6 ms·
Material world: how Google discovered what software is made of
- mandingo 12y agorepost
- msane 12y agoI find a lot of the behaviors of these UIs to be surprising in an undesirable way. When a UI does something unexpected I should be surprised by how much sense the interaction has, rather than the novelty of it or a cool animation. I should be able to anticipate the behavior in a future context. They are touting this supposed underlying physical metaphor (almost as if that is their own newly developed idea in UI), but it sure looks like a mask over the fact that they just threw in a bunch of shiny animations everywhere with much less regard for physical metaphor and reproducibility than one should expect.
- aviraldg 12y agoCould you be more specific? Which Material interaction do you think you could improve upon?
- specialist 12y agoInteraction is like dance: You just know when it's right. Even though there are visual languages for movement, the best way to explain is by example.
- magicalist 12y agoso asking for an example that's awkward would be right on point, then.
- specialist 12y agoI should be surprised by how much sense the interaction has Agreed. Principle of least astonishment.
- wingerlang 12y ago> You couldn’t do anything you wanted with them, just like you can’t just do anything with physical objects. I find this pretty funny considering all the objects in the video(s) seem to transform/split/create/shapeshift into new object all the time.
- officialjunk 12y agoThis seems to be more of an approach to UI design rather than software design as a whole. Maybe they've "answered" what UI is, but for me this doesn't answer what software is made of.
- akkawwakka 12y ago>A material metaphor is the unifying theory of a rationalized space and a system of motion. The material is grounded in tactile reality, inspired by the study of paper and ink, yet technologically advanced and open to imagination and magic. What does any of that even mean?
- platinum1 12y agoTheir metaphor for materials is the combination of two ideas: A streamlining/optimization of screen area, and a set of rules that define how things move. The material metaphor is based on things we can touch in real life. However, this metaphor is not going to be strictly adhered to in order to take advantage of the technology it's implemented on and provide a good user experience.
- manicdee 12y agoA cynical translation: "We finally realised that Apple was onto a good thing with their minimalism, layered UI and UI as a metaphor for physically interacting with your data. So we're putting a lot of fancy words together to make it sound like we're doing something amazing and new, while all we're actually achieving is explicitly stating what Apple has assumed to be common sense for decades. After all if we want all these Android developers to conform to a common human interface guideline ruleset rather than inventing their own UI for every new application, we have to make that ruleset sound sexy and awesome!" I love how the guy presenting on stage starts talking about a new material that will provide tactile feedback, as if Google is already launching phones with shape-shifting screens. Some Android fans are going to be mighty disappointed when we don't have tactile morphing screens in the stores for Christmas.
- DCKing 12y ago"Finally"? Apple announced iOS 7 barely a year ago, and they were far from 'minimal' before. Google has been using this design since Google Now was launched a year before that.
- juliendorra 12y ago
- metaphorical 12y agoI love the visual direction, and I think it will work very well for a diverse set of Google products. The style guide is beautifully done and well articulated. In terms of interaction design, however, it doesn't break any new ground, apart from better transitions (but at times, too much). > So the team set about creating this metaphorical material, which is a little bit like magical paper. A bit of nitpicking: "a bit like magical paper" can hardly be called a Metaphor. It's just a loose analogy. In fact, I have to force my imagination to see the paper-ness in the UI, otherwise it just feels like flat UIs with realistic shadows.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoThere is no interaction design in the document, it is purely a visual design language. In general: look and feel, typography, layout, animation -> visual design; story boarded user interaction flows -> interaction design (at least in America, in Europe the terms are used quite differently). I don't think the design language breaks any new ground so much as it sets a strong set of guidelines for what an application should look and feel like. All UIs are metaphorical, necessarily.
- foxhill 12y agospecifically, the idea that UI elements should behave as if they were tangible objects isn't a new idea. this is what apple have been doing for.. quite a while, and honestly I didn't think this was breakthrough stuff - elastic bounce on scroll views, smooth, clean, and consistent UI transitions, and previously skeuomorphic design principle.. the idea that that interactions with a interface should mirror our interactions with things in real life doesn't seem like a shocking revelation. what's worse is that they have had this epiphany, and then.. seemingly ignored it.
- andybak 12y agoI think the term 'skeuomorphic' has become a little muddled but for the sake of argument let's distinguish between 'functional' and 'decorative' skeuomorphism. It was an excess zeal for the latter kind that Apple quite rightly got criticized for. The green baize in Games Center and the leather-bound notebooks in wherever. UX/UI people have been talking about 'affordance' for years and if a button looks raised due to subtle shading then that aids in recognising that it's clickable. Techniques such as this have been around since the birth of the GUI.
- pirateking 12y agoSoftware is made of a set of symbols unique to its particular function, and user interaction at its most primitive is no more than the relationship of those symbols to the ones present in the mind of the user. The latest fads in user interaction design seem to ignore this perspective, and instead treat "UI" as another abstraction layer of unique symbols on top of software, then expecting all software to be designed top-down based off this "unified design language". This approach unfortunately ignores the user, providing further indirection away from the underlying software and it's function, herding the user into a church of the designer's own construction where they are now forced to worship interaction in the abstract as a prerequisite to using the software (or at least blindly perform whatever rituals it demands). The aim of design unification is often a false path, born out of convenience for the designer, and it's pursuit shows a certain level of disrespect to both the user and other designers. Programming languages - arguably interaction design in its purest form - are a more interesting path towards better software (see Smalltalk, Swift playgrounds, and the work at VPRI). Material is not what software is made of, but it is a pretty good sign of what marketing is made of these days.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoA long time ago, programming was the way to interface with the computer. So people looking at making programming more usable came up with visual languages, and that spun off into the whole academic HCI industry that we have today. That being said, material design is a pure visual design language and says nothing about interaction design.
- pirateking 12y agoI consider visual design to be a part of interaction design, and taking one without the other is a failure to understand design (to the limited extent it can be understood at all). An example: a traffic light's visual design is fundamental to its interaction design.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoRight, but visual and interaction design are different activities with different outputs. An interaction design language is more about patterns of flows while visual design language is about style and metaphor. Contort them at your own peril.
- echion 12y agoThe title leaves a lot to be desired. "Software" is more than a visible interface. "Discovery" is more than articulation.
- dasil003 12y agoThat's a very charitable comment. I was struck by the outright arrogance and hubris of such a title. Of course I'm sure no one at Google would use those words, it's just some tech blogger or editor with a knack for linkbait titles.
- dsirijus 12y agoAfter reading this morning about it, going out, then getting back and reading about it again, I still literally don't have a clue what they're talking about.
- bavcyc 12y agoA little more complex version of hypercard?
- Roboprog 12y agoThe sample phone screen they showed gave me the creeps. All the little stacked up sheets reminds me of a desk stacked with unopened bills. I can do without that kind of real world clutter in my UI. It helps me to focus on one thing at a time, not have a bunch of slivers beckoning around the edges of the current "window", thank you very much.