's population, and a negligible part of the area. Housing prices on the SF peninsula once were in line with the rest of the country. Then came anti-development fervor, pushed in large part by existing homeowners who benefited from a rise in demand coupled by fixed supply. That's one reason why, even though I have enough land to build a small guest cottage that I could then rent out on the SF peninsula, my local government makes it cost-prohibitive or impossible to do (can't cut down trees, can't disturb natural habitat, can't build within 40' of a stream, etc.). That's also why Facebook's massive new campus logically should be surrounded by high-density housing instead of ranch homes on quarter-acre lots, and isn't, and why no housing can be built within walking distance of the Googleplex in MV. Thomas Sowell, an economist at Stanford's Hoover Institution, wrote about this back in April: http://www.dallasnews.com/opinion/latest-columns/20140423-open-spaces-and-housing--the-high-cost-of-liberalism.ece http://www.dallasnews.com/opinion/latest-columns/20140423-op... "There are people who claim that astronomical housing prices in places like Palo Alto and San Francisco are due to a scarcity of land. But there is enough vacant land (open space) on the other side of the Interstate 280 freeway that goes past Palo Alto to build another Palo Alto or two — except for laws and policies that make it impossible. As in San Francisco and other parts of the country where housing prices skyrocketed after building homes was prohibited or severely restricted, this began in Palo Alto in the 1970s. Housing prices in Palo Alto nearly quadrupled during that decade. This was not from expensive houses being built, because not a single new house was built in Palo Alto in the 1970s. The same old houses simply shot up in price. That is part of the unacknowledged cost of open space and just part of the high cost of liberalism."
- mtviewdave 12y ago>That is part of the unacknowledged cost of open space and just part of the high cost of liberalism. The devotion to open-space around Stanford/Palo Alto actually comes out of the backlash to all the highway construction in the 50s and 60s. I find it odd to see opposition to big government programs described as "liberalism".
- Fuxy 12y agoStupid question but why don't big companies like Google and Apple just move the bulk of their office outside of San Francisco where there are no regulations and they could just build everything they need there. If SF is being so hostile towards basically the driving engine of their local economy the best option is to relocate to a place where there are fewer restriction. A build your own small city kind of situation. They can certainly afford it. It's win-win Google gets their employes close to the office the employees get cheaper housing and if it's a large enough community you will be getting new people coming in opening shops and other stuff to take advantage of the demand. The only one slightly worse off is SF with all the money leaving the place but it's not like they appreciate what they have now anyway.
- fernly 12y agoAs noted in the article, Google is in Mountain View, Apple in Santa Clara, both suburban towns well outside SF. Both towns have strict development laws, also described in the article, that throttle development. Apple has proposed building a new HQ and Santa Clara may actually approve it, but that does nothing to increase housing. There is no land with 100 miles of Silicon Valley where you could "build a town". Supposing they went the necessary distance (500 miles, or even more, into Nevada perhaps) how practical would it be to get 1000s of employees to relocate to live in a "company town" in the middle of nowhere?
- Fuxy 12y agoSeems pretty practical to me instead of fighting with the locals to do basic things spending god knows how much money trying to approve things. Plus once you do it you have all the room you need to expand build towers, create housing etc. It doesn't even need to be something very complex at first just something quick and dirty to see if it's a valid solution. I find it amazing that there's no large areas of land for sale withing a 100 miles of Silicon Valley. As for as employee relocation is concerned don't they already have to relocate to SF and the surrounding suburbs to work there?
- optimusclimb 12y ago
- visarga 12y ago> This is the tone of a now-dominant narrative among the city’s progressives—that workers in the technology industry do not belong here and are not the type of people who are supposed to be in San Francisco. I find this kind of phobia as repulsive as xenofobia or discrimination against blacks. Why are they so holy they can't accept the Google employees as regular folks?
- Shivetya 12y agoThere is nothing in common with the plights of blacks in the city to tech workers, unless you count of course that many well off people moving in drove minorities and the poor into further substandard housing because the cost of living skyrocketed. Mom and Pop businesses folding so trendy restaurants and boutiques can take their spot. For an industry that boasts connectivity it sure seems location bound at times. Frankly, the fact they have to have / desire to have charted bus services just for themselves should be a hint - your living in the wrong place, be closer to work. However, many in the industry who like think they are open minded and above it all it must be fun to find out that your not wanted by people that are normally associated with open mindedness.
- nerfhammer 12y ago> Frankly, the fact they have to have / desire to have charted bus services just for themselves should be a hint - your living in the wrong place, be closer to work. To be a real NIMBY is to be able to say with a straight face that those darn people ought to be fighting other NIMBYs somewhere else.
- wutbrodo 12y ago> However, many in the industry who like think they are open minded and above it all it must be fun to find out that your not wanted by people that are normally associated with open mindedness. You seem to think this says something about people in the industry; To me it seems the only sane reaction is to conclude that the association of the second group of people with open-mindedness is an illusion.
- ojbyrne 12y ago"When I moved to San Francisco in 2003, I found a place to live in one weekend." But from what I recall after moving to San Francisco in 2005, you would not have been able to. And from what I've been told, if you moved to San Francisco in 2000, you also would have had a difficult time. boomcalifornia seems to be an appropriate name.
- toufka 12y agoMoved to SF in 2008 - stayed with a friend in Berkeley over a long weekend and found a place to rent on craigslist by the time I left. Was 'expensive' compared to my midwestern rents - but still within reason. Literally impossible now.
- dba7dba 12y agoWhen people claim it's too expensive to live and do business in California, I think some miss the influence of the geography. Yes the tax in CA is higher than other states but not THAT high. CA state tax is not 100% or 200% higher than most states. But housing is. The point of moving to CA for most people is to live on or near the coast, I think... Thus most centers of commerce in CA is relatively close to the beach, like SF or LA or San Diego. What this does is it almost immediately cuts the the available land for housing by HALF. In midwest of US (including Texas), you put a dot and draw 30 mile circle around it. All of that land is available for housing. In coastal regions like coastal California, put a dot near coast and draw a 30 mile circle around it. You get HALF of a circle available for housing. No wonder house price in coastal CA is easily double of equivalent in Texas and other cities. Tax in CA is not that bad. But the geography is bad for making affordable housing available, and that's not the fault of the politicians or Democrats or etc.