13 ms·
Why has Google cast me into oblivion?
- HNJohnC 12y agoSomeone needs to make a search engine that only returns results for things that people have tried to hide under this law.
- B-Con 12y agoOr just make it hard to find all the instances. For example, this article itself references the content in the article that was removed from search results. The effectiveness of having the original link removed is probably very minimal unless this page is also removed. Ultimately, it's a race. The "hider" has to find all the things they want hidden and explicitly list them. As long as the content spreads faster than it is banned, the banning is negated.
- tokenizerrr 12y agoIt's just weird that the search engine is tasked with the removal. If other sites can legally link to the "forgotten" content - which appears to still be online - then why can't a search engine link to it? If they want this ruling to make sense at all, the removal requests should go directly to the entity hosting the content in my opinion.
- outside1234 12y agodon't confuse logic with politics! :)
- WiseWeasel 12y agoSince the impact of such an implementation would be greater, it would be harder to pass a law requiring it. This is a more gentle way to censor public debate, while allowing more specialized "research" search engines to continue providing the information to those who could not accept to have it denied. Not to mention how much easier it is to send all requests to a handful of major search providers rather than having to determine who hosts what and hoping they know how to properly deal with such a request.
- personZ 12y agoTo be fair to Google, it opposed the European court ruling. But its implementation of it looks odd, perhaps clumsy. I find it incredible that Google is held at fault in this case because they don't choose whether it is "inadequate, irrelevant or no longer relevant" in a way that fits the author's view. Such an analysis is so absurdly subjective, and it is impossible for Google to satisfy both sides. The European Court ruling is pure absurdity, and this article could more accurately be titled "European Court Rules That Past Must Be Wiped. Much Comedy As Result." There is no possible way that Google can implement it that won't endlessly earn them criticism, such as this piece.
- cwyers 12y agoUnless Google wants to treat the EU like they did China and redirect all searches to a jurisdiction with actual press freedoms, they're doing all they can here.
- bitJericho 12y agoPerhaps they should.
- lclarkmichalek 12y agoAh, contempt of court. Always a solid tactic
- cwyers 12y agoI don't really see how it would be contempt of court for Google to shut down its European servers and redirect all its European domains to go to Google.com. It would be a lot of other things, but I don't think it would be contempt of court.
- brador 12y agoIn Europe they're more serious about the concept of "spirit of the law". Particularly when circumvention is used as a route around a ruling.
- natosaichek 12y agoI like that they told the author that his article would no longer be viewable. If that's the case, and the 'removal' is not secret, then they could (should?) totally make available a separate database of articles that people have asked to be removed. Basically, the original article may be old (or theoretically irrelevant) but the fact that someone asked for it to be removed is very new and not at all irrelevant. It would be awesome to see this as the Streisand effect writ large - everything that people want to see buried actually gets a new surge of attention.
- Mithaldu 12y agoThis is actually a very good outcome. It will end up with those things where people do not mind something being forgotten actually being forgotten, while the decision to revive the content is still a perfectly viable option.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoPresumably he can then reissue the article. That for Google is a different instance and recent content making it outside the auspices of the EU law?
- bitJericho 12y agoIn fact just publish the original request alongside the notice that the search results are censored.
- magicalist 12y agoThe Guardian reported[1] that they were at least considering a notice at the bottom of a search result page that had a result removed, like they do with DMCA requests. If that's the case, hopefully they can do what they do with DMCA notices, and link to a copy of the actual takedown request (which would include a link or links to what was taken down). ChillingEffects.org could start a new section for right to be forgotten requests. On the other hand, reprinting DMCA takedown notices is protected by the First Amendment in the US, but reprinting right to be forgotten requests may be frowned upon by EU courts. Edit: according the newer Guardian piece that thegregjones posted above, there is a warning[2], but just a "Learn more" link, no link to the actual removal request. [1] http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/jun/08/google-search-results-indicate-right-to-be-forgotten-censorship http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/jun/08/google-sea... [2] https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BrYpLOwIgAE8pF0.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BrYpLOwIgAE8pF0.jpg
- gadders 12y agoThe EU really is a joke. I think if people want to hide stuff like revenge porn, or obvious slander, then fair enough. But unindexing legitimate journalism is stupid.
- privong 12y ago> I think if people want to hide stuff like revenge porn, or obvious slander, then fair enough. But unindexing legitimate journalism is stupid. The difficulty with following that logic is in the blurry middle area. Where is the line drawn and who makes that decision?
- troels 12y agoFor starters, they could require a court order for each case. That would certainly limit the amount of requests.
- jim-greer 12y agoThat sequencing is probably not in compliance with the law. The fact sheet put out by the European high court makes it explicit: http://ec.europa.eu/justice/data-protection/files/factsheets/factsheet_data_protection_en.pdf http://ec.europa.eu/justice/data-protection/files/factsheets... "In practice, a search engine will have to delete information when it receives a specific request from a person affected... Google will then have to assess the deletion request on a case-by-case basis and to apply the criteria mentioned in EU law and the European Court’s judgment.... The request may for example be turned down where the search engine operator concludes that for particular reasons, such as for example the public role played by John Smith, the interest of the general public to have access to the information in question justifies showing the links in Google search results. In such cases, John Smith still has the option to complain to national data protection supervisory authorities or to national courts. Public authorities will be the ultimate arbiters of the application of the Right to be Forgotten. "
- Dylan16807 12y ago
- lotharbot 12y agoThis is a great example of the Streisand effect [0] -- trying to hide something draws attention to it. Specifically, I now know about Stan O'Neal, who "was forced out of Merrill [Lynch] after the investment bank suffered colossal losses on reckless investments it had made." Google may no longer be showing the original result, but now I see the reason for the original article and the fact that he wanted it hidden. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect
- keithpeter 12y agoA Google UK search on Stan O'Neal from within the UK yields the wikipedia page, then at #2 a Salon article explaining how Google has given notice to Mr Peston that the original BBC article may be de-indexed. The next half dozen links are pretty critical of Mr O'Neal as well. Oddly, this new BBC page is not apparent in the index (yet).
- keithpeter 12y agoAs of 1921 BST on 2014 July 3rd, the BBC article in question is now second link when searching for Stan O'Neal. So you can ask for a page to be de-linked but if you are in the public eye and the de-linking gets noticed, the results may not be what you expected.
- gnerd 12y agoSpot on. All this will do for the person trying to erase their past is drag up old memories and re-syndicate whatever they are running away from. More eyeballs, more indexing of new pages, more edits to the Wikipedia page, more comments on social media. Sometimes the best thing to do is nothing at all.
- thegregjones 12y agoJames Ball at the Guardian has written about some of their articles that have been disappeared: http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/jul/02/eu-right-to-be-forgotten-guardian-google http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/jul/02/eu-righ...
- magicalist 12y agoThis is really good and should be the top article, not the rather silly BBC piece. Speaking of the Streisand effect, if you search for "Dougie McDonald Guardian" on google.co.uk as it suggests, the offending links are gone, but now all the top links are to stories about the offending links.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI wonder if Google is making a statement here about the ruling. They've been really vocal about how they are taking away "useful" (certainly in the sense of background checks) information that is in places people don't expect to be censored (like newspapers). This will lead people to point out that they can go to the city library and look at the back issue of the newspaper and it won't be censored there. And that will lead to the question of what is, and what is not, the public record and what sort of damage to that record is tolerated in the interest of justice.
- outside1234 12y agoHere's how this is going to do down: Google is going to slowly be asked to forget all of Europe, including the holocaust (since this is a stain on the families involved). This will cause a backlash against "erasing European history" And then they will repeal this. All through this, Google will be the villain, not the ding-dongs running the EU.
- valas 12y agoFWIW, in some EU countries holocaust denial is a crime.
- thisjepisje 12y agoBut not speaking about the holocaust isn't.
- jstalin 12y agoDown the memory hole goes everything in the EU. I'm thankful every day for the First Amendment in the US.
- CodeMage 12y agoI'm sorry if I'm being naive, but can someone explain to me why everyone blames EU for this? I mean, the motivation behind the ruling seems to be a very good one. So what am I missing?
- jonknee 12y agoWho else is to blame? Google was very much against it and there aren't other parties at stake. The motivation has no bearing whatsoever, people doing bad things don't usually think of themselves as bad people.
- rguldener 12y agoIt is very hard to define exactly what "inadequate, irrelevant or no longer relevant" means and if Google refuses to delete an entry upon request the person asking for the deletion can sue them if they disagree with Google (which they probably would since they asked for the deletion in the first place). This could potentially result in thousands of expensive cases for Google which means they will probably just follow through with most of the deletion requests. This in turn means that many fear cases like this, where somebody could be trying to clean up their past, getting rid of entries that display them in a negative light, if justified or not. At its core the idea of the law is probably desirable but the current wording and its subsequent implementation mean that is a powerful weapon for everybody trying to clean their past from the web.
- gress 12y agoGoogle has a definition of what is relevant. It's not hard to come up with one. What is hard is to get people to agree. Right now Google controls the definition, but given it's monopoly status in Europe, it is not surprising that The EU is starting to work on this.
- renata 12y agoPeople tend to respond negatively to bad outcomes regardless of good intentions, and I'm not so sure the intentions are good in the first place. Additionally, the law showcases an utter misunderstanding of how the internet works and unfairly singles out a single company that many people are generally in favor of.
- j2kun 12y ago> Google must delete "inadequate, irrelevant or no longer relevant" data from its results when a member of the public requests it. Could Google legally get around this ruling by claiming that recent deletion requests inherently make the data in question relevant? Since the right to be forgotten is important news, the stories about people requesting the deletion of their data (and what kinds of data are being deleted) is very relevant. It's the equivalent of the "every number is interesting" paradox. Edit: proper quote from the ruling is actually "inaccurate, inadequate, irrelevant or excessive"
- martco 12y agoWait, so Google hasn't actually done anything to the article? "Although the BBC has had the notice from Google that my article will not show up in some searches, it doesn't appear to have implemented this yet."
- auxbuss 12y agoThere's a possible darker side to this, of course. Today, the following story -- regarding an ex-member of the British Cabinet and a paedophile network -- started gaining a lot of traction in the UK, mainly because there are an increasing number of Members of Parliament (MPs) demanding an inquiry[0]: http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2014/jul/02/lord-brittan-1980s-dossier-sex-abuse-claims http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2014/jul/02/lord-brittan... The story itself has been around for decades. Coincidentally, Google have begun removing articles relating to the story[1] -- for example, the search "Leon Brittan PIE" will return -- at the bottom of the page: "In response to a legal request submitted to Google, we have removed 1 result(s) from this page. If you wish, you may read more about the request at ChillingEffects.org." Currently, for this notice, chillingeffects.org returns[2]: "Notice Unavailable: The cease-and-desist or legal threat you requested is not yet available. Chilling Effects will post the notice after we process it." Coincidence or not, it's a troubling how easily this mechanism can be abused. [0] http://www.exaronews.com/articles/5282/pressure-builds-in-parliament-to-address-child-sex-abuse-in-uk http://www.exaronews.com/articles/5282/pressure-builds-in-pa... [1] http://tompride.wordpress.com/2014/07/02/google-searches-for-leon-brittan-and-pie-censored-after-cease-and-desist-notice/ http://tompride.wordpress.com/2014/07/02/google-searches-for... [2] http://www.chillingeffects.org/notice.cgi?sID=1719125 http://www.chillingeffects.org/notice.cgi?sID=1719125
- Justsignedup 12y agoNobody has attacked the elephant in the room. If an article was written about me committing murder, and I want that "forgotten", then I will request google to take the info down in the EU. Great. A background checking company goes to "www.google.com" and finds that article. They don't give a shit that they are in France and should abide by the french blocks, or they'll use a proxy. That's the point, this is completely stupid and prevents a common untrained person from accessing the information, but does nothing for background checks and the like.
- brownbat 12y agoShould Google try to interpret the ruling as closely as possible, only blocking the most clearly irrelevant information, and honoring requests for appeals from journalists whenever possible? That would limit damage to those seeking information, but risk another turn at the courts. Or should they just implement it as broadly and bluntly as possible, lowering their risk of noncompliance, reducing their costs of evaluating each case, while increasing the chance that people will start to grasp the negative consequences they argued about to the court? Despite the near term harms, if we're worried more about the long run, there's a case to be made for the latter...
- vbuterin 12y agoThere should be a name for deliberately making a big fuss of following every regulation as expansively as possible to prove a point; inverse civil disobedience, civil obedience maybe?
- shakethemonkey 12y agoThere is, it's called "work-to-rule."
- arg01 12y agoSomewhat ironically some countries have laws that make work-to-rule (usually phrased in law as malicious compliance) as illegal.
- malka 12y agofor individuals, that's being passive-agressive.
- mblakele 12y agoThere used to be, but it isn't PC: "white mutiny". See also http://english.stackexchange.com/questions/79793/phrase-for-observing-a-rule-in-a-malicious-way http://english.stackexchange.com/questions/79793/phrase-for-...
- RexRollman 12y agoWhat I want to know is, if you are searching from outside the EU, is the info also censored? Or does it affect everyone?
- exbbc 12y agoIndeed it is clumsy because the media is exempt of this ruling. Which makes me suspect this was an easy way of drawing some media attention, and spreading misinformation.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- magicalist 12y agoThe media is exempt from having to censor their own stories, but search engines are not exempt from removing links to media stories. The whole ruling was about forcing google to remove links to news stories about Costeja González.
- exbbc 12y agoNo it wasn't about news stories from legitimate news organisations. This is all misinterpreted by people not knowing the facts nor the law, but lets ignore that and jump on the outrage bandwagon.
- drakaal 12y agoI do this "for a living". Reputation Management is when you pay someone like me to make that result fall to the 5th page of Google so people searching for you only see the happy fun stuff you have done. What is missing from the implementation from Google, that Google really needs to be "fair" is an OPT OUT. You see when I go in and fix a reputation by outranking bad stuff with good, the bad stuff is still there if you know what you are looking for. BBC JOHN DOE KILLS BABYSITTER is not going away, just not showing up when you Google JOHN DOE BABYSITTER because I will have place the top 40 results with things about How awesome SUSAN THE 16 YEAR OLD is who is now JOHN DOE's babysitter. If Google did an OPT OUT, you would be able to say, "I am John Doe of Hicksville, IN" here is my picture, remove me from the interwebs. And nothing about you would be there. No good, No Bad. Is this just me having sour grapes that my business of shaping reality is going away? No. If anything this is good for business. People will want what the EU has and flock to me. For those who think I am a bad person. Yeah, I know that http://www.blackwaterops.com http://www.blackwaterops.com didn't pick its name because we thought we were the good guys. But at the same time a lot of what we do is good. We work with organizations that share the name with bad people. You know how hard it is when you share the name with a serial killer to get a job even after that serial killer was executed? You know how hard it is to recover from stuff 20+ years after the the Jack in the Box ecoli outbreak? Or being named Play Boy's Hottest X and then trying to get a job working with kids? Even if you didn't ask to be associated with Play Boy?
- walshemj 12y agoAll google has to do is buy an European news paper and become a traditional publisher - they could buy the independent cheaply.
- webhat 12y agoI'm seeing a catch-22: by writing and posting this article this article made the other article relevant. And Stan O'Neal, if he requested it deleted, is relevant again - albeit in a context of filing a removal notice.
- fmax30 12y agoRelevant : http://www.google.co.uk/policies/faq/ http://www.google.co.uk/policies/faq/
- fpgeek 12y agoClearly this person should sue Google on the grounds that all of the time, effort and energy they put into their blog entry means that it has a "right to be remembered". Or, at the very least, they have a right to a specific explanation about why it is being blocked, so they can challenge it properly (ultimately in court, if necessary).
- blisterpeanuts 12y agoI don't understand; did they single out Google, or does the ruling also apply to Bing, Yahoo, DuckDuckGo, Apple, Facebook, and many other companies that cache results? Search engines may cache information, but the content usually originates on some other hosting site. Those hundreds of thousands of hosting sites may still have the content, so what the Court is saying is all the more silly--you must disallow search results if anyone in the world opts out. I say, Google should just go about its business and if EC doesn't like it, Google should pull out of Europe and just allow anyone to access it from overseas servers. It will be just like China, which blocks Google. Information wants to be free. This is a huge step backward.
- grrowl 12y agoIf they adopt an attitude like that, they'll run out of countries to remove themselves from in not long.
- rsiqueira 12y agoI also received (yesterday) this same message from Google: Subject: [Webmaster Tools] Notice of removal from Google Search "We regret to inform you that we are no longer able to show the following pages from your website in response to certain searches on European versions of Google: [one url with a post in my site] For more information, see www.google .com/policies/faq/?hl=en The post in my site that was blocked by Google had only some catalog information about a car dealer in Netherlands and I could not understand why it was removed by Google search.
- fortuitous 12y agochomps on popcorn This can only get better.